lilac_angel Posted February 26, 2005 Posted February 26, 2005 Hi, I have a little question regarding Proverbs. I really love reading them (it's been too long). I'm a little confused about the ones that seem to talk of earthly rewards for good conduct, for example, these: Proverbs 12:21 No harm befalls the just, but the wicked are overwhelmed with misfortune. Proverbs 13:22 The good man leaves an inheritance to his children's children, but the wealth of the sinner is stored up for the just. A lot of the Proverbs seem like common sense, but am I to read certain ones only from the perspective of a Jewish person in Old Testament times? Because it was a Jewish concept that good fortune in the same life would befall those who feared God. However, after Christ came, He obviously stressed the afterlife. So did the meaning of Proverbs like these change slightly? Or is it possible that God not only rewards the just in the afterlife, but even perhaps blesses them with a little bit of extra earthly reward (that they wouldn't otherwise experience if they were unjust) too? And I don't even necessarily mean riches, but maybe just an easier time, or a tad more "luck," or whatever. I guess I'm just wondering too how seriously we are to take them, because most of them [i]do[/i] seem to make a lot of sense...does the fact that they're Old Testament make them less "reliable" or "necessary" advice for current day-to-day living? Thanks for any input...or any other thoughts you have on Proverbs.
phatcatholic Posted February 26, 2005 Posted February 26, 2005 [quote name='lilac_angel' date='Feb 26 2005, 02:02 AM'] So did the meaning of Proverbs like these change slightly? Or is it possible that God not only rewards the just in the afterlife, but even perhaps blesses them with a little bit of extra earthly reward (that they wouldn't otherwise experience if they were unjust) too? [/quote] i would say both. many of the proverbs are indeed indicative of a particular place and time. this is something we must acknowledge of every biblical work. however, i think we have to fight the urge to pick and choose what applies to our lives, discrediting those passages we don't understand or can't accept as only relevant to the author's immediate audience. the bible must have relevance to our present place and time b/c it is meant to be a guide for all men. so, often times, difficult passages are not irrelevant as much as they are applicable in a different way. this would appear to be a sound way to read the bible, but i am certainly open to correction. as for the verses you mention, they do seem to represent the notion of punishment and reward that was common then. it was often thought that if a person was sick or diseased it was b/c of their own sin or the sin of their parents. this was one reason--besides the contageous nature of the disease--that lepors were so ostracized. while today we are more exact in determing the cause of sickness and other forms of misfortune (for example, the psychosis behind abnormal or dysfuntional behavior, and the science behind natural disasters) we must acknowledge that misfortunate befalls those who reject God. grace is the only thing that sustains us in our disordered world. if we reject this grace, then we can only expect more pain and heartache. conversely, accepting this grace provides great reward. now, this reward manifests itself in many ways, and not always through earthly treasure. also, it may seem like the life of a saint is without reward, considering the the pain we often go through on behalf of our faith. but we must remember two things: 1. just imagine that same life [i]without[/i] the grace that is being accepted. it would be far worse!! 2. our reward is often not in this life but in the next so, we have here biblical passages that, while reflecting the culture and understanding of OT Judaism, are still relevant to us today. i hope that helps pax christi, phatcatholic
corban711 Posted February 26, 2005 Posted February 26, 2005 well i think it is also important to remember that we read the Old testament in light of the New. in the new we find things like Jesus saying, if we get rid of everything we will be paid back a hundredfold even [i]in this life[/i]. does that mean, nothing bad will happen or we will be rich? no, not necessarily. but the reward is much deeper and full of joy. and in a certain sense...for someone who finds joy in all things, no harm can come upon him. the just man can be truly joyful in all things while the wicked will be miserable. so you could read those proverbs in a different light and they make a little more sense. well, at least for me they do! hope that helps! hehe
lilac_angel Posted February 28, 2005 Author Posted February 28, 2005 (edited) Thank you very much, for the well thought out replies They were very helpful! I must say that for those two quotes, it might have been a King James translation (I found them online) So I looked for the Douay Rhiems translation for 12:21...it seems to make more sense: "Whatsoever shall befall the just man, shall not make him sad: but the wicked shall be filled with mischief."" The DR translation for the other one is probably better too. Also, I learned from another thread that by definition a proverb states a general truth. [i]Generally[/i] hard work eventually pays off while laziness leaves you hungry, but there are exceptions. Edited February 28, 2005 by lilac_angel
phatcatholic Posted March 2, 2005 Posted March 2, 2005 [quote name='lilac_angel' date='Feb 27 2005, 08:47 PM'] Thank you very much, for the well thought out replies They were very helpful! I must say that for those two quotes, it might have been a King James translation (I found them online) So I looked for the Douay Rhiems translation for 12:21...it seems to make more sense: "Whatsoever shall befall the just man, shall not make him sad: but the wicked shall be filled with mischief."" The DR translation for the other one is probably better too. Also, I learned from another thread that by definition a proverb states a general truth. [i]Generally[/i] hard work eventually pays off while laziness leaves you hungry, but there are exceptions. [/quote] yes, yes, your last point is VERY important. it is my experience that charismatic protestants in particular tend to view certain proverbs as [i][b]absolutes[/b][/i], instead of as general statements about mankind.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now