Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Catholics....Rhythm?


Recommended Posts

Posted

one thing i have noticed through my years of being Catholic is that CAtholics have no rhythm...........cant keep a beat........why is this....too much Holy Spirit?........what are your thoughts on why.....

peace and bless,
Aloha918

Posted

It's the off beat/ on beat/ man with the most-est/ Like Hostess/ I eat mc's/ and ya know this.



I have rhythm and I'm Catholic lol.

I got more soul than the bottom of James Brown's shoes after he does one of his spins.


It's just like anything else. Some people have it and some people dont. I dont think it's a religious thing.

Or maybe it's because we dont dance in mass.

Posted

I'm confoosed.....

We have a handful of Catholic musicians on this board, they all have a lot of rhythm.


I have rhythm :unsure: maybe :P

do u mean rhythm in body movements. I think it has more to do with skin color than religious affiliation. :rolleyes: I also think it has everything to do with neither of the above mentioned.... did i confuse you yet? haha.

AMDG
~S.

ryanmeyersmusic
Posted

we've just got more rhythm and like clapping on the 16ths and 32nds of the beat.

Posted (edited)

cause we aren't used to protestant prasing!!! so when we try to clap in church *shuddering* we can't do it...not enough practice...rythm is learned.

but the better question: Why can't catholics sing????

Edited by SevenSorrows
Posted

I can sing i have rhythm... um check out one of my songs

[u][b]Fall[/b][/u]
By Silver Spirit

Floating and falling, freedom is calling
Swirl and spin to land upon the ground
Wind is blowing, calling the new season
Floating and falling, the leaves are falling

From left to right, the warm wind is shifting
Forming pictures in the cooling minds
Summoning the cold hearts to the warm house
From left to right, the cool wind is pushing

Down, down the leaves will fall
Around the leaves will spin
Leaves beckon the new age

Down, down the leaves do fall
Around the elven den
Leaves fall upon the stage

Floating on the babbling stream in upward gaze
Watching his fellow brothers and sisters
They too make the same wind crossed dance of grace
Floating on the babbling stream in falling daze

Washing away the warm summers blaze
Swirling the warm colors together
Giving the last warming thoughts of the year
Washing away living thoughts in the haze

Floating down the stream bed
Calling for the harvest
Giving thanks to giving

Floating down river beds
Calling out to the best
Giving thanks for living

well its prolly not the kind of rhythm your thinking... it flows nice and i can sing to it

Guest Eremite
Posted (edited)

[quote]but the better question: Why can't catholics sing????[/quote]

For the same reason most people can't sing. It's not their talent. Just because someone joins in a Church hymn doesn't make them a singer. Heck, we'd be better off is some of our CANTORS didn't join in Church hyms, lol.

Edited by Eremite
Posted

it's nice to see people sing in church though, whether they can sing or not. i know i have a nice voice but it gets me in trouble because i start thinking about how i sound instead of what i'm doing, which is praising God through my voice. maybe it's a blessing to be tone-deaf...i know a guy who is, but he sings anyway. going beyond his insecurities, he's lifting his voice to God, Who gave him that voice.

and...as much as off-beat clapping irks me (and being korean i hear a lot of it--clapping on 1 and 3 instead of 2 and 4 like you should), it's nice that at least people are clapping. showing signs of life you know.

Posted

We might not have rhythm, but we sure as heck got melody! ;)

God bless,

Jen

Posted

some catholics have rhythm... im certainly not one of them but... i can sing though so thats good

KnightoftheImmaculate1
Posted

I know I am just being a smart you know what, but we as Christ's faithful may not express an outward rhythm in clapping or whatever Protestants or anybody else chooses to do, but we sure as heck go with the rhythm of life, in that we are the only ones who possess life in the Eucharist. No Eucharist means no life, no life means no possibility for rhythm. Maybe the solution would be to support our Catholic artists who have the rhythm, but that isn't happening because there is nobody to represent them because everyone is to busy reppin the other artists in the field of music. It should be our duty to bring rhythm to those within the communion of Christ's holy Church by supporting our own. Its about time we work for ourselves and keep God's family together.

In the Embrace of Mary,

Servus

KnightoftheImmaculate1
Posted

Oh, I almost forgot, if you want some Catholic rhythm check MC Just's new "Gates of Hell II." If that aint rhythm I don't know what is.

Posted

ok when i posted this topic i was being very general.........obviously some catholics have rhythm.........i guess i got the idea from the last Steubenville conference that i was on........but then again the rhythm thing might be a midwest thing(yes another geranlization).........

Posted

I've got no rhythm, can't dance, can't sing. I fit the stereotype. :P

Posted

...really? Ummm, I agree with my boy Sammy Blaze...I got rhythm. I can't sing for the life of me....that's why I chose to be an emcee. ---> As for the clap part. Man, I got that down...sometimes I add the double-clap in the mix. Once you got that down...look out! Hahahaha.

Posted

[quote name='aloha918' date='Jan 24 2005, 10:10 AM'] ........but then again the rhythm thing might be a midwest thing(yes another geranlization)......... [/quote]
ooohhhh, now you're gonna die :angry:







;) seriously, though, watch it.

actually, it's funny. i think that to compare religion to rhythm is crazy. Catholics are everywhere. whether or not they can clap and sing means nothing, and is not related at all to religion. i personally know a lot of Catholics who sing really well, and plenty of non-Catholics who can't. i can sing a little. but, ya know, you have to sing to get better, and a lot of Catholics don't sing. maybe that's the prob!!

and the whole clapping on the 1 and 3 beat thing is a pet-peeve of mine. my friends do it here to make me laugh, though, cause it's become a joke. i am a guitarist at heart, but also play drums, and that kills me!! clap on the snare beat people! it's not that hard! :rolleyes:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...