Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Do souls exist in heaven before we enter earth?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Do our souls exist [b]before[/b] we arrive on earth? I have a feeling this is true, and it would make sense. There is even a scripture passage that refers to this, but don't know where it is.

Fiat_Voluntas_Tua
Posted

I want to say no...but I forgot where I read that...I will get back to you.

Totus Tuus,
Andy

Posted

Nope, the soul is created at conception.

Posted

B-I-N-G-O.

Are you neglecting your Aquinas?

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Nov 8 2004, 09:38 PM'] B-I-N-G-O.

Are you neglecting your Aquinas? [/quote]
By being on here, I am.

Posted

I don't know the verse, but isn't there a verse in the Scriptures that says something the along the lines of: [i]"I knew you, before you were born"[/i] ???

Posted

It's saying how God knows us before we're born. First of all, when we're conceived, we're not actually born yet, so this is a verse (from Jeremiah) proving the idea of a soul at conception. Also, God has known for all of eternity that you will exist, for He knows no time. :)

Posted

Not necessarily. If heaven exists outside this universe's Space-Time, then once we depart this world and enter the next, we would - from this world's perspective - have been there "eternally"; hence, before the world began. I've actually been thinking about this for awhile, now... If you would like, I could post a little of what I've been writing about it.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Ziggamafu' date='Nov 9 2004, 06:48 PM'] Not necessarily. If heaven exists outside this universe's Space-Time, then once we depart this world and enter the next, we would - from this world's perspective - have been there "eternally"; hence, before the world began. I've actually been thinking about this for awhile, now... If you would like, I could post a little of what I've been writing about it. [/quote]
I've thought about this before, too, but comparing time to eternity is far beyond our understanding. I mean, if you know your math, then you know that when you deal with finite numbers, you deal with one set of rules, but when you deal with infinity, it's just screwy... :wacko:

We can exist in the sense of a ray, which is still infinite, but has a starting place. ;)

Posted

The problem with us having eternal souls is that we wouldn't change, meaning we wouldn't have free will.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='qfnol31' date='Nov 9 2004, 07:00 PM'] The problem with us having eternal souls is that we wouldn't change, meaning we wouldn't have free will. [/quote]
Yeah, the only way we could be eternal and have free will is if we were like a wave...changing and eternal, and not like a line, a point stretched over eternity...

Either way, we don't have eternal souls and it's a mystery. We simply know it because it has to be and we must accept that we can't know why it is that way.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' date='Nov 9 2004, 05:03 PM'] Yeah, the only way we could be eternal and have free will is if we were like a wave...changing and eternal, and not like a line, a point stretched over eternity...

Either way, we don't have eternal souls and it's a mystery. We simply know it because it has to be and we must accept that we can't know why it is that way. [/quote]
Actually, that's a poor translation, because eternal in that sense is actually something in time, or something that is aeveternal.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='qfnol31' date='Nov 9 2004, 07:08 PM'] Actually, that's a poor translation, because eternal in that sense is actually something in time, or something that is aeveternal. [/quote]
Yeah...through all time instead of outside of time...

There is no way to express God's eternity in human terms. If you think the Theory of Relativity is tough, don't even think you can grasp this. :P

Posted

LoL, eternity is above time, aeveternity is in between eternity and time. :) Time to eternity is like a rainbow to a white light.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='qfnol31' date='Nov 9 2004, 07:25 PM'] LoL, eternity is above time, aeveternity is in between eternity and time. :) Time to eternity is like a rainbow to a white light. [/quote]
Yes, but I was saying that a lot of people think of eternity as being all of an uncreated time. We all know time is a part of creation, but some people don't think of it when they try to comprehend eternity, so they consider that eternity must be an infinite amount of time, where we know that eternity is actually outside of time completely, and therefore holds no amount of time.

Posted

Wanna get confused, talk about "imaginery time."

Posted

[quote name='qfnol31' date='Nov 9 2004, 06:00 PM'] The problem with us having eternal souls is that we wouldn't change, meaning we wouldn't have free will. [/quote]
Ah, but just because we would exist in a higher dimension - a "sub" eternity-eternity - doesn't mean we would exist in infinity...God alone is infinite; eternity is merely an attribute of infinity and refers to time. Thus, there could be a higher plane of time outside of space-time in this universe and there would still be infinity (where changlessness resides) beyond that. Hugh Ross (an evangelical astro-physicist) wrote an interesting book about this, I think. When my wife gets home, I'll copy the essay I wrote on her laptop over to this site.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Definitions help:
ETERNITY. In its full sense, duration of being without beginning, succession, or ending. Only God possesses the fullness of eternity, since only he always existed (no beginning), has no succession (no change), and will never end (no cessation). It is defined Catholic doctrine that God possesses the divine Being in a constant undivided now. His eternity is the perfect and simultaneous total possession of interminable life.

Rational creatures share in God's eternity, but only approximate it, by participation. Angels have a beginning, and they have a succession of past, present, and future, but they have no cessation since they are pure spirits that will never die or cease to be. Human beings likewise have a beginning and they have succession, but unlike the angels they will die in body, to be later resurrected, while the souls live on forever. In God's absolute power, however, angels and human souls could be deprived of existence. Their eternity depends on the goodness and will of God.

homeschoolmom
Posted

I think Mormons hold to the idea that souls are in heaven waiting for bodies... sorta like a cosmic gumball machine... if your soul is next, you get the next body born... :wacko:

franciscanheart
Posted

Yeha the soul to my understanding, as it has already been stated, is not created until conception.

BAH--->what zach and micah said.


and the whole eternity thing.... its confusing the mess out of me. i mean i follow what yall are saying but to think about it.... its confusing. it really is beyond our understanding.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...