hopeful1 Posted December 13, 2004 Posted December 13, 2004 O, i got into an arguement with someone at school today about organized religion, and some guy said he was against it because it creates prejudice and causes wars like the Crusades (believes in god tho). So i asked him if he thought that truth was subjective, and he just shrugged it off and said people are goin to believe different things anyway. i don't know if i'll be speaking with this person again, but how would i defend this arguement in the future?
Don John of Austria Posted December 13, 2004 Posted December 13, 2004 I would begin by asking him what was wrong with the Crusades, ask him to be specific, usually people are so ignorant of tem they can't form any real arguements agianstthem, then you have a place to start, with his ignorance, once he admitshis ignorance abut one thing it will be easier to show him that he is ignorant of other things, and that is where you can start showing him the Truth of the Faith.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 13, 2004 Posted December 13, 2004 Just because people will believe different things doesn't mean that the truth is determined by popular vote. In any event, wars aren't inherent to organized religion, they are inherent to an abuse of organized religion. The closest claim he could make is that organized religion is necessary for there to be an abuse of it, but that doesn't mean that organized religion itself is the cause of the wars and such. Not even that...it is an abuse of organization which happens to be religious, not of religion itself. Any organization can be abused that way, but it doesn't make all organizations a bad thing. Instead, it is those who are trying to disorganize the organizations, by sending them off to causes they aren't meant for, who cause the wars and such. It is the people who are against organized religion, in a sense, who are behind the misuse of organized religion. Instead, a person should recognize the inherent goodness in organized religion (and in organizations in general) and should work to keep those organizations safe from people who would try to abuse them. It may be harder than just disregarding organizations as a whole, but if we guide organized religion properly and use it correctly, it can bring about great good, whereas apathy toward organized religion can really do no good, but can only lead people astray.
spathariossa Posted December 13, 2004 Posted December 13, 2004 The crusades were NOT an invasion of "muslim lands." Gimme a break. I've heard this ignorant view so many times it makes me ill. The crusades were an attempt at winning back Christian lands from Muslim invaders. At the time of the crusades, the muslims had been in control of the holy land for 300 years, true enough. However, they stole the lands from the Byzantine empire who had held them for 700 years. They also stole Egypt, North Africa, Sicily, and Spain. It was a full scale invasion of Europe that predated the crusades by 300 years. Then, the Turks began threatening to destroy Constantinople and Alexios Komnenos (one of the best Emperors of the later Empire imho - even if the Alexiad was propaganda) wrote to the pope for help. He wanted a small mercenary army to defeat the Turks. However, when Pope Clement preached the crusade, thousands of men, women, and children took up the call. Through a series of miracles, they destroyed the Turkish army, captured many important cities and finally after 3-4 years they captured Jerusalem itself. Every crusade after that first one in the Holy Land was an attempt to keep the muslims at bay and hold onto the Holy Land. Now, as for other crusades after the first crusade, they have many reasons. The Northern Crusades against pagans in the Baltic were carried out by the Poles (Wends) and have been dubbed the Wendish Crusades. They were followed by The Prussian Crusade and the Samogitian Crusade fought by the Teutonic Knights. The baltic states contained the last pagans in Europe. THese people were highly aggressive and tended to attack nearby Catholic states. Therefore subduing them was necessary in order to achieve safety for Poland. The Spanish Crusades were also clearly in the right. They were there to push the muslim conquerors out of Spain. The reconquista is often looked upon as barbaric by modern liberals who lack an understanding of, well, anything. The truth is that the Muslims invaded Spain, set up their own government, and enforced their culture on the Christians. One is often mistaken in believing that the Christians killed all muslims while the muslims let Christians live in peace. In actual fact, the Christians just wanted to retake their homeland and for several hundred years they didn't care what the religious views of the peasantry were. That people were converted to christianity is more a sign of it returning to dominance that anything. After all, Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan, Syria, Israel, Algeria, Somalia, etc, all used to be Christian. Finally, the Albigensian crusades of the early 13th century were sent to put down the Cathar heresy - a form of manicheism. I haven't studied this crusade extensively simply because of the lack of crusading orders but I'm getting there.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 13, 2004 Posted December 13, 2004 [quote name='spathariossa' date='Dec 13 2004, 02:50 PM'] The crusades were NOT an invasion of "muslim lands." Gimme a break. I've heard this ignorant view so many times it makes me ill. The crusades were an attempt at winning back Christian lands from Muslim invaders. At the time of the crusades, the muslims had been in control of the holy land for 300 years, true enough. However, they stole the lands from the Byzantine empire who had held them for 700 years. They also stole Egypt, North Africa, Sicily, and Spain. It was a full scale invasion of Europe that predated the crusades by 300 years. Then, the Turks began threatening to destroy Constantinople and Alexios Komnenos (one of the best Emperors of the later Empire imho - even if the Alexiad was propaganda) wrote to the pope for help. He wanted a small mercenary army to defeat the Turks. However, when Pope Clement preached the crusade, thousands of men, women, and children took up the call. Through a series of miracles, they destroyed the Turkish army, captured many important cities and finally after 3-4 years they captured Jerusalem itself. Every crusade after that first one in the Holy Land was an attempt to keep the muslims at bay and hold onto the Holy Land. Now, as for other crusades after the first crusade, they have many reasons. The Northern Crusades against pagans in the Baltic were carried out by the Poles (Wends) and have been dubbed the Wendish Crusades. They were followed by The Prussian Crusade and the Samogitian Crusade fought by the Teutonic Knights. The baltic states contained the last pagans in Europe. THese people were highly aggressive and tended to attack nearby Catholic states. Therefore subduing them was necessary in order to achieve safety for Poland. The Spanish Crusades were also clearly in the right. They were there to push the muslim conquerors out of Spain. The reconquista is often looked upon as barbaric by modern liberals who lack an understanding of, well, anything. The truth is that the Muslims invaded Spain, set up their own government, and enforced their culture on the Christians. One is often mistaken in believing that the Christians killed all muslims while the muslims let Christians live in peace. In actual fact, the Christians just wanted to retake their homeland and for several hundred years they didn't care what the religious views of the peasantry were. That people were converted to christianity is more a sign of it returning to dominance that anything. After all, Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan, Syria, Israel, Algeria, Somalia, etc, all used to be Christian. Finally, the Albigensian crusades of the early 13th century were sent to put down the Cathar heresy - a form of manicheism. I haven't studied this crusade extensively simply because of the lack of crusading orders but I'm getting there. [/quote] Alina...this is when you give your credentials so they know you are a reliable source.
spathariossa Posted December 13, 2004 Posted December 13, 2004 Also, I'm reminded of the words of CS Lewis, a brillian mant. He said something to the effect of: We have organized government, organized schools, organized healthcare, organized business, what's so wrong with organized religion?
spathariossa Posted December 13, 2004 Posted December 13, 2004 [quote name='Raphael' date='Dec 13 2004, 01:51 PM'] Alina...this is when you give your credentials so they know you are a reliable source. [/quote] Okay Alina - Official Crusades Apologist.
hopeful1 Posted December 13, 2004 Author Posted December 13, 2004 [quote name='spathariossa' date='Dec 13 2004, 02:52 PM'] Also, I'm reminded of the words of CS Lewis, a brillian mant. He said something to the effect of: We have organized government, organized schools, organized healthcare, organized business, what's so wrong with organized religion? [/quote] THANK YOU! I'll have to remember this quote.
drewmeister2 Posted December 15, 2004 Posted December 15, 2004 It is through this "organized religion" that we can grow in holiness, which leads us to Salvation. The Sacraments, which are part of the organized religion of the Catholics, give us Grace, and help lead us closer to Him. If we weren't part of this organized religion, one being the Catholic Faith, it would be hard to obtain the same Graces from the Sacraments, leading us to Him.
hopeful1 Posted December 16, 2004 Author Posted December 16, 2004 how do i explain that to an excatholic ( or at least i think he is) who may have never believed in any of that in the first place?
Scofizzle Posted December 16, 2004 Posted December 16, 2004 [quote name='spathariossa' date='Dec 13 2004, 01:50 PM'] The crusades were NOT an invasion of "muslim lands." Gimme a break. I've heard this ignorant view so many times it makes me ill. The crusades were an attempt at winning back Christian lands from Muslim invaders. At the time of the crusades, the muslims had been in control of the holy land for 300 years, true enough. However, they stole the lands from the Byzantine empire who had held them for 700 years. They also stole Egypt, North Africa, Sicily, and Spain. It was a full scale invasion of Europe that predated the crusades by 300 years. Then, the Turks began threatening to destroy Constantinople and Alexios Komnenos (one of the best Emperors of the later Empire imho - even if the Alexiad was propaganda) wrote to the pope for help. He wanted a small mercenary army to defeat the Turks. However, when Pope Clement preached the crusade, thousands of men, women, and children took up the call. Through a series of miracles, they destroyed the Turkish army, captured many important cities and finally after 3-4 years they captured Jerusalem itself. Every crusade after that first one in the Holy Land was an attempt to keep the muslims at bay and hold onto the Holy Land. Now, as for other crusades after the first crusade, they have many reasons. The Northern Crusades against pagans in the Baltic were carried out by the Poles (Wends) and have been dubbed the Wendish Crusades. They were followed by The Prussian Crusade and the Samogitian Crusade fought by the Teutonic Knights. The baltic states contained the last pagans in Europe. THese people were highly aggressive and tended to attack nearby Catholic states. Therefore subduing them was necessary in order to achieve safety for Poland. The Spanish Crusades were also clearly in the right. They were there to push the muslim conquerors out of Spain. The reconquista is often looked upon as barbaric by modern liberals who lack an understanding of, well, anything. The truth is that the Muslims invaded Spain, set up their own government, and enforced their culture on the Christians. One is often mistaken in believing that the Christians killed all muslims while the muslims let Christians live in peace. In actual fact, the Christians just wanted to retake their homeland and for several hundred years they didn't care what the religious views of the peasantry were. That people were converted to christianity is more a sign of it returning to dominance that anything. After all, Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan, Syria, Israel, Algeria, Somalia, etc, all used to be Christian. Finally, the Albigensian crusades of the early 13th century were sent to put down the Cathar heresy - a form of manicheism. I haven't studied this crusade extensively simply because of the lack of crusading orders but I'm getting there. [/quote] wow i have necer heard explained better......
nikkan_hanil Posted December 16, 2004 Posted December 16, 2004 Here is um...another anticath site... [url="http://www.jesus-is-lord.com/#rc"]http://www.jesus-is-lord.com/#rc[/url] They got a lot of confusing arguements...
Don John of Austria Posted December 17, 2004 Posted December 17, 2004 (edited) [quote]In any event, wars aren't inherent to organized religion, they are inherent to an abuse of organized religion[/quote] Raphael Ecumenical Councils have called directly for war, are you saying they where abusing religion. spathariossa -- [quote]The reconquista is often looked upon as barbaric by modern liberals who lack an understanding of, well, anything. [/quote] That was [i]AWESOME[/i], really. Your whole post was good butthat line genuinly made me laugh outloud. Edited December 17, 2004 by Don John of Austria
spathariossa Posted December 17, 2004 Posted December 17, 2004 [quote name='Don John of Austria' date='Dec 16 2004, 07:53 PM'] Raphael Ecumenical Councils have called directly for war, are you saying they where abusing religion. spathariossa -- That was [i]AWESOME[/i], really. Your whole post was good butthat line genuinly made me laugh outloud. [/quote] Thank you! Be careful though, my greatest sin is pride.
Don John of Austria Posted December 17, 2004 Posted December 17, 2004 bump because I really what raphael to answer me.
luciana Posted December 18, 2004 Posted December 18, 2004 spathariossa, great post. That's explained so well. You've studied Church history? where do you get all your info.? Something simple I can present to middle schoolers in a history class. When I tell them about the crusades, some only half-trust the truth cause they hear the half-truths and outright distortions that is the common knowledge of the crusades.
FiZzGiG Posted December 18, 2004 Posted December 18, 2004 hmmmmm... i was just thinkin about organized religion... when you think about it, you gotta ask yourself: could the United States prosper and survive through time if it didn't have a distinct leader with distinct constitution (in the sens of how the government is made up AND a list of rules/laws)? Probably not. The rules and the leader go hand in hand don't they? If there was no leader, how could the rules be properly enforced? Well i'm not politician so maybe I'm wrong. But if that's true for a country (which is a society of people), it can be true for a church as well (once again, a society of people). I'd say that the Church needs the organization in order to stand the test of time and prosper--after all it's mission lasts until the end of the world. just a thought... but that's probably incredibly weak. i'm no apologist or anything!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now