hopeful1 Posted November 19, 2004 Posted November 19, 2004 we were discussing PAS today in one of my classes today, but someone said that a form of PAS already exists. For example, a person in hospice is in a tremendous amount of pain and near death is given morphine. however the person is given increased amounts of morphine to control the pain, until he's given so much that it evenually chokes the person and kills him/her. Now i may have typed this wrong so it may sound a little muddled, but after thinking this example over, it almost sounded like this example falls under the theory of Double Effect, where an unintended consequence happens as a result. The way i interpreted it was the morphine was continually given with the intent to control/ease the pain, but the death of the patient was unintended. Is this correct or morally sound with the church's teaching on euthanasia/PAS? Did this question make any sense?
Adeodatus Posted November 23, 2004 Posted November 23, 2004 Yes, the example you give, or rather your own interpretation of it, does fall in the category of Duble Effect. When people who are dying are in pain, they are usually given morphine or some other opiate painkiller. Morphine in higher doses has the side-effect of compromising respiration. So when someone is in great pain and distress, what do you do? Leave them in pain, or help alleviate their pain although it will make their breathing worse? From my days in the Guild of Catholic Doctors, we always understood that this was a clear-cut case of double effect. We would give morphine with the intention of relieving pain, and enough morphine to achieve that effect (i.e. pain-killing). We did not give a huge bolus of morphine with any other intention (i.e. patient-killing!). The side-effect of such high doses of pain killers, given with the intention of relieving pain, is the hastening of death. And this is tolerated as an evil side-effect---but it is not the intended outcome of medical treatment. The principle of Double Effect can be misused. Any action that is done cannot in itself INTEND the death of an innocent person. So for example, you cannot kill a fetus saying that your intention is to treat the mother. In the case mentioned above, it does sound close to intending the death of the patient, but that is not true. Death is not intended or desired. We may know it is close for this patient, but we do not hurry the process. We only treat the patient for the pain he or she has, no more, no less.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now