Balthazor Posted November 16, 2004 Posted November 16, 2004 I have a classmate that is a former Catholic, he has trouble with some things, I try my best but I just can't answer all of his questions....So I had him write down what he wanted asked. Here is one of them, I would appreciate any help you can give me. How can Joan of Arc be declared anathama and a heretic and then be given sainthood? How can you have this and yet still claim infallibility of the Magisterium? Help me out here, the question itself rings a discordant note but I can't put my finger on it. Thank you very much.
StColette Posted November 16, 2004 Posted November 16, 2004 (edited) Reading this may help [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08409c.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08409c.htm[/url] especially towards the middle where it begins talking about the trial and of course this part of the article: Twenty-four years later a revision of her trial, the procès de réhabilitation, was opened at Paris with the consent of the Holy See. The popular feeling was then very different, and, with but the rarest exceptions, all the witnesses were eager to render their tribute to the virtues and supernatural gifts of the Maid. The first trial had been conducted without reference to the pope, indeed it was carried out in defiance of St. Joan's appeal to the head of the Church. Now an appellate court constituted by the pope, after long inquiry and examination of witnesses, reversed and annulled the sentence pronounced by a local tribunal under Cauchon's presidency. The illegality of the former proceedings was made clear, and it speaks well for the sincerity of this new inquiry that it could not be made without inflicting some degree of reproach upon both the King of France and the Church at large, seeing that so great an injustice had been done and had so long been suffered to continue unredressed. Even before the rehabilitation trial, keen observers, like Eneas Sylvius Piccolomini (afterwards Pope Pius II), though still in doubt as to her mission, had discerned something of the heavenly character of the Maid. In Shakespeare's day she was still regarded in England as a witch in league with the fiends of hell, but a juster estimate had begun to prevail even in the pages of Speed's "History of Great Britaine" (1611). By the beginning of the nineteenth century the sympathy for her even in England was general. Such writers as Southey, Hallam, Sharon Turner, Carlyle, Landor, and, above all, De Quincey greeted the Maid with a tribute of respect which was not surpassed even in her own native land. Among her Catholic fellow-countrymen she had been regarded, even in her lifetime, as Divinely inspired. At last the cause of her beatification was introduced upon occasion of an appeal addressed to the Holy See, in 1869, by Mgr Dupanloup, Bishop of Orléans, and, after passing through all its stages and being duly confirmed by the necessary miracles, the process ended in the decree being published by Pius X on 11 April, 1909. A Mass and Office of St. Joan, taken from the "Commune Virginum," with "proper" prayers, have been approved by the Holy See for use in the Diocese of Orléans. [Note: St. Joan was canonized in 1920 by Pope Benedict XV.] Edited November 16, 2004 by StColette
StColette Posted November 16, 2004 Posted November 16, 2004 This is pretty interesting too [url="http://www.stjoan-center.com/Trials/null01.html"]http://www.stjoan-center.com/Trials/null01.html[/url] It is about the trial that declared her innocent.
Cure of Ars Posted November 17, 2004 Posted November 17, 2004 [quote]Concerning the related issue of clerical infallibility (the stereotype which says that every tribunal was considered incapable of error and therefore, in the minds of some revisionists, could not be defied under any circumstances): this is a distortion based mostly on doctrines that deal with entirely different issues. Among other sources, Aquinas and St. Hildegard outline the actual doctrine in the "Summa Theologica" and "Scito Vias Domini" (respectively), where they point out that a sentence of excommunication by an ecclesiastic tribunal is neither an infallible ruling nor does it condemn the person's soul. Hildegard warns the clergy that if they convict someone in error it is they who will be punished for it by God, not their victim;3 Aquinas similarly states that an erroneous excommunication has no effect.4 [/quote] [url="http://archive.joan-of-arc.org/joanofarc_protestant_issue.html"]http://archive.joan-of-arc.org/joanofarc_p...tant_issue.html[/url] [quote]Footnote 3 From St. Hildegard's "Scito Vias Domini" ("Scivias"), in a section quoting God (in one of her visions) concerning the duties of the clergy with regard to excommunication, referred to using the standard term from Matthew 16:19 ("whatsoever you shall bind on Earth, it will be bound also in Heaven"). Hildegard deals with the issue as follows: A harsh denunciation of corrupt clergy (Book II, 95) is followed by a section [II, 96] stating that the power to bind [excommunicate] is granted "as long as you consider rightly what it is you should bind." Farther down (II, 98) a warning is given to those who seek to judge an alleged heretic: "But you shall not bind an innocent person; for when you bind such a one you bind yourselves in bonds of dire guilt." If it is possible for the clergy to erroneously convict an innocent person, then they are obviously not "infallible"; and if it is they themselves who will be "bound" for an erroneous conviction, it is clear that God is the ultimate judge. See: St. Hildegard's "Scivias", pp. 286 - 287. [/quote] [url="http://archive.joan-of-arc.org/joanofarc_footnote_578.html"]http://archive.joan-of-arc.org/joanofarc_footnote_578.html[/url] [quote]Footnote 4 "Summa Theologica" [Suppl. Q. 21 Art. 4]: Aquinas notes that there are two reasons why an excommunication may be unjust, and deals with the second and more serious of the two accordingly: "Secondly, [it may be unjust] on the part of the excommunication, through there being no proper cause, or through the sentence being passed without the forms of law being observed. In this case, if the error, on the part of the sentence, be such as to render the sentence void, this has no effect, for there is no excommunication..." In the same section he quotes St. Jerome on the principle, derived from Matthew 16:19, which forms the basis for the power to excommunicate by granting the Apostles the power to "bind and unbind": "It is a pharisaical severity to reckon as really bound or loosed, that which is bound or loosed unjustly." So Aquinas adds: "But that severity was proud and erroneous. Therefore an unjust excommunication has no effect." See: Aquinas' "Summa Theologica" at NewAdvent. [/quote] [url="http://archive.joan-of-arc.org/joanofarc_footnote_579.html"]http://archive.joan-of-arc.org/joanofarc_footnote_579.html[/url]
Cure of Ars Posted November 17, 2004 Posted November 17, 2004 (edited) [quote][b]Dissenters from papal authority, trying to downplay the authority of documents such as Humanae Vitae and Ordinatio Sacerdotalis, use Joan of Arc as an example of the Church making a decision and then reversing it, thereby proving itself fallible. What is the story of Joan of Arc, and does it make a dent in infallibility? [/b] Joan of Arc was born in France in 1412. A poor, illiterate peasant girl known for her piety, she began hearing "voices" from God at age 13. Five years later she revealed the message of the voices: to deliver France from the control of England, gained by Henry V in the Treaty of Troyes in 1420. Joan convinced Charles VII (known as the Dauphin), rightful heir to the French crown, to assemble an army and help relieve the city of Orleans, which had resisted the English and been under siege for eight months. With Joan in command, the French army marched on Orleans and ended the siege in eight days. A succession of further victories saw Joan present at Charles's coronation at Rheims in 1429. Charles, once crowned, became apathetic and opposed Joan's plans for further action, and when she tried to move to relieve the city of Compiegne, she was arrested and, in 1430, sold to the English, who wished to eliminate their staunchest adversary and at the same time discredit the coronation of Charles, owed directly to Joan. Pierre Cauchon, bishop of Beauvais and strong ally of the English, tricked her into an admission of guilt, and, after a three-month trial, she was convicted of heresy. She was excommunicated and turned over to the state, which on May 30, 1431 had her burned at the stake. In 1456, after a posthumous trial, Joan was formally rehabilitated by Rome, which canonized her in 1920. This reversal of Cauchon's judgment in no way affects the Church's teaching authority. [color=red]A lone bishop's determinations of an individual's sanctity or personal revelations does not fall under the Church's charism of infallibility. Joan was condemned by an individual bishop who had a clearly political agenda. [/color] Cauchon's personal corruption says nothing about the universal Church's ability to teach authoritatively on matters of faith and morals. On the positive side, note the relative speed (by fifteenth-century standards) with which she was rehabilitated; keep in mind also that she was burned by the secular power, not by the Church. [/quote] [url="http://www.newadvent.org/library/almanac_thisrock94.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/library/almanac_thisrock94.htm[/url] Edited November 17, 2004 by Cure of Ars
phatcatholic Posted November 17, 2004 Posted November 17, 2004 also this, from [url="http://www.geocities.com/prisoner_girl/Joan_Myths.html"][b]Myths and Distortions about Joan of Arc[/b][/url] (in the Anti-Catholicism entry):[list] [*]It's still erroneously believed that Joan of Arc was tried and convicted by the Inquisition with the blessing of the Catholic Church, even though the main judge, Pierre Cauchon, was not a member of the Inquisition, and the only representative of the Inquisition to preside at the trial (a Vice-Inquisitor named Jean LeMaistre) was induced to attend after being threatened by the English. LeMaistre seems to have felt that the trial was illegal from the beginning, a position with which his fellow Inquisitor Jean Bréhal wholeheartedly agreed when the case was appealed and came up for a retrial about 20 years after her death (from 1450-1456), leading the Church to overturn the original conviction. Cauchon himself did not even have the legal jurisdiction to try the case under canon law, and his own notaries (the clergymen Guillaume Manchon, Guillaume Colles de Boisguillaume, and Nicolas Tacquel, who served as clerks at the trial) accused him and the English of fraud, bias, and intimidation, as did several of the clergy who were chosen to serve as assessors. One of these was imprisoned for speaking out against the dishonest tactics which were being used against Joan of Arc, and another was told that he'd be thrown into the Seine unless he kept his mouth shut. [/list]
Guest JeffCR07 Posted November 17, 2004 Posted November 17, 2004 dang guys, that was a seriously thorough response
phatcatholic Posted November 17, 2004 Posted November 17, 2004 [quote name='JeffCR07' date='Nov 17 2004, 12:38 PM'] dang guys, that was a seriously thorough response [/quote] that's how we get down
phatcatholic Posted November 18, 2004 Posted November 18, 2004 balthazor................welcome to the Apo board. take off ur coat and stay a while
StColette Posted November 18, 2004 Posted November 18, 2004 I really love topics like this lol I agree with Jeff great responses
Balthazor Posted November 18, 2004 Author Posted November 18, 2004 [quote name='phatcatholic' date='Nov 17 2004, 11:15 PM'] balthazor................welcome to the Apo board. take off ur coat and stay a while [/quote] Thanks a lot I appreciate the education, I will probably be posting here a lot. I get a lot of questions from curious and sometimes condemnatious people..... so I will have someone write down a question I can not answer or am unsure of off hand and then when I get the answer I get back to them, I am admittedly an amature apologist, but I am a good medium. These guys would never ask a priest or look it up on the internet or come to phatmass.... so I am kinda like Gods messenger girl Thank you all so much for your thoughtful and thorough answers.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now