franciscanheart Posted June 5, 2006 Posted June 5, 2006 [quote name='Aloysius' post='991134' date='May 26 2006, 03:00 PM'][quote name='BonnieLass' post='991130' date='May 26 2006, 02:45 PM'][quote name='Aloysius' post='991111' date='May 26 2006, 02:19 PM'] history teaches me this lesson: prior to the late 20th century marriage ages were always very very low. after the modern world (led by the public school system, which in many ways was engineered to postpone marriage rates of young catholic irish immigrants in an attempt at population control) postponed marriage ages until mid 20's or mid 30's, the sexual revolution came in full swing and premarital sex rates rose at astronomical rates. to me that indicates that the old ways of allowing marriage closer to the time when a person's body was telling them they should marry was a better way to protect them from the temptations of premarital sexual immorality. i think rather than petitioning the church to change canon law based upon the modern culture of western civilization, we should be petitioning western civilization to learn its history lesson and fix the shambles it's created by going against natural law. the reason for the high divorce rates among young marriages is not because they are young, it is because their society is not raising them to be ready by that age; but their bodies are telling them they should be ready by that age so then they marry and it doesn't work out. in my estimation that is an indication that their society, their culture, has failed them. [/quote] However, the code which urges priests to discourage marriage by minors is universal, not regional. Cultures mature, they are not static. St. Paul said that the single/chaste life was the higher state of being. Chastity, therefore, offers one a larger portion of grace. Your argument caters to the weaker aspects of the will; whereas, chastity caters to the strengths of God's grace. Mother of BonnieLass [/quote] no, it's an argument from natural law. celibacy is a vocation of super-nature, chastity is a virtue which permeates single and married life. if you are to be in the natural vocation of marriage, you ought to marry when natural law says you are to marry and remain chaste within that marriage. the Catholic Church does not call everyone to super-nature, that would be irresponsible. she calls people to act according to a restored right human nature. it is a very clear natural law argumetn-- God made our bodies to be prepared for marriage at a certain age, the further we postpone it after that age the further against the natural law. i would agree with discouraging minors from seeking marriage without their parent's consent, but i would not agree with discouraging them from marrying with their parent's consent. the main direction I'm aimed at is not to encourage minors to go against their parents wishes, but to encourage parents and societies to make customary marriage ages more in line with the natural law. I would very much discourage a "Romeo and Juliet" style marriage, infatuation ought to be avoided at any age. But I do not call it the maturing of a society when their youth become too immature to be able to marry when their bodies tell them to. as an anthropology major, and a reader of GK Chesterton and CS Lewis, I would say that is completely wrong to say that just because that is the direction our western civilization has gone (pushing back marriage age), that does not make it "progress". one need only look at the fruits. show me good fruits from pushing the average marriage age back, and I will consider it. but all I know is that the young marriage age throughout the majority of human history has produced good fruits with stable family and kinship systems; and that the modern social experiment of postponing it has led to nothing other than a decay of sexual morality. [/quote] So we should get married when we feel drawn to sex? Is that really your argument? [quote name='puellapaschalis' post='997230' date='Jun 5 2006, 07:43 AM'] A person's xth year is completed on the day after his xth birthday. Consider a baby who is three months old; his age is 0 years, 3 months, but he is in his first year. Thus his first year is completed the day after his first birthday. Love and prayers, PP [/quote] i was going to point that out.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now