phatcatholic Posted November 13, 2004 Posted November 13, 2004 i think ur awesome Lucy, and ur doin the right thing. don't every quit standing up for what is right and true. we got ur back holla if u need us pax christi, nick
Guest Aluigi Posted November 13, 2004 Posted November 13, 2004 Pius XII, Humani Generis... polygenism cannot be believed by a Catholic. every human being was descended from one original man and one original woman. we are monogenites when it comes to where mankind came from. when i get to theology class in college, boy am i gonna have some battles! i will be well equipped to stomp down all heresy! :angry:
Cure of Ars Posted November 14, 2004 Posted November 14, 2004 This might be of interest. How to Read the First Chapter of Genesis [url="http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/apologetics/ap0034.html"]http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/...ics/ap0034.html[/url]
Guest Aluigi Posted November 14, 2004 Posted November 14, 2004 but adam and eve are still real ppl according to the Magisterium and every human being descended from Adam
Guest Aluigi Posted November 14, 2004 Posted November 14, 2004 "When, however, there is question of another conjectural opinion, namely polygenism, the children of the Church by no means enjoy such liberty. For the faithful cannot embrace that opinion which maintains that either after Adam there existed on this earth true men who did not take their origin through natural generation from him as from the first parent of all, or that Adam represents a certain number of first parents. Now it is no no way apparent how such an opinion can be reconciled with that which the sources of revealed truth and the documents of the Magisterium of the Church propose with regard to original sin, which proceeds from a sin actually committed by an individual Adam and which, through generation, is passed on to all and is in everyone as his own." [Pope Pius XII, Encyclical Letter Humani Generis, no. 37]
BurkeFan Posted November 15, 2004 Posted November 15, 2004 [quote name='Aluigi' date='Nov 14 2004, 11:39 AM'] Pope Pius XII, Encyclical Letter Humani Generis, no. 37 [/quote] That won't work. It was pre-Vatican II, and so will be instantly ignored. It also disagrees with the sacrosanct theory of polygenism (as Dennis Bonnette put it), and so will be rejected out of hand. I've tried it and experienced this result.
BurkeFan Posted November 15, 2004 Posted November 15, 2004 [quote name='Raphael' date='Nov 10 2004, 02:14 AM'] In other, brighter news, Bishop Burke was in Lincoln last Friday for a Pro-life banquet. I didn't get to meet him...I was on a Koinonia Retreat, but a friend of mine did and said he was awesome. [/quote] If you ever get the chance to meet him, just tell him you know Nauta.
White Knight Posted November 16, 2004 Posted November 16, 2004 [quote name='Lucy89' date='Nov 9 2004, 08:08 PM'] Hi!! I am Kateri05's sister and I go to a Catholic High School. My religion teacher has told us over and over again that Adam and Eve did not actually exsist and that they are a myth. I was taught otherwise and I was just wondering if you guys could help me out. Thanks... P.S. She has said a whole bunch of other things I'm POSITIVE the Catholic church doesn't believe...but I'll save that for another topic [/quote] Well unforunately, your teacher is misinformed on this topic. Let me say it plain and simple, so you dont have to listen to anyone else's LONG REPLY one something so long, and over explained reply, but yet a simple one. [b]"The Catholic Church DOES APPROVE of the EXISTANCE of Adam and Eve"[/b] On Faith issues, and moral Issues, the Catholic Church is always correct. (This is coming from a believer who is not a Catholic.) lol I hope that explains it. [b]God Bless You, Pax Christi. Also, God Bless Your High School Religious Teacher.[/b]
phatcatholic Posted November 16, 2004 Posted November 16, 2004 [quote name='White Knight' date='Nov 16 2004, 01:47 AM'] Well unforunately, your teacher is misinformed on this topic. Let me say it plain and simple, so you dont have to listen to anyone else's LONG REPLY one something so long, and over explained reply, but yet a simple one. [/quote] are we not succinct enough for you?
Guest Aluigi Posted November 16, 2004 Posted November 16, 2004 [quote name='BurkeFan' date='Nov 14 2004, 08:29 PM'] That won't work. It was pre-Vatican II, and so will be instantly ignored. It also disagrees with the sacrosanct theory of polygenism (as Dennis Bonnette put it), and so will be rejected out of hand. I've tried it and experienced this result. [/quote] :angry: stupid people! i'll make them pay attention!
Lucy89 Posted November 17, 2004 Author Posted November 17, 2004 (edited) Here's my issue...my religion book says that they are a myth and did not actually exsist. So priests, Catholics, and the Catholic Church is telling me that they do, but my Catholic religion book and my teachers at my Catholic schools are saying that we don't know how sin first entered the world so we made up the story of Adam and Eve to explain it. It's like my arms are being pulled into two different directions. I don't know what to do. P.S. How can I be sure if my Catholic religion book is approved by the bishop??? Edited November 17, 2004 by Lucy89
Guest Aluigi Posted November 17, 2004 Posted November 17, 2004 there would be an imprimature, imprimi potest, and/or nihil obstat on the same page with like, copywrite info and stuff. it'll say who issued them and when. that doesn't always guarentee a book is orthodox anymore (it usedta be more respectable )
Cure of Ars Posted November 17, 2004 Posted November 17, 2004 [quote name='Lucy89' date='Nov 16 2004, 07:08 PM'] Here's my issue...my religion book says that they are a myth and did not actually exsist. So priests, Catholics, and the Catholic Church is telling me that they do, but my Catholic religion book and my teachers at my Catholic schools are saying that we don't know how sin first entered the world so we made up the story of Adam and Eve to explain it. It's like my arms are being pulled into two different directions. I don't know what to do. P.S. How can I be sure if my Catholic religion book is approved by the bishop??? [/quote] You need to define the word myth. It has more than one meaning. If you are using the term to mean, "A fiction or half-truth, especially one that forms part of an ideology." then this would not apply to Adam and Eve. But if it is used to mean, "a traditional story accepted as history; serves to explain the world view of a people" then yes Adam and Eve are myth. Also there is scientific evidance that humanity came from a single women and even one man. [url="http://encyclopedia.thefreedictionary.com/Mitochondrial%20Eve"]Mitochondrial Eve[/url] The book of Genesis is the Word of God. It is not something that was just made up. But at the same time it is not a book that is trying to answer the questions of science but instead humanities place and situation in the world in relation to God.
Guest JeffCR07 Posted November 17, 2004 Posted November 17, 2004 Lydia, God Bless, and welcome to phatmass! This is Jeff, one of Lina's friends from Dickinson. First, I would just like to highlight a particularly important excerpt from the first link that Cure provided for you. It deals with the issue of myth, as well as the more fundamental question as a whole: [quote]While they do not teach science, the early chapters of Genesis are history and not myth. But they are not history as it would be written by a modern historian. (It is not as though there was a camcorder in the Garden of Eden.) You might say that they are history written in mythic language — a poetic compression of the truth, as it were. We are obliged to believe the fundamental truths expressed by the sacred author — for example, that our first parents, tempted by the devil, committed a primal act of disobedience whose effects we still suffer (cf. Catechism, no. 390). But the Catholic doctrine of original sin is entirely outside the realm of physical science. It’s worth keeping in mind, however, Newman’s remark that the more he contemplated humanity, the clearer it became to him that the race was “implicated in some terrible aboriginal calamity.” [/quote] I highlight this point because far too often people tack too far in either direction and in doing so leave the protection and guidance of the Magisterium. Some attempt to read science into the text, others attempt to read doctrine and dogma out of it. But in doing so, both groups of people are taking on an authority that only the Church has. What the Church teaches - what is critical to the creation story and cannot be thrown out - is the fact that: 1.) There were indeed "First Parents" of humanity - that is, a male and female in whom the Father breathed life (ie caused a unity of body and soul) - who were created [i]Imagio Dei[/i], in God's image, and from whom [b]all[/b] of mankind descended. 2.) There was indeed a Fall of Man - that is, a real point in history in which mankind first sinned - and that this sin caused mankind to break communion with God and to fall from His Grace. Moreover, that sin was both the result of temptation from Satan as well as a free choice of man. 3.) That Original Sin (the lack of sanctifying Grace or communion with God) has been passed on to all of mankind from our First Parents, and that we are incapable of healing such a rift on our own and must rely on God for our salvation, which he provides from us in the form of the Sacrifice of His Son, Jesus Christ Also, I know how hard it is to have teachers that do not teach the faith, and I know what its like to feel pulled in two different directions. But the one thing that you can always trust is the Church. It alone is protected by the Spirit. The Catechism is your best friend whenever you are feeling torn or indecisive. The Holy Father has called it "a sure norm for teaching the faith" and so if you are unclear as to what the Church actually teaches about something, you can always go to, and trust in, what the Catechism says. Don't get discouraged, I know its disheartening, but just stick with it and never compromise the teachings of the Church. Remember that not just you, but all the kids in your class as well, have a right to know what the Church actually says, and so every time you stand up against false teachings, you're helping to lead them to the truth as well! - Your Brother In Christ, Jeff
phatcatholic Posted November 17, 2004 Posted November 17, 2004 yes Lydia, refer to the paragraphs from the Catechism i provided. they affirm the three points that Jeff made in his post, and they prove your teacher and your religion book to be very much in error.
kateri05 Posted November 18, 2004 Posted November 18, 2004 Thanks pham for helping my sister out, I really appreciate it I went to this same high school and apparently its getting worse! Please keep her and her teachers in your prayers
Lucy89 Posted November 18, 2004 Author Posted November 18, 2004 Yeah, thanks guys ! I found out that my religion book this year is not approved by a bishop but by a reverend in Oregon or something. I want to write out bishop and find out what the deal is with this school and how I can fix it. Thank you guys for all of your insight
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now