goldenchild17 Posted September 27, 2004 Author Posted September 27, 2004 But is he saying? I don't understand.
phatcatholic Posted September 27, 2004 Posted September 27, 2004 [quote name='goldenchild17' date='Sep 27 2004, 02:53 PM'] But is he saying? I don't understand. [/quote] go back thru this thread. i may have already answered your question
goldenchild17 Posted September 27, 2004 Author Posted September 27, 2004 Yeah, thanks. I'll try to study it more. I'm just confused I guess, about the ex operato thingy. I don't really understand it, or what arguments scripturally are made for it or against it. I'll keep reading though.
phatcatholic Posted September 27, 2004 Posted September 27, 2004 u should PM Apotheoun and see what he says i don't entirely understand it myself
goldenchild17 Posted September 29, 2004 Author Posted September 29, 2004 A couple things more... [quote]I still dont see why the sacraments necessarily are the only means of grace in the NT. They are appointed means, but why must they be the only appointed means? Why must God always work through them? Where has He claimed He would do so always?[/quote] I'm not sure I explained this very well. I was trying to talk about how God instituted the sacraments as a means of conferring His grace. [quote]Hmm, I am confused. If the sacraments automatically confer grace, regardless of the recepient, then why is it said that when the sacraments are "Celebrated worthily in faith, the sacraments confer the grace that they signify"? Why do the "fruits of the sacraments also depend on the disposition of the one who receives them"? [/quote] What about this?
phatcatholic Posted September 29, 2004 Posted September 29, 2004 [quote name='goldenchild17' date='Sep 29 2004, 01:38 PM']A couple things more... [quote]I still dont see why the sacraments necessarily are the only means of grace in the NT. They are appointed means, but why must they be the only appointed means? Why must God always work through them? Where has He claimed He would do so always?[/quote] I'm not sure I explained this very well. I was trying to talk about how God instituted the sacraments as a means of conferring His grace.[/quote] well, they are not the only means of grace, but they are the only [i][b]sure [/b][/i]means. for instance, God probably gives us actual grace when we pray for things. but, he doesn't always do this. he may not want to give us what we ask for, in which case we would not receive grace. but, how do we know if we have recieved it or not? often times we have to rely on our own subjective feelings, which can betray us. however, we know that w/o a shadow of a doubt, every single time we participate in a sacrament, we recieve his grace. no questions, no doubt, no reliance on my feelings. just a promise that he always keeps. [quote][quote]Hmm, I am confused. If the sacraments automatically confer grace, regardless of the recepient, then why is it said that when the sacraments are "Celebrated worthily in faith, the sacraments confer the grace that they signify"? Why do the "fruits of the sacraments also depend on the disposition of the one who receives them"?[/quote] What about this?[/quote] i am unsure..........
StColette Posted September 30, 2004 Posted September 30, 2004 [quote]Hmm, I am confused. If the sacraments automatically confer grace, regardless of the recepient, then why is it said that when the sacraments are "Celebrated worthily in faith, the sacraments confer the grace that they signify"? Why do the "fruits of the sacraments also depend on the disposition of the one who receives them"?[/quote] I'm not really sure what they are getting at, except maybe with the example of Communion. When we have sin upon us we are shut off from the graces of God, until we have confessed our sins and have become pure in heart once again. If you receive Communion with mortal sin upon your soul the graces within the Communion are not given to you and you are committing sacrilege.
goldenchild17 Posted October 1, 2004 Author Posted October 1, 2004 I am having difficulty with that last one. If the sacraments do automatically confer grace then isn't it contradictory to say that it depends on the disposition of the recipient.
StColette Posted October 1, 2004 Posted October 1, 2004 [quote name='goldenchild17' date='Oct 1 2004, 02:18 AM'] I am having difficulty with that last one. If the sacraments do automatically confer grace then isn't it contradictory to say that it depends on the disposition of the recipient. [/quote] Like I said, when we are in mortal sin we are cut off completely from God's graces, the sacraments themselves would still hold these graces but we would be unable to receive them because of the mortal sin upon us.
phatcatholic Posted October 1, 2004 Posted October 1, 2004 ok, here's my question: if i'm an adult convert to catholicism, and i'm going to be baptized, but i don't believe that my baptism will actually do anything..........will it still do something? will it still cleanse me of my sin? the answers to these questions essentially give goldenchild the answer he's looking for
goldenchild17 Posted October 1, 2004 Author Posted October 1, 2004 Yeah, that's what I'm looking for.
goldenchild17 Posted October 2, 2004 Author Posted October 2, 2004 This is just getting worse and worse. In quotes is my response, next is his reply. [quote]These are the only guaranteed means of grace. God can impart grace as He wishes, but these are the fundamental means and are for sure. Everything else isn't for sure. God can, if He wishes, give us actual grace say if we pray or something. But He doesn't need to. Through the sacraments we can KNOW that we are getting the grace that God promises. This assurance isn't there if we don't get these sacraments. If we don't have the sacraments how can we know that we are getting grace? This is something that has to rely on our emotions, our feelings. But with the sacraments there is absolutely no doubt that we are recieving grace, because this is their purpose. [/quote] What evidence do you have that God always gives salvation through baptism ex opere operato? [quote]I'm not sure the question. One doesn't recieve grace if they aren't in communion with God. If we are in mortal sin then we cannot take part in the sacraments until we have repented through confession. [/quote] So we don't know absolutely that we will receive grace through the sacraments. That's not what you said above.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now