Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Need Help responding to an email


Recommended Posts

Posted

i sent some people the [url="http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showtopic=27636"]23 Ways to Identify a Faithful Parish[/url] and they've emailed me back this response. Can anyone help me refute some of this stuff? their comments are in red.

4. The church has kneelers. Period.  [color=red]Good thing there is Love in Jesus?[/color]

6. As you enter the church, you see people in the pews in prayer or, at least, reverent silence. If, on the other hand, it looks like social time down at the bingo parlor, that's a bad sign.  [color=red]Is the ‘Church’ stuffy and not caring enough to welcome in a visitor into the community.[/color]

8. The Mass is said according to the General Instruction of the Roman Missal and the instructions of the local bishop. Improvisation is great in jazz. Mass isn't jazz.  [color=red]And when every bishop in the U.S is totally different in interpretation do you not get improvisation.[/color]

9. The gospel is not being read, nor the homily given, by someone other than a priest or deacon.  [color=red]Prophets were not ordained by the religious leaders of the day and helped form our beliefs.[/color]

12. The liturgical music focuses on God, not the community. We are there, after all, to worship Him, not ourselves. And there's never a good reason to sing songs about bridges over troubled waters. You can do that at home, Mr. Garfunkel.  [color=red]Rejoiceful music comes in all words and when sung in church is always proclaiming God’s greatness.[/color]

19. The pastor isn't afraid to preach on the tough issues: abortion, divorce, contraception, cloning, etc. That's not to say that every homily should cover those topics. But a priest should truly believe the Church's teaching and defend them without pause. [color=red] The Church is there to share the Word of God not to pass judgement for no man, ordained or not, has the right to do God’s work.[/color]

Posted

btw, this is family, so i need to be sensitive in my response.

Posted (edited)

19. Go see 1 Cor 5 and 1 Cor 6 to blow this one out of the water. The man living with his father's wife is to have "his body handed over to satan so that his spirit might be saved" by the Church. It is important to note that the discipline of the sinner is for his own salvation. 1 Cor 6 Paul chastises the Cornithian Church for being unable to judge rightly. Also of course Matt 18 clearly indicates the judging role of the Church.

Edited by thessalonian
FightingforGod
Posted

[quote]9. The gospel is not being read, nor the homily given, by someone other than a priest or deacon.  Prophets were not ordained by the religious leaders of the day and helped form our beliefs[/quote]

no, they were ordained by GOd himself, who through the the Pope, Bishops, Priests, ordains others.

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' date='Jan 17 2005, 03:24 PM']

[/quote]
random thoughts on what to type back, blue is what i'm thinking to write back, black is if i'm not sure.

[color=blue]First, ---, I forwarded this along as an informational list. This is a good list especially for those who are going to a new parish. Some of the items on this list are preferential, some are required by Canon Law.[/color]

[quote name='Lil Red'] 4. The church has kneelers. Period.  [color=red]Good thing there is Love in Jesus?[/color][/quote]

[color=blue]i don't understand what you are saying here[/color]

[quote name='Lil Red'] 6. As you enter the church, you see people in the pews in prayer or, at least, reverent silence. If, on the other hand, it looks like social time down at the bingo parlor, that's a bad sign.  [color=red]Is the ‘Church’ stuffy and not caring enough to welcome in a visitor into the community.[/color][/quote]

[color=blue]There is a difference between people being sociable in the Gathering Area of the church (think of my church's gathering area, it is a defined space that is different from the main vestibule of the church) and being sociable in a sacred space.

[quote name='Lil Red']8. The Mass is said according to the General Instruction of the Roman Missal and the instructions of the local bishop. Improvisation is great in jazz. Mass isn't jazz.  [color=red]And when every bishop in the U.S is totally different in interpretation do you not get improvisation.[/color][/quote]

i'm a little confused as to what to respond with.

[quote name='Lil Red']9. The gospel is not being read, nor the homily given, by someone other than a priest or deacon.  [color=red]Prophets were not ordained by the religious leaders of the day and helped form our beliefs.[/color][/quote]

[color=blue]this is required Canon law. [/color] i'll insert Canon/GIRM law # here, if anyone has it, that would be great

[quote name='Lil Red']19. The pastor isn't afraid to preach on the tough issues: abortion, divorce, contraception, cloning, etc. That's not to say that every homily should cover those topics. But a priest should truly believe the Church's teaching and defend them without pause. [color=red] The Church is there to share the Word of God not to pass judgement for no man, ordained or not, has the right to do God’s work.[/color][/quote]

[color=blue] Go see 1 Cor 5 and 1 Cor 6 to blow this one out of the water. The man living with his father's wife is to have "his body handed over to satan so that his spirit might be saved" by the Church. It is important to note that the discipline of the sinner is for his own salvation. 1 Cor 6 Paul chastises the Cornithian Church for being unable to judge rightly. Also of course Matt 18 clearly indicates the judging role of the Church.[/color]

thess, i'll probably refine your statement slightly. thanks for the help!

Posted

[quote name='FightingforGod' date='Jan 17 2005, 03:55 PM']
no, they were ordained by GOd himself, who through the the Pope, Bishops, Priests, ordains others. [/quote]
nice addition, thanks.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Well, I'll address the issues, but you'll have to put them in your own writing...I don't know what would offend and what would be charitable.

4. There is love in Jesus, and love requests reciprocation. Jesus was more than willing to fall on His knees on the road to calvary...I don't see why we shouldn't fall on ours for Him.

6. It's perfectly acceptable to welcome people into the church, but this should be done in the vestibule. There is no need for it within the church itself, which is a place of peaceful worship. Greeting people in the vestibule is a friendly thing to do, but greeting them in the church, and interrupting the prayers of others, is not.

8. These are not different interpretations of the rubrics. The rubrics are very clear. Some bishops, however, simply choose to consider themselves autonomous.

9. Prophets were given a direct mandate by God. However, we know because the Magisterium says so that God does not want unordained people proclaiming the Gospel at Mass. We cannot pretend that God wants them to do so when it is clear from the Church, the Bride of Christ who knows Her Husband intimately, that they are not to do so.

12. A person can also sing songs which mock God in a rejoiceful way. It is not just the sound of the music, nor the tone, but the theology contained within which matters. Music is supposed to help us in our worship of God. If instead it contains faulty theology or misplaces the focus of Mass, then it is not helping us worship God, but some false idea of God.

19. The Church passes judgment on the actions of men. This is not only allowed, but it is the responsibility of the Church to condemn all evil. Equating this to having a judgmental attitude is like saying that God's laws were to hold us back. God's laws are from love...so is filial correction. If our focus is love, then our actions will reflect God's will...there will be no judgment of people, but only of actions, and this is what we are called to do...to hate the sin and not the sinner, and to help the sinner to reach Heaven.

Posted

thanks, micah, that was very nicely put.

Posted

the kneeler thing, think not of calvary, how about Gesthemne?

Anyways, look to the times in ages past. Being on the knees was a sign of great respect shown usually to kings. Prolly why it is now part of Catholic traidtion. You are showing respect. It stems from the [b]true[/b] presence of Christ in the Eucharist.

Posted

i got an email back, basically saying, thanks for the clarification on those points...which means, in my family-speak, "okay, i don't want to debate with you and i don't agree with you" :sadder:

Posted

that is kinda sad. I will keep him in my prayers and just hope that sometime he brings it up and is ready to talk. Though usually don't mention debate. People tend not to like that.

Posted

well, maybe argue is a better word...because we're pretty close

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' date='Jan 17 2005, 11:04 PM'] i got an email back, basically saying, thanks for the clarification on those points...which means, in my family-speak, "okay, i don't want to debate with you and i don't agree with you" :sadder: [/quote]
I'm sorry - there are some differences of opinion on what makes a church in every family. This sounds reminiscent of some discussions I've had with my son. You're not alone in arguing to the wind. (Would I be correct in thinking these are protestant types? or real gung ho liberation theology Vatican II types? Some of those comments sound like they had no formation training)(How many people would like a GIRM for their birthday? probably not these folks, that might interfere with what they think ought to be)

Buck up, live the life, and the joy you receive and share from your involvement will likely carry more weight with your family than he most cogent of argumentative e-mails. :unsure:

Community does have to be there somewhere. It has the same root word, etymologically speaking, as communion.

I had some questions about the list - primarily because our parish is still very young, and we haven't had the opportunity to grow into the level of "maturity" the list presupposes. Our parish has only been around since 1990 ish - as a mission church for a more established church about 20 miles away

1. We don't have a parish priest - we're lucky to get a priest every Sunday, and sometimes we don't. The parish community has a cow if they have to "settle" for a liturgy of the word service without a priest - but what can we do? There are only so many priests available - and we can't drag one in from his deathbed.

2. Does once a month count as regular?

4. We don't have pews, and only one multi-purpose space - It is our gathering space, sanctuary, social hall, and overflow religious ed space. So we stand or sit. There are two, maybe three, who kneel anyway.

QUOTE (Lil Red)
4. The church has kneelers. Period. Good thing there is Love in Jesus?

What do kneelers have to do with love? As Raphael (I think) said, it has to do with worshop, with respect. And the GIRM has a nice bit on standing being a sign of respect.

6. see 4 . . . So yes, we socialize in the sanctuary.
I agree with the other poster that once we have a dedicated gathering space, that is the place for greeting, chatting, socializing, but bad habits are going to be hard to break - I was thinking about suggesting praying the rosary starting about 20 minutes before Mass - I figure that might keep the socializers out in the gatheriing space.

QUOTE (Lil Red)
6. As you enter the church, you see people in the pews in prayer or, at least, reverent silence. If, on the other hand, it looks like social time down at the bingo parlor, that's a bad sign. Is the ‘Church’ stuffy and not caring enough to welcome in a visitor into the community.

It is a matter of place and respect. The sanctuary is a "faith" place, not a "visiting" space. Just like the school board doesn't think the bathrooms are where students should smoke, to pick a really bad example.


QUOTE (Lil Red)
8. The Mass is said according to the General Instruction of the Roman Missal and the instructions of the local bishop. Improvisation is great in jazz. Mass isn't jazz. And when every bishop in the U.S is totally different in interpretation do you not get improvisation.

got us there - if the bishops don't all follow the same rules, there's only one person who can whip them into line . . . and it isn't you or me


9. The former (retired-emeritus) bishop authorized the pastoral coordinator to teach a reflection once a month - the present bishop rescinded that - so we comply - since the pastoral coordinator is a woman, even that reflection was a cause of contention.

QUOTE (Lil Red)
9. The gospel is not being read, nor the homily given, by someone other than a priest or deacon. Prophets were not ordained by the religious leaders of the day and helped form our beliefs.

Prophets were ordained by God to raise hell with the established (church/state). As such, they were rarely invited to read from the Scrolls of the Torah. If your job is to shake up the church, it isn't going to happen during the proscribed readings.


10. Vatican II also calls for active participation - the US bishops may have thought that being able to hear and understand the Mass (in the vernacular) may have been useful for that purpose. The Latin Mass I've attended was mumbled in the other direction, and even if I could have understood it, I couldn't hear it.

11. They aren't styrofoam wafers, but they aren't supposed to have any illicit ingredients.

12. I really like "Lord of the Dance" and about a half dozen of the other songs in the blue liturgy/hymnal. Chant, what's that?

13. 1 priest, no deacon, and 300-350 on a standing room only Sunday - I'd like to think we need the EMs - my son disagrees - and again, this is something to activate the laity. I'm thrilled to be receiving theh Eucharist, I'd probably fall over if I was asked to be a server.

14. not a word about the Magisterium - but we conduct "ourselves in keeping with the values of the Catholic Church." Does that count?

15. There are a lot of mixed marriages in our parish - the Baptist Church is our biggest "branch office" when the Ladies Guild sells chocolate eggs for Easter - there is a Men's Club, rather then KofC - the Episcopal Church has the religious thrift shop in town. There is a bible study group - but the pastoral coordinator and DRE aren't part of it - so it is a bunch of lay folks talking about what they read (sort of like my comments on our bible reading thread)

16. once a year on Holy Thursday

17. I don't know how active the pro-life group is; but we do work with the Food Bank, a group home for men, and the local Christian Outreach group.

18. see 1

19. I think usually we get more formation issues - rather than issue specific
That was a topic that also set my son off - Every couple of months, the pastor would do a series of "teaching" Masses, explaining what he was doing and why at different points of the Mass. I liked it, he said it was distracting, and we should already know this stuff. I asked when he learned it, and when his brothers and sisters did - and he agreed maybe it was needed, but it was still a distraction from the worship.

QUOTE (Lil Red)
19. The pastor isn't afraid to preach on the tough issues: abortion, divorce, contraception, cloning, etc. That's not to say that every homily should cover those topics. But a priest should truly believe the Church's teaching and defend them without pause. The Church is there to share the Word of God not to pass judgement for no man, ordained or not, has the right to do God’s work.

The purpose of the homily is to teach, not to judge. Teaching the church's position on the tough issues is not to "judge" but is to instruct the parish.


20. haven't asked

21. I don't know if I'd call it vibrant . . . I think it is a little bit "mushy, touchy-feely, what do you think about this" sort of ed - at least that was my RCIA experience . . . the pastoral coordinator has a masters from Loyola, the DRE is still going through diocesan training (now she is a vibrant personality, and is really in love with Jesus and the Church - her classes are fun - she's a convert too - but I can see her saying something ugly about about a bunch of old men in dresses and meaning it)

22. I'm the acting webmaster - and right now it doesn't have any links at all, the PC says when I get to that point, she wants to review the links, so I don't think there's much risk of me getting us too far off the range

23. no Crisis, but we do have some of the Franciscan publications (St. Andrew Messenger inserts - Everyday Catholic, Catholic Update)


I do tell my son that the real benefit of faith, the real temple of the Mass, is in the heart. The Church is not a building, not a rite or a rubric, the Church is us. (We won't be there for a few months, sneak a peek at the CCC starting at 748, but keying in around 781-786.)

God Bless You for trying, and keep it up.

Posted

well, like i was sharing with someone else...my diocese is pretty awful when it comes to this stuff...and this person in my family was raised in this diocese (and the only reason i'm different is because i did my research) and just recently moved out of it into an awesome diocese....so they are having trouble adjusting. i just hope and pray that they are willing to learn and to change to correct teachings.

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' date='Jan 17 2005, 05:24 PM'] i sent some people the [url="http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showtopic=27636"]23 Ways to Identify a Faithful Parish[/url] and they've emailed me back this response. Can anyone help me refute some of this stuff? their comments are in red.

4. The church has kneelers. Period.  [color=red]Good thing there is Love in Jesus?[/color]

6. As you enter the church, you see people in the pews in prayer or, at least, reverent silence. If, on the other hand, it looks like social time down at the bingo parlor, that's a bad sign.  [color=red]Is the ‘Church’ stuffy and not caring enough to welcome in a visitor into the community.[/color]

8. The Mass is said according to the General Instruction of the Roman Missal and the instructions of the local bishop. Improvisation is great in jazz. Mass isn't jazz.  [color=red]And when every bishop in the U.S is totally different in interpretation do you not get improvisation.[/color]

9. The gospel is not being read, nor the homily given, by someone other than a priest or deacon.  [color=red]Prophets were not ordained by the religious leaders of the day and helped form our beliefs.[/color]

12. The liturgical music focuses on God, not the community. We are there, after all, to worship Him, not ourselves. And there's never a good reason to sing songs about bridges over troubled waters. You can do that at home, Mr. Garfunkel.  [color=red]Rejoiceful music comes in all words and when sung in church is always proclaiming God’s greatness.[/color]

19. The pastor isn't afraid to preach on the tough issues: abortion, divorce, contraception, cloning, etc. That's not to say that every homily should cover those topics. But a priest should truly believe the Church's teaching and defend them without pause. [color=red] The Church is there to share the Word of God not to pass judgement for no man, ordained or not, has the right to do God’s work.[/color] [/quote]
Re: 4 - What the heck are they talking about? Almost every religion includes a whole lot of kneeling. Even Mennonites kneel when begging for mercy. I don't get their point.

Re: 6 - While its nice to be greeted, the shmoozing can wait until after mass. At my Church, people are greeted at the doors, given their missals, and sent on their way. People talk [i]after[/i] mass. And definately not in the Sanctuary. Make sure to point out that geniuses arent supposed to go running around the place when its time to 'share the sign of peace'.

Re: 8 - See Raphael's post.

Re: 12 - I don't get this person's arguments at all. Theyre kind of ... meaningless. Music should render Glory to God, not humans. Whats wrong with that? Rejoicing music doesn't always proclaim God's greatness. For example, Kelis likes to rejoice about her wonderful Milkshake, but that isn't exactly God's work.

Re: 19 - Cripes. I really don't get this person. Since when is teaching some[i]thing[/i] is wrong passing judgement on some[i]one[/i]. God doesn't want babies being aborted, people using contraception, period. Nobody is going and saying 'Hey you, third row from the back, next to the wall... you're going to hell suh.'

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='crusader1234' date='Jan 18 2005, 01:24 AM'] Nobody is going and saying 'Hey you, third row from the back, next to the wall... you're going to hell suh.' [/quote]
im sorry i know thats not funny but :lol: i cant help it!

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' date='Jan 18 2005, 01:09 AM'] well, like i was sharing with someone else...my diocese is pretty awful when it comes to this stuff...and this person in my family was raised in this diocese (and the only reason i'm different is because i did my research) and just recently moved out of it into an awesome diocese....so they are having trouble adjusting. i just hope and pray that they are willing to learn and to change to correct teachings. [/quote]
It sounds to me like what is needed is to get to the root of the problem. That is Matt 16:18 and Matt 18, heb 13:17, binding and loosing, authority, etc. etc.

Piccoli Fiori JMJ
Posted

I sent the same list to my Catholic C0-chaplain that is teaching the school's Roman Catholicism Today Class... I got a very interesting response... I could use a bit of help with some things though... Don't worry, he says he wants my opinions on things, but there are a few I could use a bit of help with... Anyone want to try to help? (His response is in [color=green]green[/color].) Also, he did not respond to all of the 23 ways... Just a few he thought had issues...

Also, he kinda tends towards liberal... His one wish for Catholicism is to go back to when the Church started with the Apostles for Mass...

[quote][color=green]As for the list of 23 ways to identify a faithful parish, these things are often a muddled mess of opinion, poking fun a little bit and also offering some ideas or tools that are helpful in getting people to find a parish that is good for them.  I do not read Crisis Magazine regularly, but my guess is that this list was offered as a fun and helpful piece at the same time. 
I didn't agree with all that I read and it seems clear to me that the author has a more traditional view of Catholicism and Mass.  I would like it if you responded here to some of my comments.  This is a great talking point for us.[/color][/quote]

[quote]1. There is at least one daily Mass. Obviously, if a parish shares a pastor with other parishes, this may not always be possible. But barring that, a parish needs to offer daily Mass.[/quote]
[quote]2. Confession is offered for a set time... not just "by appointment only." The absolute importance of that sacrament must not be diminished[/quote]
[quote][color=green]1 and 2 are right on.  Liturgy is central to Catholicism.  How can a
Parish not offer it?  And confession- if it isn't offered regularly, who would call for an appointment?  Not many people.  However, there are plenty of realities in some of our rural churches today where there simply aren't the number of priests to have mass daily or weekly.  To say that in those situations the parish somehow how becomes a less than faithful parish is a hurtful thing to say.[/color][/quote]
MY THOUGHT:It does clearly say that for Daily Mass, with the sharing of Priests it is not always possiable... Maybe he missed that part...

[quote]3. The tabernacle is inside the main church in a prominent place. It's always frustrating to have to play "Where's Jesus?" when you walk into a parish for the first time. I recall once when visiting a church I'd never been in before, I confusedly genuflected to everything from the cantor to a statue of St. Therese before I figured out where the tabernacle was.[/quote]
[quote][color=green]#3 on the list is not a view that is in keeping with current church
Teaching about placement of the tabernacle.  A smaller chapel or room off to the side of the main worship space is completely acceptable. Very much in keeping with the new General Instruction for the Roman Missal.  I know some people prefer that it be at the center or highly visible, but to imply that a church is not a faithful parish because the tabernacle is in a special side chapel is only an opinion.  You can read the text of that section of the GIRM at #314 at
[url="http://www.usccb.org/liturgy/current/chapter5.shtml#sect3"]http://www.usccb.org/liturgy/current/chapter5.shtml#sect3[/url]
If the author really confusedly genuflected to the cantor and a statue Of St. Theresa thinking that these were the tabernacle, then the problem is with the author.  New prescription for eyeglasses maybe?[/color][/quote]

[quote]5. The church doesn't have a sign in the front that describes itself as a "Catholic Community." I know, this one seems petty at first, but it tends to be true. If a parish has an objection to the word "church," that's a good indication that a larger problem exists. And if that parish magnifies the nonsense with a sign that says something like, "An Open, Inclusive Community of Catholic Christians Who Care and Share," stop, turn around, run.[/quote]
[quote]6. As you enter the church, you see people in the pews in prayer or, at least, reverent silence. If, on the other hand, it looks like social time down at the bingo parlor, that's a bad sign.[/quote]
[quote][color=green]#5 Really rather silly in my mind that this person would make an issue of the title "Catholic Community."  He or she probably doesn't understand the issues that go into the naming.  The word community implies that there is more to that Catholic property than just a church structure building. 
It is more than a church.  A community may mean a school, a center for other times for prayer and religious development, social justice activities and lots of other events than help people to live out their Catholic faith after they have been to Mass.  I know of a few places that have named themselves community and it has never been that they were uncomfortable being called a church, rather they wanted to name themselves in a way that gave the message that there was a lot of Catholic stuff, including mass, happening there.
Why should someone run away from "An Open, Inclusive Community of Catholic Christians Who Care and Share?" Sounds like Jesus to me and it is not at all opposed to anything Catholic.
Which leads into some comments about #6.  You know from that article [url="http://www.americancatholic.org/Newsletters/CU/ac0698.asp"]http://www.americancatholic.org/Newsletters/CU/ac0698.asp[/url]
You read last week and our teaching mass that the liturgy is supposed to be a combination of times of personal prayer and communal prayer.  At times it should be reverent and silent and at other times it should be a bit more like a bingo hall.  We should not always be coming to mass to be left alone.[/color][/quote]

[quote]10. Latin has pride of place in the Mass. It's right there in the documents of the Second Vatican Council. That should be reflected in the liturgy itself.[/quote]
[quote][color=green]#10- Pride of place does not mean that Latin should be the first choice used as often as possible.  Pride of place just means that the Church esteems Latin as part of our rich tradition.  A parish that never speaks a word of Latin may very well be a more faithful parish than one that does use Latin.  I do feel that Latin offers a sense of reverence and mystery to the Mass.  But people who prefer Latin should be careful to make sure that they understand their tastes to be only their tastes and not then craft a message that those who do not use Latin are somehow inferior in their worship.[/color][/quote]

[quote]12. The liturgical music focuses on God, not the community. We are there, after all, to worship Him, not ourselves. And there's never a good reason to sing songs about bridges over troubled waters. You can do that at home, Mr. Garfunkel.[/quote]
[quote][color=green]12- Church documents on music throughout the years (Musicam Sacram, The Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy, Tra le Sollecitudini, Musicae Sacrae Disciplina to name a few of those documents) have consistently supported the idea that Liturgical music is supposed to achieve what the liturgy itself is to achieve- that is the worship of God and the transformation of human beings in holiness.  Indeed the focus of the music is us, not always God alone.  Ignore songs that are written by contemporary musicians, even some of the very rites of the mass that maybe set to song and hey- even in Latin are about us- Lord Have Mercy- on who? Us.  Not God.  O yeah.  We praise God by singing about Him, but we transform us by lifting our prayers in the form of songs that sometimes focus on us and those with whom we worship.[/color][/quote]

[quote]13. Extraordinary ministers do not outnumber the parishioners. There's a reason, after all, that we refer to them as EXTRAORDINARY ministers. We only use them when there are too many people for the priest and deacon to handle.[/quote]
[quote][color=green]#13- I don't understand the concern here.  Was the author really at a church where there were more EM's than there were people receiving Communion?  I doubt it.  But regardless, there is no statement in the GIRM about the number of EM's.  Of course there shouldn't be more than is reasonable.  Isn't that implied?[/color][/quote]

[quote]14. If you're able to find the mission statement of the parish (it's often carried in the bulletin), make sure it says something about fidelity to the Magisterium of the Church.[/quote]
[quote][color=green]#14- Concerned about fidelity to the magesterium of the church, but
wouldn't it also be important to mention something about Jesus too?  Just because they exclude it doesn't mean the author doesn't find it important though.
How faithful is this author being though by saying that the tabernacle must be somewhere that the magesterium does not say it has to be?  Are they being more faithful to the magesterium?[/color][/quote]

[quote]15. And while you're thumbing through the bulletin, see if there are other good groups there, like the Knights of Columbus, Legion of Mary, St. Vincent de Paul, and Holy Name Society. A faithful Bible study group is also a great sign. [/quote]
[quote]22. The church's Website doesn't link to dissident groups like Call to Action, Voice of the Faithful, or Catholics for a Free Choice.[/quote]
[quote][color=green]Finally- #15 and #22- dissident?  Call to Action and Voice of the
Faithful? They are different organizations from the Knights of Columbus and  Legion of Mary and what not, but dissident?  No. They are called upon by the bishops of the US to present at their national conferences sometimes and they are also supported by various Bishops.  They push for discussion of important issues, but that does not make them dissident.[/color][/quote]

Some of my overall thoughts: He seems to make connections with things and making assumtions about many of them. He didn't hit many of them, but it seems like these are the ones that struck a chord with him. SOme of this can be due to lack of understanding in some aspects. Any help would be appriciated! (Sorry about my horrendous spelling...)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...