Lil Red Posted November 25, 2004 Posted November 25, 2004 How sad....I just got this in my Crisis e-letter: It's common at Christmastime to see Salvation Army bell-ringers at store and mall entrances. However, you'll no longer be seeing them outside of Target. The superstore chain has now forbidden the Salvation Army from collecting donations on their property. In making the decision, Target said that they receive a lot of requests from groups asking for permission to collect money or signatures in front of the stores; if they continue to allow the Salvation Army to stand there, they claim, they'll have to let everyone else do the same. This is a silly argument. As a private organization, Target has the right to choose who may or may not use their property for solicitations. Furthermore, the Salvation Army bell-ringer is an American institution -- no fair-minded person could complain if they're given an extra measure of deference. Target's decision will really hurt the Army's charitable work. Last year, the organization raised about $9 million outside of Target stores -- making the chain one of their best locations. Now, with the dramatic loss in donations, they'll have to curtail some of their work. Of course, the hardest hit are the poor children, disaster victims, shut-ins, and the elderly that the Salvation Army helps so selflessly, year after year. While it's certainly true that Target has every right to decide who collects money on their property, you and I have every right to decide where we'll spend our money. If you're like me, you'll no longer be spending it at Target.
Balthazor Posted November 25, 2004 Posted November 25, 2004 This is very sad to hear that the Salvation Army got kicked out of Target....I hate to say it but the bell ringing really annoys me. If the guy standing there isn;t ringing a bell he gets twice what I normally give. I know I am a bad person. I do feel bad that they can't or wont let the Salvation collect money there though...
Guest Aluigi Posted November 25, 2004 Posted November 25, 2004 so when does the target boycott start? i'm sure there's someone out there to organize one.
Lil Red Posted November 25, 2004 Author Posted November 25, 2004 i dunno...i just got the email tonight/this morning.
rachael Posted November 25, 2004 Posted November 25, 2004 well i've already donated to the salvation army this season, so i don't feel so bad about going to target. plus, target is my favorite store of all time.
Andrea348 Posted November 27, 2004 Posted November 27, 2004 PROBLEM: Target won't allow Salvation Army peeps to collect in front of the store SOLUTION: The Salvation Army sets up in front of Manhatten Bagels right next door to Target. when I was out shoppin today I saw them and I smiled....
cmotherofpirl Posted November 27, 2004 Posted November 27, 2004 Why would you donate to the Salvation Army [which is a church] instead of your local parish, food kitchen, or dioceasan Catholic Charity?
Lil Red Posted November 27, 2004 Author Posted November 27, 2004 then i don't understand why the Crisis email would send this to people. they are (as far as I know) pretty orthodox
Sinner Posted November 27, 2004 Posted November 27, 2004 Well...... CMOM is correct. The Salvation Army is a church. [b]Donate to your Parish instead.[/b] [b]The Arminian/Wesleyan Tradition and the Holiness/Pentecostal Movements[/b] Arminianism started in Holland, as an offshoot of Reformed theology. The distinctive issue is free will. Reformed theology sees justification as occurring entirely by God's initiative. Arminianism acknowledges that without God we are doomed. So God must initiate the process, but we respond freely, and can reject God. Arminian theology had its largest impact through John Wesley and the Methodists. Wesley was an Anglican pastor, and the Methodists were originally a sort of reform movement within the Anglican Church. It emphasized evangelical preaching, and reaching working class and poor. While there were originally Reformed participants, Wesley was Arminian, and Methodism generally adopted this theology. This Methodist/Arminian theology as the foundation of much of today's evanglicalism, although there is also a strong Reformed influence. The Wesleyan/Arminian tradition has resulted in a large number of churches in the US. First, there is the Methodist Church and some smaller Wesleyan groups. Next, there's a whole line of developments. Wesley believed in "Christian perfection", the idea that it is possible to become spiritually perfect, by an act of the Holy Spirit in purifying you. This idea, which has been variously called "entire holiness" and "crisis sanctification" developed into the Holiness movement. By this time, the Methodist Church had become a bit traditional, so these were really attempts to put some evangelical fervor into the tradition, but they also pushed Wesley's idea of perfection in a direction that eventually led to Pentecostalism: the idea that the Holy Spirit would become active in us and renew us with visible results. Churches in this family survive, e.g. the Church of the Nazarene, [b][color=red]the Salvation Army (yes, it's actually a church, not just a charity)[/color][/b], the Wesleyan Methodist Church, the Free Methodist Church, the Brethren in Christ, and the evangelical Friends.
Fool4Christ Posted November 27, 2004 Posted November 27, 2004 [quote]Balthazor Posted on Nov 25 2004, 01:31 AM This is very sad to hear that the Salvation Army got kicked out of Target....I hate to say it but the bell ringing really annoys me. If the guy standing there isn;t ringing a bell he gets twice what I normally give.[/quote] I'm sorry, but I am volunteering to ring that annoying Salvation Army bell. [quote]cmotherofpirl Posted on Nov 26 2004, 09:49 PM Why would you donate to the Salvation Army [which is a church] instead of your local parish, food kitchen, or dioceasan Catholic Charity?[/quote] Didn't know that Salvation Army was a church. That's interesting. But I don't have any problems with donating time or money to them, because they do some great things for people. I donate to Catholic charites too, but just because they are not Catholic, doesn't mean we shouldn't support them.
Balthazor Posted November 27, 2004 Posted November 27, 2004 YOu can sing.....that would be better than ringing the bell I'll give you a lot more if you don't ring, but are friendly , or sing or even stand there looking cold and grumpy. Honestly, the ringing drives me up a wall, anything but the bell, anything None the less I hope your volunteering is fruitful.
CatholicCrusader Posted November 27, 2004 Posted November 27, 2004 Just an aside: the Salvation Army is a religion (protestant religion, I think)--they don't believe in Baptism... I think it would be better to not give money and clothes, etc. to a protestant religion but rather instead to give it to St. Vincent de Paul and Catholic organizations.
crusader1234 Posted November 27, 2004 Posted November 27, 2004 I work at a soup kitchen, and I can tell you for sure that we need money more than the salvation army. Give your money (or even better, your time) to a charity that is Catholic, such as a soup kitchen.
CatholicCrusader Posted November 27, 2004 Posted November 27, 2004 [quote name='CatholicCrusader' date='Nov 27 2004, 12:27 AM'] Just an aside: the Salvation Army is a religion (protestant religion, I think)--they don't believe in Baptism... I think it would be better to not give money and clothes, etc. to a protestant religion but rather instead to give it to St. Vincent de Paul and Catholic organizations. [/quote] Sorry I hadn't read through the thread first. It seems the point was already made.
shelly_freak Posted November 27, 2004 Posted November 27, 2004 To tell you the truth it doesn't matter to me that the Salvation Army isn't Catholic.
crusader1234 Posted November 27, 2004 Posted November 27, 2004 I think any honest charity is good - I just think that Salvation Army doesn't need as much support as a lot of others do.
cmotherofpirl Posted November 27, 2004 Posted November 27, 2004 I just think charity begins at home. Start with your local parish, before you support other religions.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now