Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

protestants and indulgences


Recommended Posts

CreepyCrawler
Posted

I was thinkin' the other day...indulgences aren't really a way to buy your way out of purgatory, they are a way to make us holier, right? because purgatory is to purify us and make us holy and an indulgence gets us 'less time' in purgatory, which basically means God makes us holy through whatever act. BUT i understand you have to ask for an indulgence specifically (and go to confession, mass, and other-requirements) in order to be granted one. but protestants don't ask for indulgences b/c they don't know about purgatory. they simply try and do things and pray in order to be made holier, like reading the bible (which i believe is an indulgence if you do it for half and hour) or doing charity work or praying. but aren't these actions just like an indulgence in that the purpose is to be made holier (and God can see our hearts) and these things can make us holier, meaning we wouldn't have to spend AS much time being purified as if we hadn't done these things? does that make sense?

Posted

An indulgence does impart grace (makes us holier) but so do all charitable acts. Specifically what makes an indulgence and indulgence is that it remits (partially or completely) our temporal punishment for our sinfulness. Basically, our sins are forigiven by God and we are given grace when we confess. Yet, the effects of that sin and the need for purification (purgatory) remains. An indulgence remits part (or all) of the effects and need for purification.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...