dtofdh Posted December 1, 2004 Posted December 1, 2004 I was asked this question: [quote]In deciding whether to submit to the authority of the Bible or that of the Church, we need to take into consideration the fact that what the Catholic Church believes to be right or wrong changes with the passing of time. To have the communion service in the language of the people was, at one time, a Protestant heresy. The mass had to be said in Latin. Then came a period of reform started by Pope John the twenty third, when it had to be in the languages of the people instead. The Bible, however, does not change and therefore cannot always agree with a changing church. [/quote] [quote]Since the Bible agrees with the present Catholic doctrine that eating meat on Fridays is not sin, it could not agree earlier that eating meat on Fridays was sin. [/quote] Could someone answer this for me as soon as possible? Thank you, Gina
cmotherofpirl Posted December 1, 2004 Posted December 1, 2004 The quick answer is that the Catholic Church is older than the bible we have today, and in fact are the people who put it together. Jesus founded the Church in 33 AD, and the bible reached its current form in 497 AD after a Catholic Church council what books would be in the canon and what would not. The person who wrote the comment does not understand the difference between Dogma which never changes, doctrine - the various explanations we have of dogma, and discipline - how we carry out various activities of the Church - the forms and words of the Mass and Sacraments. They also do not understand the Church is the final earthly authority - the loosing and the binding. Please look up above in the reference section for sections on the Bible and Church Authority.
amarkich Posted December 1, 2004 Posted December 1, 2004 The least that we can say, in reply to this kind of thing, is that such changes in discipline may be scandalous but are not heretical insofar as they are not dogmas. While it is certainly better to have Mass in Latin, this is not required right now (hopefully this will change back). Also, the Church still commands that the faithful abstain from meat on Fridays. It is a myth that this is no longer a law of the Church. Ask a canon lawyer about it. The one here in the Archdiocese of Atlanta (who is on the tribunal for the Archdiocese) has said that it is still the Church's law (and anyone who is able to read can affirm this). Here is what Canon Law says: Can. 1251 Abstinence from meat, or from some other food as determined by the Episcopal Conference, is to be observed on all Fridays, unless a solemnity should fall on a Friday. Abstinence and fasting are to be observed on Ash Wednesday and Good Friday. Abstinence from meat on ALL Fridays is still binding.
Quietfire Posted December 1, 2004 Posted December 1, 2004 (edited) The Mass was said in Latin because at the time..that was the common language of the people. The Church has always provided Scripture in common language according to country. Most learned people spoke and read Latin. If you couldnt read though, what good would an English, (spanish, dutch,latin whatever,) Bible do you? There is more to it than that though. Please read "Where we got the Bible-our debt to the Catholic Church" small book....big punch. Edited December 1, 2004 by Quietfire
Mateo el Feo Posted December 1, 2004 Posted December 1, 2004 (edited) [quote name='amarkich' date='Nov 30 2004, 11:44 PM'] The least that we can say, in reply to this kind of thing, is that such changes in discipline may be scandalous but are not heretical insofar as they are not dogmas. While it is certainly better to have Mass in Latin, this is not required right now (hopefully this will change back). Also, the Church still commands that the faithful abstain from meat on Fridays. It is a myth that this is no longer a law of the Church. Ask a canon lawyer about it. The one here in the Archdiocese of Atlanta (who is on the tribunal for the Archdiocese) has said that it is still the Church's law (and anyone who is able to read can affirm this). Here is what Canon Law says: Can. 1251 Abstinence from meat, or from some other food as determined by the Episcopal Conference, is to be observed on all Fridays, unless a solemnity should fall on a Friday. Abstinence and fasting are to be observed on Ash Wednesday and Good Friday. Abstinence from meat on ALL Fridays is still binding. [/quote] After canon 1251, we read: [quote]Can. 1253 The Episcopal Conference can determine more particular ways in which fasting and abstinence are to be observed. In place of abstinence or fasting it can substitute, in whole or in part, other forms of penance, especially works of charity and exercises of piety. [/quote] That said, the fact remains that Friday has generally lost its meaning in the minds of most lay Catholics as a day of penance, recalling Our Lord's sacrifice on the Cross of Calvary. Also, I think the date CMom was referring to was 397 AD, not 497. [quote]To have the communion service in the language of the people was, at one time, a Protestant heresy.[/quote] Random thoughts: (1) I think the real heresy is to take the Protestant position that worship is merely a "communion service." The Catholic mass is a sacrifice to God, and that aspect was dropped by Protestantism. (2) Ironically, even Luther encouraged the continued use of Latin after he left the Church. (3) Finally, the use of Latin is a practice of the Western Church. Although the Tridentine rite was made available to the universal Church, the documents at Trent specifically mention that rites older than 200 years (maybe 300?) should be preserved and were not superceded by Trent. This includes both Eastern Rites (e.g. Byzantine, Maronite, Chaldean) and also Western Rites (e.g. Ambrosian, Mozarabic). Enjoy! Edited December 1, 2004 by Mateo el Feo
dtofdh Posted December 5, 2004 Author Posted December 5, 2004 Thank you all for responding so quickly. My husband and I have been debating with some friends from a Protestant church that he used to belong to. We are newbies here and I have to say I am really impressed with this board. I really appreciate the way people respond in such a timely manner. People here seem to be so kind and respectful, there are a lot of resources to draw from, and there's always a lot of action on this board! This board is a really great support system for us while we attempt to minister to our Protestant friends from the Catholic perspective. Your responses really helped. God Bless, Gina
phatcatholic Posted December 5, 2004 Posted December 5, 2004 (edited) dtofdh, make sure you check out the [url="http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showforum=21"][b]reference section[/b][/url]. it should have all the information you need in order to share this faith we hold so dear pax christi, phatcatholic Edited December 5, 2004 by phatcatholic
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now