popestpiusx Posted November 22, 2004 Posted November 22, 2004 [quote name='DemonSlayer' date='Nov 22 2004, 05:20 AM'] Not sure about Medjegorje, but the pope believes in it it seems. [/quote] Not so. Ratzinger made it very clear that the statement attributed to the Holy Father was false.
popestpiusx Posted November 22, 2004 Posted November 22, 2004 [quote name='the_rev' date='Nov 22 2004, 08:46 AM'] You heard... Let's leave it at that. [/quote] To leave it at that would be gossip, even calumny. See [url="http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showtopic=9859&st=50"]http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showtopic=9859&st=50[/url] where this is discussed.
popestpiusx Posted November 22, 2004 Posted November 22, 2004 Here is what I was attempting to link to: The first incident is documented in the 1990 statement by Msgr. Zanic which is printed in full under the date May 1990. It concerns a Franciscan priest, Father Ivica Vego, who was dispensed from his vows and expelled from the Franciscan Order by a direct command of Pope John Paul II. Father Vego seduced a nun, Sister Leopolda, and when she became pregnant they both left the religious life and began to live together near Medjugorje where their child was born. They now have two children. But prior to this, Fr. Vego refused to accept his expulsion and continued to celebrate Mass, administer the sacraments, and pass the time with his mistress. Why mention such a distasteful event? The reason is that the seers claimed that Our Lady appeared to them on thirteen occasions stating that Father Vego was innocent, that he was as entitled to celebrate Mass as any other priest, and that the bishop was harsh! Any reader with a true sense of being a Catholic, a sensus catholicus, will need to read no further to realise the full extent of the mendacity of the seers, a mendacity which cannot be excused simply on the grounds that they have been manipulated by their Franciscan mentors. What credibility can be given to those who claim that the Mother of God told them repeatedly that an immoral priest, expelled from his order on the instructions of the Holy Father himself, is innocent, and that the Bishop, who had taken the only course open to him, was the guilty party! And how does a supposedly reputable theologian, such as Father René Laurentin, who has made a great deal of money from books on Medjugorje, react when confronted with such facts. Msgr. Zanic gave us the answer. Laurentin begged the Bishop not to publish details of the incident. Msgr. Zanic told us that this has been Laurentin's consistent position—to hide the truth and defend falsehood. Despite the fact that the truth about Ivica can no longer be denied, his prayer book is still sold in Medjugorje and beyond in hundreds of thousands of copies! Propagandists for Medjugorje still insist that Ivica Vego is the innocent party and the bishop, the guilty one. Their "proof" is that Our Lady is supposed to have told Vicka that this was the case, and where they are concerned any statement by Vicka is a self-evident truth. In a pro-Medjugorje booklet published in 1991,Our Lady is alleged to have spoken as follows to Vicka on 3 January 1982: Ivica is not guilty. Have him keep the faith even if he is expelled. I do not cease to repeat, "peace, peace, peace," and in the meantime agitation increases. He is not guilty (Our Lady repeated this three times). The Bishop does not keep order. That is why he is responsible. The justice which you have not seen will come back.
mark3200 Posted November 22, 2004 Posted November 22, 2004 Here's my thoughts on the ORIGINAL post.... I heard about apparitions, et al of The Blessed Mother way before I became Catholic. I dealt with people who regularly made pilgrimages to Lourdes, Mejugore, et al. I remember seeing them display all the STUFF they had purchased while there. Now, please don't misunderstand me - I am fighting the US social consumerism approach to owning things as much as anyone else. And, I own my share of crucifixes, rosaries (although, I find I am only able to use ONE rosary at a time), bibles, etc. I guess my point is that we have a tendency to allow ourselves to become enmeshed with the consumerism surrounding holy sites. Make a pilgrimage for the sake of the Spiritual, not to see what else the tourist traps are hawking. Personally, I have yet to visit any of the sites, and remain a bit skeptical. That's OK, since belief in the apparitions (even approved ones) is not a mandatory article of faith. Yes, folks have been helped along in the Faith due to the sites, which is outstanding. Me, I don't know yet. I just don't know. Something else is obvious to me - this remains a huge point of contention, even within the Mother Church. Back to the original question: Can Satan make use of this? Let's see.....Catholics are spending time arguing amongst ourselves regarding the apparition instead of uniting. A mountain climber uses any little crack or crevasse as a handhold to pull himself up to the summit. You think this little crack might be used to drive yet ANOTHER wedge into the Church? Could just be me.....
Fides_et_Ratio Posted November 22, 2004 Posted November 22, 2004 I just went to Medjugorje in September for a few days, and honestly, even though I wasn't expecting anything, I really didn't see the point. I trecked up Apparition Hill, "witnessed" an "apparition" and heard Ivan talk. It really just didn't seem like anything special to me. Yes, it was awesome that so many people were going to Confession and going to Mass, but there's more to it than just that. I don't really have much time to explain, but I just wanted to say, as one who's actually been to Medjugorje... it's not very "real". Nothing like meeting the Pope, walking through the catacombs... etc.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now