Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi, I'm Kyle and I'm 19 years old. I'm an old phatmass member but I haven't logged on in a long time (maybe 10 months to a year). I recently joined the Army and I've been assigned to the Third Infantry Division (Ft. Stewart, GA) which is deploying to Iraq in January. I'm so looking forward to spending eighteen months in a barren wasteland and dodging bullets and mortar shells every day. :cool:

I converted to the Catholic Church when I was sixteen, prompted by reading Thomas Merton, G.K. Chesterton, and St. Augustine, as well as browsing through Catholic apologetics websites and the Catechism of the Catholic Church. I went to RCIA for two years and I was confirmed during Easter Vigil 2003. I was previously baptized at a "Bible church" in North Rome, PA, when I was eleven years old.

I was invited to attend a charismatic prayer meeting at a local Protestant church the other day. I decided to go just because I had nothing else to do. I've been enjoying the freedom and boredom of a four-day weekend, and besides, I didn't see any harm in it. It was very strange and very dramatic. The people were all shouting, jumping up and down, clapping their hands, speaking in tongues, exclaiming, "Oh, Jesus! Oh, Jesus! Hallelujah!" The preacher spoke in strange, rhythmic tones, gyrating and gesticulating to the sounds of hollering and hallelujahs. His speech was full of passionate denunciations and exclamations and pleading and weeping and laughing and reverence and sentimentality.

After about an hour or so of this display, this obscene exhibitionism, I had to go out and smoke a cigarette. I know it's not good for me, but there's only so much my nerves can take. It was like, tribalism, shamanism, totemism, whatever you want to call it, repackaged in a Christianized form. It was very disturbing to see people swaying back and forth, chanting in mystical tongues spoken probably nowhere on earth, moaning, crying, sighing....Praise Jesus! Hallelujah! It was like John Wesley meets Joseph Conrad, the heart of darkness located right here in Hinesville, GA, at your friendly neighborhood church.

Afterward, I was invited to a cook-out the next day, and of course I went because, like I said, I needed something to do and sometimes you just get sick of chow hall and MREs. The food was good. There were friendly people there. But I found out the preacher was an extremist of sorts. Very right-wing. Very ideological. I'm sure there are a lot of conservatives here, people who support the war in Iraq, but, geez, you should have heard this guy. He was practically calling for an all-out religious war. Bring back the Crusades! Declare a holy Christian jihad on all the heathen hordes! He tried to make out that if we didn't beat the hajis and proclaim pax Americana in Baghdad, they would come over here, tear the old family Bible out of your weeping grandmother's hands, and throw a veil over her head, after they mutilated her....womanhood, of course. And God forbid to think what they would do to your sister!

Yeah, I don't know about these guys. I politely declined to go to another prayer meeting with them today, and I said I would be going to the cathedral in Savannah for the 3PM Mass on Sunday. I'm not sure if I really want to get involved with them, because honestly they seem like a bunch of raving fanatics. Any thoughts?

homeschoolmom
Posted
:unsure:

Wow... welcome back to PM...

... and thanks for your service...
AfroNova No Limit Soldier
Posted

Kyle, bless you. You will be in my prayers.

The Catholic Charismatic movement has been blessed by the Pope.

WEBSITE:
[url="http://vatican.mondosearch.com/cgi-bin/MsmFind.exe?CFGNAME=MssFind.cfg&QUERY=charismatic&EN=X&NO_DL=X&x=0&y=0"]http://vatican.mondosearch.com/cgi-bin/Msm...NO_DL=X&x=0&y=0[/url]

However, there are some charismatics who have broken off from the Church & made their own Catholic Charismatic cult. Pretty sad. There's also the charismatics who are all show. It sounds like maybe thats the kind of place you went to?? I'm not sure. Maybe God is calling you to look into the Catholic Charismatic movement.

Also, that preacher preaching holy war... Hmmm... Yeah, don't get involved with them.

What city are you in? Also, I just started reading about GK Chesterton. I'm reading this book called Letters to a Young Catholic by George Wiegel who is the official biographer of the Pope. It's awesome, and he talks a lot about Chesterton, Edith Stein, Evelyn Waugh, John Neumann. Check the book out!

BLESS YOU KYLE!!1

Posted

Thank you for your service sir, and belated Vets day to you. I would stay away and stick with a nice regular Mass myself.

Posted (edited)

I grew up in a charismatic family (some Catholic and Protestant influences). Charismatic Catholics are in right standing with the Church. Though with Protestants, they have some of the Truth but imperfect in doctrine. Even though I don't consider myself a charismatic (though sometimes I'm in that mood), I can't discrimate those who are. Most of them are very sincere, and I admire that. Though if they preach things that are contrary, watch out.

Firstly, thank you for answering the call to the Armed Forces!

Secondly, I have a strong desire to join the US Army as well. I was stuck between the Marines and the Army, but I finally decided if I were going to join, it would be the Army. The Army seems more diverse, larger, with more opportunities and programs than the Marines.

What's your MOS? I haven't decided myself, but 11B (Infantryman) is one on my list. Ranger school sounds pretty good to me (Rangers lead the way!).

Edited by Paladin D
Posted

Forgot to add, I'm turning 18 on January 26th. I'm not sure if I'll be joining the US Army right there and then, but most likely either before or after college.

Posted

Hey everybody,
First of all, Paladin, you are definitely making the right choice. Everyone knows the Army is better than the Marines. My MOS is 13-F (Fire Support). I would suggest making the Army pay for your education.
Second, I went to a church dinner last night, and the preacher led a question and answer session afterward. He said some truly horrible things about the Catholic Church, so I doubt I will be going back. Though it will be difficult, because one of the medics invited me, and he seems like such a nice guy.
Third, I've had an interest in Catholic Charismatic movement for a long time, but I don't know of any groups around, either back home or here in Georgia. All the charismatic groups I know of are Protestant.
Fourth, Afronova, I live on post at Ft. Stewart. The nearest town is Hinesville, GA, which is near Savannah. I saw that book you mentioned at the library back home. I'm going on leave on the 25th, so I'll check it out and read it over the weekend.

PVT KYLE DE WOLF

Posted

wow, stay the heck away from there...
Charismatics are iffy for me. There is that potential to really screw up when you mess around like that.
What did that ignoramus say about the Church? I'm curious. If you want to know how to prove him wrong, you know that this place is an Apologetics haven.

Posted

He said Catholics get athlete's mouth from kissing the pope's feet. He also ridiculed the Blessed Sacrament.

Posted

ahhh. well our best intelligence indicates he'll be in Hell for Eternity unless he's just horribly ignorant. I guess the best we can do is pray he's just really stupid.

Posted

[quote name='kdewolf2' date='Nov 13 2004, 03:04 PM'] It was like John Wesley meets Joseph Conrad, the heart of darkness located right here in Hinesville, GA, at your friendly neighborhood church.

[/quote]
that's what we get for living in georgia :P

Posted

[quote name='kdewolf2' date='Nov 16 2004, 07:57 PM'] First of all, Paladin, you are definitely making the right choice. Everyone knows the Army is better than the Marines. My MOS is 13-F (Fire Support). I would suggest making the Army pay for your education. [/quote]
Yeah, and considering a certain situation came up (long story), it's more than likely that I'll be joining the Army before college (aiming for age 19, would like a year break after HS).

Will you have web access while on deployment? Would they provide laptops or do you have your own? Got an e-mail address that you'll be using?

Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Nov 16 2004, 07:15 PM'] ahhh. well our best intelligence indicates he'll be in Hell for Eternity unless he's just horribly ignorant. I guess the best we can do is pray he's just really stupid. [/quote]
Our best intelligence isn't all that...intelligent, you know. I'm sure you know that, just wanted to point it our. There is so much we as human beings don't know about the afterlife.

I personally wouldn't throw out the entire Charismatic movement based on your experience. For one thing, it wasn't Catholic at all, (I'm assuming you are Catholic?) while most Charismatic events are in line with the Church. On the other hand, you yourself would probably be better off going to a regular old Mass.

PS: Just feel that I should advise you to be careful with those cigs!

Posted

[quote name='XIX' date='Nov 16 2004, 09:33 PM'] Our best intelligence isn't all that...intelligent, you know. I'm sure you know that, just wanted to point it our. There is so much we as human beings don't know about the afterlife.

[/quote]
yeah I know. I just like using that best intelligence line.

Posted

Dude, I was converted to Christianity in general at a Pentecostal -- Charismatic -- service...


=\ I just thought they were really excited and loved God. Nothing evil.

CatholicCrusader
Posted

[quote]I converted to the Catholic Church when I was sixteen, prompted by reading Thomas Merton...[/quote]

That is surprising. I think more people who read him become buddhist than Catholic...

[quote]I was invited to attend a charismatic prayer meeting at a local Protestant church the other day.  I decided to go just because I had nothing else to do.  I've been enjoying the freedom and boredom of a four-day weekend, and besides, I didn't see any harm in it.  It was very strange and very dramatic.  The people were all shouting, jumping up and down, clapping their hands, speaking in tongues, exclaiming, "Oh, Jesus!  Oh, Jesus!  Hallelujah!"  The preacher spoke in strange, rhythmic tones, gyrating and gesticulating to the sounds of hollering and hallelujahs.  His speech was full of passionate denunciations and exclamations and pleading and weeping and laughing and reverence and sentimentality. [/quote]

Yes, that sort of blasphemy is quite disturbing. I don't know why you would expose yourself to such. Also, you said you didn't see any harm in going. I would suggest you read some things from Popes St. Pius X, Leo XIII, Pius IX, and the Popes against Modernism, especially the Syllabus of Errors of Pius IX to see exactly what is the harm in going to an heretical and blasphemous "prayer" service.

Posted

[quote name='CatholicCrusader' date='Nov 17 2004, 12:54 AM']
That is surprising. I think more people who read him become buddhist than Catholic...
[/quote]
You know, Thomas Merton celebrated the Tridentine mass . . .

Posted

I had a similar experience to you Kyle, I know exactly where you are coming from!
When I was in high school there was a mass exodus of cafeteria Catholics to an evangelical Pentecostal church....at least I think it was Pentecostal. I was invited by a friend on Tuesday night, being curious I went.....well actually I went to two services.

It was certainly an experience, it felt more like a pep rally than a service. All the girls were in skirts and had really long hair. The church was very very stark, like a newly drywalled gym only with pews. And they all had thier hands in the air and were very vocal. I felt like I was Waldo in a where's Waldo book, only it was ore like "find the Catholic"....you know the one that looks really uncomfortable and doesn't have thier hands in the air. Any way the first service was just pretty much singing and someone talking at us, one of the preachers went off on how alcohol was the evil of the world..... that rubbed me the wrong way.

The second service though, they first sang and a preacher preached...and then they started talking in tongues. That freaked me out right there. We all paired off, and the chick I was wanted me to try and speak in tongues or induce tongues. I refused, and so we talked and prayed. At one point she looked at me and said " have you ever felt this way in a church? " .....I replied "have you ever been to a Polka mass?"

Anyways back to the tongues part... I don't have a problem with people speaking in tongues....but from my view it looked like they were trying to induce tongues.
My philosophy on this is if God choses me to receive it I will, but I will not go looking for trouble....

Freaked me out man, I tell you though it was a very good experience. I appreciate being Catholic so much more, I understand being Catholic so much more. And I know I am in the right place.

God bless,
Balthazor

Posted

Wow...that sounds like a prayer meeting I went to once. They were all into the Toronto Blessing ( :crazy: ) and were freaking out and all that happy stuff that makes Christians look like they should be institutionalized. :rolleyes: I've seen some amazing things happen before the Blessed Sacrament, but nothing disruptive. The Holy Spirit is not disruptive. So if people are yelling out in "tongues" and shaking on the floor or whatever, there's a good chance the Holy Spirit isn't the cause. :ph34r:

Posted

Don't get me wrong they were very nice people. But there was no sanctity in their service. One of the treasures I find in Catholicism is the reverence and the sanctity and the treasure of the mass. It simply was not here.... I am not going to pretend that it was.

Joy is a very Christian thing indeed, and these people definatley had joy. But what is left after the hype wears off? Where is the holiness and sanctity of God? I crave holiness, this did not satisfy me, I could have gotten the same level of hype at a concert.

Perhaps I was missing something in that service, I don't want to sound judgemental. But once you have had steak you will never be satisfyed with gruel.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...