Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Passing out Pamphlets in Department Stores


Recommended Posts

Posted

Today I was in a local store called fleet farm. It's kind of a hardware/sporting goods/farm needs department store. I have purchased some paphlets from Catholic answers called "God's Love for You". I bring a few of them in to stores with me and on occassion will ask someone if they would like one. If they do I hand it to them. If not I say God bless you and walk off. Well today I was picking up some Christmass gifts and had given a few of these out but seemed to be having more rejections that usual. A security guy came walking up and started dancing around in front of me like he was about to arrest me and like I was going to get away. Then he very sternly asked about the pamphlets and told me some people didn't like that and for me to stop. He was very rude about it. Asking me to stop is one thing but the way he acted was down right silly. I said I would stop and said God Bless you. He turned his back and walked away without a word. I left my purchases on the shelf and walked out mainly due to what I consider shabby treatment. It is certainly within their right to ask me to stop but I am a paying customer as well and you would think they would have some consideratoin for that.

I called the manager a bit later and explained my position. He was silent at first. It was apparent he didn't know how to react. I then spoke of my free speach and how I didn't see that I had to have their permission to give out pamphlets but if they told me not to I willfully submitted. It is their property. But I also said I would not check my religous beliefs at the door and felt free to say God bless you and Merry Christmass to people. His reaction was again silence. This I thought rather odd. Was he only for people making purchases in his store in honor of our saviors birthday but did not want any interaction between customers. Does he not realize that his store is being blessed by the birthday of the savior of the world. I doudt it.

I sent two emails to the company. Here is the second one. I think it quite providential the radio program that I was listening to before I went in. Read on.

I just emailed you about 10 minutes ago. In that time I talked to a manager. He did speak words of apology but essentially said I do not have free speach rights on fleet farm property. When I said I would say God bless and Merry Christmass to people in his store he gave no indication that that was okay. I could tell from his reactions to me that his apology was not heartfelt. He really didn't say much at all. Oh well. Something struck me as funny however. Just as I was going in to the store I was listening to the radio and they were talking about a store where a manager went to order some magazines for the store. He selected some magazines in a packet but left out those that were pornographic. A few days later he got a call from a lawyer saying that he was violating the magazine's free speach rights (even though it was his own Private store) by excluding the pornographic material. He stood his ground and told them to take him to court. A few days later he was fired by the store and the pornography was purchased for sale. It is my opinion that fleet farm would do similarly by my experiences there today. Therefore I will shop at Menards.

Is it wrong to pass out pamphlets at stores and in Malls which are private as well?

Blessings

Posted

It's iffy if they have no solicitation policies. I think if you tell someone "God Bless You" you are certianly in your right to. As far as passing stuff out on their property, if they ask you not to, don't.

Posted

Yes, it is wrong. It is their property and they have the right to regulate what happens in it. If someone is offended, they are going to blame the store and could threaten legal action.

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Dec 18 2004, 05:59 PM'] It's iffy if they have no solicitation policies. I think if you tell someone "God Bless You" you are certianly in your right to. As far as passing stuff out on their property, if they ask you not to, don't. [/quote]
I didn't see any and the manager didn't indicate to me that there were any when I spoke to him. I was fully willing to quit if they asked. Of course their reation was not unexpected either. It just seems they would be careful not to offend either side on the issue. I in no way represented myself as a part of fleet farm.

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Dec 18 2004, 05:59 PM'] It's iffy if they have no solicitation policies. I think if you tell someone "God Bless You" you are certianly in your right to. As far as passing stuff out on their property, if they ask you not to, don't. [/quote]
You can ussually look for a sign on the door or somewhere near the entrance and it'll list "no solicitation as one of their rules.

Posted

[quote name='p0lar_bear' date='Dec 18 2004, 06:01 PM'] Yes, it is wrong. It is their property and they have the right to regulate what happens in it. If someone is offended, they are going to blame the store and could threaten legal action. [/quote]
Polar Bear,

I agree it is within their right to tell me to stop passing out pamphlets. I most certainly am not arguing that. I don't agree that if they don't have policies forbidding it displayed that I cannot pass out pamphlets on my own initiative until they tell me to stop. As for them being sued it seems to me that according to the porn story I posted I might be able to do so if I were that sort. But of course I am not.

Do you say, polar bear that I can't say "god bless you" you in their stores either. If they forbid that then I most definitely will not shop there again.

God bless

Posted

"
soliciting

1. transitive and intransitive verb plead for something: to try to get something by making insistent requests or pleas


2. transitive verb ask somebody for something: to plead with or petition a person or group for something


3. transitive and intransitive verb offer sex for money: to offer to participate in sexual activities in return for money


4. transitive verb get somebody to do something wrong: to attempt to draw somebody into participating in illegal or immoral acts"

I saw no such policy and the manager did not indicate there was one. However I do not think that I was being insistent by any means. So I don't think I violate the definition either. I politely asked if they wanted one and if they said no left it at that.

Posted

Of course you can say "God bless you." But if you want to use their property to hand out evangelization materials, you need to ask their permission in advance. You put the management in a difficult situation by not asking. If you ask, they can take time to consider it, check with superiors and policy, etc. If you don't you end up putting the manager on duty on the spot when he or she doesn't necessarily have the authority to make a decision on it.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='p0lar_bear' date='Dec 18 2004, 06:13 PM'] Of course you can say "God bless you." But if you want to use their property to hand out evangelization materials, you need to ask their permission in advance. You put the management in a difficult situation by not asking. If you ask, they can take time to consider it, check with superiors and policy, etc. If you don't you end up putting the manager on duty on the spot when he or she doesn't necessarily have the authority to make a decision on it. [/quote]
Ok,

I guess I can buy that. Though I think the porn story puts him in another difficult situation potentially with me. I certainly don't agree that they should be able to force their trash in but I would not like to take bets on which way that one would have gone in the courts. It does seem the manager would have some legal recourse.

God bless

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

Is yours the most charitable approach?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Dec 18 2004, 06:22 PM'] Is yours the most charitable approach? [/quote]
?????

Am I charitable when I do it? I certainly make every effort to be. I insist on nothing and don't bager them if they don't accept my offer. I simply say God bless with a smile an nd walk off. By the way, it is not street preaching. I have not graduated to that level yet, though I hope to. I simply ask if they would like a pamphlet. The pamphlet speaks for itself.

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

What you did is fine. What they did is fine too. It is indeed their property (kinda like my house is mine) and they can ask you to stop doing things on their property. They can also ask you to leave. No harm no foul. And you should be polite enough to abide by this (which it seems you were). You will win more souls in your obedience than you will in your disobedience.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...