Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

traditionalist teaching


Recommended Posts

Posted

Alright guys I got another question from my friend from school. It wouldn't be so hard with this guy except he is on a higher level than I am on... he took a year long course in how to not-be-Catholic!

Here it is in his own hand writing:

I & II Peter and James,
Specifically reject traditionalist teachings as well as inner-church legalism.... (i.e. circumcision of Gentiles) how does this rectify with the teaching at the [u]authority [/u]of Catholic tradition?



Okay guys have fun and thanks again,

Balthazor

Posted

i haven't forgotten about ya bro. i plan on responding to this as soon as i get a chance........

Posted

I don't understand the question. :mellow:

Fiat_Voluntas_Tua
Posted

neither do I??? I like simple question's...I am a man of simple questions and simple premises.

Totus Tuus,
Andrew

Posted (edited)

your friend is rather vague, so i can only guess as to what he is referring to w/ different statements. i will try to answer the best i can

[quote]I & II Peter and James,
Specifically reject traditionalist teachings as well as inner-church legalism.... (i.e. circumcision of Gentiles)[/quote]
what exactly does he mean by "traditionalist teachings"? since he pairs this phrase w/ "inner-church legalism" i assume that he means "a church w/ a visible structure and hierarchy of authority." operating under this assumption, i hardly see how 1 & 11 Peter and James refute this image of the Church.

1st Peter is about the salvation we have received through Christ Jesus, and how we should behave as new creatures and children of God. it is also a word of caution that we will suffer as Christians, but through suffering we obtain the grace that brings us to our ultimate goal: eternal life with Jesus. where does this speak against a "traditionalist" or "legalistic" church? if anything, 1st Peter affirms a church w/ a structure like ours. in ch. 5, Peter speaks to presbyters who tend the flock, and to the laity that must follow them:

[b]1 Pet 5: 1-5[/b]
[b]1 [/b]So I exhort the presbyters among you, as a fellow presbyter and witness to the sufferings of Christ and one who has a share in the glory to be revealed.
[b]2 [/b]Tend the flock of God in your midst, (overseeing) not by constraint but willingly, as God would have it, not for shameful profit but eagerly.
[b]3 [/b]Do not lord it over those assigned to you, but be examples to the flock.
[b]4 [/b]And when the chief Shepherd is revealed, you will receive the unfading crown of glory.
[b]5 [/b]Likewise, you younger members, be subject to the presbyters. And all of you, clothe yourselves with humility in your dealings with one another, for: "God opposes the proud but bestows favor on the humble."


i don't see how II Peter rejects "traditionalist teachings" either. its not even about how the Church should be structured or how it should be goverened. instead, the entire letter is a warning to the church about wolves in sheep's clothing, and about how we should prepare ourselves for the coming of the Lord. in fact, one characteristic of the deceiver that Peter warns us about is the tendancy to [i]reject[/i] authority ([b][url="http://bible.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?new=1&word=2+Pet+2%3A10§ion=0&version=str&language=en"]2 Pet 2:10[/url][/b]). so, this letter too is an affirmation before it is a rejection.


in James we find our first hint at something that could be used to speak against the Catholic idea of "church" and "religion":

[b]James 1:26-27[/b]
[b]26 [/b]If anyone thinks he is religious and does not bridle his tongue but deceives his heart, his religion is vain.
[b]27 [/b]Religion that is pure and undefiled before God and the Father is this: to care for orphans and widows in their affliction and to keep oneself unstained by the world.

anyone who viewed Catholicism as merely a religion whose adherents abandon a foundation of love and think it only important to call oneself "catholic" could indeed use this verse against the Church. but, that is not Catholicism. being catholic means uniting onself to the Body of Christ and embracing Truth in its fullness. it has never been good enough to merely be a technical member of the Church and go about the motions. catholics don't depend on a "religion," we depend on the One Body of Christ instituted by Christ himself to unite us to Himself. therefore, this verse from James gives me no cause to be alarmed and it is hardly accusatory.

also, for a letter that is supposed to reject legalism, the following verses are quite out of character:

[b]James 2:10-12[/b]
[b]10 [/b]For whoever keeps the whole law, but falls short in one particular, has become guilty in respect to all of it.
[b]11 [/b]For he who said, "You shall not commit adultery," also said, "You shall not kill." Even if you do not commit adultery but kill, you have become a transgressor of the law.
[b]12 [/b]So speak and so act as people who will be judged by the law of freedom.

these seem to be rather legalistic words from an apostle who supposedly rejects such a notion. follow the law. keep every portion of it. if you transgress it, you will be judged. actually, this disctinction between different transgressions of the law points to legalism on the part [i]of the protestant[/i], not the Catholic. afterall, it is the protestant who believes that ALL sins are equal in their effect on our soul (at least, this is my impression of their position), whereas Catholics make the necessary distinction between sins that are mortal and sins that are not. is not the protestant more unrelenting?

in ch. 5 the Catholic Church is affirmed even more:

[b]James 5:14-15[/b]
[b]14 [/b]Is anyone among you sick? He should summon the presbyters of the church, and they should pray over him and anoint (him) with oil in the name of the Lord,
[b]15 [/b]and the prayer of faith will save the sick person, and the Lord will raise him up. If he has committed any sins, he will be forgiven.

men are healed and forgiven by God [i]through the presbyters of the Church[/i]. this is subordinate mediation by persons of authority, who lend to the Church its visible nature and hierarchical structure. very "traditional" if you ask me ;)


[quote]how does this rectify with the teaching at the [u]authority [/u]of Catholic tradition?[/quote]
i would say quite well. i have provided several examples that in fact support the authority of the Church, and see nothing in the works of Peter or James that would deny this, even when i force myself to read them w/ a protestant mindset. i am curious to see how your friend supports his claims.

i hope this helps

pax christi,
phatcatholic

Edited by phatcatholic
Posted

I know ...this is one of the reasons he is so hard to debate with.... I will tyr to get him online or try to get him to clarify. thank you though

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...