traichuoi Posted October 21, 2003 Author Posted October 21, 2003 thanks Adeodatus...I just learned something new today! I always thought celibacy meant chaste celibacy...freakin media :angry:
Norseman82 Posted October 21, 2003 Posted October 21, 2003 I'm not singling anyone out here, but I want to point out the other side of the coin.... For all those who are pointing out the positive aspects of loneliness, please remember that things can be pushed too far. How many of you have nobody to come home to? No families? How many lost their families early in life and have had to essentially had to figure things out for themselves? For how many of you is Christmas dinner throwing a TV dinner in the oven? How many of you have to dread social occasions where everyone else has someone to accompany them and you don't? Or have to hear the whispers behind your back (or even in front of your face) of "Is he/she gay?" How many people have been lied to and stabbed in the back by people who say that to find the right person "just be a virtuous person and the right person will recognize it" only to find out that they prefer fornicating bums (and if they do get their brains straightened out they are a bunch of disease-ridden people who can't give you the 100% that you are giving them?)? How many of you have nobody - parents, siblings, nobody? How many of you will have children who will never be able to meet some of the older generation because they will have passed? For how many of you will death be like that man on the NW side of Chicago who was dead for four years and nobody knew about it because he had no family? For how many of you, in order to obey God, have you had to suppress your feelings for so long that you may not be able to get them back? For how many of you have you been alone so long that you don't know anything else, and even if God dropped the VCS (virgin Catholic supermodel) you wouldn't know what to do? How many of you are so used to it, like a battered wife is so used to her husband's beatings that she knows nothing else? For those who preach chastity, are you yourselves virgins, or were virgins on your wedding night? If you are not, do believe you know more than those who have held out longer than you? Trust me, I've been dealing with some of these issues longer than some of you kids have been alive, so take it from someone who has some experience in these matters.
cmotherofpirl Posted October 21, 2003 Posted October 21, 2003 You can be lucky and have a family, or you can make a family.
Adeodatus Posted October 21, 2003 Posted October 21, 2003 (edited) I don't think any of us here would want to glorify loneliness. This thread began because traichuoi opened his/her heart to us and asked us how the rest of us coped. The point about chastity for single people is that it's not about running away. It's about giving ourselves in friendship, and maybe finding ourselves again in the process. It's about doing a positive thing which is the opposite of loneliness. As for virginity, no one has to be a virgin to be chaste. No one has to be a 'virgin sacrifice' to be a nun or sister or monk or priest or deacon or bishop, or inDouche to be a good Catholic. If we're virgins, fine---fantastic! Keep it that way till you're married. If we haven't been pure, fine, just go to confession. God can give us back our purity of heart. But God calls all of us to be chaste, to be friends --- good and true and caring friends ---- to each other. Chastity should help us to be friends to the friendless. And it is certainly not about 'suppressing' your feelings. It's about being really alive, channeling those energies outwards to other people. The term they use is 'sublimation'. The Pope and Blessed Mother Teresa are both great examples of saintly figures who sublimate their feelings into caring for other people. No suppression involved here at all! And let's not neglect married people, for whom chastity is the basis for a deep, wonderful and intimate friendship. This is a great example of how chastity is the enemy of loneliness. Edited October 21, 2003 by Adeodatus
notbilln Posted October 22, 2003 Posted October 22, 2003 Yeah, lonliness stinks. It may make you appreciate love once you find it,but as someone who has been alone for almost two years, it is hard. Every weekend I think to myself, all I need to do is head on down to ye olde tavern and turn on the bill charm and poof, loniless be gone! But, I know what will be expected of me, I cannot deliver. I've met women and been invited "up for coffee" a couple times. Thats a tough thing to do, and it takes a lot out of me. Its a shame because as evident from this thread it does lead us to be more cynical about the opposite gender and our society in general. I almost belive that all women are easy. If not for my out of town female freinds ,I wouldn't have any eveidence to the contrary. So, we hold these points to be self evident. That it is intrinsically difficult to find others of the same values in our daily lives. So what physical locations are there to meet those of simular persuasions? What wateringhole do we frequent in an attempt to find our better halves? Its as if we are an endangered species that needs special breeding ground sanctuaries. I appologize for the vernacular, but what places outside of church realted events do christian women congrigate. ( note I say christian and not catholic. If either my parents or grand parents had stayed with in their denominations, I wouldn't be here. )
notbilln Posted October 22, 2003 Posted October 22, 2003 Yeah, been there. Is it me or is it slightly sleazy to use church as a place to pick up women? I mean, it wouldn't be as bad if it was a church function, rather than mass itself. My one and only purpose of going to mass should be to grow closer to God. I guess I could go around to all functions of all the parishes in town, but even if I'm doing that it seems wrong to decide to join or not join a group based upon how many young women are members. Then again, its exactly this kind of thinking that keeps me single, and not a preist. Stupid Logical ethics. I should base them on something other than logic, but thats the only thing that comes natural to me. I think the only way to find my vocation in married life, or holy orders is to actually defy my own sense of right and wrong for the greater good of a productive life. That in a nutshell is my problem, or at least my current understanding of my situation as of today. Then again, I can never really trust my own analysis of the situation to be unbiased. Maybe I'm still single because I'm a jerk with out realising it.
Norseman82 Posted October 22, 2003 Posted October 22, 2003 Yeah, lonliness stinks. It may make you appreciate love once you find it,but as someone who has been alone for almost two years, it is hard. Every weekend I think to myself, all I need to do is head on down to ye olde tavern and turn on the bill charm and poof, loniless be gone! But, I know what will be expected of me, I cannot deliver. I've met women and been invited "up for coffee" a couple times. Thats a tough thing to do, and it takes a lot out of me. Its a shame because as evident from this thread it does lead us to be more cynical about the opposite gender and our society in general. I almost belive that all women are easy. If not for my out of town female freinds ,I wouldn't have any eveidence to the contrary. So, we hold these points to be self evident. That it is intrinsically difficult to find others of the same values in our daily lives. So what physical locations are there to meet those of simular persuasions? What wateringhole do we frequent in an attempt to find our better halves? Its as if we are an endangered species that needs special breeding ground sanctuaries. I appologize for the vernacular, but what places outside of church realted events do christian women congrigate. ( note I say christian and not catholic. If either my parents or grand parents had stayed with in their denominations, I wouldn't be here. ) Hey, notbilln, I just read your profile and noticed something......we have the same birthday!!!!
Norseman82 Posted October 22, 2003 Posted October 22, 2003 (edited) Start with Church I'm going to say something controversial and catch a lot of flack, but I don't care, it has to be said and frankly I won't know I've done my job until, like the prophet Jeremiah, I've been thrown down a well: Opus Dei needs to desegregate more. With the exception of some of the events at the Opus Dei parish in Chicago, most are for either male or for female. I can understand keeping retreats segregated, but why not some of the evenings of recollection or circles? I'd be willing to even help out at an apologetics bible study..... Edited October 22, 2003 by Norseman82
notbilln Posted October 22, 2003 Posted October 22, 2003 Hey, notbilln, I just read your profile and noticed something......we have the same birthday!!!! Interesting. There are a lot of people with our birthday. My brother was born on my biirthday in 1985, and our neighbor had a child on April 15, 1986. Ah, the tax day children.
Norseman82 Posted October 22, 2003 Posted October 22, 2003 Interesting. There are a lot of people with our birthday. My brother was born on my biirthday in 1985, and our neighbor had a child on April 15, 1986. Ah, the tax day children. My late uncle Stas was born on my birthday 43 years before I was born, and my cousin's daughter was born on my birthday last year. My dad and two of his sisters were all born on Feb. 27, but different years.
traichuoi Posted October 22, 2003 Author Posted October 22, 2003 okay so back to topic... (BTW adeodatus, i'm a her ) Norseman, I agree with you that loneliness can be pushed too far in the sense that we dwell so much in the loneliness that it causes paralysis. But I think that's what Adeodatus is right in saying that there is a difference between being alone and loneliness. So that when we are alone, in order to draw away from loneliness we need to reach out. I was just reflecting on this some more the past couple days and thought about Thomas Merton's Solitude (Aloneness) vs. Loneliness. He talks about how loneliness is something we need to draw away from but if we are in aloneness that is where God allows us to switch around our priorities. In switching around our priorities we are not looking to be needy as in loneliness, but we are looking for God to be the center of our spirituality. I believe when we are alone, that is what God is allowing us to do...to put Him at the center. By doing so, it makes reaching out to others so much easier. I think there's something we must all fulfill in being alone...in a way, we need to learn how not to be needy with relationships or the such but being fulfilled or happy in being alone because we realize it is God in our lives first who we need. I believe only then when we are grounded in our own fulness of aloneness that we are healthy enough to be in dating relationships...and sometimes friendships so that we are not using the other person just to fulfill our neediness but that we are in a friendship that is not "using love" but "selfless love". okay i've rambled enough...i don't even know if what i wrote makes sense. makes sense in my thoughts! :P
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now