Sojourner Posted December 7, 2004 Posted December 7, 2004 I'm still struggling with the newness of Catholicism. As a disclaimer, I'm totally confident that I made the right choice to become Catholic, and I'm now at a place where I actually have a few good friends at my church and a few other places, which is really good. However, I don't quite feel like I fit in yet. Like I went to a Catholic Bible study last night, and I walked in and didn't know anyone and hardly anyone talked to me and I felt totally like an outsider. It really hit home to me yet again that I didn't grow up in this church. All the people I know from my childhood are Protestant, and the main part of my friend network is Protestant. I knew, of course, that things would be different in my life when I became Catholic, but I guess I didn't fully anticipate just how different. Like, I realized yesterday that my new Bible doesn't have any highlights in it. I have the same Bible I used as a teenager, and it's got hightlights of various verses that have been important to me over the years, but now I have to start totally over with a different Bible. And all the verses I memorized as a kid are in the wrong version. So I just wonder when I will stop feeling like the new kid on the block. When will walking into a Catholic church feel as natural as walking into a Protestant church? I guess I feel like I keep getting these little reminders that I'm not part of the "club" or something like that, and last night really drove that home.
Fiat_Voluntas_Tua Posted December 7, 2004 Posted December 7, 2004 I kind of felt the same way...I have been Catholic for about a year. And I LOVE IT! But at times I feel like I am a 'newbie'...I have never had any Advent traditions or Christmas traditions...but I like the fact that my soul feels at home, even if my body doesn't. Totus Tuus, Andrew Joseph
Sojourner Posted December 7, 2004 Author Posted December 7, 2004 [quote name='Fiat_Voluntas_Tua' date='Dec 7 2004, 10:54 AM'] I kind of felt the same way...I have been Catholic for about a year. And I LOVE IT! But at times I feel like I am a 'newbie'...I have never had any Advent traditions or Christmas traditions...but I like the fact that my soul feels at home, even if my body doesn't. Totus Tuus, Andrew Joseph [/quote] That's a good way of putting it, I think. My soul definitely does feel at home, that's for sure. I also do love the whole building new traditions into my life ... my family never did much to anticipate or celebrate Christmas or Easter, so it's nice to spend these seasons focusing on internal conversion.
homeschoolmom Posted December 7, 2004 Posted December 7, 2004 I know how you feel, Soj.... I was thinking about some of these things myself lately. I realized that I'm Catholic yesterday when I learned that my friend had lost his job... my instant thought was to ask St. Joseph for his intercession on behalf of my friend... Not my nature, to be sure... My very good (protestant) friend lamented the other day that her church (our former church) didn't do anything to signal the beginning of Advent. (She's really Catholic, she doesn't know it yet)... They sometimes do, and they sometimes don't. But she was pretty bothered by the fact that even in children's church they didn't say or do anything... I wanted to say, "well, what did you expect?" but I didn't because the time and place was not appropriate, but I will get back to her. (She aslo lamented during Lent that she wished her children were being taught more about the Passion... but I digress)... I am starting to be comfortable in our new parish... though not as at home as I used to be in our old church.
Sojourner Posted December 7, 2004 Author Posted December 7, 2004 It's interesting, I also recently had an experience that drove home the fact that I'm not Protestant anymore, either ... I went to my old church, and while it was good to see several friends, I found that I was irritated that the church had stolen so many things I consider "Catholic" -- like, they celebrate church seasons (they even put up the different colors for different seasons) they have a similar worship order, and they celebrate communion every week. Where I once liked these things, now I think it's a cheap reflection of the beauty of a church I've come to love. They want all the trappings of Catholicism without having the heart of it. It makes me feel offended, but also sad.
homeschoolmom Posted December 7, 2004 Posted December 7, 2004 We were at our old church last Sunday afternoon for their children's Christmas program... HSkids' friends were in it (and they would have been, too, had things been different). It was a lavish production... a huge musical... not a "pagent" per se. It was a story of Christmas from the angels' perspecive... Whatever. HSdaughter wasn't sure if she wanted to go or not-- feeling that she'd be left out.... ... I think the fact that she's in our much lower key children's choir made it easier. Our choir meets only three times before serving (I say that rather than "performing"...) as opposed to the year round choir of our old church... I am very happy that the children's choir will sing carols at Mass on Christmas Eve. Then they sing again at Easter. Nuff for me... and it's participating in the worship-- not a separate "child focused" production... Anyway, it was weird being back there. Like going back to your college town after many years away... or something like that...
homeschoolmom Posted December 7, 2004 Posted December 7, 2004 [quote name='Sojourner' date='Dec 7 2004, 11:59 AM'] They want all the trappings of Catholicism without having the heart of it. It makes me feel offended, but also sad. [/quote] they [b]think[/b] they have the [color=red]heart[/color] of it without the trappings... It should also offend you that they have Bibles... I guess I'm not offended by these things... Though I find it odd.
Sojourner Posted December 7, 2004 Author Posted December 7, 2004 Yeah, you're right about that. There's definitely a lot of sadness, and maybe offended isn't the right word ... maybe it's frustration or something along those lines. It's just the thought that you can enjoy the icing without the cake. Yes, it tastes sweet, but there's so much more substance if you have the cake too ...
AfroNova No Limit Soldier Posted December 8, 2004 Posted December 8, 2004 May I offer you a suggestion? Get involved - volunteer, teach CCE, etc. Call the diocesan (sp?) office, get involved with young adult ministry/youth ministry, go on retreats. That's how I met so many awesome people. And remember that you don't have to go out looking for anyone. The good Lord will send them all to you. You just have to get involved. Blessings in Christ through Mary to you! JMJ
Sojourner Posted December 9, 2004 Author Posted December 9, 2004 [quote name='AfroNova No Limit Soldier' date='Dec 8 2004, 05:22 PM'] May I offer you a suggestion? Get involved - volunteer, teach CCE, etc. Call the diocesan (sp?) office, get involved with young adult ministry/youth ministry, go on retreats. That's how I met so many awesome people. And remember that you don't have to go out looking for anyone. The good Lord will send them all to you. You just have to get involved. Blessings in Christ through Mary to you! JMJ [/quote] Really, it's not about not being involved. I'm actually pretty involved with several different activities ... hence, I've been able to make some friends. The thing is that everything is still new, and I'm constantly reminded that this is not the faith or the church that I grew up in, and that I don't quite fit in yet.
homeschoolmom Posted December 9, 2004 Posted December 9, 2004 Last night we were at a talk given by our priest on Vatican 2 (what was supposed to happen, what happened-- good and bad, very well done, btw). It was a very casual talk. Anyway, our priest light-heartedly mentioned that HSdad and I were recent converts... that we came from a very Scripture rich background... we were going to help bring Catholics up to speed... etc. It was all light hearted... Then a few minutes later, he wanted to discuss the Council of Jerusalem, so he starts looking in the bible for Acts... and he was flipping around... and he said, "I know it's here right after Luke..." and someone said, "Uh, it's after John"... To which I jokingly said, "Oh great, we're outta here." and got up as if to leave... Poor Father... he wasn't joking... and being Irish, he I have no idea why I am including this anticdote here... I had a point when I started...
Sojourner Posted December 9, 2004 Author Posted December 9, 2004 I think one of the hardest things has been not throwing out the baby with the bathwater when it comes to my upbringing ... like you say, hsmom, we former Prots have very scripture-rich backgrounds, which is something many of our other Catholic brethren don't have, sadly.
duarc Posted December 9, 2004 Posted December 9, 2004 I know how you feel about not fitting in. It's happened to me thrice. One was when I went with my little brother to his church (I don't remember the sermon that day but I know it made me mad) and when I went with my dad to his meeting thing a few weeks ago. When I actually had a bible with me, I was so lost. I don't know my way around a bible. (My little brothers were so fustrated with me when I kept asking them were what book of the bible was The eldest of them made some crack about Catholics later on that made me want to knock his block off, though. ) The third was when I started going to my current church. I still don't talk to many people though. It makes me miss the little parish I went to a few years ago. People were so friendly there.
daugher-of-Mary Posted December 9, 2004 Posted December 9, 2004 Yeah, I know how you feel. I was walking down to Adoration the other day and passed by a little Protestant church. It really hit me that I've been Catholic for 5 years, and I would rather die than leave the Church, but I do miss really knowing the people I go to church with. My parish is too large to get to know everyone personally as I did as a protestant.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now