Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Is there anything the Church has a say on when a boy becomes a man?

I have a book (non-Catholic though) http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/156...4180887-6984815, it's pretty interesting. The description is the following...

What does it mean to be a man? Moreover, how does a father instill these qualities in his son? By Raising a Modern-Day Knight. Beginning with a biblical perspective of manhood, author-pastor Robert Lewis shares a unique approach to shaping a boy into a man by equipping him with three essential elements: a vision, a code of conduct, and a cause (Christianity) in which to invest his life. Complete with ceremony ideas to celebrate accomplishments and ingrain them in his mind, this softcover is as insightful as it is practical in raising a boy to be a chivalrous, godly man.

In today's society, there isn't a clear vision on what turns a boy into a man. Yet again, I'm very curious and wanting to know if the Catholic Church has anything like this? Would the Knights of Columbus count?

Don John of Austria
Posted

Tradisionaly Confirmation was seen as the rite of adulthood followed by Full Communion with the Church( by takeing the Eucharist) it was not until the 20th century that children were allowed to take communion. still I would say Cofirmation would be it.

I find it amusing that a protestant would speak of knighthood in such a positive light,; since Chivalry and knighthood are all tied up with Catholicism.

Posted

Tradisionaly Confirmation was seen as the rite of adulthood followed by Full Communion with the Church( by takeing the Eucharist) it was not until the 20th century that children were allowed to take communion. still I would say Cofirmation would be it.

Are you sure about that? It was the tradition of the Church to confirm you right when you were baptised. Communion usually came after both sacraments were already given.

Jake Huether
Posted

I always thought the first sign of becoming a man was when you started to get peach fuzz! :lol:

Posted

Is the Knights of Columbus a good role model for men?

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

Is the Knights of Columbus a good role model for men?

I'd say that in 9 cases out of 10 (at least!) the answer would be yes. :) Many parishes have a group for boys/young men called the Squires, too, and when they are old enough they can join the Knights. :)

Posted

I always wanted to become a Knight :) .

Jake Huether
Posted

Laugh at my joke! :angry:

Posted

Laugh at my joke!  :angry:

:lol::lol::lol:

That's funny, Jake! You rock!

Posted

Laugh at my joke!  :angry:

LMAO LMAO LMAO!!!!

*Feel better?* ;)

Guest Legion
Posted (edited)

I was 35 when I joined the Knights. I held back for so long because all I saw was them drinking and not acting very much like Christian men. Then it dawned on me that their purpose and code were very Christian. I then decided that, just like church, It's the organization not the people that you join. The Knights of Columbus are the self proclaimed "Right arm (hand) of the Church". I would highly recommend joining your local council, but I would not put it in the catagory of coming of age.

p.s. no, I do not consider Church an organization, I just lacked the word I wanted to use. ;)

Jake, I think it's more fuzz than just a peach :P

Edited by Legion
cmotherofpirl
Posted

Remember we women are always looking for a knight in shining armor :lol:

Don John of Austria
Posted

Are you sure about that? It was the tradition of the Church to confirm you right when you were baptised. Communion usually came after both sacraments were already given

Yes I am sure, on both counts, it was the tradition of the church to confirm you at about 13 at least since the early middleages, the practice of slaping the confirmed( still symbolicly done) came from the midieval tradition of the buffet( at knighting) this was supposed to represent your becoming a soldier of Christ. Cradle catholics where always confirmed as yong adults even though they were baptised as infants. Furthermore first holy communion was reserved for those who were confirmed, it was only in the reign of PiusX that Children were allowed to recieve the Eucharist.

Posted

Ya know, in the Eastern rites they still confirm children right after baptism.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Yes I am sure, on both counts, it was the tradition of the church to confirm you at about 13 at least since the early middleages, the practice of slaping the confirmed( still symbolicly done) came from the midieval tradition of the buffet( at knighting) this was supposed to represent your becoming a soldier of Christ. Cradle catholics where always confirmed as yong adults even though they were baptised as infants. Furthermore first holy communion was reserved for those who were confirmed, it was only in the reign of PiusX that Children were allowed to recieve the Eucharist.

Communion was dropped from 12 to 7.

Posted

Ok Jake, I was just making sure. My mother and all of her siblings were confirmed at their baptism. (before Vatican II) and my understanding has been that the earlies tradition of the Church was that Baptism and Confirmation were given together, folled by First Communion . . .

To be honest with you, I think there is a lot of revisionist sacramental history going on in the Church. My gut reaction is to say "are you SURE that's the tradition of the Church." You hear it everytime you talk to a 'liturgist' who says that Trent distorted the way that Christians worship and that Vatican II restored the earlier and truer form of Eucharistic celebration with a focus on the community. Pshaw! As if!

From the Catechism:

Two traditions: East and West

1290 In the first centuries Confirmation generally comprised one single celebration with Baptism, forming with it a "double sacrament," according to the expression of St. Cyprian. Among other reasons, the multiplication of infant baptisms all through the year, the increase of rural parishes, and the growth of dioceses often prevented the bishop from being present at all baptismal celebrations. In the West the desire to reserve the completion of Baptism to the bishop caused the temporal separation of the two sacraments. The East has kept them united, so that Confirmation is conferred by the priest who baptizes. But he can do so only with the "myron" consecrated by a bishop.[100]

1291 A custom of the Roman Church facilitated the development of the Western practice: a double anointing with sacred chrism after Baptism. The first anointing of the neophyte on coming out of the baptismal bath was performed by the priest; it was completed by a second anointing on the forehead of the newly baptized by the bishop.[101] The first anointing with sacred chrism, by the priest, has remained attached to the baptismal rite; it signifies the participation of the one baptized in the prophetic, priestly, and kingly offices of Christ. If Baptism is conferred on an adult, there is only one post-baptismal anointing, that of Confirmation.

1292 The practice of the Eastern Churches gives greater emphasis to the unity of Christian initiation. That of the Latin Church more clearly expresses the communion of the new Christian with the bishop as guarantor and servant of the unity, catholicity and apostolicity of his Church, and hence the connection with the apostolic origins of Christ's Church.

Here's JP2 on the sacrament http://www.trincomm.org/research/retrieve_....cfm?RecNum=582

And of course, the Catholic Encyclopedia http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/04215b.htm

Posted

According to Ernest Hemmingway, one becomes a man when he 1)Has a child of his own, 2)Publishes a book, & 3)Runs with the bulls.

Posted

Confirmation is the third and final Sacrament of Initiation into the Church. We receive gifts of the Holy Spirit that perfect and strengthen our Faith and enables us to be soldiers for Christ. We also get a spriirtual seal. Read the Catechism.

As with all Sacraments, we get the graces, but spend our lives learning to utilize our gifts of grace. The Western tradition lies in the concept that these particualr gifts are gifts utilized with reason. If we get them as infants, there isn't much we can do with them until later. Confirmation is given at a bit older age in the hope the Candidate will be catechized about the gifts and be more likely to use them all.

We still derive a certain benifit from the graces despite our understanding which is why Eastern Churches Confirm at baptism. The US Church is moving that way anyway along with an effort for better catechesis of adults and older kids.

Here's a little known fact. Just like Baptism, we can (and should) give that Sacrament if we come accross someone dying. Who can tell me why??

Posted

So in simple terms? :D

Guest jrob8503
Posted

Well don't you remember? I told you in December that a boy is not a man until he makes a stand.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...