Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Will there be married priests?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Jonathan asks:

Hello. For some time I had been considering a vocation to the priesthood, but now that I am in college (freshman year at a catholic university) I have heard some strange things that are changing my mind. Our campus ministry priests seem very certain that the priesthood will change soon after we get a new pope. Supposedely there will be married priests and women priests.... Anyway, it all sounded suspicious to me until I talked over Christmas with a parish priest at home and he said that there will "indeed be changes" to counter the priest shortage, and that we must act in the spirit of Vatican II. I am very confused, not just because of this but because of a lot of the stuff that goes on in school. The Masses in the chapel don't even seem like Mass, like when they teach us to say the Our Father AND MOTHER. Is the church really changing like this? It doesn't seem right. Anyway, what is the point of me going into the seminary now if this all really going to happen? Are these rumors true? Please offer any advice you can.




Dear Jonathan,

These people are not living in the real (Catholic) world. Thirty years ago they were saying the same, that after Paul VI another Pope a little more sensible will come along and change his teaching on birth control and celibacy.

Steer away from those who can damage your faith. Get your guidance from priests, religious and lay-people who are not busy telling God what he has to do, but doing what he wants.

Don't let anyone rob you of your faith. Study the catechism, read good books and listen to tapes that can provide you with the answers. (St Joseph's Communications, Catholic Answers are two good sources). Get your friends interested in their faith and listen to the tapes together and discuss them.

Go to Mass often, and when you receive Christ in Communion tell him you want to serve him, and be a light for your brothers and sisters. He will strengthen you, and lead you

StPiusVPrayForUs
Posted

I believe priests abstain. It's one of the dead horse subjects so I'm not going to go in detail. But I want to make clear that some priests are allowed to be married.

The Byzantine churches allow priests to be married.

Above most people know. But I remember reading that some English church pastors who converted to Catholicism are allowed to be married priests. Their liturgies are similar to what they once had but of coarse with some changes.

Posted

Actually, Byzantine Catholic Priests aren't allowed to marry in America, only in Europe, unless they get special permission from the Vatican, as I understand.

Posted

Why are they allowed to get married?

Posted

they're not allowed to GET married, but if they are already married (anglican and episcopalian clergy are generally married), and if they convert and want to be priests in Catholicism, they can receive a special dispensation from the Pope. i think there are only 150 married priests in the world, though. God knew what He was doing when He set up celibate clergy...as st paul said it, it leaves a man free of worries about how to please his wife, and only with thoughts of how to please God.

from what i hear, it's basically because anglicanism has received some actual sacramental holy orders in their ordinations because some eastern orthodox bishops, who retained apostolic succession, also laid hands on the seminarians when the anglican bishops did. so some have holy orders and some don't...kinda weird. so i suppose to be safe, it's allowed. the reason why one can receive a dispensation from celibacy is because it's a church practice, not a doctrine. practices [celibacy, fasting on fridays, etc] can be modified or done away with as needed, as evident by vatican ii, but doctrine [immaculate conception, the Eucharist] can't be. and though we know that several of the apostles were married, it does say in scripture that if you want to marry, you should marry instead of being a clergyman.

Posted

It is part of the Eastern Tradition. The idea of Celibacy developed in the West, and was never adopted in the East. The Eastern Orthodox, however, do allow their priests to be married in the US. The Byzantine Catholics have adopted a more Western ideal in the US of Celibacy, but in Europe, they still maintain the Eastern tradition that they can marry.

Posted

[quote name='StPiusVPrayForUs' date='Jan 16 2005, 10:47 AM'] The Byzantine churches allow priests to be married.
[/quote]
Clarification: They may ordain married men, but men may not marry after ordination.

Posted

no priest in the history of the Catholic Church past or present has gotten married.


married men have become priests. there is a big difference.

the only way a married priest can exist is if he is Eastern Rite (unless at such a time, though i think it unwise, the Roman Church adopted the practice) and he is first married and then ordained.

so, to the big shagrin of all those priests: they will never be allowed to break the vow of celibacy they already took. they will never be able to get married even if hell freezes over and pigs fly, because the Infallible Church does not believe it is possible to marry a man who has first married the Church. she believes it is possible to marry a man to the Church who has first married a woman though.

Posted

[quote name='jiyoung' date='Jan 16 2005, 05:18 PM'] they're not allowed to GET married, but if they are already married (anglican and episcopalian clergy are generally married), and if they convert and want to be priests in Catholicism, they can receive a special dispensation from the Pope. [/quote]
While it is true that an exception is sometimes for Anglican priest converts, no "exception" is necessary for Eastern Catholic priests.

Both married and celibate men may be, according to the Code of Canons for the Eastern Churches, ordained in Eastern Catholic Churches.

hyperdulia again
Posted

"no priest in the history of the Catholic Church past or present has gotten married."


That's not entirely true. Priests in the early church whose wives had died were somtimes able to get dispensations to marry if they still had young children--these marriages would have been valid too, because the teaching on the impossibility of marrying the ordained was not yet well understood, so in good faith many of the ordained were married.

Posted

seriously, your entire purpose is just to make me look stupid isn't it? :lol:

fine fine, but that was a different time before the doctrine developed, and it was with extreme conditions necessary (that they had been married when they got ordained, the wife died, so since they had already been married to a woman before getting married to the Church they could get a replacement (that didn't intend to sound objectifying, sorry, lol))

hyperdulia again
Posted

"seriously, your entire purpose is just to make me look stupid isn't it?"

I'm sorry. :( I like you and find your posts interesting, so I look for them.

"
fine fine, but that was a different time before the doctrine developed, and it was with extreme conditions necessary (that they had been married when they got ordained, the wife died, so since they had already been married to a woman before getting married to the Church they could get a replacement (that didn't intend to sound objectifying, sorry, lol)) "

:)

Posted

[quote name='drewmeister2' date='Jan 16 2005, 05:19 PM'] The Byzantine Catholics have adopted a more Western ideal in the US of Celibacy, but in Europe, they still maintain the Eastern tradition that they can marry. [/quote]
This is, unfortunately, not accurate. Eastern Catholics in the United States did not voluntarily conform to the Western model of only celibate priests; this requirement was imposed on them. Married men have always been ordained in Eastern Catholic churches in Europe and the Middle East. The practice was banned in the United States in 1929 after Irish Latin-rite bishops complained that Slavic priests with wives and children were scandalizing the Irish faithful.

I would argue that it would have been better for the Church as a whole if this had not happened. It is the fault of the Irish American bishops, and [i]not[/i] the Eastern Catholic priests, that the Irish American Catholics were so poorly catechized about the diversity of the Catholic Church.

Pope John Paul II, following the Vatican II document [i]Orientalium Ecclesiarum[/i], has called for Eastern Catholics to reclaim their own traditions and cast off Western practices they had adopted in order to blend in. As part of that renewal, the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches authorized each self-governing Eastern Catholic Church to develop laws for its own territory.

If I am not mistaken, the Ruthenian Church in the United States now allows married men to be ordained, subject to the approval of the Holy See. Perhaps, as time goes by, they will return to their original practice completely.

Posted

[quote name='cathqat' date='Jan 16 2005, 04:26 PM'] Clarification: They may ordain married men, but men may not marry after ordination. [/quote]
Except in the US, unless you have special Papal permission

Posted

[quote name='the_rev' date='Jan 16 2005, 10:30 AM'] Jonathan asks:

Hello. For some time I had been considering a vocation to the priesthood, but now that I am in college (freshman year at a catholic university) I have heard some strange things that are changing my mind. Our campus ministry priests seem very certain that the priesthood will change soon after we get a new pope. Supposedely there will be married priests and women priests.... Anyway, it all sounded suspicious to me until I talked over Christmas with a parish priest at home and he said that there will "indeed be changes" to counter the priest shortage, and that we must act in the spirit of Vatican II. I am very confused, not just because of this but because of a lot of the stuff that goes on in school. The Masses in the chapel don't even seem like Mass, like when they teach us to say the Our Father AND MOTHER. Is the church really changing like this? It doesn't seem right. Anyway, what is the point of me going into the seminary now if this all really going to happen? Are these rumors true? Please offer any advice you can.




Dear Jonathan,

These people are not living in the real (Catholic) world. Thirty years ago they were saying the same, that after Paul VI another Pope a little more sensible will come along and change his teaching on birth control and celibacy.

Steer away from those who can damage your faith. Get your guidance from priests, religious and lay-people who are not busy telling God what he has to do, but doing what he wants.

Don't let anyone rob you of your faith. Study the catechism, read good books and listen to tapes that can provide you with the answers. (St Joseph's Communications, Catholic Answers are two good sources). Get your friends interested in their faith and listen to the tapes together and discuss them.

Go to Mass often, and when you receive Christ in Communion tell him you want to serve him, and be a light for your brothers and sisters. He will strengthen you, and lead you [/quote]
Did you get that from Vocations.com newsletter?

Posted

[quote name='Dudette' date='Jan 16 2005, 09:27 PM'] Did you get that from Vocations.com newsletter? [/quote]
I found it on their site..

I should have referenced it, my error.

Posted

[quote name='drewmeister2' date='Jan 16 2005, 05:52 PM'] Except in the US, unless you have special Papal permission [/quote]
even in the US with papal permission there's no marrying after ordination. I don't think that's what you meant, just clarifying though. -Pax-

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...