Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

If a political party agreed with everything the Church believes, except is Pro-Choice. How would you vote? (if the rival party was totally against the Church, except is pro-life)  

43 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

ilovechrist
Posted

[quote name='flip' date='Jul 23 2004, 05:18 PM'] I found that most of what the Democratic party stands for is often in line with Church teaching, excet the abortion issue. [/quote]
um..

have you forgotten about gay marriages, and stem cell research? it goes further than just abortion..

shelly_freak
Posted

yeah, gotta remember stem cell reasurch

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I love Cmom. And I love how she thinks.

I used to be more of a sympathizer with the Democratic party, a decade ago. Now I think they are worse than the Republicans. Republicans and Democrats are basically the same. The difference is, Democrats put on a mask of wanting to appear more socially aware as Volvo-driving, aluminum-can recycling, I'm-personally-affluent-my-hubby-works-for-Microsoft-and-we-live-a-comfortable-life, but I *REALLY* care about poor people, including the starving people with AIDS in Africa, but would not want anyone doing away with big business or any demands that involve altering my lifestyle, or "reproductive choice" in the event of sexual irresponsibility! After all, we can't "impose" on other people's moralities, even though that involves getting to the root of the problem!?




...

You can NOT compromise when the building blocks of a peaceful society -- family and marriage -- are threatened and disregarded as being "religious issues." That seems to quiet the rightfully troubled conscience when you're thinking about matters of life and death. I used to vote pro-choice and played the usual arguments in my mind and tried to comfort my conscience into saying "it's not a one issue race." Not any more. Catholics need to stop putting up with the b.s.

If you stand up against pro-choice politicians, they will stop supporting abortion. They will do anything for your vote.

If you do away with respect for life and family, you end up with Jerry Springer world. There is no peace with that. And people wonder why radical Muslim terrorists think we are hedonistic and should be removed from the planet? Is the question really that hard to answer?

Posted

I voted for them. But in relaity I probly wouldn't vote for either. Rejecting one teaching of the Church is just as bad as rejecting 101. So yeh.

Don John of Austria
Posted

still no answer on the article that Ratzinger is being sited in, no letter name or anything?

Posted

You gotta figure that if someone was pro-abortion, they'd also probably support unlimited embryonic stem cell research. Abortion kills millions of people each year. It also kills more than war and the death penalty combined. If the pro-abortion candidate was against gay "marriage," cloning, and euthanasia, and if the anti-abortion candidate supported all of those things, I'm not sure what I'd do. I don't know the exact effects gay "marriage" would have on society, but I know it wouldn't be good. More than likely, I probably wouldn't vote. But if I did, I'd probably vote for the person who supported the least amount of killing. In this case, it'd be the pro-life person.

Bush is definitely more pro-life than Kerry is in terms of abortion. (I wrote about this on [url="http://www.xanga.com/dabeenabobba"]my blog[/url] on July 17th. You should check it out.) Bush is against abortion, for the most part. Kerry has said he refuses to appoint judges who will overturn Roe v. Wade to the Supreme Court. Overturning Roe v. Wade will definitely be more possible with Bush in office. Bush supports the Iraqi War and the death penalty, which have killed thousands of people combined, but Kerry supports abortion, which kills millions of innocent children each year. Bush seems to support the least amount of killing.

Bush is also against gay "marriage" and is willing to do something to stop it. Kerry, on the other hand, doesn't have much of a problem with it. He's shown himself unwilling to do anything to stop it.

As for cloning, embryonic stem cell research, and euthanasia: I'm going to do some more research to see where Kerry and Bush stand on these issues.

God bless,

Jennifer

Posted

Helping the poor and other such things, while important, aren't nearly as important as the abortion issue. Helping the poor, etc. has to do with improving the quality of life for people. Abortion deals with life itself. War and the death penalty also deal with life itself, but the difference is that going to war and using the death penalty aren't intrinsically wrong in that they're not always wrong (unlike abortion, which is [b]always[/b] evil).

God bless,

Jen

Posted

I will probably vote for Kerry because even though Bush is "pro-life," he hasn't made any concerted effort that I know of to halt the abortion killings. I agree with Flip in that I agree mostly with the democratic ideals, but am pro-life. Therefore, since I agree with Kerry on more issues than I do Bush, added to the fact that Bush has proven he has no intention of making changes in abortion policy anyway...I will vote for John Kerry...I think...probably. :unsure:

:)

Posted

[quote name='flip' date='Jul 23 2004, 06:40 PM'] helping the less fortunate (health care and welfare) [/quote]
Hi, just wondering.. What more should we be doing through the government for the less fortunate? There are welfare, soup kitchens, clothing drives, medicaid (medical and dental), charities, social security, housing, WIC, financial aid for schools, and homeless shelters, just to name a few.

God bless.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Faithful Catholics cannot vote for abortion-loving politicians.

Posted

Also, why is this an unjust war? I would like some opinions, please. Saddam Hussein has done many of the things Hitler did, to his own people. Is it Christian to sit aside and let that happen?

Posted

[quote name='Don John of Austria' date='Jul 23 2004, 06:59 PM'] \

Absolute fire please post a link to this articale as i couldn't find it on texasCatholic.com, this is not in keeping with other statments Ratzinger has made, no=r is it in keeping with the other teachings of the Church, so I am highly suspect, can you give a name to the letter this is ascribed to or anything. [/quote]
I also looked for the article and couldn't find it--I would like to see it, too.

shelly_freak
Posted

[quote name='Apollo' date='Jul 30 2004, 07:18 PM'] I will probably vote for Kerry because even though Bush is "pro-life," he hasn't made any concerted effort that I know of to halt the abortion killings. I agree with Flip in that I agree mostly with the democratic ideals, but am pro-life. Therefore, since I agree with Kerry on more issues than I do Bush, added to the fact that Bush has proven he has no intention of making changes in abortion policy anyway...I will vote for John Kerry...I think...probably. :unsure:

:) [/quote]
that's just how i see it. i keep getting yelled at for sayin that im voting for kerry and that im sinning and im a terrible perston and such. but really bush never did anything to stop abortion so how does this make him any better? i dont know how many of you know this but kerry does believe that life is sacred. I dont know, maybe this only makes sense in my little head, but the way i see it if Bush isnt doing anything about abortion why should I vote for him on that soul reason?

franciscanheart
Posted

there seems to be a general concensus.... which is good


abortion is big.

good question.... i like :)

Posted

A Catholic isn't a Catholic unless they are in line with every teaching of the Church.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...