Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I have some question and would like some opinions...


Is it immoral to listen to bands that have immoral Lyrics?

Is it immoral to cover songs with immoral Lyrics? (example - "baby got back")

Is it immoral to support bands that sing immoral songs? (buy CD, go to concert)

Is it immoral to support bands that do immoral things? (sex, drugs, support pro-choice)


Do Jet or Incubus fit into any of these catagories??
Thanks,
-Joey Herzog


(similar subject: rock for life, rock4life)

Posted

[quote]Is it immoral to listen to bands that have immoral Lyrics?[/quote]
Yes.

[quote]Is it immoral to cover songs with immoral Lyrics? (example - "baby got back")[/quote]
Yes.

[quote]Is it immoral to support bands that sing immoral songs? (buy CD, go to concert)[/quote]
Yes.

[quote]Is it immoral to support bands that do immoral things? (sex, drugs, support pro-choice)[/quote]
Yes.

[quote]Do Jet or Incubus fit into any of these catagories??[/quote]
I don't know.

Posted

What if you listen to Jet or Incubus and do not bother to find out if they fit into any of these catagories because you like their music and because you do not have time to find out. Or because you like them so much that you do not want to find out (incase it is immoral to listen/support them?).

Are you sure about your previous answers?? can you elaborate a little more. Why,...Yes...Yes...Yes...Yes??

PS - (I agree with you, I just want to know the reasons why so that I can help a friend).

golden.silence
Posted (edited)

[b] Is it immoral to listen to bands that have immoral Lyrics?[/b]

Yup. Do I do it? Sometimes...

[b] Is it immoral to cover songs with immoral Lyrics? (example - "baby got back")[/b]

Yup.

[b] Is it immoral to support bands that sing immoral songs? (buy CD, go to concert)[/b]

Yup. Your money = more success for them = more success in spreading audio poision...

[b] Is it immoral to support bands that do immoral things? (sex, drugs, support pro-choice)[/b]

Yes!!!

[b]Do Jet or Incubus fit into any of these catagories??[/b]

I don't know about Jet...but - yeah, Incubus DOES fit into these categories...

Edited by golden.silence
Posted

How does Incubus fit into any of these catagories, can you please elaborate?
Thanks

golden.silence
Posted

[quote name='zogdog602' date='Aug 17 2004, 02:19 AM'] How does Incubus fit into any of these catagories, can you please elaborate?
Thanks [/quote]
"Smokin' The Herb Again"
by [b]Incubus[/b]

[i]beaver dam I really wish I could find my sack man
It must've got eaten by pac-man
If I had I would smoke again
Smoke with my friends until the very end
But now I'm trying to comprehend
When's the next time that I'll smoke again
I need to know please tell me
When will we smoke again

I got a buddy his name is Ted
He's got a problem going through his head
he doesn't know how to puff puff give
But I like him so I'll teach him
And I'll let him live
Everyday we teach him right
And when he defy's we have to fight
But at the end of the trying day
We say it's ok and we puff away

Just the other night I saw you
You were smokin not sharing and being tight
But that's ok you are my friend
And we'll smoke it all until the end
The lessons that we put out
We wanted you to try it out
It's nice to smoke
Yea that's what it's all about

Smokin, we're smoking
We're smoking the herb again

I smoke you smoke
We smoke they smoke (he smokes weed)
Smokin everywhere
I smoke you smoke
We smoke they smoke (he smokes all the weed)
Smokin all together[/i]

Do these look like the lyrics of a morally sound band that you should promote?

golden.silence
Posted

Moderator - it's all good if you delete and/or edit these lyrics...

I understand...

Posted (edited)

also- incubus is the name of a demon which means "to lie upon"

INCUBUS - A spirit or demon thought in medieval times to lie on sleeping persons, especially women, with whom it sought sexual intercourse.
- not sure if this was folklore or if there really is a demon named incubus

I dont know about you but i wouldnt want to be supporting a band who got thier name from a demon who has sex with women.('specially if the demon and the lady aren't married(WHICH I DOUBT THEY WOULD BE!......ya know) cuz that would be bad)

ok serious time-
*i feel like i should say a little about non-Catholic like music as it was once a big barrier in my walk with Christ. basically, led zeppelin used to be my favorite band. i used to listen to all that stuff and pretend that i wasnt listening to the lyrics. while i may not have been listening to the lyrics, the message of that music still came through. This type of music always put me in a sinful attitude because the message is present in many other ways than just in the lyrics. The very nature of the music gives us an inclination to sin. i do not say this in meaning that any genre is inherantly sinful, what i mean is that the message of the lyrics is still presented to us, even in an almost subliminal manner, if we chose not to "pay attention" to the lyrics. we will still understand the just of what the band stands for and this will be present in our minds as we rock out to thier music. do you honestly think that haveing for example- "you shook me all night long" blasting over and over in your head will not affect you in some way? i used to kid my self that it wasnt. and if you honestly think this type of music doesnt affect you(which i now understand to be impossible in my mind), what will others think about you as a Christian when they see you pulling up in your car with it eccoing throught the parking lot? also, getting enjoyment out of any type of music makes the lyrics and its message more attractive. why do you think companies use catchy jingles or use music in the background to advertise thier products? its the same idea. you cannot escape the message no matter how hard you try. its like trying to run away from a chicken with like michael johnson sized quads and unlimited stamina and then it eats you and you die. same idea if you any of you have had that type of problem before. im a testiment to that. but seriously, i have notice a definate turn around in my spiritual life since i stopped listening to anti-Christian music. do not kid yourself into thinking that its not affecting you like i did.
i pray for those who have this problem as music is very addictive (at least for me) and i pray expecially that people may first recognize that anti-Chrisian music is causeing a problem, because that is the hardest part.

Edited by louisville
Posted (edited)

so like throw them cd's away and getcho self some righteous b or the massmatics album or sumptin. yo

Edited by louisville
golden.silence
Posted

You make some real good points, bro...

Listen - the easiest way to determine if you should or should not support a musician is really to ask yourself:

Is this musician glorifying God through their music?

The same is true for our actions...you feel me?

I'm not claimin' that every musician should sing, rap, or play STRICTLY "Christian" music...but, it shouldn't promote anything other than life...

Posted

umm... supporting any thing immoral is a bad thing. We are called to be in this world, not of it. There are many secular not immoral bands. I usually go on the guidelines for secular music by the large amounts of lustfulness, excessive cursing, anti-Christian anything... I do listen to a lot of secular music that questions Christianity but not against it, which is understandable. People without truth will not understand it, and will question it.

Posted

[quote]Is it immoral to listen to bands that have immoral Lyrics?[/quote]
Yes, because this is all based on our morals, so we set the standards for immoral music. Am I going to stop listening to something because it's immoral? No.

[quote]Is it immoral to cover songs with immoral Lyrics? (example - "baby got back")[/quote]Yes, refer to explanation above.

[quote]Is it immoral to support bands that sing immoral songs? (buy CD, go to concert)[/quote]Yes, refer to explanation above.

[quote]Is it immoral to support bands that do immoral things? (sex, drugs, support pro-choice)[/quote] Right there, you are telling me what is immoral in your examples. If I don't find these things immoral personally, I wouldn't have a heavy conscience for supporting them. So yes and no.

[quote]Do Jet or Incubus fit into any of these catagories??[/quote]
I'm not an expert on either band, but if they have one song as above that I disagree with, I'm not going to disregard them totally.

Posted (edited)

While I feel to do you justice, I'd have to have one long post, I'll make it easier on whosoever wants to read this by being to the point. I can do follow up questions...

[quote]Is it immoral to listen to bands that have immoral Lyrics?[/quote]

If you are still asking this question, are you really heading towards Christ, or are you putting one foot in, and one foot out? Any type of music that is against morality seeps into your mind, and the values imposed in the music become common place to you. Weather you want them to or not, they register in your mind (subconciously mostly). When evil has a place in your heart/mind, you are open for enslavement under the devil, and his demons. Imagine this, you go to a porn site, and those images register. You may have no intention of lusting while at the sight, you may have no intention to even remember this stuff, but this maybe your strongest impression of sex, and on your marriage night, it maybe all you know. Same for this music, you may listen to it, and even if the song calls you to be angry, resentful, unkind, or it calls you to do drugs, and you don't do any of these things, it has regestered in your mind. If you are in a situation described by a song, you may find it difficult to resist, because this is the strongest influence in that area of your life.

[quote]Is it immoral to cover songs with immoral Lyrics? (example - "baby got back")[/quote]

I have no idea what "covering songs" is, so I won't try to respond, but I wouldn't mind someone telling me.

[quote]Is it immoral to support bands that sing immoral songs? (buy CD, go to concert)[/quote]

Is it immoral to support a satanist group? This is nearly the same question. You are asking if it is wrong to support evil. I am sure this one need not be answered. You could replace "bands" and "immoral songs" with any evil. Abortion, adultry, homosexual acts, perjury. I don't need to go on. This question answers itself.

[quote]Is it immoral to support bands that do immoral things? (sex, drugs, support pro-choice)[/quote]

Again, is it wrong to support John Kerry who supports abortion (immoral things). This question answers itself. Another way to look at it is if you were to ask yourself, would it be RIGHT to support bands that do immoral things? I am sure you know this answer.

[quote]
Do Jet or Incubus fit into any of these catagories??[/quote]

Incubus has been talked about. I will say Jet is also immoral. With such songs such as "Cold heart B****" you mary realize the immorality. (Sample lyrics)

Cold hard *****
Just a kiss on the lips
And I was on my knees
I'm waiting give me
Cold hard *****
She was shakin' her hips
And I that was all that I need
I'm waiting give me
Cold hard *****
Just a kiss on the lips
And I was on my knees

There is cursing, and the sexual references are obvious, and fornification screams from these lyrics. I looked through the other stuff, it isn't so bad. I would consider this to be a step up from such bands as Incubus. If it hard to give up immoral music, listen to this stuff, then slowly remove it as well. I wouldn't call this band immoral because of a single song, but I tell you what, it is as close as you can get without crossing over. It is not something you'd listen to as you grow in spiritual life, when you(not you in particular) stop shooting for the thintgs that are acceptable, and start leaning towards things that are rewardable in the life after this one.

Sorry for the lengthy post. Anyways, my main tip to you is to get both feet in when following Christ, because it seems your having trouble saying goodbye to this music, and it does you no good. The best way to give it up, is to just do it.

God bless,

Mikey

Edited by MichaelFilo
Posted

Bump (semi Good topic)

God bless,

Mikey

gopherball33
Posted

I like two Incubus songs, "Drive" and "Megalomaniac"
I don't think the lyrics are that bad at all for Drive:

Sometimes, I feel the fear of uncertainty stinging clear
And I can't help but ask myself how much
I'll let the fear take the wheel and steer.
It's driven me before, and it seems to have a vague,
haunting mass appeal.
But lately I'm beginning to find that I
should be the one behind the wheel.

Whatever tomorrow brings,
I'll be there with open arms and open eyes, Yeah
Whatever tomorrow brings, I'll be there..I'll be there.

So, if I decide to waiver my chance to be one of the hive
Will I choose water over wine and hold my own and drive?
Aah-ah-oo-o-o.

It's driven me before and it seems to be the way
that everyone else gets around.
But lately I'm beginning to find that when
I drive myself my light is found.

Whatever tomorrow brings,
I'll be there with open arms and open eyes, Yeahhh
Whatever tomorrow brings, I'll be there...I'll be there.

Would you choose water over wine....hold the wheel and drive?

Whatever tomorrow brings,
I'll be there with open arms and open eyes, Yeah
Whatever tomorrow brings, I'll be there..I'll be there.
Do do do do do do do do




Megalomaniac isn't too bad except for the three f-bombs, I think:
I hear you on the radio
You permeate my screen, its' unkind but
If I met you in a scissor fight
I'd cut off both your wings on principle alone
On principle alone

Hey megalomaniac
You're no Jesus
Yeah, you're no f****** Elvis
Special, as you know yourself
Baby, just step down, step down

If I were your appendages
I'd hold open your eyes
So you would see
That all of us are heaven sent
There was never meant to be only one
To be only one

Hey megalomaniac
You're no Jesus
Yeah, you're no f****** Elvis
Special, as you know yourself
Baby, just step down, step down

Yeah
You're no Jesus
You're no Elvis
...
You're no answer

Hey megalomaniac
You're no Jesus
Yeah, you're no f****** Elvis
Special, as you know yourself
Just step down


Would I be ok sticking with these two?

gopherball33
Posted

Is it REALLY bad to listen to songs bands that fit into a category above? I mean no the satanic stuff. I wouldn't touch that with a pole. But stuff like Blink-182 or The Strokes or Outkast.

Posted

You have to realize, as I mentioned above, you aren't looking for "what can I get away with?" but instead, "what is spiritually good for me". So by the way you ask the questions alone, I'd say no, those songs are NOT ok. That response itself may not be satasifactory, so read on.

The first one conveys a good message, and isn't really too bad at all. I don't know about the actual beats (this alone can be ALOT worse then the lyrics).

The second song however, convey's no good message, but instead is a song about hate. It makes another person seem like less. The line with Jesus and then Elvis, shows a comparison between the two, even if it isn't said outright. I'd say, stear cleer of that one. It would fit into the "what can I get away with category".

My point is, if your asking the questions to see what you can get away with, than that is enough to say both are wrong. Why is that? Because you are looking for, not what can you listen to so that you may grow in the love of Jesus, but what can you llistn to so that it doesn't hurt your relationship with Jesus, and how you act daily.

However, if you never asked the question, I'd say no to the second song, the first is acceptable.

God bless,

Mikey

geetarplayer
Posted

gopher, I'd drop Blink 182 and Outkast if I were you. I don't know about the Strokes, I haven't really ever listened to them.

-Mark

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...