Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I just got finished watching the last hour and 1/2 of a 2 hour special on Martin Luther on PBS.

Liam Neeson (who I thought was Catholic) narrated.

Overall, it was okay, but it seemed as if it was really trying to show Martin Luther as this great emancipator, whos only concern was the truth. To me, it almost depicted him as some kind of saint, only briefly touching on some of the negative aspects of his life right at the end of the program (where he encouraged the slaughtering of peasants).

Did anyone else see this program? I'd like to hear some other thoughts.

Posted

I was watching it for a little while, but got tired of the spin it was being done with.

For example, showing ML on the cart, traveling through the snowy wilderness then cutting to the Pope in the fancy cassock and gloves in sunny Rome, signing the excommunication decree in a dark smokey room. Come on.

Then it was a pure appeal to the American ideal of individualism when it said that ML found his greatest ally against Rome in the printing press. Then it glossed over how ML took advantage of the political state of Germany to fight Rome while having theolgians 'glow' about how brave a crusader ML was in defiance to possible burning at the stake by secular authorities after he was excommunicated.

It's no wonder Protestants continue to exist is historical denial.

Posted

And it spoke nothing of his poo fights with the devil.

Posted

That's why I stopped watching.

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

i think st. thomas more said it best when he described Luther because he was a major factor and was THE Church Defender when martin Luther was attacking the church.....

he said that Martin Luther saw the Catholic Church, "through a pair of evil spectacles of ire and envy; he was prompted by the inch and tickling of vanity and vainglory".

St. Thomas More Pray for us!

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

amesome quote Flowery!!!

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

thanks i did a bio of him...it was an "I" search...meaning you write a bio...but using "I" for the person your researching on.....it was neat. i had to do it for a history class and boy was i excited when I got to do a saint! haha my teacher was mad cuz i did st. thomas, he didn't like catholics (he was a meanie!)

Posted

How long was your bio on ML? Wanna post or link to it?

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

who' me?

:unsure::unsure:

Posted (edited)

Yeah, you.

And are there any 'poo' or 'stinker' stories? (j/k)

Edited by jasJis
littleflower+JMJ
Posted

haha no i didn't do a bio on martin luther....i did it on st. thomas more...hahah

ml's bio would have been too stinky, like what your sig says...

:unsure::unsure:

and i linked my bio on st. thomas more....but geocities is cheapo so forgive me if you can't read it....

Posted

It was on down here in Australia, on SBS.

But

I didn't watch it, because the promo made Luther seem like a hero who conquered over the Catholic Church which was described as corrupt and evil.

Posted

So, Liam Neeson isn't a Catholic anymore?

Posted

I just got finished watching the last hour and 1/2 of a 2 hour special on Martin Luther on PBS.

Liam Neeson (who I thought was Catholic) narrated.

Overall, it was okay, but it seemed as if it was really trying to show Martin Luther as this great emancipator, whos only concern was the truth. To me, it almost depicted him as some kind of saint, only briefly touching on some of the negative aspects of his life right at the end of the program (where he encouraged the slaughtering of peasants).

Did anyone else see this program? I'd like to hear some other thoughts.

I saw parts of it, and started getting annoyed because I could not counter any of what was said.... ML had deep personal issues, he was a fool.

GBLCM,

ironmonk

cmotherofpirl
Posted

It was typical anti-catholic rhetoric, made to appear as actual history.

Kilroy the Ninja
Posted

Does anyone know who made this bit of televised poo?

Posted

Man they made Luther look like a Saint and our Church like the Synagogue of satan. It was aweful. I was angry while watching it.

That man destroyed Unity in Europe. That was not a good thing. Why did he get praised for it? His followers went out and murdered thousands of Peasants. He treated the poor like agents of satan. He was a evil man if anything he was the Devil.

Posted (edited)

Ya'll please pray for me I think i'm becoming Anti-Protestant.

Edited by Mc-Just†
Posted

"Martin Luther" on PBS was pure Bull-oney -- false history presented as true and heroic. It was Luther alone against that big bad ole Catholic Church. Luther is to be counted among the "Great Emancipators" of history, one commentator opined, for "freeing us" from the clutches of the Church. The stench rising from the screen was nauseating. Truth is, little is wrong in our society today that cannot be traced to Luther and Protestantism, beginning with Individualism.

I was looking for a sponsor to boycott, but all I picked up was that 'Luther' was made possible "by contributors like you" or whatever that line is that PBS uses to mean general public contributions.

I contribute zero to PBS. Never, not ever, not one cent. They regard similated sex acts as entertainment, promote abortion, and advocate homosexual marriage, among other things, not to mention that PBS is chronically anti-Catholic .

Posted

GBLCM,

ironmonk

An accurate and truly historical book on the life of Luther would counter it! PBS got his name right, after that it was pure fabrication and distortion of the truth.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...