Icthus, When Where You Catholic?

[ironmonk]

Please show us some posts that show you believed what the Catholic Church taught, because all I can remember is you posting is that you had some crisis of faith.

And with you posting attacks against basic Catholic teachings, which are grossly wrong... I find it hard to believe that you where Catholic, and I need you to affirm it, as I'm sure others here too would be interested.


Afterward, please take the challenge to prove the Church wrong.

God Bless,
ironmonk

Edited August 26, 2004 by ironmonk

[ironmonk]

After a look at all the posts on this board... you were calling parts of the CCC heresy since the day you signed up on this board.

I think you've been "playing Catholic". I could be wrong, but I doubt it... it would be nice if we could see the old board posts. Seeing that mustbenothing has been on this one longer than you... I could easily see some scheming going on.

Stuff you are saying just isn't adding up.

The end does not justify the means... Acting Catholic to get Catholics out of the Church with "Crisis of faith" posts doesn't work.


God Bless,
ironmonk

[Justified Saint]

A wolf in sheep's clothing? Sounds likely

[Apotheoun]

I didn't vote in the poll, because I only joined Phatmass on June 8th, and since I haven't looked at all of ICTHUS' posts prior to that time, I don't know whether he was genuinely Catholic or not. But I don't really see why he would pose as a Catholic, since up till now he hasn't made a very convincing argument for the theology of John Calvin. It seems rather counterproductive if you think about it. Overall, I have to say that I like ICTHUS, but he does appear to be a very theologically confused person. Hopefully, he will continue to seek out the truth, and God willing, find it.

[cmotherofpirl]

This thread is closed since the entire premise is uncharitable.