Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Pope Francis will not say Fetus is a Person


Recommended Posts

KnightofChrist
Posted

"On abortion, I can tell you these things, which I’ve said before. In any book of embryology it is said that shortly before one month after conception the organs and the DNA are already delineated in the tiny fetus, before the mother even becomes aware. Therefore, there is a living human being. I do not say a person, because this is debated, but a living human being. And I raise two questions: Is it right to get rid of a human being to resolve a problem? Second question: Is it right to hire a “hit man” to resolve a problem? The problem arises when this reality of killing a human being is transformed into a political question, or when a pastor of the church uses political categories." - Pope Francis 

 

Source: https://www.americamagazine.org/faith/2022/11/28/pope-francis-interview-america-244225

Posted

 

And behold, you will conceive in your womb and bear a son, and you shall call his name Jesus. He will be great and will be called the Son of the Most High. And the Lord God will give to him the throne of his father David (Luke 1:31–33).

4 hours ago, KnightofChrist said:

I do not say a person

When Gabriel informed Mary about upcoming birth he didn’t mix words, he said: “you will conceive in your womb and bear a son”.   Sounds like a person, to me?

Merry Christmas 

Posted (edited)

It has been theorized that when Gabriel informed Mary that she was with child, she was 12 weeks along.

The heart of a fetus is fully developed by the 10th week of pregnancy.

(if your from Texas, you know that already)

Edited by little2add
Posted

Pope Francis does say that the fetus is a human being. "Person," in this context, may have more to do with cognitive development, or being physically independent of the mother, or other kinds of technical distinctions. There's not enough information in this quotation for me to know what he's referring to, but that's probably what he means by "this is debated." But he does say, clearly, and twice, "living human being" and "human being" twice after that. I think his stance is pretty clear.  

KnightofChrist
Posted
5 minutes ago, Luigi said:

Pope Francis does say that the fetus is a human being. "Person," in this context, may have more to do with cognitive development, or being physically independent of the mother, or other kinds of technical distinctions. There's not enough information in this quotation for me to know what he's referring to, but that's probably what he means by "this is debated." But he does say, clearly, and twice, "living human being" and "human being" twice after that. I think his stance is pretty clear.  

I don't believe his stance is at clear at all if he cannot say a human being is a person.

The legal or political separation has historically allowed some human beings to be legally killed because they're not legal persons. Who still makes any such separation of the two for any other group of human beings? I can only think of people who hold some form of bigotry. 

Posted
2 hours ago, little2add said:

It has been theorized that when Gabriel informed Mary that she was with child, she was 12 weeks along.

That's a very interesting theory.  I haven't heard of that before.  It seems contrary to her Fiat.  But worth reading up on. 

Thanks.

1 hour ago, Luigi said:

or other kinds of technical distinctions.

Specifically, legal distinctions.  The fact that he's backing off of the wording used in legal distinctions is frightening, because those are the issues that allow or disallow murder, by law.  He should state the Catholic position, which is that they are both human beings and persons.

Posted

I think Pope Francis is just stating the obvious. He didn't say the fetus is not a person, he just said it's debated, which it is. I think anyone who approaches the abortion argument from a theological or religious perspective is making a mistake, because, unless you just love preaching to the choir, non-religious people don't care.

I think the pope likes to approach issues this way. I think he likes to use language that is accessible to the non-religious. By using "human being" instead of person, he's making it very black and white and science based.

KnightofChrist
Posted
22 minutes ago, dUSt said:

I think Pope Francis is just stating the obvious. He didn't say the fetus is not a person, he just said it's debated, which it is.

He stated he will not say person, because it is debated. Not just that it is debated.

It is debated, agreed, but who debates the Personhood of certain groups of human beings?

It was debated in pre1860s America if slaves were persons. It was also debated if Jews in 1930s to 40s Germany were persons.

Can you imagine the amount of confusion (at best) if a Pope were to state the same of Africans or Jews?

"The African/Jew is a living human being. I will not say person because it is debated." - Pope Confusion 

 

22 minutes ago, dUSt said:

I think anyone who approaches the abortion argument from a theological or religious perspective is making a mistake, because, unless you just love preaching to the choir, non-religious people don't care.

I think the pope likes to approach issues this way. I think he likes to use language that is accessible to the non-religious. By using "human being" instead of person, he's making it very black and white and science based.

The word Person isn't non-accessible to non-religious, human being and person for most common folk are interchangeable and is understood. 

Posted
40 minutes ago, dUSt said:

I think the pope likes to approach issues this way. I think he likes to use language that is accessible to the non-religious. By using "human being" instead of person, he's making it very black and white and science based.

Two things: first, Pope Francis's academic training is as a scientist, so he is very comfortable in that world. Second, all of this is in translation from the original language. Do not presume that whatever ambiguity you perceive is also in the original (for the record, I don't think it's ambiguous at all).

One more thing: some people here seem to imply that they are literally more Catholic than the Pope. I find that troubling, and highly presumptuous.

Posted

 Sometimes things get missed in translation. I don't know if he said this in Italian, Spanish, Latin or what.  My late father was german. Sometimes he'd say some phrase, and I'd ask him what it meant. He'd translate it, and depending on the words used, might say a particular word didn't have an equvilanet in english and would give you  some sort of idea  what it meant. Let's face it, we don't know when  a child receives their soul. Is it when the child is concieved, is it  when mom first feels the baby moving, or is it at the moment  when we  are born?  No one knows except God.  When we recieve our soul, it makes us a complete human being. I believe that when we someday find this out,  than there won't be this debate over whether a fetus is a person or not. Besides,  what does both the Old and New Testaments say on the subject?  What does the Torah or other holy jewish writings say on the subject? Surely   there must be a  jewish position on this whole subject, going back centuries. Abortion and birth control  have been around since the dawn of time. Unless people use  something to prevent unwanted pregnancies and use Moral Restraints when it comes to sex, the whole subject of abortion will always be an issue. I wonder if St.Augustine, St.Thomas Aquinas and other Doctors of the Church have to say if anything on the issue.

KnightofChrist
Posted
1 hour ago, Nunsuch said:

Two things: first, Pope Francis's academic training is as a scientist, so he is very comfortable in that world. Second, all of this is in translation from the original language. Do not presume that whatever ambiguity you perceive is also in the original (for the record, I don't think it's ambiguous at all).

One more thing: some people here seem to imply that they are literally more Catholic than the Pope. I find that troubling, and highly presumptuous.

It's the same script. Pope Francis says something odd or strange in a interview, "it's a translation error." "The true meaning was lost in translation.", "You're making yourself more Catholic than the Pope."

I don't care for American magazine but I highly doubt they're so unprofessional that they are unable to accurately translate the original Spanish. Which is linked in the article. 

Rather, I believe you make these points to avoid facing things about Pope Francis you don't wish to face. 

Pope Francis believes a fetus is a human being but doesn't want to say a fetus a person because it's debated.

This is confusing and a strange thing for a Pope to say.  

Lastly, as always I believe you are a good Catholic. If you do not return the same honor to me is not a matter I can control. 

 

 

Posted
3 hours ago, dUSt said:

non-religious people don't care.

A lot of so-called Religious people don’t care either :stubborn:

Posted
3 hours ago, KnightofChrist said:

It's the same script. Pope Francis says something odd or strange in a interview, "it's a translation error." "The true meaning was lost in translation.", "You're making yourself more Catholic than the Pope."

I don't care for American magazine but I highly doubt they're so unprofessional that they are unable to accurately translate the original Spanish. Which is linked in the article. 

Rather, I believe you make these points to avoid facing things about Pope Francis you don't wish to face. 

Pope Francis believes a fetus is a human being but doesn't want to say a fetus a person because it's debated.

This is confusing and a strange thing for a Pope to say.  

Lastly, as always I believe you are a good Catholic. If you do not return the same honor to me is not a matter I can control. 

 

 

I have no desire to judge whether or not you are a good Catholic; I assume you are. I also assume the Holy Father is. I don't find his statement at all confusing. 

KnightofChrist
Posted
52 minutes ago, Nunsuch said:

I have no desire to judge whether or not you are a good Catholic; I assume you are. I also assume the Holy Father is. I don't find his statement at all confusing. 

You desired to passive aggressively judge 'some people' here for believing they are literally more Catholic than the Pope. Doesn't sound good but at least you could say they were people. 

Anyway, there aren't any legitimate debates on the Personhood of any other groups of human beings. And it would be completely unacceptable for the Pope or anyone else to say "The African/Jew is a living human being. I will not say person because it is debated."

Posted
14 hours ago, KnightofChrist said:

You desired to passive aggressively judge 'some people' here for believing they are literally more Catholic than the Pope. Doesn't sound good but at least you could say they were people. 

 

And thank you for your judgment of me. I'm not going to engage with you further.

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

Similar troubling news is the strange things that have been coming out of the Pontifical Academy of Life earlier this year and before. 

The Academy has appointed various pro-abortionists as members. After Archbishop Paglia, made President of the Academy by Pope Francis, removed a requirement that members make a pledge to protect life in union Church teaching. 

Also strange was an interview with Archbishop Paglia on Rai 3, Italian TV. 

During the interview the Archbishop Paglia stated

"I think that Law 194 (that legalized abortion in Italy) is now a pillar of our social life.”

When he was asked

“Is it not up for debate?”

The Archbishop replied

“But no, absolutely not, absolutely not.”

After a massive outcry from many Prolife groups the Academy claimed the Archbishop was taken out of context. 

The Pontifical Academy of Life's Twitter account earlier this year also caused great confusion when it repeatedly casted doubt on the binding nature of Humanae Vitae. Tweets they have since deleted. 

 

 

Edited by KnightofChrist
Posted
On 11/29/2022 at 3:03 PM, KnightofChrist said:

It's the same script. Pope Francis says something odd or strange in a interview, "it's a translation error." "The true meaning was lost in translation.", "You're making yourself more Catholic than the Pope."

I don't care for American magazine but I highly doubt they're so unprofessional that they are unable to accurately translate the original Spanish. Which is linked in the article. 

Rather, I believe you make these points to avoid facing things about Pope Francis you don't wish to face. 

Pope Francis believes a fetus is a human being but doesn't want to say a fetus a person because it's debated.

This is confusing and a strange thing for a Pope to say.  

Lastly, as always I believe you are a good Catholic. If you do not return the same honor to me is not a matter I can control. 

 

 

This was an intentional choice, and it was the right choice. This was a choice of teaching. As a former teacher, I know that this "choice of teaching" is a question of a domain called "pedagogy" -- the philosophy and study of teaching and learning.

What the Pope did here was that he chose to laser focus the learning of his chosen audience.

  • The Pope's chosen audience: The Pope here is not seeking to speak with Catholics who already accept the Church teaching, such as yourself. He is seeking to engage those who don't currently accept Church teaching on abortion. Consequently, he is less concerned if you misunderstand his message, and more concerned if his chosen audience misunderstands his message.
  • "Laser Focus": The Pope wanted to make sure that his chosen audience would focus on what he wanted them focus on: the message, and not a controversy of personhood. He knew that the question of personhood was too advanced of a concept for his audience -- that was like trying to teach calculus to a kindergartner; best to start with counting and addition, first. No, Pope Francis was going to start with the easy stuff, the stuff that there couldn't be disagreement on, the science: this was a human being, biologically speaking. We'll talk about the harder and more-controversial stuff later. Moreover, this stylistic choice highlighted the argument that he was trying to make, "No, let's not talk about the philosophical right now. Let's just talk about the scientific: is this, physiologically speaking, human?".

Teachers teach this way. We call it scaffolding: one step at a time. Hell, if you accept that the Old Testament was an extended lesson where God the Father slowly preparing the Israelites for Christ over time, then God scaffolded the Israelites. The very "grades" of K-12 in school are modelled after scaffolding, where each year in school students zoom in closer and closer on topics that they had learned about the previous year, or are introduced to new topics.

In short, the Pope's educational choice here was pedagogically brilliant -- the mark of a master teacher. It got the devout Catholics talking about it. It got everyone else to pay attention. It educated, and it did so at the lowest-common denominator with the most-compelling argument.

KnightofChrist
Posted
11 minutes ago, mommas_boy said:

This was an intentional choice, and it was the right choice. This was a choice of teaching. As a former teacher, I know that this "choice of teaching" is a question of a domain called "pedagogy" -- the philosophy and study of teaching and learning.

What the Pope did here was that he chose to laser focus the learning of his chosen audience.

  • The Pope's chosen audience: The Pope here is not seeking to speak with Catholics who already accept the Church teaching, such as yourself. He is seeking to engage those who don't currently accept Church teaching on abortion. Consequently, he is less concerned if you misunderstand his message, and more concerned if his chosen audience misunderstands his message.
  • "Laser Focus": The Pope wanted to make sure that his chosen audience would focus on what he wanted them focus on: the message, and not a controversy of personhood. He knew that the question of personhood was too advanced of a concept for his audience -- that was like trying to teach calculus to a kindergartner; best to start with counting and addition, first. No, Pope Francis was going to start with the easy stuff, the stuff that there couldn't be disagreement on, the science: this was a human being, biologically speaking. We'll talk about the harder and more-controversial stuff later. Moreover, this stylistic choice highlighted the argument that he was trying to make, "No, let's not talk about the philosophical right now. Let's just talk about the scientific: is this, physiologically speaking, human?".

Teachers teach this way. We call it scaffolding: one step at a time. Hell, if you accept that the Old Testament was an extended lesson where God the Father slowly preparing the Israelites for Christ over time, then God scaffolded the Israelites. The very "grades" of K-12 in school are modelled after scaffolding, where each year in school students zoom in closer and closer on topics that they had learned about the previous year, or are introduced to new topics.

In short, the Pope's educational choice here was pedagogically brilliant -- the mark of a master teacher. It got the devout Catholics talking about it. It got everyone else to pay attention. It educated, and it did so at the lowest-common denominator with the most-compelling argument.

What do base your position on that Catholics who accept church teaching aren't his target audience in his interview with America? 

The question asked which prompted his answer was focused on how we (Catholics) know who abortion is wrong, how abortion plagues and separates the church, and how bishops should treat abortion in relation to other social justice issues.

Lastly, a fetus or any developing preborn child being recognized as a human being is just as hotly debated and denied by those that don't accept Church teaching as a fetus being recognized as a person. Calling a child a human being but not willing to say person will just confuse most any audience. As most people use the terms interchangeably. 

ETA the question as asked from the original source

"Gloria Purvis: Holy Father, abortion is a heavily politicized issue in the United States. We know it is wrong. And the United States Supreme Court recently ruled that there is no constitutional right to abortion. However, it still seems to plague the church in the sense that it separates us. Should the bishops prioritize abortion in relation to other social justice issues?"

Posted
1 minute ago, KnightofChrist said:

What do base your position on that Catholics who accept church teaching aren't his target audience in his interview with America?

Presumably, a Catholic who accepts Church teaching already wouldn't need education in this lesson; the Pope would otherwise be preaching to the Choir.

2 minutes ago, KnightofChrist said:

The question asked which prompted his answer was focused on how we (Catholics) know who abortion is wrong, how abortion plagues and separates the church, and how bishops should treat abortion in relation to other social justice issues.

The Pope's answer chose one specific "proof" for the immorality of abortion. Instead of using a fact from the bible as the starting axiom for his argument, the Pope chose instead an axiom from science, as Pope knew that this would be an axiom that would be acceptable to both those who are Faithful and those who are not. This is rhetorically advantageous.

5 minutes ago, KnightofChrist said:

Lastly, a fetus or any developing preborn child being recognized as a human being is just as hotly debated and denied by those that don't accept Church teaching as a fetus being recognized as a person. Calling a child a human being but not willing to say person will just confuse most any audience. As most people use the terms interchangeably. 

Perhaps using "human being" was not good on my part. The Pope wanted to focus on what species a fetus belongs to; physiologically, is this fetus homo sapiens sapiens? The principle remains the same: let's focus on first principles.

KnightofChrist
Posted
2 minutes ago, mommas_boy said:

Presumably, a Catholic who accepts Church teaching already wouldn't need education in this lesson; the Pope would otherwise be preaching to the Choir.

The Pope 'preaches to the choir' all the time. It's often needed actually.

2 minutes ago, mommas_boy said:

The Pope's answer chose one specific "proof" for the immorality of abortion. Instead of using a fact from the bible as the starting axiom for his argument, the Pope chose instead an axiom from science, as Pope knew that this would be an axiom that would be acceptable to both those who are Faithful and those who are not. This is rhetorically advantageous.

Yes however by making the point, going out of his way to say he will not say a fetus is a person will confuse most any audience. It wasn't even a comment that needed to be said, even accepting for sake of argument your position that his target audience was not pro life Catholics. 

2 minutes ago, mommas_boy said:

Perhaps using "human being" was not good on my part. The Pope wanted to focus on what species a fetus belongs to; physiologically, is this fetus homo sapiens sapiens? The principle remains the same: let's focus on first principles.

Stating that a fetus or any preborn child is a homo sapien is just as hotly debated and denied as stating a fetus is a human being or a person. Those that reject the Church's teaching don't accept the humanity of the child in anyway. It's just a 'blob of cells', parasitical, non living matter, a part of the woman's body, belongs to the woman's body, etc. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...