Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Proper Exegisi Of These Verses?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Rom 10:13

basically all of the verses used from this chapter to support assurance of salvation...thanks.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Dude! St. Moses the Black rocks!! que padre! :)

About Romans 10, I have seen some great online commentaries that examine the text in great detail (from an objective standpoint) and the results are Catholic. I do not have my favorites because I'm on a public internet thing, but maybe someone else knows what I'm talking about.

Peace.

Posted

Oh I have no doubt it supports the catholic viewpoint I just need them for an email Im writing.

Posted (edited)

i've been looking for some catholic commentary. here's the homilies of St. John Chrysostom on Rom 10:[list]
[*][u][b]HOMILY XVII: ROM. X. 1.[/b][/u]

"Brethren, my heart's desire and prayer to God for them is, that they might
be saved."

HE is now going again to rebuke them more vehemently than before.(*)
Wherefore he again does away with every suspicion of hatred, and makes a
great effort beforehand to correct misapprehension. Do not then, he says,
mind words or accusations, but observe that it is not in any hostile spirit
that I say this. For it is not likely that the same person should desire
their salvation, and not desire it only, but even pray for it, and yet
should also hate them, and feel aversion to them. For here he calls his
exceeding desire, and the prayer which he makes (eudoki'an), "heart's
desire." For it is not the being freed from punishment only, but that they
may also be saved, that he makes so great a point of, and prays for. Nor is
it from this only, but also from the sequel that he shows the good- will
that he hath towards them. For from what is open to him, as far as he can,
he forces his way, and is contentious to find out some shadow at least of
an excuse for them. And he hath not the power, being overcome by the nature
of the facts.

[b]Ver. 2. "For I bear them record," says he, " that they have a zeal of
God, but not according to knowledge."[/b]

Ought not this then to be a ground for pardoning and not for accusing
them? For if it is not of man[1] that they are separated, but through zeal,
they deserved to be pitied rather than punished. But observe how adroitly
he favors them in the word, and yet shows their unseasonable obstinacy.

[b]Ver. 3. "For they being ignorant," he says, "of God's righteousness."[/b]

Again the word would lead to pardon. But the sequel to stronger
accusation, and such as does away with defence of any kind.

"And going about," he says, "to establish their own righteousness, have
not submitted themselves unto the righteousness of God.

And these things he says to show, that it was from a petulancy and love
of power that they erred, rather than from ignorance, and that not even
this righteousness from the deeds of the Law did they establish. (Matt.
xxi. 38; John. xii. 19, 42.) For saying "going about to establish" is what
one would do to show this. And in plain words indeed he has not stated this
(for he has not said, that they fell short of both righteousnesses), but he
has given a hint of it in a very judicious manner, and with the wisdom so
befitting him. For if they are still "going about" to establish that, it is
very plain that they have not yet established it. If they have not
submitted themselves to this, they have fallen short of this also. But he
calls it their "own righteousness," either because the Law was no longer of
force, or because it was one of trouble and toil. But this he calls God's
righteousness, that from faith, because it comes entirely from the grace
from above, and because men are justified in this case, not by labors, but
by the gift of God. But they that evermore resisted the Holy Ghost, and
vexatiously tried to be justified by the Law, came not over to the faith.
But as they did not come over to the faith, nor receive the righteousness
thereupon ensuing, and were not able to be justified by the Law either,
they were thrown out of all resources.

[b]Ver. 4. "For Christ is the end of the Law for righteousness to every
one that believeth.[/b]

See the judgment of Paul. For as he had spoken of a righteousness, and
a righteousness, lest they of the Jews which believed should seem to have
the one but be excluded from the other, and to be accused of lawlessness
(for even these there was no less cause to fear about as being still newly
come in), and lest Jews should again expect to achieve it, and should say,
Though we have not at present fulfilled it, yet we certainly will fulfil
it, see what ground he takes. He shows that there is but one righteousness,
and that has its full issue[2] in this, and that he that hath taken to
himself this, the one by faith, hath fulfilled that also. But he that
rejects this, falls short as well of that also. For if Christ be "the end
of the Law," he that hath not Christ, even if he seem to have that
righteousness, hath it not. But he that hath Christ, even though he have
not fulfilled the Law aright, hath received the whole. For the end of the
physician's art is health. As then he that can make whole, even though he
hath not the physician's art, hath everything; but he that knows not how to
heal, though he seem to be a follower of the art, comes short of
everything: so is it in the case of the Law and of faith. He that hath this
hath the end of that likewise, but he that is without this is an alien from
both. For what was the object of the Law? To make man righteous. But it had
not the power, for no one fulfilled it. This then was the end of the Law
and to this it looked throughout, and for this all its parts were made, its
feasts, and commandments, and sacrifices, and all besides, that man might
be justified. But this end Christ gave a fuller accomplishment of through
faith.(*) Be not then afraid, he says, as if transgressing the Law in
having come over to the faith. For then dost thou transgress it, when for
it thou dost not believe Christ. If thou believest in Him, then thou hast
fulfilled it also, and much more then it commanded. For thou hast received
a much greater righteousness. Next, since this was an assertion, he again
brings proof of it from the Scriptures.

[b]Ver. 5. "For Moses," he says, "describeth the righteousness which is of
the Law."[/b]

What he means is this. Moses showeth us the righteousness ensuing from
the Law, what sort it is of, and whence. What sort is it then of, and what
does it consist in? In fulfilling the commandments. "He (R. T. the man),
that doeth these things," He says, "shall live by (or in), them." (Lev.
xviii. 5.) And there is no other way of becoming righteous in the Law save
by fulfilling the whole of it. But this has not been possible for any one,
and therefore this righteousness has failed them. (diape'ptwken). But tell
us, Paul, of the other righteousness also, that which is of grace. What is
that then, and of what does it consist? Hear the words in which he gives a
clear sketch of it. For after he had refuted[1] the other, he next goes on
to this, and says,

[b]Ver. 6, 7, 8, 9. "But the righteousness which is of faith speaketh on
this wise, Say not in thine heart, Who shall ascend into heaven (that is,
to bring Christ down from above): or, Who shall descend into the deep?
(that is, to bring up Christ again from the dead.) But what saith it? The
word is nigh thee, even in thy mouth, and in thy heart, that is, the word
of faith which we preach. That if thou shalt confess with thy mouth the
Lord Jesus, and shalt believe in thine heart that God hath raised Him from
the dead, thou shall be saved.[/b]

To prevent the Jews then from saying, How came they who had not found
the lesser righteousness to find the greater? he gives a reason there was
no answering, that this way was easier than that. For that requires the
fulfilment of all things (for when thou doest all, then thou shall live):
but the righteousness which is of faith doth not say this, but what? "It
thou confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and believe in thy heart that
God hath raised Him from the dead, thou shalt be saved." Then again that we
may not seem to be making it contemptible by showing it to be easy and
cheap?[2] observe how he expands his account of it. For he does not come
immediately to the words just given, but what does he say? "But the
righteousness which is of faith saith on this wise; Say not in thine heart,
Who shall go up into heaven? (that is, to bring Christ down); or, Who shall
descend into the deep? (that is, to bring up Christ again from the dead.")
For as to the virtue manifested in works there is opposed a listlessness,
which relaxeth our labors,[3] and it requireth a very wakeful soul not to
yield to it: thus, when one is required to believe, there are reasonings
which confuse and make havoc of the minds of most men, and it wants a soul
of some vigor to shake them thoroughly off. And this is just why he brings
the same before one. And as he did in Abraham's case, so he does here also.
For having there shown that he was justified by faith, lest he should seem
to have gotten so great a crown by a mere chance, as if it were a thing of
no account, to extol the nature of faith, he says, "Who against hope
believed in hope, that he might become the father of many nations. And
being not weak in faith, he considered his own body now dead, and the
deadness of Sarah's womb. He staggered not at the promise of God through
unbelief; but was strong in faith, giving glory to God; and being fully
persuaded that what He had promised He was able also to perform" (Rom. iv.
18-21): so he showed that there is need of vigor, and a lofty soul, that
takes in things beyond expectation, and stumbles not at appearances. This
then he does here also, and shows that it requires a wise mind, and a
spirit heavenly (Gr. heaven-reaching) and great. And he does not say
merely, "Say not," but, "Say not in thine heart," that is, do not so much
as think of doubting and saying with thyself, And how can this be? You see
that this is a chief characteristic of faith, to leave all the
consequences[4] of this lower world, and so to seek for that which is above
nature, and to cast out the feebleness of calculation, and so to accept
everything from the Power of God. The Jews, however, did not merely assert
this, but that it was not possible to be justified by faith. But himself
turns even what had taken place to another account, that having shown the
thing to be so great, that even after it had taken place it required faith,
he might seem with good reason to bestow a crown on these: and he uses the
words which are found in the Old Testament, being always at pains to keep
quite clear of the charges of love of novelties, and of opposition to it.
For this, which he here says of faith, Moses says to them of the
commandment,[1] so showing that they had enjoyed at God's hand a great
benefit. For there is no need to say, he means, that one must go up to
heaven, or cross a great sea, and then receive the commandments, but things
so great and grand hath God made of easy access to us. And what meaneth the
phrase, "The Word is nigh thee?" That is, It is easy. For in thy mind and
in thy tongue is thy salvation. There is no long journey to go, no seas to
sail over, no mountains to pass, to get saved. But if you be not minded to
cross so much as the threshold, you may even while you sit at home be
saved. For "in thy mouth and in thy heart" is the source of salvation. And
then on another score also he makes the word of faith easy, and says, that
"God raised Him from the dead." For just reflect upon the worthiness of the
Worker, and you will no longer see any difficulty in the thing. That He is
Lord then, is plain from the resurrection. And this he said at the
beginning even of the Epistle. "Which was declared to be the Son of God
with power ... by the resurrection from the dead." (Rom. i. 4.) But that
the resurrection is easy too, has been shown even to those who are very
unbelieving, from the might of the Worker of it. Since then the
righteousness is greater, and light and easy to receive, is it not a sign
of the utmost contentiousness to leave what is light and easy, and set
about impossibilities? For they could not say that it was a thing they
declined as burdensome. See then how he deprives them of all excuse. For
what do they deserve to have said in their defence, who choose what is
burdensome and impracticable, and pass by what is light, and able to save
them, and to give them those things which the Law could not give? All this
can come only from a contentious spirit, which is in a state of rebellion
against God. For the Law is galling (epachthh`s), but grace is easy. The
Law, though they dispute never so much, does not save; Grace yieldeth the
righteousness resulting from itself, and that from the Law likewise. What
plea then is to rescue them, since they are disposed to be contentious
against this, but cling to that to no purpose whatever? Then, since he had
made a strong assertion, he again confirms it from the Scripture.
[*]

[b]Ver. 11-13. "For the Scripture saith, "he proceeds, "Whosoever
believeth on Him, shall not be ashamed. For there is no difference between
the Jew and the Greek; for the same Lord over all is rich unto all that
call upon Him. For whosoever shall call upon the Name of the Lord shall be
saved."[/b]

You see how he produces witnesses, whether to the faith, or to the
confession of it. For the words, "Every one that believeth," point out the
faith. But the words, "Whosoever shall call upon," set forth confession.
Then again to proclaim the universality of the grace, and to lay their
boasting low, what he had before demonstrated at length, he here briefly
recalls to their memory, showing again that there is no difference between
the Jew and the uncircumcised. "For there is," he says, "no difference
between the Jew and the Greek." And what he had said about the Father, when
he was arguing this point, that he says here about the Son. For as before
he said in asserting this, "Is He the God of the Jews only? Is He not of
the Gentiles also? Yes, of the Gentiles also: seeing it is one God" (Rom.
iii. 29, 30):--So he says here also, "For the same Lord over all is rich
unto all (and upon all)." (Rom. iii. 22.) You see how he sets Him forth as
exceedingly desiring our salvation, since He even reckons this to be riches
to Himself; so that they are not even now to despair, or fancy that,
provided they would repent, they were unpardonable. For He who considereth
it as riches[2] to Himself to save us, will not cease to be rich. Since
even this is riches, the fact of the gift being shed forth unto all. For
since what distresseth him the most was, that they, who were in the
enjoyment of a prerogative over the whole world, should now by the faith be
degraded front these thrones, and be no wit better off than others, he
brings the Prophets in constantly as foretelling, that they would have
equal honor with them. "For whosoever," he says, "believeth on Him shall
not be ashamed" (Is. xxviii. 16); and, "Whosoever shall call upon the Name
of the Lord shall be saved." (Joel ii. 32.) And the "whosoever" is put in
all cases, that they might not say aught in reply. But there is nothing
worse than vainglory. For it was this, this most especially, which proved
their ruin. Whence Christ also said to them, "How can ye believe, which
receive glory one of another, and seek not the glory which cometh of God
only?" (John v. 44.) This, with ruin, exposes men also to much ridicule and
before the punishment in the other world involves them in ills unnumbered
in this. And if it seem good, that you may learn this clearly, leaving for
the present the heavens which that puts us out of, and the hell which it
thrusts us into, let us investigate the whole matter as here before us.
What then can be more wasteful than this? what more disgraceful, or more
offensive? For that this disorder is a wasteful one is plain from the
people who spend to no purpose whatsoever on theatres horse-races, and
other such irrelevant expenditures: from those that build the fine and
expensive houses, and fit up everything in a useless style of extravagance,
on which I must not enter in this discourse. But that a person diseased in
this way must needs be extravagant, and expensive, and rapacious, and
covetous, anybody can see. For that he may have food to give the brute, he
thrusteth his hand into the substance of others. And why do I talk of
substance? It is not money only but souls also that this fire devoureth,
and it worketh not death here only, but also hereafter. For vanity is the
mother of hell, and greatly kindleth that fire, and the venomous worm. One
may see that it hath power even over the dead. And what can be worse than
this? For the other passions are put an end to by death, but this even
after death shows its force, and strives to display its nature even in the
dead corpse. For when men give orders on their death-bed to raise to them
fine monuments, which will waste all their substance, and take pains to lay
out beforehand a vast extravagance in their funeral, and in their lifetime
insult the poor that come to them for a penny and a single loaf, but when
they are dead give a rich banquet to the worm, why seek any more exorbitant
thraldom to the disease? From this mischief also irregular loves are
conceived. For there are many whom it is not the beauty of the appearance,
nor the desire of lying with her, but the wish to boast that "I have made
conquest of such an one," hath even drawn into adultery. And why need I
mention the other mischiefs that spring of this? For I had rather be long
(3 Mss. dihnekw^s) the slave of ten thousand savages, than of vanity once.
For even they do not put such commands upon their captives, as this vice
lays upon its votaries. Because it says, Be thou every one's slave, be he
nobler or be he lower than thyself. Despise thy soul, neglect virtue, laugh
at freedom, immolate thy salvation, and if thou doest any good thing, do it
not to please God, but to display it to the many, that for these things
thou mayest even lose thy crown. And if thou give alms, or if thou fast,
undergo the pains, but take care to lose the gain. What can be more cruel
than these commands? Hence grudging beareth sway, hence haughtiness, hence
covetousness, the mother of evils. For the swarm of domestics, and the
black servants liveried in gold, and the hangers on, and the flatterers,
and the silver-tinselled chariots, and the other absurdities greater than
these, are not had for any pleasure's sake or necessity, but for mere
vanity. Yes, one will say, but that this affliction is an evil, anybody can
see; but how we are to keep quite clear of it, this is what you should tell
us. Well then, in the first place, if you persuade yourself that this
disorder is a baneful one, you will have made a very good beginning towards
correcting it. For when a man is sick, he speedily sends for the physician,
if he be first made acquainted with the fact that he is sick. But if thou
seekest for another way besides to escape from hence, look to God
continually, and be content with glory from Him; and if thou find the
passion tickling thee, and stirring thee to tell thy well-doings to thy
fellow-servants, bethink thyself next, that after telling them thou gainest
nothing. Quench the absurd desire, and say to thy soul, Lo, thou hast been
so long big with thy own well-doings to tell them, and thou hast not had
the courage to keep them to thyself, but hast blabbed them out to all. What
good then hast thou gotten from this? None at all, but loss to the utmost,
and avoidance of all that had been gathered together with much labor. And
besides this, consider another thing also, which is, that most men's
opinion is perverted, and not perverted only, but that it withers away so
soon. For supposing they do admire you for the time, when the occasion has
gone by they will have forgotten it all, and have taken away from thee the
crown God had given, and have been unable to secure to thee that from
themselves. And yet if this were abiding, it were a most miserable thing to
exchange that for this. But when even this hath gone, what defence shall we
be able to make for betraying the abiding one for the sake of the unabiding
one, for losing such blessings for the sake of credit with a few? And
indeed even if they who praise were numerous, even for this they were to be
pitied, and the more so the more numerous those who do it. But if thou art
surprised at what I have said, hear Christ giving His sentence in this way,
"Woe unto you, when all men speak well of you." (Luke vi. 26.) And so
indeed it should seem. For if in every art you look to the workmen
(dhmiourgous) in it to be judges of it, how come you to trust the proving
of virtue to the many, and not most of all to Him Who knoweth it more
surely then any, and is best able to applaud[1] and to crown it? This
saying then, let us inscribe both on our walls and our doors and our mind,
and let us keep constantly saying to ourselves, "Woe unto us, when all men
speak well of us." For even they that so speak slander one afterward as a
vain person, and fond of honor, and covetous of their good word. But God
doeth not so. But when He seeth thee coveting the glory that cometh of Him,
then He will praise thee most, and respect (thauma'setai om. in most Mss.)
thee, and proclaim thee conqueror. Not so man; but, when he finds thee
slavish instead of free, by gratifying thee often by bare words with false
praise, he snatches from thee thy true meed, and makes thee more of a
menial than a purchased slave. For those last men get to obey them after
their orders, but thou even without orders makest thyself a slave. For thou
dost not even wait to hear something from them, but if thou merely knowest
wherein thou mayest gratify them, even without their command thou doest
all. What hell then should we not deserve, for giving the wicked pleasure,
and courting their service before they give orders, while we will not
hearken to God, even when He every day commands and exhorts us? And yet if
thou art covetous of glory and praise, avoid the praise that cometh of men,
and then thou wilt attain to glory. Turn aside from fair speeches, and then
thou wilt obtain praises without number both from God and from men. For
there is no one we are used to give so much glory to, as the man who looks
down upon glory, or to praise and respect so much as the man who thinks
scorn of getting respected and praised. And if we do so, much more will the
God of the universe. And when He glorifieth thee and praiseth thee, what
man can be more justly pronounced blessed? For there is not a greater
difference between glory and disgrace, than between the glory from above
and that of men. Or rather, there is a much greater, aye an infinite
difference. For if this, even when it does not get put beside any other, is
but a base and uncomely one, when we come to scrutinize it by the other's
side, just consider how great its baseness will be found to be! For as a
prostitute stands at her place[2] and lets herself out to any one, so are
they that be slaves of vanity. Or rather, these be more base than she. For
that sort of women do in many instances treat those enamoured of them with
scorn. But you prostitute yourself to everybody, whether runaway slaves, or
thieves, or cut-purses (for it is of these and such as these that the play-
houses that applaud you consist), and those whom as individuals you hold to
be nothing worth, when in a body, you honor more than your own salvation
and show yourself less worthy of honor than any of them. For how can you be
else than less worthy, when you stand in need of the good word of others,
and fancy that you have not enough by yourself, unless you receive the
glory that cometh of others? Do you not perceive, pray, beside what I have
said, that as you are an object of notice, and known to every body, if you
should commit a fault, you will have accusers unnumbered; but if unknown,
you will remain in security? Yes, a man may say, but then if I do well I
shall have admirers unnumbered. Now the fearful thing is, that it is not
only when you sin, but even when you do aright, that the disorder of vanity
does you mischief, in the former case subverting thousands, in the present
bereaving thee entirely of thy reward. It is then a sad thing, and replete
with disgrace of every kind, to be in love with glory even in civil
matters. But when even in spiritual you are in the same plight what excuse
is there left remaining for you, when you are not minded to yield God even
as much honor as you have yourself from your servants? For even the slave
"looketh to the eyes of his master" (Ps. cxxiii. 2), and the hireling to
his employer, who is to pay him wages, and the disciple to his master. But
you do just the contrary. Having left the God that hired thee, even thy
Master, thou lookest to thy fellow-servants; and this knowing that God
remembers thy well-doings even after this life, but man only for the
present. And when thou hast spectators assembled in Heaven, thou art
gathering together spectators upon earth. And where the wrestler struggles,
there he would be honored; but thou, while thy wrestling is above, art
anxious to gain thee a crown below. And what can be worse than madness like
this? But let us look, if it seem proper, at the crowns also. For one is
formed by haughtiness, and a second by grudging against another, and a
third by dissimulation and flattery, another again by wealth, and another
by servile obsequiousness. And like as children at their childish play put
crowns of grass upon one another, and many a time laugh at him that is
crowned behind his back; thus now also they that pass their praises upon
thee, many a time joke by themselves at their putting the grass upon us.
And would it were grass only! But now the crown is laden with much
mischief, and ruins all our well-doings. Taking then the vileness of it
into consideration, flee from the damage entailed. For how many would you
have to praise you? A hundred? or twice, or thrice, or four times as many?
Or rather, if you please, put them at ten times or twenty times as many,
and let there be two or four thousand, or if you will, even ten thousand to
applaud you. Still these be no better than so many daws cawing from above.
Or rather taking the assemblage of the angels into consideration, these
will seem more vile than even worms, and their good word of not so much
solidity as a cobweb, or a smoke, or a dream. Hear then how Paul, who saw
through these things thoroughly, is so far from seeking after them, that he
even deprecates them, in the words "But God forbid that I should glory,
save in the cross of Christ." (Gal. vi. 14.) This glory then be thou also
emulous of, that thou mayest not provoke the Master, because in so doing
thou art insulting God, and not thyself alone. For if thou even wert a
painter, and hadst some pupil, and he were to omit showing thee his
practice of the art, but set forth his painting publicly just to any body
that chanted to observe it, thou wouldest not take it quietly. But if this
even with thy fellow-servants were an insult, how much more with the
Master! But if you have a mind to learn on other grounds to feel scorn for
the thing, be of a lofty mind, laugh at appearances, increase thy love of
real glory, be filled with a spiritual temper, say to thy soul as Paul did,
"Knowest thou not that we shall judge angels?" (1 Cor. vi. 3) and having by
this roused it up, go on to rebuke it, and say, Thou that judgest the
angels, wilt thou let thyself be judged of off-scourings, and be praised
with dancers, and mimics, and gladiators, and horse-drivers? For these men
do follow after applause of this sort. But do thou poise thy wing high
above the din of these, and emulate that citizen of the wilderness, John,
and learn how he was above regarding the multitude, and did not turn him to
look at flatterers, but when he saw all the dwellers in Palestine poured
forth about him, and wondering, and astonished at him, he was not puffed up
with such honor as this, but rose up against them, and discoursing to his
great concourse as if to one youth, he thus rebuked them and said, "Ye
serpents, ye generation of vipers!" (Matt. iii. 7.) Yet it was for him that
they had run together, and left the cities, in order to see that holy
personage, and still none of these things unnerved him. For he was far
above glory, and free from all vanity. So also Stephen, when he saw the
same people again, not honoring him, but mad upon him, and gnashing their
teeth, being lifted above their wrath, said, "Ye stiff-necked and
uncircumcised in heart." (Acts vii. 51.) Thus also Elias, when those armies
were present, and the king, and all the people, said, "How long halt ye
upon both your hips?" (1 Kings xviii. 21, LXX. true sense of "halt.") But
we flatter all, court all, with this servile obsequiousness buying their
honor. Wherefore all things are turned upside down, and for this favor[1]
the business of Christianity is betrayed, and everything neglected for the
opinion of the generality. Let us then banish this passion, and then we
shall have a right notion of liberty, and of the haven, and the calm. For
the vain man is ever like persons in a storm, trembling, and fearing, and
serving a thousand masters. But he that is clear of this thraldom, is like
men in havens, enjoying a liberty untainted. Not so that person, but as
many acquaintances as he has, so many masters has he, and he is forced to
be a slave to all of them. How then are we to get free from this hard
bondage? It is by growing enamoured of another glory, which is really
glory. For as with those that are enamoured of persons, the sight of some
handsomer one doth by its being seen take them off from the first: so with
those that court the glory which cometh from us men, the glory from heaven,
if it gleameth on them, has power to lead them off from this. Let us then
look to this, and become thoroughly acquainted with it, that by feeling
admiration of its beauty, we may shun the hideousness of the other, and
have the benefit of much pleasure by enjoying this continually. Which may
we all attain to by the grace and love toward man, etc.

[u][b]HOMILY XVIII: ROM. X. 14, 15.[/b][/u]

"How then shall they call on Him in Whom they have not believed? and how
shall they believe in Him of Whom they have not heard? and how shall they
hear without a preacher? and how shall they preach except they be sent? as
it is written."

HERE again he takes from them all excuse. For since he had said, "I
bear them record that they have a zeal of God, but not according to
knowledge," and that "being ignorant of God's righteousness, they submitted
not themselves" to it: he next shows, that for this ignorance itself they
were punishable before God. This he does not say indeed so, but he makes it
good by carrying on his discourse in the way of question, and so convicting
them more clearly, by framing the whole passage out of objections and
answers. But look further back. The Prophet, saith he, said, "Whosoever
shall call upon the Name of the Lord shall be saved." Now somebody might
say perhaps, "But how could they call upon Him Whom they had not believed?
Then there is a question from him after the objection; And why did they not
believe? Then an objection again. A person certainly may say, And how could
they believe, since they had not heard? Yet hear they did, he implies. Then
another objection again. "And how could they hear without a preacher?" Then
an answer again. Yet preach they did, and there were many sent forth for
this very purpose. And whence does it appear that these are those persons
sent? Then he brings the prophet in next, who says, "How beautiful are the
feet of them that preach the Gospel of peace, and bring glad tidings of
good things!" (Is. iii. 7.) You see how by the kind of preaching he points
out the preachers. For there was nothing else that these men went about
telling everywhere, but those unspeakable good things, and the peace made
by God with men. And so by disbelieving, it is not we, he implies, whom you
disbelieve, but Isaiah the prophet, who spake many years ago, that we were
to be sent, and to preach, and to say what we do say. If the being saved,
then, came of calling upon Him, and calling upon Him from believing, and
believing from hearing, and hearing from preaching, and preaching from
being sent, and if they were sent, and did preach, and the prophet went
round with them to point them out, and proclaim them, and say that these
were they whom they showed of so many ages ago, whose feet even they
praised because of the matter of their preaching; then it is quite clear
that the not believing was their own fault only. And that because God's
part had been fulfilled completely.
[*]

[b]Ver. 16, 17. "But they have not all obeyed the Gospel. For Esaias
saith, Lord, who hath believed our report? So then faith cometh by hearing,
and hearing by the word of God." (ib. liii. 1.)[/b]

Since they pressed him with another objection again to this effect,
that if these were the persons sent upon the mission by God, all ought to
have hearkened to them: observe Paul's judgment, and see how he shows that
this very thing which made the confusion, did in fact do away with
confusion and embarrassment. What offends you, O Jew, he would say, after
so great and abundant evidence, and demonstration of the points? that all
did not submit to the Gospel? Why this very thing, when taken along with
the others, is of force to certify thee of the truth of my statements, even
in that some do not believe. For this too the prophet foretold Notice his
unspeakable wisdom too; how he shows more than they were looking for, or
expected him to have to say in reply. For what is it that you say? he
means. Is it that all have not believed the Gospel? Well! Isaiah foretold
this too from of old. Or rather, not this only, but even much more than
this. For the complaint you make is Why did not all believe? But Isaiah
goes further than this. For what is it he says? "Lord, who hath believed
our report? Then since he had rid himself of this embarrassment. by making
the Prophet a bulwark against them, he again keeps to the line he was
before upon. For as he had said that they must call upon Him, but that they
who call must believe, and they who believe must hear first, but they who
are to hear must have preachers, and the preachers be sent, and as he had
shown that they were sent, and had preached; as he is going to bring in
another objection again, taking occasion first of another quotation from
the Prophet, by which he had met the objection a little back, he thus
interweaves it, and connects it with what went before. For since he had
produced the Prophet as saying, "Lord, who hath believed our report"
(akoh(i)^)? he happily seizes on the quotation, as proving what he says,
"So then faith cometh by hearing" (akoh^s). And this he makes not a mere
naked statement. But as the Jews were forever seeking a sign, and the sight
of the Resurrection, and were gaping after the thing much; he says, Yet the
Prophet promised no such thing, but that it was by hearing that we were to
believe. Hence he makes this good first, and says, "so then faith cometh by
hearing." And then since this seemed a mean thing to say, see how he
elevates it. For he says, I was not speaking of mere hearing, nor of the
need of hearing men's words and believing them, t but I mean a great sort
of hearing. For the hearing is "by the word of God." They were not speaking
their own, but they were telling what they learnt from God. And this is a
higher thing than miracles. For we are equally bound to believe and to obey
God, whether speaking or working miracles.[1] Since both works and miracles
come of His words. For both the heaven and everything else was established
in this way. (Ps. xxxiii. 6-8.) After showing then that we ought to believe
the prophets, who always speak God's words, and not to look after anything
more, he proceeds next to the objection I mentioned, and says,

[b]Ver. 18. "But I say, Have they not heard?"[/b]

What, he means, if the preachers were sent, and did preach what they
were bid, and these did not hear? Then comes a most perfect reply to the
objection.

"Yes, verily, their sound went into all the earth, and their words unto
the ends of the world."[2]

What do you say? he means. They have not heard? Why the whole world,
and the ends of the earth, have heard. And have you, amongst whom the
heralds abode such a long time, and of whose land they were, not heard? Now
can this ever be? Sure if the ends of the world heard, much more must you.
Then again another objection.

[b]Ver. 19. "But I say, Did not Israel know?"[/b]

For what if they heard, he means, but did not know what was said, nor
understand that these were the persons sent? Are they not to be forgiven
for their ignorance? By no means. For Isaiah had described their character
in the words, "How beautiful are the feet of them that preach the Gospel of
peace." (Is. lii. 7.) And before him the Lawgiver himself. Hence he
proceeds.

"First Moses saith, I will provoke you to jealousy by them that are no
people, and by a foolish nation I will anger you. (Deut. xxxii. 21.)

And so they ought even from him to have been able to distinguish the
preachers, not from the fact of these disbelieving only, not from the fact
of their preaching peace, not from the fact of their bringing the glad
tidings of those good things, not from the word being sown in every part of
the world, but from the very fact of their seeing their inferiors, those of
the Gentiles, in greater honor. For what they had never heard, nor their
forefathers, that wisdom did these[3] on a sudden embrace
(hephiloso'phoun). And this was a mark of such intense honor, as should
gall them, and lead them to jealousy, and to recollection of the prophecy
of Moses, which said, "I will provoke you to jealousy by them that are no
people." For it was not the greatness of the honor alone that was enough to
throw them upon jealousy, but the fact too that a nation had come to enjoy
these things which was of so little account that it could hardly be
considered a nation at all. "For I will provoke you to jealousy, by them
which are no nation, and by a foolish nation will I anger you." For what
more foolish than the Greeks (Heathen, see pp. 373, 377)? or what of less
account? See how by every means God had given from of old indications and
clear signs of these times, in order to remove their blindness. For it was
not any little corner in which the thing was done, but in land, and in sea,
and in every quarter of the globe. And they saw those in the enjoyment of
countless blessings now, who had formerly been objects of their contempt.
One should consider then that this is that people of which Moses said, "I
will provoke you to jealousy by them that are no people, and by a foolish
nation will I anger you." Was it Moses only then that said this? No, for
Isaiah also after Him saith so. And this is why Paul said, "First Moses,"
to show that a second will come who says the same things in a clearer and
plainer way. As then he says above, that Esaias crieth, so too here.

[b]Ver. 20. "But Esaias is very bold, and saith."[/b]

Now what he means is something of this kind. He put a violence on
himself, and was ambitious to speak, not some thing veiled over, but to set
things even naked before your eyes, and choosing rather to run (Origen in
loc.) into dangers from being plain spoken, than by looking to his own
safety, to leave you any shelter for your impenetrableness; although it was
not the manner of prophecy to say this so clearly; but still to stop your
mouths most completely, he tells the whole beforehand clearly and
distinctly. The whole! what whole? Why your being cast out, and also their
being brought in; speaking as follows, "I was found of them that sought Me
not, I was made manifest of them that asked not after Me." (Is. lxv. 1.)
Who then are they that sought not? who they that asked not after Him?
Clearly not the Jews, but they of the Gentiles, who hitherto had not known
Him. As then Moses gave their characteristic mark in the words, "no people"
and "a foolish nation," so here also he takes the same ground to point them
out from, viz. their extreme ignorance. And this was a very great blame to
attach to the Jews, that they who sought Him not found Him, and they who
sought Him lost Him.

[b]Ver. 21. "But unto Israel He saith, All the day long have I stretched
forth My hands l unto a disobedient and gainsaying people." (Is. lxv. 2.)[/b]

Observe now that difficulty, which so many I make a subject of
question, is discovered laid up from of old in the words of the Prophet,
and with a clear solution to it too. And what is this? You heard Paul say
before. "What shall we say then? That the Gentiles which followed not after
righteousness have attained unto righteousness. But Israel which followed
after the law of righteousness hath not attained to the law of
righteousness." (Rom. ix. 30, 31.) This Esaias also says here. For to say,
"I was found of them that sought me not, I was made manifest unto them
which asked not after me," is the same with saying, "that the Gentiles
which followed not after righteousness have attained unto righteousness."
Then to show that what was happening was not of God's grace only, but also
of the temper of those who came to Him, as also the casting off of the
others came of the disputatiousness of those who disobeyed, hear what he
proceeds with. "But to Israel He saith, All the day long have I stretched
forth My hands to a disobedient and gainsaying people;" here meaning by the
day the whole period of the former dispensation. But the stretching out of
the hands, means calling and drawing[1] them to Him, and inviting them.
Then to show that the fault was all their own, he says "to a disobedient
and gainsaying people." You see what a great charge this is against them!
For they did not obey Him even when He invited them, but they gainsaid Him,
and that when they saw Him doing so, not once or twice or thrice, but the
whole period. But others who had never known Him, had the power to draw Him
to them. Not that he says they themselves had the power to do it, but to
take away lofty imaginings even from those of the Gentiles, and to show
that it was His grace that wrought the whole, He says, I was made manifest,
and I was found. It may be said, Were they then void of everything? By no
means, for the taking of the things found, and the getting a knowledge of
what was manifested to them, was what they contributed themselves.[2] Then
to prevent these saying, But why wast Thou not made manifest to us also? he
sets down what is more than this, that I not only was made manifest, but I
even continue with My hands stretched out, inviting them, and displaying
all the concern of an affectionate father, and a mother that is set on her
child. See how he has brought us a most lucid answer to all the
difficulties before raised, by showing that it was from their own temper
that ruin had befallen them, and that they are wholly undeserving of
pardon. For though they had both heard and understood what was said, still
not even then were they minded to come to Him. And what is far more, He did
not cause them to hear these things and to understand them only, but a
thing which hath more force to rouse them up and draw them to Him, when
they were disobedient and gain-saying, He added to the others. Now what is
this? It is His exasperating them, and making them jealous. For ye know the
domineering might of the passion, and how great the power is which jealousy
is naturally possessed of for bringing all disputatiousness to an end, and
rousing those who have grown remiss. And why need one say this of man when
in brutes without reason, and children before they are of full age, the
power it shows is so great? For a child often will not submit to its father
when it is called, but continues obstinate. But when another child has
notice taken of it, then it even though not called comes to its father's
bosom, and what calling could not do, provoking to jealousy will. This then
God also did. For He not only called and stretched out His hands, but
stirred up in them the feeling of jealousy also, by bringing those far
inferior to them (a thing which makes men excessively jealous) not into
their good things, but (what was a much stronger step, and makes the
feeling even more domineering,) into much greater good things, and of
greater necessity than theirs, and such as they had never even fancied in a
dream. But still they did not submit. What pardon then do they deserve who
exhibit such excessive obstinacy? None. Yet this he does not say himself,
but leaves it to the consciences of his hearers, to gather it from the
conclusion of what he had stated, and again also confirms it by what he
goes on to in his usual wisdom. And this he did also above, by introducing
objections both in the case of the Law (see on Rom. vii. 7, PP. 420, I) and
of the people, which presented an accusation beyond the true one; and then
in the answer, which was to overthrow this, yielding as much as he
pleased, and as the case allowed, so as to make what he was saying not
unwelcome. And this he doth here, writing as follows: Chap. xi. ver. 1 "I
say then, Hath God cast away His people whom He foreknew? God forbid."
[*]

And he introduces the form a person would use in doubt, as though
taking occasion from what had been said, and after making this alarming
statement, by the denial of it he causes the sequel to be allowed with
readiness; and what by all the former arguments he had been laboring to
show that he makes good here also. What then is this? That even if there be
but a few saved, the promise yet stands good. This is why he does not
merely say "people," but "people which He foreknew." Then proceeding with
the proof that the "people" were not cast off, "For I also am an Israelite,
of the seed of Abraham, of the tribe of Benjamin."

I, he says, the instructor, the preacher. Now since this seemed
contrary to what was said before in the words, "Who hath believed our
report ?" and, "All the day long have I stretched forth My hands to a
disobedient and gainsaying people;" and, "I will provoke you to jealousy by
them which are no people;" he was not satisfied with the deprecation, nor
with having said, "God forbid," but makes it good by taking it up again and
saying, "God hath not east away His people." But this is not a
confirmation, men may say, but an assertion. Observe then the confirmation,
both the first, and that which follows it. For the first is that he was
himself of that race. But He would not, if on the point of casting them
off, have chosen from them him to whom He entrusted all the preaching, and
the affairs of the world, and all mysteries, and the whole economy. This
then is one proof, but the next, after it, is his saying, that "people whom
He foreknew," that is, who He knew clearly were suited to it, and would
receive the faith. (Pococke on Hos. p. 23. See Acts ii. 41; iv. 4; xxi.
20.) For three, five, even ten thousand were believers from among them. And
so to prevent any from saying, Art thou the people, then? And because thou
hast been called, hath the nation been called? he proceeds.
[/list]
i'll keep looking.

pax christi,
phatcatholic

Edited by phatcatholic
Posted

this article comments on verses from Rom 10 as well as what Paul means by the words "saved" and "faith." basically we find that when Paul speaks of faith he means not a purely intellectual assent, but an [i]obedient [/i]faith. in this way, Rom 10 is more in line w/ catholic soterology then the protestant kind

--[url="http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/most/getwork.cfm?worknum=168"]"Saved" in Scripture[/url]

the articles in the [i]Salvation, Justification, and Predestination[/i] entry under the subheadings "Hope for Salvation vs. Assurance of Salvation" and "Faith and Works by Grace vs. Faith Alone" will drive this point home.

pax christi,
phatcatholic

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...