Guest Posted January 11 Posted January 11 I had a young cousin who had a 6 year old child who passed away today from cancer. The cousin passed away not the child, so his daughter is orphaned now. I have prayed fervently, rosaries, chaplets, novenas, I’ve been praying for months, I promised to God and some saints, especially St. Rita of Cascia that I’d do anything if Heaven delivered him. He was in cancer hospice sleeping mostly recently. And he quietly passed away after I did my prayers yesterday. His wife was catholic but she had left the church. I had told him about Jesus and how he had saved me and he was so moved the last time they visited us and I told him I believe that Jesus can save him. I genuinely believe a seed was planted that day, because he told everybody about that story and he was so moved by it. Had he lived, he would have really converted, and his family would return to the church. But now he died an unbeliever and we can never be certain where his soul resides now, I can only hope it’s not hell especially after all of the suffering and fear he has endured. My best friend also passed away from cancer 4 years ago. I was not a christian then, nor was she, but I really believe if she lived she would have converted with me and she would have become a far better christian than anybody else. I pray for so many things but this was one of the most important prayer petitions for me, for him to be healed. Now this makes me feel like god failed me and that he won’t answer any prayers at all. Do I just stop praying novenas rosaries and chaplets and prayers in general if they are unanswered after a certain amount of time ? I heard people say pray for something 3 times, no more. Is there anything in the bible for this? Mother Mary says in every single apparition to pray ceaselessly and pray lots. I do pray everyday and I pray lots but they are unanswered. I feel so abandoned and hurt after all this. Seeing the opposite of what you are praying for hurts so much, especially when it’s death. My feelings are just so convoluted I don’t even know how to explain, I feel angry, sad, abandoned and everything all at once. Why didn’t god restore him? Why did all our prayers go unanswered?
Luigi Posted January 11 Posted January 11 My aunt was diagnosed with cancer when she was in her early 40s. She and her husband had 8 children, all still at home. My aunt took all the treatments and therapies they could give her - she was bound and determined to see that last daughter make her First Communion. She suffered a great deal. She had 12 brothers and sisters, all Catholic, and 3 of the sisters were women religious. Everyone prayed, like BIG dogs, for the 4 or 5 years of the disease's progress. My aunt died anyway, and before the last daughter received her First Communion. Does that mean that God doesn't hear our prayers? No. Does that mean that God doesn't answer our prayers? Maybe. God is not a vending machine of miracles; we know what we want, and we usually know why we want it. But God's plan is bigger than our understanding, especially when we're focused on a very specific outcome. So if we don't get the miraculous outcome we pray for, it's because God has other outcomes or opportunities in mind. But God can and does bring good out of bad events and situations, even tragedies. It may us take years to see what the good was/is/will be. But when God created the world, at the end of each day, He said, "It is good." And I think we have to take that same attitude - at the end of the day, we have to say "It is good. I don't know how yet, but it is good." About whatever happens. As far as praying for something 3 times, I've never heard that before. I seriously doubt that's Biblical. I've always heard that we're supposed to pray without ceasing. The Biblical example that's always held up is the widow who wanted a just judgment from the corrupt judge - she kept bringing her case before him until he rendered a decision. But when we pray for anything - even a specific outcome - the final words need to be "Thy will be done" followed by a "Glory be to the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit." Pray, like a BIG dog, and then accept that God has heard your prayers and rendered the best decision. And I'm sorry for your loss.
Lou Posted January 12 Posted January 12 I am so sorry for your loss too. God always hears and answers us: we are told that in nearly all the psalms. He just doesn't answer in the way we think he should or might or ought. Don't stop praying. Don't stop! Please keep going. Your prayers are efficacious. They are making a difference for people, for the world. They are contributing to the economy of salvation. But only God sees everything, knows everything. Only God can bring about beautiful things that our little minds cannot even imagine. I can attest to this in a small way. My friend was praying for a woman named Martha, a young mother who was dying as an unbeliever. Martha died. My friend felt despair towards God and found it difficult to cope with God not having restored Martha's health when she had prayed and fasted for her. Yet, Martha's family did not suffer so much. They had so much grace to accept her death and move on with their lives in a really healthy and integrated way. They remember Martha with great love and thanksgiving. Maybe my friends prayer contributed to that gift. Maybe many other gifts were wrought through her prayer for that family. We will not know. Hope is never defeated. Hope in Him, who can do all things better than we will ever know.
Didacus Posted January 12 Posted January 12 Very sorry for your loss. Losing someone is painful and never easy. I won't pretend to be an expert on anything... but here's a few thoughts on what you said. God does hear the prayers, every single one. But His plan is better than anything we desire. Your friend's life on earth may have come to an end - but trust that your friend's soul is better now than it ever has been. Quote But now he died an unbeliever and we can never be certain where his soul resides now, I can only hope it’s not hell especially after all of the suffering and fear he has endured If your friend desired the Truth, wanted to convert and was a good person; then I would have no worries for your friend's soul. Some purgatory (like just about everyone else) and then heaven awaits - to that I have no doubt. Quote Mother Mary says in every single apparition to pray ceaselessly and pray lots. Every thought of the Lord is a prayer in itself. You writing what you wrote, was a prayer. Prayer is more than just reciting old format and words - it is thoughts offered toward God, His Mother, His saints and His angels. Every thought you offer to Him and His own, you build a relationship with Him and it becomes more and more profound and blessed. From what you wrote, I think you might be praying far more than you think you have been.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now