Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Setting the record straight


Recommended Posts

Posted

So Good Friday, what do you know about transexuals? I hardly believe you're qualified to comment yourself. Their "condition" is hardly comparable in psychological, genetic and biological terms to homosexuality. Homosexuality deals with sexual preference, transexualism deal with gender preference. I know society often clusters transexuals, and gays and lesbians as if they of the same social clique, but this is cultural percpetion, not rational. They are exclusive conditions, and thus requiring different research methods and epistemology.

Posted

[quote name='Phazzan']So Good Friday, what do you know about transexuals? I hardly believe you're qualified to comment yourself.[/quote]
That's the point, which I've made multiple times now. I don't know the first beaver dam thing about transsexuality! No one does, except transsexuals, and the only way we can come to know anything about transsexuality is from those who experience it. I'm not saying that they should listen to [b]me[/b] about anything regarding their transsexuality -- in fact, I have not given them advice on how to live their transsexuality at all, except to say that they should live it as they see fit. The advice I've given them is not to listen to the Church, either, because the Church doesn't know anything about transsexuality. Those who don't know transsexuals don't know anything about transsexuality.

Posted

You seem to have some thing very confused GF. You are indeed correct that we are the Church. However, authority to teach and preach and govern was not given to the laity, but rather the Apostles and their successors. This is where the word Magisterium comes from, magister, meaning teacher. The authority to teach and govern (it's called binding and loosing in the scriptures) rests firmly with the bishops, who are the Church and they are the ones against whom we test whether the particular inspiration of the Spirit we think we have received is authentic or not.

If what we believe is an inspiration of the Spirit does not correspond to what the church teaches, then we are wrong, not the bishops.

Of course, you will take issue with this, not so much because you know better, but because you want to live without consequences. It's funny, but throughout history all heresy has had its roots in a personal preference for a sin that someone wanted to rationalize. It's no different today, apparently.

Ora et Labora
Posted

Ok... so... Good Friday and Nathan are Gay... And their Catholic... Can you do that? And if you are transsexual that means... Im lost! :huh:

Mrs. Bro. Adam
Posted

You can be homosexual and be Catholic. Being and doing are two different things. If a homosexual acted upon their temptations, then they'd be in mortal sin and would be cutting themselves off from the church.

It's in the Catechism. Look it up ;)

Posted

BLAZEr, I know all that garbage about the magisterium. I'm not an idiot. I also know better than to think that every utterance out of a bishop's mouth is the magisterium. It isn't. The magisterium has no teaching on transsexuals.

[quote name='Ora et Labora']Ok... so... Good Friday and Nathan are Gay... And their Catholic... Can you do that? And if you are transsexual that means... Im lost![/quote]
First of all, it would be helpful to know that Good Friday + Nathan = the same person. I am Good Friday and Nathan. My screen name is Good Friday, my real name is Nathan. Nice to meet ya. :)

Being gay and Catholic can be done. Being gay, Catholic and not a member of Courage can be done. Being gay, Catholic and partnered can be done. All of this, contrary to popular belief. It isn't easy, you frequently have a lot of folks telling you that it can't be done.

I'm not transsexual, however. I am defending two people here who are transsexual against the abuse of the Vatican and its minions. I am gay.

[quote name='Mrs. Bro. Adam']You can be homosexual and be Catholic. Being and doing are two different things. If a homosexual acted upon their temptations, then they'd be in mortal sin and would be cutting themselves off from the church.[/quote]
Actually, mortal sin does not cut one off from the Church. Even if a homosexual were in mortal sin because of his or her behavior, it would not cut him or her off from the Church -- he or she would still be Catholic.

Mrs. Bro. Adam
Posted

You're correct. my apologies.. I used the wrong words. What I was going for is cut off as far as not being able to receive the sacraments (Blessed Eucharist).

Posted (edited)

Sex change operations do not change the fact that people are men or women.

People who go through them should seek spritual and professional help.

Whatever we are born as we remain...

Men that get things changed are still men; only eunuchs.

God Bless.
ironmonk.

Edited by ironmonk
Posted

[quote name='ironmonk']Men that get things changed are still men; only eunuchs.[/quote]
That was a delightful way of putting it.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Good Friday' date='Jan 21 2005, 11:15 AM'] Those who don't know transsexuals don't know anything about transsexuality. [/quote]
Actually, we know transexuals feel an intense desire to be considered a member of the opposite sex. That's what what transexuality is. The psychological and physiological reasons for this would be as unbeknownst to the transexual as it would be for anyone else. They would be deeply rooted somewhere in the their unconscious, and not consciously accessible. What we don't know is what it's *like* to be a transexual, but that's a far cry from [u]understanding[/u] it. What the transexual does have is the social and cultural perceptions of this condition, but little insight into the condition itself (i.e. why?). The Church does, but any knowldege into this condition plays no role in its moral judgement. Now, it's not wrong to want to be a transexual, slightly disordered perhaps, but this issue here is not the means of wanting to become a member of the opposite sex, but the gross manipulation and abuse of the body in order to acheive it (albeit falsely). As the Bible says, the body is a temple of the Holy Spirit, thus we don't have willful control over what we can do to/with it. What you're in fact arguing is whether the Church should have any influence on what a person can do to his/her body, but unfortuantly for transexuals that is one of the conditions of being Catholic, we give it to God, not to ourselves.

Edited by Phazzan
Posted

[quote name='Phazzan']What you're in fact arguing is whether the Church should have any influence on what a person can do to his/her body, but unfortuantly for transexuals that is one of the conditions of being Catholic, we give it to God, not to ourselves.[/quote]
[b]The Church is NOT God.[/b]

Posted

[quote name='Good Friday' date='Jan 21 2005, 12:25 PM'] [b]The Church is NOT God.[/b] [/quote]
The Church represents God, at least that's what a Catholic (i.e. hyperdulia again) would have you believe.

Posted

[quote name='ironmonk' date='Jan 21 2005, 12:02 PM'] Sex change operations do not change the fact that people are men or women.

People who go through them should seek spritual and professional help.

Whatever we are born as we remain...

Men that get things changed are still men; only eunuchs.

God Bless.
ironmonk. [/quote]
Ironmonk - what you're saying comes from a place of complete lack of understanding but at the same time you're right. Go figure.

One of the things I've learned in my transition is that it is impossible to transition. I will never be a real girl. I will never feel normal in either gender. I refer to myself sometimes as a hyper-effeminate eunuch. Because that's basically what I am. I'm physically a eunuch. I'm mentally female. I act like a girl. So really, that's a pretty decent descriptor.

What you need to realize however is that society doesn't have room for hyper-effeminate eunuchs anymore. I can't get a job doing it the way the Prophet Daniel (a eunuch) could. Society has room for men and for women. I can't live as a man. Living as a girl is perfectly acceptable. So I live as a girl.

Mentally, I am a girl so you can't really call me a man. Why? Well you are assuming that the body is of primary importance. It isn't. Tell me, what is more important - Ironmonk the person on the inside or Ironmonk the physical body? Losing a leg would force you to adapt and would probably make you struggle and be a bit more bitter - but it wouldn't fundamentally change who you are on the inside. Similarly, if I was always a girl on the inside then the external stuff really doesn't matter so much.

Posted

[quote name='Phazzan' date='Jan 21 2005, 12:21 PM'] Actually, we know transexuals feel an intense desire to be considered a member of the opposite sex. That's what what transexuality is. The psychological and physiological reasons for this would be as unbeknownst to the transexual as it would be for anyone else. They would be deeply rooted somewhere in the their unconscious, and not consciously accessible. What we don't know is what it's *like* to be a transexual, but that's a far cry from [u]understanding[/u] it. What the transexual does have is the social and cultural perceptions of this condition, but little insight into the condition itself (i.e. why?). The Church does, but any knowldege into this condition plays no role in its moral judgement. Now, it's not wrong to want to be a transexual, slightly disordered perhaps, but this issue here is not the means of wanting to become a member of the opposite sex, but the gross manipulation and abuse of the body in order to acheive it (albeit falsely). As the Bible says, the body is a temple of the Holy Spirit, thus we don't have willful control over what we can do to/with it. What you're in fact arguing is whether the Church should have any influence on what a person can do to his/her body, but unfortuantly for transexuals that is one of the conditions of being Catholic, we give it to God, not to ourselves. [/quote]
The Church allows me to transition. What I've done on hormones doesn't constitute a gross manipulation of my body. I've merely changed my body chemistry. I agree that surgery is gross in the most normal sense of the word. It grosses me out. I'm not sure I want it. But I'm not doing anything against the Church and I'm not going to.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I applaud and pray for your efforts to stay within guidelines.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Jan 21 2005, 01:34 PM'] I applaud and pray for your efforts to stay within guidelines. [/quote]
Yeah it's almost like I'm Church Faithful or something ;)

CatholicAndFanatical
Posted

good gravy, this thread should close now..

Posted

[quote name='CatholicAndFanatical' date='Jan 21 2005, 02:04 PM'] good gravy, this thread should close now.. [/quote]
Why?

hyperdulia again
Posted

The Church is God's representative on this earth, and I would live and die in misery a thousand times here before I seperated myself from her.

Ironmonk, you are right men and women are born not made. But I think e have very different understandings of what that means.

Posted (edited)

(Vatican City) The Vatican has ruled that sex-change procedures do not change a person's gender in the eyes of the church. The decision, made by the department in charge of doctrine, is contained in a confidential document obtained by the Catholic News Service. CNS, quoting a source familiar with the text, says the document instructs bishops never to alter the sex listed in parish baptismal records and says Catholics who have undergone "sex-change" procedures are not eligible to marry, be ordained to the priesthood or enter religious life.



I care for your soul bro.

God Bless,
ironmonk

Edited by ironmonk
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...