Ash Wednesday Posted July 28, 2004 Posted July 28, 2004 [quote name='crusader1234' date='Jul 28 2004, 06:05 PM'] If a man is infertile and he gets married its not a valid marriage.. so its sort of a double edged sword. [/quote] I have never heard of infertility, when it is not intentional, as being a reason to make a marriage invalid. Can someone verify if this is true? Obviously he would want to be up front with girlfriend/fiancee that he might be infertile, if they start discussing marriage and children.
Ash Wednesday Posted July 28, 2004 Posted July 28, 2004 [quote name='1337 k4th0l1x0r' date='Jul 28 2004, 06:09 PM'] An infirtile man can get married. An impotent man cannot. [/quote] I've never heard this before, either. As I understand what impotence is, one would normally NOT know or experience impotence until AFTER they were married and were attempting the, uh, marriage act.
1337 k4th0l1x0r Posted July 28, 2004 Posted July 28, 2004 From the apologetics reading room. [url="http://www.catholicherald.com/saunders/98ws/ws980723.htm"]Marriage without Children[/url]
jasJis Posted July 28, 2004 Posted July 28, 2004 If you read Canon law, the requirement is to be open to children. I did not see where it addressed suspected sterility, but it did address suspected impotence. It specifically says that [u]suspected[/u] impotence was not a deterent to a valid marriage. Suspected infertility would logically be considered the same. People are married without knowing their fertility. Discovering infertility later on does not mean the marriage is invalid or should be anulled (or even can be anulled. Consider a certain King of England???!!??). Get married, and try to have babies. That's the sure fire test and is accepting of God's will in either case. It's not like he was 'artificially' made sterile by a vasectomy or something.
Ash Wednesday Posted July 28, 2004 Posted July 28, 2004 [quote] With this in mind, let us address the issue of impotence. A man or woman who suffers impotence, either physically or psychologically, cannot enter into marriage because he or she cannot physically consummate the marriage. [/quote] (From the site) But how would one KNOW that they are impotent if they are virgins until marriage? Two people get married, and come wedding night, the male is impotent, it turns out? Do they call it all off? I always thought impotence was a medical condition that could be treated, and is at times caused by side effects of medications, or a psychological problem. But I'm not a male, so I'm not totally in the know... What about disabilities? A couple at our parish is married in the church, the woman has disability and is in a wheelchair, which makes me wonder if they are unable to consumate, or have kids, physically, this makes the marriage invalid?
Ash Wednesday Posted July 28, 2004 Posted July 28, 2004 [quote name='Raphael' date='Jul 28 2004, 06:33 PM'] Well, I'd ask EWTN... [/quote] Word.
1337 k4th0l1x0r Posted July 29, 2004 Posted July 29, 2004 I think consumation is required for a marriage to be valid. They would have to call it off if the man is unable to consumate the marriage.
Philippe Posted July 29, 2004 Posted July 29, 2004 [quote name='IcePrincessKRS' date='Jul 28 2004, 03:40 PM'] I think the options here are to not get a test at all and be honest with his future spouse about the possibility of infertility, or get the test done, be in a state of sin and have to go to confession. And really, sin isn't much of an option. [/quote] that makes no sense because if u go have the test done and u sin, then u really arent sorry for your sin so the confession would be invalid
1337 k4th0l1x0r Posted July 29, 2004 Posted July 29, 2004 I'd still put my money on collecting it during a nocturnal emission. It would just be a sin to try to stimulate one, but not wait for one. There is an issue, however, of how much time you have to perform the actual fertility test. There are some logistics issues, but I think they can be overcome.
Madonna Posted July 29, 2004 Posted July 29, 2004 I have heard that a man should wait for a nocturnal emission to do the test as well.
BLAZEr Posted July 29, 2004 Posted July 29, 2004 To wait for a nocturnal emission seems absurd. First of all, when the sample is taken at home the man is supposed to deliver it to the clinic withing one hour and is supposed to carry it near his body to keep it at body temperature. The problem with waiting for a nocturnal emission is that, first of all, most guys don't have them regularly. They don't happen all that often. They happen when you're asleep so you don't even know when they happen, and if you had one, you wouldn't be able to get it to the clinic in the middle of the night. Not only that, but how in the world would you collect it at night? It seems totally odd. The guy would have to wear plastic underwear. I seriously don't think this is an option. The fact is that virgins don't know if they will be fertile when they enter marriage, but they enter with goodwill and good intent. If one person has reason to believe that they might not be fertile (as in the case of the young man in this example) he should be honest with his future wife, but should also realize that A.) he won't be able to give a guarantee and B.) God can do amazing things . . . even make the infertile and barren people bring forth life . . . think Sara, think Zecchariah, think the Virgin Mary . . . what place is more hopeless then the womb of a Virgin . . . a place where the possibility of life is impossible, because it is virginal . . . yet took that barrenness and allowed it to bring forth life. Part of marriage is not just Canon Law requirements. It's faith. Faith that your marriage doesn't even belong to you, but to God. And he will bring forth his will if you let him.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted July 29, 2004 Author Posted July 29, 2004 Thank you for the informative responses. Now if I can just convince him that he has to wait and see.
Theoketos Posted August 28, 2004 Posted August 28, 2004 [quote name='thedude' date='Jul 28 2004, 05:10 PM'] Yeah I know about the proccess for married men, but the problem is he isn't married yet and he doesn't want to be until he can tell his future spouse whether or not they can have kids. [/quote] Impotence does not premit marriage, but one may and still become married if he feels the call to marriage,because infertility does mean that they can not adopt. Openess to life is the key.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted August 28, 2004 Author Posted August 28, 2004 That's true, but I'm afraid that they will disregard Church teaching if they can't have their own kids (which makes my head explode).
Paladin D Posted August 28, 2004 Posted August 28, 2004 Two questions... [b]1.[/b] So those who know they themselves are infertile, cannot get married whatsoever? [b]2.[/b] How about testing for STD's (so you can know if your fiance has one or not)? Does that require semen samples too?
Theoketos Posted August 28, 2004 Posted August 28, 2004 OK I am going to be frank so people who can not handle blunt discussion should not read further.... . . . . That being said I will try to be as dicrete as possible. [quote name='"Code Canon Law 1983"']Can. 1061 §1 A valid marriage between baptised persons is said to be merely ratified, if it is not consummated; ratified and consummated, if the spouses have in a human manner engaged together in a conjugal act in itself apt for the generation of offspring. To this act marriage is by its nature ordered and by it the spouses become one flesh.[/quote] and [quote name='"Canon 1083"']§2 If the impediment of impotence is doubtful, whether the doubt be one of law or one of fact, the marriage is not to be prevented nor, while the doubt persists, is it to be declared null. §3 Without prejudice to the provisions of can. 1098, sterility neither forbids nor invalidates a marriage. [/quote] Basically all the plumming has to work, at least technically one time, but fertility is not an issue, so long as both are open to life. Other nifty facts Later impotence does not invalidate the marriage. A marriage can be ratified but not consumated, before the first conjugal act and still be a marriage, though the marriage bond is easily broken. A man must be Sixteen before he get married, but a women only 14! And a sterility test is thus never necessary.
IcePrincessKRS Posted August 28, 2004 Posted August 28, 2004 [quote name='Philippe' date='Jul 28 2004, 09:31 PM'] that makes no sense because if u go have the test done and u sin, then u really arent sorry for your sin so the confession would be invalid [/quote] One could become sorry for the sin later on though... I was giving the benefit of a doubt that there would be some repentance!
Laudate_Dominum Posted August 28, 2004 Posted August 28, 2004 [quote name='IcePrincessKRS' date='Aug 27 2004, 10:37 PM'] One could become sorry for the sin later on though... I was giving the benefit of a doubt that there would be some repentance! [/quote] You can't sin and just plan on repenting later. That is presumption. Augustine says that someone who commits a sin intending to repent later is no penitent but a mocker of God, and Scripture says, "God will not be mocked". You could go to hell over a stupid sperm sample. Remember, masturbation is grave matter. Just my $0.02
BLAZEr Posted August 28, 2004 Posted August 28, 2004 STD tests only require blood tests. Thanks Theoketos for getting the canon law on the issue. LD, I think that what IcePrincess is referring to here is the fact that we can pray for someone's repentance, even if they do not intend to repent. My mother had a tubal ligation after the birth of my sister. At the time she saw no reason to repent, as she had been advised to do so by a priest. As she grew in her relationship with Christ and the teachings of the Church she became very repentant of her decision. The same can be true for any sin. That is the mystery of God's grace! I think this has been a great discussion!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now