D0RK4JP2 Posted December 16, 2004 Posted December 16, 2004 Gday, I've often wondered for the past few years what can and cannot be done within a Catholic church. For example, a church is the preferred and primary place for Mass to be celebrated and the only ordinary place for the Blessed Sacrament to be kept, but holding a rock concert in a church is not allowed. Common sense tells us both of these but what of the other things that can be done in a church? I know that before Mass the GIRM says we need to keep silent but what about when you're in a church and there isn't Mass coming up? And I know that we are allowed to go and adore Jesus in the Blessed Sacrament outside of Mass, and it is definetly prescribed to do so, but what of other types of praise and worship in a Church, namely with loud music - drum kits, mic'd singers, amps, lights etc? Could someone please help me on this. I know this is the right place to go to get questions like this answered. Thanks! JMJ
Robbi Posted December 17, 2004 Posted December 17, 2004 Ive started a topic on this before on some ther site. Before I knew much about the Catholic church - I liked the idea of a band in the church, Baptists do this alot (full band, amps, drums lighting etc..) and it almost drew me to there church because of it. As a musician, I liked the idea of playing in the church because im now heavily influenced by bands such as Third Day - and love thier style of worship music. But Ive come to realise that the CATHOLIC church is not a stage for a show, but a place to worship God. Theres something special about a Catholic mass and church that I couldnt mangle it with rock music - even if it is worship music. Now and then, outside mass, I might pop in to a church and kneel and pray quietly in peace, just me and God.
Dreamweaver Posted December 17, 2004 Posted December 17, 2004 If one wants to have a concert in the church, isn't that what the church basement is for? The actual church should be devoted to only worship, with our focus on God, not guitars and drums. Wouldn't it just feel weird to have Christ in the tabernacle be secondary to a rock band in front of the altar?
p0lar_bear Posted December 17, 2004 Posted December 17, 2004 Concerts are allowed to be held in churches. The Eucharist, of course, must be moved to a different location. There is an actual document on this, but I can't remember where to find it. Also, I don't think there is any reason that praise and worship (even including guitars and the like) should not be held in a church with the Eucharist present.
Apotheoun Posted December 17, 2004 Posted December 17, 2004 Secular concerts are not permitted in Byzantine Catholic Churches. The Church building has been consecrated to God for sacred acts of worship, and thus all things profane are to be avoided. God bless, Todd
D0RK4JP2 Posted December 17, 2004 Author Posted December 17, 2004 Gday, [i'll round down the predicament to a specific example i know] There's a church in Brisbane where they have praise & worship, in the church, with drums and other loud instruments, not to mention disco lighting. They also facilitate the use of sitting on the ground, just infront of the sanctuary, by putting down bean-bags. Silence is not encouraged, for when the 'event' is over the church turns into a very noisy place, much like a hall filled with people. At all times the most Blessed Sacrament is present. I have spoken to a handfull of some of the attendees - this event is under the Charismatic movement - and they tell me it's all to do with being fired up for Jesus and being given the gifts of the Holy Spirit. A priest i know always tells me that God never contradicts Himself, so either the Church has accepted this type of activity in a church, or She hasn't, making it therefore a contradiction of God's law which they so fervently praise. Yeh, let's get more thoughts on this situation because it's becoming more and more popular - church's turning into more 'normal' place, if you get my meaning... JMJ
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now