Guest Zewe Comma Chris Posted February 12, 2005 Posted February 12, 2005 [b]KEEP IN MIND THAT THIS IS PURELY HYPOTHETICAL, I AM JUST CURIOUS AS TO THE ANSWER[/b] Hum...alright. If I were to walk into a confessional booth thing and confess to everything I've done over the past 5 years (list below) or so, what do YOU think my penance would be? - Devil worship - Buddhism - Taoism - Shinto - Wicca - Islam - Atheism - Engaging in adultery with both sexes - Stealing well over $500 in items from stores and the like, on top of an unkown number from pockets/houses/etc. - Disrepecting my parents excessively - Proclaiming myself as the son of God - Proclaiming myself as God - Proclaiming myself as Satan - Proclaiming myself as the Antichrist - Countless hundreds of small offenses. Answer?
Adeodatus Posted February 13, 2005 Posted February 13, 2005 Some sins require restitution as part of repentance, for example sins of stealing or destroying someone's reputation. In justice we must restore what we have unlawfully taken away. Some sins may incur separation from the sacramental life of the Church (i.e. excommunication). Reconciliation must involve the restoration of this sacramental sharing, and it may be up to the bishop or the Apostolic See to do this. Some sins involve scandal, and may require a public abjuration of error, e.g. a bishop who apostasises and repents, may have to repent publically. A penance however is not a punishment. It is suited to the healing of the penitent. It is NOT the case that the more serious the sin the more severe the penance. Getting 10 Hail Marys doesn't mean you're a greater sinner than someone who gets 5 Hail Marys. Much of the healing that penance does is also done by charity, by the degree of contrition we undergo when we repent of our sins. Someone who is perfectly (i.e. completely) contrite and repents because of the love of God would---strictly speaking---require no penance at all, e.g. the Good Theif who repented when crucified with Jesus, or the penitent woman who anointed Jesus' feet. He who loves much is forgiven much, as the gospel says.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now