musturde Posted February 9, 2005 Posted February 9, 2005 [quote name='AtheistAlex' date='Feb 8 2005, 11:04 PM'] Irrelevant. I said we'd all BE atheists, which is not dependant on whether or not there would be a term for atheism. In fact, I am sure there would not be such a term. Still, we would all have the one characteristic of atheism, which is that we'd be without theism, simple as that. Don't be a stranger, Alex [/quote] No, there wouldn't be a term for it. Theist = believer of God. Atheist is derived from that.Without the belief of God, there are no people who are claimed atheist because you have to have a group of people believing in something to label yourself into a group that rejects it.
AtheistAlex Posted February 9, 2005 Author Posted February 9, 2005 It seems you misunderstand atheism still, my friend. Atheism itself is only the lack of a belief in God, so it is not a rejection of God, nor an acceptance of an existence we can't prove, it only encompasses the fact that we cannot, and/or do not believe in a God or gods, for any number of reasons. I said, "If we knew there to be no God, we'd ALL be atheists." That means, if we KNEW there to be no God, we'd all be atheists. But, truthfully, I must admit, that wouldn't be true, probably. Skeptics of all kinds and creeds will always exist.
crusader1234 Posted February 9, 2005 Posted February 9, 2005 I'm a Catholic concenred with social justice, human rights, moral issues, and the environment. Anything less than perfect isn't good enough for me to apply my name to... so I'd say I'm just... Catholic. Everyone else is corrupt anyways. I'm not going to say 'I don't have a label' because, after all, chosing not to conform is really just conforming to anarchy.
popestpiusx Posted February 9, 2005 Posted February 9, 2005 [quote name='AtheistAlex' date='Feb 9 2005, 12:20 AM'] Atheism itself is only the lack of a belief in God, [/quote] Kind of like evil is the lack of a due good, huh?
allis-challmers Posted February 9, 2005 Posted February 9, 2005 I am going to reply to the original message about politics. I am a union electrician and a cathlic. all i want for christmass is a pro life demicrat
AtheistAlex Posted February 9, 2005 Author Posted February 9, 2005 [quote name='musturde' date='Feb 8 2005, 10:54 PM'] Atheist: "There's no God" That doesn't make sense. If you are able to say the word "God", he must exist as a thought. If he exists as a thought, then saying "There is no God" is a contradiction to itself. Agnostic: "There may be a God but we have no definite proof of it" That makes more sense. I classify all "atheists" as agnostics. So, you're either "A theist" or an agnostic but i wont call you an atheist. [/quote] Sorry, I missed this earlier. The part about atheists saying "God" meaning they accept God is incorrect. To say the name of a concept is, in my mind, and in the mind of a lot of my friends, a way of showing respect to your audience. I could put quotes around it, and act arrogant, as to insult your belief in such a concept, but I show you the respect I wish you to reciprocate, by saying God as you would, though I am arguing against God's existence. Oh, and as a human concept, God does obviously exist. But not necessarily as a supernatural concept. Let's speed it up, I can't wait for your responses all night, Alex P.S. Agnostic Atheist, all together now. Agnostic Atheist!
musturde Posted February 9, 2005 Posted February 9, 2005 [quote name='AtheistAlex' date='Feb 8 2005, 11:20 PM'] It seems you misunderstand atheism still, my friend. Atheism itself is only the lack of a belief in God, so it is not a rejection of God, nor an acceptance of an existence we can't prove, it only encompasses the fact that we cannot, and/or do not believe in a God or gods, for any number of reasons. I said, "If we knew there to be no God, we'd ALL be atheists." That means, if we KNEW there to be no God, we'd all be atheists. But, truthfully, I must admit, that wouldn't be true, probably. Skeptics of all kinds and creeds will always exist. [/quote] without the ideas of Gods, there'd be no atheists. which would mean that they creat atheists.
AtheistAlex Posted February 9, 2005 Author Posted February 9, 2005 [quote name='popestpiusx' date='Feb 8 2005, 11:23 PM'] Kind of like evil is the lack of a due good, huh? [/quote] That's a good little quip, there. Get them in now. Kind of like how blind faith is the lack of facts, huh? See, we can all play that game. Hakuna Matata y'all, Alex
Scofizzle Posted February 9, 2005 Posted February 9, 2005 so why do you capatalize it as if it were a proper noun? I simply don't believe the notion that someone cannot believe in the existence of God. Whats your real problem with Christianity and the Church?
musturde Posted February 9, 2005 Posted February 9, 2005 [quote name='AtheistAlex' date='Feb 8 2005, 11:26 PM'] Sorry, I missed this earlier. The part about atheists saying "God" meaning they accept God is incorrect. To say the name of a concept is, in my mind, and in the mind of a lot of my friends, a way of showing respect to your audience. I could put quotes around it, and act arrogant, as to insult your belief in such a concept, but I show you the respect I wish you to reciprocate, by saying God as you would, though I am arguing against God's existence. Oh, and as a human concept, God does obviously exist. But not necessarily as a supernatural concept. Let's speed it up, I can't wait for your responses all night, Alex P.S. Agnostic Atheist, all together now. Agnostic Atheist! [/quote] You didn't understand me. God, to atheists, exists as an idea. If he exists as an idea, he exists even by thought.
AtheistAlex Posted February 9, 2005 Author Posted February 9, 2005 [quote name='musturde' date='Feb 8 2005, 11:28 PM'] without the ideas of Gods, there'd be no atheists. which would mean that they creat atheists. [/quote] Without the [i]ideas[/i] of God, which precludes belief in such entities, there'd be no theists, actually...You see, the ideas of over-arching deities create deity-worshippers, or theists. Before such ideas, everyone is atheistic, whether they like it or not. [quote]so why do you capatalize it as if it were a proper noun? [/quote] Atheism? It's a specific concept. Not a religion, no, but it is still a definable human concept.
Scofizzle Posted February 9, 2005 Posted February 9, 2005 [quote]so why do you capatalize it as if it were a proper noun? Atheism? It's a specific concept. Not a religion, no, but it is still a definable human concept. [/quote] sorry I meant when you capatalize God.
musturde Posted February 9, 2005 Posted February 9, 2005 [quote name='AtheistAlex' date='Feb 8 2005, 11:32 PM'] Without the [i]ideas[/i] of God, which precludes belief in such entities, there'd be no theists, actually...You see, the ideas of over-arching deities create deity-worshippers, or theists. Before such ideas, everyone is atheistic, whether they like it or not. [/quote] No, they wouldn't even consider themselves atheists because there wouldn't even be theists for there to be atheists. You need people to believe in God(s) to be people who classify themselves as atheists. Atheists say "there is no God', before the idea of God, people wouldnt even be able to say that.
popestpiusx Posted February 9, 2005 Posted February 9, 2005 It's too bad I won't be on here until Easter (come midnight tonight). This could be a fun debate.
AtheistAlex Posted February 9, 2005 Author Posted February 9, 2005 [quote name='musturde' date='Feb 8 2005, 11:29 PM'] You didn't understand me. God, to atheists, exists as an idea. If he exists as an idea, he exists even by thought. [/quote] True that God exists as an idea, but not as a supernatural idea, rather as a manmade concept, you see? [quote]I simply don't believe the notion that someone cannot believe in the existence of God. Whats your real problem with Christianity and the Church?[/quote] See now, that's not nice. I was trying to have a civil discussion with *about 4 different people*, and then you try to make this an issue of revenge? For your information, I find that I feel equal unease with all religions, even Shinto. Still, I like talking about it with people because it can break down the barriers that make hatred towards atheists acceptable behaviour. Arigatou Gozaimasu, Alex
Scofizzle Posted February 9, 2005 Posted February 9, 2005 I'm sorry i didn't mean to come off that way.....i tend to be a little blunt.....just curious what is keeping you away from the Love
AtheistAlex Posted February 9, 2005 Author Posted February 9, 2005 [quote name='musturde' date='Feb 8 2005, 11:34 PM'] No, they wouldn't even consider themselves atheists because there wouldn't even be theists for there to be atheists. You need people to believe in God(s) to be people who classify themselves as atheists. Atheists say "there is no God', before the idea of God, people wouldnt even be able to say that. [/quote] That's what I was saying. There wouldn't be the term, most definitely. I was trying to convey that the underlying meaning, the lack of belief that atheism (maybe I shouldn't capitalize it...) is about would be far, far more prevalent. [quote]sorry I meant when you capatalize God.[/quote] Oh, okay. Most of the people who I argue with are Christian. By far. I wish I could've debated against some Buddhists in Japan, but they weren't having it.
Scofizzle Posted February 9, 2005 Posted February 9, 2005 hah...thats the funny thing about Buddhism......no converts.....you are either born Buddhist or not....... (or is that hinduism?)
musturde Posted February 9, 2005 Posted February 9, 2005 [quote name='AtheistAlex' date='Feb 8 2005, 11:42 PM'] That's what I was saying. There wouldn't be the term, most definitely. I was trying to convey that the underlying meaning, the lack of belief that atheism (maybe I shouldn't capitalize it...) is about would be far, far more prevalent. Oh, okay. Most of the people who I argue with are Christian. By far. I wish I could've debated against some Buddhists in Japan, but they weren't having it. [/quote] No, because Atheism is a statement of belief against God, these people can't say that because they dont know what a God is. Without God(s), there'd be no man who was against the idea of there being a God.
AtheistAlex Posted February 9, 2005 Author Posted February 9, 2005 Probably both, since Hinduism spawned Buddhism. It has been a long while since my Asian Studies class.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now