Guest :: JP2Iloveyou :: Posted February 5, 2005 Posted February 5, 2005 OK. I am taking New Testament this semester, and already I can see where this course is heading. It is focusing on a historical study of Scripture. Of course, this is just a guise for not having to acknowledge Christ as the Son f God and Scripture as the Word of God. Anyway, I have a two-fold question. First of all, I have already read in chapter 1 of my textbook that the canon of Scripture as we know it today is merely the result of random chance, not divine inspiration. The argument goes something like this: there were many groups of early Christians (gnostics, marcionites, Adoptionists, and the proto-orthodox, as they call them). The proto-orthodox "won out" so to speak in winning the most converts which resulted in their being able to choose what the beliefs of the early Christians were and what was included in Scripture. So, my question is, what is a way to refute this? I know that the canon of Scripture was officially defined at the Council of Trent, but what about prior Church councils? Also, what truth is there, if any, to their argument that the proto-orthodox were merely the largest among several groups of Christians, each believing in something different?? Secondly, I have an apologetic question relating to this. Using some basic philosophy, it seems that the Church is on shaky ground with her argument for Papal and Magisterial infallibility. Here's what I mean. If someone asks a Catholic why he believes in Papal Infalibility, he would probably respond by saying, "Because Christ gave the keys to Peter in Mathew's Gospel (16:18 I think, or is it 18:16? I can never remember!)" Then, the person questioning the Catholic would respond by asking, "Why do you think the Bible is inspired?" The Catholic would be left saying, "Because the Church says so." Which begs the question, "Why?" The next answer would be because the Bible says so. The result is a viscious circle. So, inevitably when I get asked this question in class, how should I respond?
Adeodatus Posted February 7, 2005 Posted February 7, 2005 Good questions! 1. The Canon. If your textbook really says what you just said, it must utterly awful and stupid. Seeing that you're responding to secular academia, look up a decent book acceptable to such people on the same topic, like Bruce Metzger's book on the formation of the New Testament canon. The Gnostics, Adoptionists, Marcionites come later than the Catholic Church, and in the case of Marcion he scandalised the Christian churches because of his mutilation of the perceived canon at the time. No secular person could rationally demonstrate that the Canon is the result of random chance or bias. Nor can we prove empirically that the Canon was recognised by the power of the Holy Spirit because such things do not belong to the realm of empirical scrutiny. But what we can say about the Canon is that it is the collection of sacred writings the Church has prayed in her liturgy, either reading or singing. 2. The argument is not quite a circular one. If it were purely circular we'd be saying: the Bible says Peter is the Pope, and the Pope says the Bible is inspired. This is more like a spiral (looks like a circle, but moves on in another dimension not immediately obvious): the Bible says Peter is the head of the Apostles, but that's not why we believe the Pope is the successor of the Prince of the Apostles etc. We believe the Pope is Peter's successor because that's what has come down to us from the Apostles. The Bible happens to confirm this, but we'd believe this anyway if the Bible never existed. We believe the Bible is inspired Scripture because the Church has always prayed the Bible, and pondered the Bible by the light of the Holy Spirit, and handed down (i.e. [i]traditio[/i]) a way of reading the Bible which comes to us from the Apostles. So whether it's the Pope or the Bible we're talking about, we believe these things because they come to us from the Apostles, because it's [b]historical Christianity[/b], the Christianity of Christ Himself. The Church herself is the living witness to the Resurrection, and because of the Church we believe what we believe. Why do we believe the Church? Because she is a reliable witness. The example of the early Christians, their faith and martyrdom, move us to acknowledge what they also confessed: that Jesus Christ is Lord to the glory of God the Father in the unity of the Holy Spirit! Can we prove this? No. Because this is in the realm of faith, and faith---while not contradicting reason at all---cannot be rationally demonstrated. Does this make us irrational? No. Something irrational must contradict reason, and faith doesn't do that. There are many things so-called scientific and rational people accept which cannot be demonstrated rationally. These all have to be accepted by a kind of "faith". For example, can they ever rationally, empirically know that their wives love them? No. You can't measure that love, or weigh it, or say what it smells like or tastes like. If you point to the evidence that their wives are nice and warm and friendly, that could still be a very elaborate hoax. My point is that there are tons of things in ordinary life which we all, rationalists included, must accept on faith. Faith does not mean a "leap into the dark" here. There are good reasons for supposing one's wife does truly love one. And there are good reasons for having faith in the Son of God. But ultimately this faith is a gift from God. Reason can bring you to the brink of this seeming abyss, to understand that the Church truly is the Body of Christ, and Christ is the Son of God made man. But only God's gift of faith can aid you to "leap into the light".
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now