phatcatholic Posted October 4, 2004 Posted October 4, 2004 pham, upon aluigi's request, i have decided to allow a unique type of debate to exist here. two catholics will pick a topic. one of them will take the catholic position and the other one will take the protestant position, and then they will both attempt to defend their side to the best of their ability. this means that if you take the protestant position, don't use this as an opportunity to make fun of protestant arguments or how they debate. take this seriously. i am allowing this b/c i see it as a unique learning opportunity. in particular, the one who takes the protestant position will have to do some serious research into why protestants believe what they do about a certain topic. of course, whoever takes the catholic position will need to be knowledgable of our side of the debate as well. also, i would ask that all "phishies" and non-catholics please refrain from participating in this exercise. if you feel the need to correct someone or you feel that one side or the other is being misrepresented, please PM the participant you wish to correct. if you engage their arguments here, it will turn into a different kind of debate, and i will have to close it. i am actually somewhat hesitant to allow this, but i find the idea intriguing so i am willing to see how it will work. i may take on the role of a moderator, chiming in with guidelines that will make this exercise more effective as a learning tool, if i feel the need. as a participant, please provide as many sources for your claims as possible, so that we can all learn from your research. now, who would like to participate? topic? let the chaos begin........ pax christi, phatcatholic
Guest Aluigi Posted October 4, 2004 Posted October 4, 2004 Hehe... sweet! I'd be interested in taking the protestant position, just to see how I can do. I ask whoever wants to take the Catholic position to pick the topic. This should be very very interesting
phatcatholic Posted October 4, 2004 Author Posted October 4, 2004 Since this is Aluigi's baby, so to speak, i would like for him to participate first. luigi, you can either wait for a catholic opponent or you can take the catholic position yourself and debate w/ applebeez on the preterist view of the end times. its ur call
franciscanheart Posted October 4, 2004 Posted October 4, 2004 I would like to try.... mind you I'm not that great with this stuff. I do humbly ask for permission to debate something. I'm not sure what though. Phat do you have any suggestions??
Fiat_Voluntas_Tua Posted October 4, 2004 Posted October 4, 2004 This seem's very interesting...but it would be futile in the end, because we all know where the Truth lies...but nonetheless it would be a good way to sharpen our swords of Apologetic's... Totus Tuus, Andy
phatcatholic Posted October 4, 2004 Author Posted October 4, 2004 [quote name='hugheyforlife' date='Oct 4 2004, 04:13 AM'] I would like to try.... mind you I'm not that great with this stuff. I do humbly ask for permission to debate something. I'm not sure what though. Phat do you have any suggestions?? [/quote] hughey, you need to pick the topic that you would be willing to debate. if i choose, i may pick one that you don't want to tackle. so far, applebeez has chosen the preterest view. you choose one. Fiat, you may want to choose one as well. then Aluigi can decide among the different topics which one he will engage.
Guest Aluigi Posted October 5, 2004 Posted October 5, 2004 Okay.. umm... i'm not quite sure about the whole preterist view thing... umm.. i donno... how about... The Eucharist. here i'll start off as if i'm protestant, and someone try to refute me and stuff, then i'll try to refute you, we'll go from there. Jesus spoke symbolically when He said "this is my body" and "this is my blood". He was clearly teaching them a lesson. the passover bread he was showing was the bread of affliction, He was merely telling them that He would have to suffer afflictions. He said the cup of salvation was His blood, so that when they saw His blood spilt, they would connect it with the passover covenant and understand why He died. It was a teaching metaphor, nothing more. He told them to do it in memory of Him, so they would be able to teach the other Jews about what Jesus' sacrifice meant as well. In fact, we need not even do the same thing anymore, because it has no significance to people in today's culture. it was meant to show them the ordinariness of faith, and the fulfillment of the passover. to show the ordinariness of faith today, we should eat cookies and drink milk. to teach the fulfillment of the passover, we should simply tell them the parallels between the Jewish passover and the sacrifice of Christ. only if today people were already well versed in the customs of the Passover service and ate bread and wine regularly would we need to still have a recreation of the Lord's Supper. refute me...
franciscanheart Posted October 5, 2004 Posted October 5, 2004 hey can i take this one?!?! and can we maybe start a different thread for it?? just a thought....
phatcatholic Posted October 5, 2004 Author Posted October 5, 2004 (edited) ok, the debate will be in this thread, since it is pinned. any discussion on the debate will be in the other thread that aluigi started. he has already given his opening statement here. hughey, it is your turn to reply, whenever you are ready. [b]note:[/b] everyone else, please refrain from posting in this thread. if you wish to say something to the participants, PM them or address it in the other thread that aluigi started. thank you and good luck to you both, phatcatholic Edited October 5, 2004 by phatcatholic
Guest Aluigi Posted October 6, 2004 Posted October 6, 2004 dude, if no one refutes me i'll havta refute myself, and that'd be out of charecter. someone refute me. (btw, I am 100% serious in the Protestant Argument that anything, milk/cookies, pizza/pop, can suffice to remember Christ as communion. see the other thread for an EXAMPLE of a REAL PROTESTANT using this argument)
phatcatholic Posted October 6, 2004 Author Posted October 6, 2004 waiting on hughey's response.......
franciscanheart Posted October 7, 2004 Posted October 7, 2004 sorry yall i sent it earlier.... dont know what happened. the file is on the school computer so ill send it again tomorrow.... sorry. didnt know it handt gone through!!
franciscanheart Posted October 9, 2004 Posted October 9, 2004 "‘I am the living bread which came down from heaven; if any one eats of this bread, he will live for ever; and the bread which I shall give for the life of the world is my flesh.’ The Jews then disputed among themselves, saying, ‘How can this man give us his flesh to eat? Truly, truly, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink his blood, you have no life in you; he who eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up at the last day. For my flesh is food indeed, and my blood is drink indeed. He who eats my flesh and drinks my blood abides in me, and I in him" (John 6:51–56). Jesus said it very bluntly – very directly. He said what He meant and He meant what He said. At other times Jesus would clarify that He was not speaking literally but metaphorically. Here there was no correction of thought. He said it and He meant what He said at face value. He even repeated Himself for greater emphasis!! In John 6:60 we read: "Many of his disciples, when they heard it, said, ‘This is a hard saying; who can listen to it?’" These were his disciples, people used to his remarkable ways. He warned them not to think carnally, but spiritually: "It is the Spirit that gives life, the flesh is of no avail; the words that I have spoken to you are spirit and life" (John 6:63; cf. 1 Cor. 2:12–14). Twelve times he said he was the bread that came down from heaven; four times he said they would have "to eat my flesh and drink my blood." John 6 was an extended promise of what would be instituted at the Last Supper—and it was a promise that could not be more explicit. Many assert that one can show Christ was speaking only metaphorically by comparing verses like John 10:9 ("I am the door") and John 15:1 ("I am the true vine"). The problem is that there is not a connection to John 6:35, "I am the bread of life." "I am the door" and "I am the vine" make sense as metaphors because Christ is like a door—we go to heaven through him—and he is also like a vine—we get our spiritual sap through him. But Christ takes John 6:35 far beyond symbolism by saying, "For my flesh is food indeed, and my blood is drink indeed" (John 6:55). He continues: "As the living Father sent me, and I live because of the Father, so he who eats me will live because of me" (John 6:57). The Greek word used for "eats" (trogon) is very blunt and has the sense of "chewing" or "gnawing." This is not the language of metaphor. Christ is alive and present in the Holy Eucharist. Jesus’s words were not meant to be symbolic therefore we do not take them that way. The Eucharist unites us as one with Christ. He meant for all to take part, not just his disciples at the Last Supper. We celebrate Mass in memory of the awesome sacrifice. We are one in Him through this specific aspect of the Mass!!
franciscanheart Posted October 9, 2004 Posted October 9, 2004 23 ¶ For I have received of the Lord that which also I delivered unto you, that the Lord Jesus, the same night in which he was betrayed, took bread, 24 And giving thanks, broke and said: Take ye and eat: This is my body, which shall be delivered for you. This do for the commemoration of me. 25 In like manner also the chalice, after he had supped, saying: This chalice is the new testament in my blood. This do ye, as often as you shall drink, for the commemoration of me. 26 For as often as you shall eat this bread and drink the chalice, you shall shew the death of the Lord, until he come. 27 Therefore, whosoever shall eat this bread, or drink the chalice of the Lord unworthily, shall be guilty of the body and of the blood of the Lord. 28 But let a man prove himself: and so let him eat of that bread and drink of the chalice. 29 For he that eateth and drinketh unworthily eateth and drinketh judgment to himself, not discerning the body of the Lord. 1 Cor 11:23-29
Guest Aluigi Posted October 11, 2004 Posted October 11, 2004 Typical Catholic response.. just throw out John chapter 6 as if it really means that. Jesus was not speaking literally, even though he used harsh language. Rabbis of the day were found of using HYPERBOLEs to get their point accross. In another instance, Jesus says that we should cut off our arms and legs. This is a hyperbole to illustrate the point that we should not want to go to hell. Eating Jesus' flesh is also a hyperbole to illustrate the point that we should accept his sacrifice to go to heaven. Unless you believe it necessary to literally cut off every limb in your body that causes you to sin, you should also not believe it necessary to literally eat Jesus' body and blood. His flesh being food indeed and his blood being drink indeed are metaphors. In that his flesh, which would be sacrificed, is like food. His blood, which would be poured out in sacrifice, is like drink. The sacrifice is what we must receive, gnaw on and savor, remember, and accept in order to be saved. Chewing and gnawing are very powerful (read: hyperbolic) metaphoric statements. To chew, gnaw, and savor the sacrifice of Christ does not require us to really eat his flesh and blood. Besides, many Eucharist-centered church members refuse to chew on the eucharist as it may be "disrespectful" or parts of "Christ's body" would get stuck to their teeth. St. Paul is reprobating those who acted bad at the breaking of the bread (which was just the Christian community coming together for a meal using common foods, bread wine and sometimes lamb or some other meat). He says they will be guilty of the body and blood of the Lord because they acted disrespectfully when everyone was suppose to be contemplating Christ's sacrifice of His body and blood. They weren't guilty of the body and blood of the Lord because they were literally defacing the literal physical body and blood, but rather because they weren't paying attention to the ideas, to the sacrifice. Christ wants us to eat a common meal and while eating think of how he is the food which really satisfies. He does not want us to worship bread and wine in church every sunday. He wants us to remember that he gave up his body and blood in sacrifice, He doesn't want us to LITERALLY [b]eat[/b] His body and blood.
franciscanheart Posted October 11, 2004 Posted October 11, 2004 [quote]Typical Catholic response.. just throw out John chapter 6 as if it really means that. Jesus was not speaking literally, even though he used harsh language. Rabbis of the day were found of using HYPERBOLEs to get their point accross. In another instance, Jesus says that we should cut off our arms and legs. This is a hyperbole to illustrate the point that we should not want to go to hell. Eating Jesus' flesh is also a hyperbole to illustrate the point that we should accept his sacrifice to go to heaven.[/quote] Jesus Christ spoke Aramaic. There is no refuting that. It is fact. Now, in Aramaic there are over [i]three dozen[/i] words that mean "represent" or "symbolize", but Jesus used none of them in his statement, "This is my body." In fact, a literal translation of the Arabic is "This my body." [quote]St. Paul is reprobating those who acted bad at the breaking of the bread (which was just the Christian community coming together for a meal using common foods, bread wine and sometimes lamb or some other meat). He says they will be guilty of the body and blood of the Lord because they acted disrespectfully when everyone was suppose to be contemplating Christ's sacrifice of His body and blood. They weren't guilty of the body and blood of the Lord because they were literally defacing the literal physical body and blood, but rather because they weren't paying attention to the ideas, to the sacrifice.[/quote] on the contrary!! St Paul was indeed saying that they would be guilty of murder. In Semetic culture, to be "guilty of one's body and blood" is to be guilty of murder. Yet, if this statement is merely metaphorical, how is one commiting murder??
Guest Aluigi Posted October 11, 2004 Posted October 11, 2004 again, you fail to understand the popularity of using a hyperbole in jewish teaching. Jesus did not use any of those words (though the Gospels are written in Greek not aramaic, so more likely we're talking about the Greek words for "like" and "symbolize") when he said "I am the door" and "I am the vine", neither did He curb his language when He said we should cut off our arms and our legs. St. Paul was a prominent Jewish Pharisee before His conversion (Saul of Tarsus) and would also be accustomed to hyperboles. Therefore, to get the point accross of how bad it is to fail to keep the Lord's Sacrifice in mind he likens it to murder (without using symbolic language, because when you speak in a hyperbole you don't use symbolic language, you just say this is this (my flesh is food; what you're doing is murder)). If you fail to take Christ's sacrifice and accept it and receive it you are as guilty of his unjust killing as those who did it.
franciscanheart Posted October 12, 2004 Posted October 12, 2004 [quote]Jesus did not use any of those words (though the Gospels are written in Greek not aramaic, so more likely we’re talking about the Greek words for “like” and “symbolize”) when he said “I am the door” and “I am the vine”, neither did He curb his language when He said we should cut off our arms and our legs.[/quote] It is important, especially in this case, to read the passage in context. The bread of life discourse begins in John 6:22. One of the very first things to look at it this: In John 6:31 the Jews ask Jesus what sign He could perform and noted also that “our fathers had manna to eat in the desert.” In reply Jesus makes the point that as the Father had sent manna from Heaven for the physical nourishment of the Israelites, he had sent Jesus for the spiritual nourishment of the world. He told them that the real bread from heaven comes from the Father. “Give us this bread,” they insisted. “But Jesus told them, ‘It is I who am the bread of life.’” (John 6:34-35) The Jews murmured at this. They murmured not because Jesus had said that he was like bread but because he said that he had been sent down from Heaven. They understood his symbolic statement regarding the origin of the manna and were scandalized by what it implied: “Is this not Jesus, son of Joseph, whose father and mother we know? How does he now say, ‘I have come down from heaven?’” (John 6:42) Jesus in verse 43 starts to respond to these objections and at the end of his answer speaks of a bread which he has yet to give. “I myself am the bread that has come down from heaven. If anyone eats of this bread, he shall live forever. And now, what is this bread that I am to give? It is my flesh, given for the life of the world.” (John 6:51-52) The Jews now understand that he is truly speaking in a literal sense and object, “How can this man give us his flesh to eat?” If Jesus had been speaking in anything but the literal sense it would have been time to clarify his meaning. But he did not. Now keeping this in mind, look at Christ’s objections in John 6:53-58: “Truly, truly, I say to you, unless you eat of the flesh of the Son of man and drink his blood, you have no life in you…For my flesh is food indeed, and my blood is drink indeed.” These words would hardly subdue the fears of the Jews that Jesus was speaking literally. In fact, following this, many of the disciples said, “This is a hard saying; who can listen to it?” (John 6:60) This is the [b]only[/b] place in Scripture where [i]anyone[/i] leaves Jesus for a purely doctrinal reason. Had Jesus been speaking metaphorically, or as you say using a hyperbole, what would have been so hard for the disciples to accept? Now to the specific example you speak of… John 10:9 “I am the door.” No one understood Jesus to be speaking literally when he said that he was the door. The narrative does not continue, “And his disciples murmured about this, saying, ‘How can he be a door? Where are his hinges? We do not see a doorknob.’ Jesus answered them saying, ‘Amen, Amen, I say to you, I am a door, and my chest is real wood, and my hips are real hinges.’” This is absurd, but it certainly helps to illustrate how shocking Jesus’ words were when he said that his flesh was real food and his blood, real drink. Furthermore, even in Greek Jesus does not use words that show he is speaking symbolically. Grammatical usage you cannot refute!! There is one way and one way only, fact not opinion. Matthew 26:26 “Touto estin to soma mou.” “This is my body”, or literally, “This is the body of me” 1 Corinthians 11:24 supports this even more forcefully: “Touto mou estin to soma” Literally, “This of me is the body” If bread (Gk. artos) really is the symbolic referent for Christ's body, then we should find touto referring to artos. However, the grammar shows otherwise: touto is a neuter demonstrative adjective. Artos is a masculine noun. Since the grammatical genders do not match, touto cannot refer to artos; the “this” that Jesus speaks of does not refer to bread. Therefore, not only is the object in his hands not bread, but bread is not a symbol for his body. What is the “this” that Jesus gives to the disciples that obviously looks, tastes, feels and smells like the bread? Here's the answer: Touto is neuter, so it has to refer to a neuter noun. Artos is out, since it's not neuter, and so the only other possibility is soma (body), which is neuter. Thus, “this” refers to the Body of Christ, not to bread. If you look further, there something in the grammar that indicates a literal meaning: As I wrote above, Touto (This) refers to the Soma (Body) because the latter is the only term in the context that matches the grammatical gender of the former. If Jesus meant it symbolically, then it would look like this: “This <body> is <a symbol of> the body of me” (Matthew 26:26) “This <body> of me is <a symbol of> the body” (1 Cor 11:24) Can we say that his body symbolizes his own body? It sounds rather awkward in construction. Usually a symbol is distinct from its referent (unless it has to do with concepts that definitely show “a making present” correspondence between a sign and the reality it signifies). In the context of the Lord's Supper, we don't find anything that indicates such a correspondence between a symbol of the body and the body itself, so it begs a more reasonable alternative. On the other hand, if Jesus meant it literally, then it would look like this: “This <body> is <literally> the body of me” (Matthew 26:26) “This <body> of me is <literally> the body” (1 Cor 11:24) Can your body literally be your body? Absolutely. In fact, the literal meaning is recognizable even if the terms "literally" were absent, which is the case of the Koine original. Thus, the grammar indicates a literal construction that is more reasonable than a purely symbolic / metaphorical / figurative explanation. The conclusion is that the “this” that Jesus gives -- which looks, tastes, feels and smells like bread -- is not bread at all but is Jesus's very own body. Taking Jesus at his word, with the eyes of Faith, Catholics therefore confess that Jesus meant what he said: “My Lord and My God! Amen.” God bless, Laura Thomas
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now