thessalonian Posted February 26, 2005 Posted February 26, 2005 Phatcatholic talked about being po'ed below at some nonsense. Well this was in our local Church paper with regard to the woman at the well in John 4: "Biblical scholars seriously doubt that this event ever took place in the life of the historical Jesus. After the resurrection of Jesus, the Johannine community, the one responsible for writing the fourth Gospel, included Samaritan believers. Thus, this scene was read back into Jesus’ lifetime by the Johannine community. It was their way of welcoming and including " At the end of John's Gospel he says " 24] This is the disciple who is bearing witness to these things, and who has written these things; and we know that his testimony is true. But there are also many other things which Jesus did; were every one of them to be written, I suppose that the world itself could not contain the books that would be written. So I guess this is false also. Now if someone believes Mr. Zannoni's words then what in John's Gospel should be believed? A dove just happened to fly by when Jesus was baptized and some the Johaniane community added in that stuff about "this is my beloved son". The story of the loaves and fish feeding 5000???? Naw, couldn't have happened. The Eucharistic discourse in John 6? Why believe it. I have to wonder when non-catholics read nonsense like this how they will ever come to the fullness of the truth. The Church would be much better off if it excommuncated all scholars and let them present their case for coming back by subjecting themselves to orthodox scrutiny. We can't have garbage like this being tolerated. I wrote an editorial in the paper and a letter to the Archbishop. God bless
phatcatholic Posted February 27, 2005 Posted February 27, 2005 [quote name='thessalonian' date='Feb 26 2005, 12:44 PM'] "Biblical scholars seriously doubt that this event ever took place in the life of the historical Jesus. After the resurrection of Jesus, the Johannine community, the one responsible for writing the fourth Gospel, included Samaritan believers. Thus, this scene was read back into Jesus’ lifetime by the Johannine community. It was their way of welcoming and including " [/quote] the syllogism employed here is horribly faulty: --the Johannine community wrote the fourth Gospel --the Johannine community included Samaritan believers --the Johannine community wanted to welcome and include these Samaritans --thus, the story of the woman at the well was fabricated to make them feel welcome anyone else see the freakin bottomless pit between steps 3 and 4? even if we do grant that a "community" wrote the Gospel, that the Samaritans among their audience felt unwelcome, and that the author(s) wanted to make them feel better, it still does not follow from necessity that the story is a fabrication. also, since when did a "community" write John's Gospel? and whatever happened to the historical reliability of the bible, at least as it pertains to the life of Christ? these "scholars" propose a rather hefty pill to swallow. i'm glad you did your part and wrote a reply
yiannii Posted February 27, 2005 Posted February 27, 2005 What an interesting hypothesis! I think to get to the bottom of this we would need to go back to the Early Church Fathers to see if the doubted the story. Did the author provide any sources?
thessalonian Posted February 27, 2005 Author Posted February 27, 2005 [quote name='yiannii' date='Feb 27 2005, 01:10 AM'] What an interesting hypothesis! I think to get to the bottom of this we would need to go back to the Early Church Fathers to see if the doubted the story. Did the author provide any sources? [/quote] Sources? Surely you jest. Why would he do that and expose the wolves he packs around with? I've been suspicious of this guy for a while but don't read him often. The whole article comes accross to me as an undermining of the all male priesthood though there is not enough evidence to publically accuse him of it. Here is the whole article online if your interested. [url="http://www.thecatholicspirit.com/articles.php?article_type=Art%20Zannoni"]http://www.thecatholicspirit.com/articles....e=Art%20Zannoni[/url]
yiannii Posted February 28, 2005 Posted February 28, 2005 LOL there is always an ulterior motive for such poor practices.
phatcatholic Posted March 2, 2005 Posted March 2, 2005 this story was in sunday's readings, did anyone catch that? anyway, as i was listening i realized something else. how could this story of the woman at the well be something added in later to make the samaritans feel welcomed if Jesus is straight-up calling her out?
thessalonian Posted March 2, 2005 Author Posted March 2, 2005 [quote name='phatcatholic' date='Mar 1 2005, 09:10 PM'] this story was in sunday's readings, did anyone catch that? anyway, as i was listening i realized something else. how could this story of the woman at the well be something added in later to make the samaritans feel welcomed if Jesus is straight-up calling her out? [/quote] because the scholars who know better than us dummies say so.
phatcatholic Posted March 2, 2005 Posted March 2, 2005 [quote name='thessalonian' date='Mar 2 2005, 05:18 PM'] because the scholars who know better than us dummies say so. [/quote] ohhhh, ok, i guess i forgot.........
WBOZ Posted March 4, 2005 Posted March 4, 2005 At my Parish we were subjected to a lay member of the parish reading (just after all were seated after the closing of the tabernacle and prior to the closing prayer)an and now for the rest of the gospel story fictional account of the woman at the well with her purported friends. It was the most touchy/feely gobbldygoop I have been subjected to since coming into the Church six years ago. For anyone from California I had the uncomfortable feeling that I was listening to a Robert Schuler sermon at the Crystal Cathedral. Please pray for the state of the Church in Southern California. WCB
yiannii Posted March 4, 2005 Posted March 4, 2005 [quote name='WBOZ' date='Mar 4 2005, 12:35 PM'] At my Parish we were subjected to a lay member of the parish reading (just after all were seated after the closing of the tabernacle and prior to the closing prayer)an and now for the rest of the gospel story fictional account of the woman at the well with her purported friends. It was the most touchy/feely gobbldygoop I have been subjected to since coming into the Church six years ago. For anyone from California I had the uncomfortable feeling that I was listening to a Robert Schuler sermon at the Crystal Cathedral. Please pray for the state of the Church in Southern California. WCB [/quote] Are there any Catholic parishes where you live? As any "church" which does not abide by the three pillars of truth (Scripture, Sacred Tradition, the Magisterium) are technically not truly Catholic. I feel forry for your situation, it must be really difficult and draining on your spirit. God bless and I'll pray 4 u and the Church in Sthn Cal!
thessalonian Posted March 4, 2005 Author Posted March 4, 2005 (edited) WBOZ, Is Bishop Weigand your bishop? Write the Bishop on such nonsense. Then at least that puts the ball in his court. If noone speaks up then it is in yours. Edited March 4, 2005 by thessalonian
toby1986 Posted March 4, 2005 Posted March 4, 2005 Look up Jesus Seminar. This is where this garbage is coming from. Too bad that some priests have fallen into that dark bin. According to them only 20 percent of what the bible says are Jesus's words were actually spoken by Him. These dudes actually vote using colored beads, or marbles to indicate whether in their opinion Jesus actually spoke those words or whether the stores or true or not. I think those marbles fell out of their brains. Me thinks they are a bunch of :clown: IMO anything that comes from the JS needs to go down the :toilet: God Bless :wub:
AngelofJesus Posted March 4, 2005 Posted March 4, 2005 I am a catechist for the LA Archdiocese. The state of orthodoxy in here is very poor. The LA religious education Congress (which I boycott every year) is plague full of dissenting speakers, one of them is Father Mcbrien. You don't have to go very far here to see the kind of heterodoxy that is taught. We need prayers here.
cmotherofpirl Posted March 6, 2005 Posted March 6, 2005 I think you guys need a Second Coming out there.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now