Krush2k2 Posted November 19, 2004 Posted November 19, 2004 I dont see how since incest is a major sin, God's plan for the human race was to be out of incest. Adam and Eve-who did thier kids procreate with? They didnt have any daughters??
Adeodatus Posted November 23, 2004 Posted November 23, 2004 The book of Genesis, especially in its first 11 chapters, is not to be read as though it is literal history. St Augustine noted this, and St Thomas Aquinas said of those people who insisted on reading the beginning of Genesis literally, that they "will make us [Christians] the laughing-stock" of the world. Having said this, Genesis is the inspired word of God and has truths to teach us. One of those truths is that mankind rebelled against God at its very beginning. We all descend from this common source, we are all humans descended from the first humans. Now if the first humans were a whole group, then your incest problem doesn't arise. If the first humans were a pair of humans, Adam and Eve, then the incest question arises. How were the first humans created? The Bible tells us that humans are made of the earth (adamah) into which God breathed His Spirit, and that is why we were given the name 'earth-creature' (adam). Humans could never have arisen from other primates MERELY as the result of evolution from other primates. That is, if you let evolution take place, nature alone cannot result in the ensoulled bodies which we call 'human beings'. You might get non-rational creatures which look just like humans, but they would not be human beings. Just funny looking apes. Would the children of Adam and Eve have procreated with such 'humanoid apes'? I doubt it! Even if these other psuedo-humans existed, reproducing with them is not consonant with the dignity of human beings. That would be bestiality. So we're back to the incest problem again. But there is a solution. Incest is a terrible sin, and it is also against natural law. But God can dispense from natural law. The Catholic Church, which is after all the Church of Christ Himself, has the power to dispense from natural law in serious situations. In the early 1970s there was a case in Italy when a husband and wife discovered to their horror that they were in fact brother and sister, given up at birth and adopted separately. Pope Paul VI exercised the power of the Church and dispensed them from the requirements of natural law, and permitted them to remain together as husband and wife and to raise their children and be a family. So it is entirely possible that if God intended all humans to descend from a single pair of human beings, and not to reproduce with any other (non-rational) species, then He certainly has the power to dispense His creatures from natural law in this respect, and allow the second generation to marry their brothers and sisters. As for God's plans coming out of major sins, seeing that the season of Advent is almost upon us, listen closely to the Gospel on 17 December, the day Advent goes into high gear. It's the genealogy of Christ from Matthew's Gospel which lists practically every scumbag in the Old Testament: murderers, adulterers, liars, thieves, etc. And out of all this evil God brings forth a great good, the greatest good, which no one could have imagined: Our Lord Jesus Christ. Jesus, like us, is a descendant of Adam and Eve, and like us, descended also from the incestuous second generation of human beings, the immediate children of Adam and Eve.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now