Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

The supreme court handed dwon a ruling showing that it is unconstitutional to proscribe the death penalty to a crime if they were under 18 when they commited the crime.

Thank God!

Here's the link.
[url="http://story.news.yahoo.com/fc?cid=34&tmpl=fc&in=US&cat=Death_Penalty"]Supreme Court Ruling[/url]

StPiusVPrayForUs
Posted

They should have fried him.

Posted

Age doesnt change severity of crimes. A 12 year old is capable of killing a whole their whole family..

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='Luthien' date='Mar 1 2005, 11:07 AM'] Age doesnt change severity of crimes. A 12 year old is capable of killing a whole their whole family.. [/quote]
Age does change the culpability. A 12 year old simply cannot know the gravity of such a crime. God holds each accountable according to the level of their understanding (the light they have been given) and so should we.

toledo_jesus
Posted

Why do we have a juvenile justice system if we are just going to execute them anyway?
Thank God that somebody showed some mercy for these youths. While they are by no means to be released back into society, by virtue of their youth they should be treated and rehabilitated if possible. If not possible, keep them in prison and let their naturally self-destructive behavior be contained.

I'm kind of appalled that anybody would think about executing a person who committed a crime as a 12 year old. What about that 6 year old who shot a classmate? What do we do with him? :angry:

Posted

In Indiana, the cutoff is 10 years old for a juvenile accused of murder to be possibly waived up to adult court. I covered a case a few years ago in which a 10-year-old shot and killed his father, on purpose, but he wasn't waived up to adult court. He's now in a rehabilitative corrections facility in PA.

Personally, I think the DP should be much more sparingly administered than it is ... and maybe should be abolished all together. There are LOTS of problems with the judicial system that aren't all that obvious from the outside. When you get into it, though, you start to wonder whether it's possible to justly administer the death penalty.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Oik' date='Mar 1 2005, 01:03 PM'] The supreme court handed dwon a ruling showing that it is unconstitutional to proscribe the death penalty to a crime if they were under 18 when they commited the crime.

Thank God!

Here's the link.
[url="http://story.news.yahoo.com/fc?cid=34&tmpl=fc&in=US&cat=Death_Penalty"]Supreme Court Ruling[/url] [/quote]
The case involved a 17 year old who hogtied his neighbor and thru her off a bridge.
PLEASE do not try to tell me he didn't know what he was doing.

toledo_jesus
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Mar 1 2005, 01:31 PM'] The case involved a 17 year old who hogtied his neighbor and thru her off a bridge.
PLEASE do not try to tell me he didn't know what he was doing. [/quote]
Again, we have a juvenile justice system for a reason, and if we suspend it in special cases we should just stop pretending to care.
He may have known what he was doing. He may also have been sick in the head and impressionable. He probably didn't fully understand just what he was doing. Young people make bad choices that can put them in bad states of mind that can lead them to do bad things.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

If you read on, he also bragged he was under 18 so they couldn't fry him.



"Young people make bad choices that can put them in bad states of mind that can lead them to do bad things. "

So? Bad choices lead to bad consequences.
If you deliberately take a life you forfeit your own.

toledo_jesus
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Mar 1 2005, 01:48 PM'] If you read on, he also bragged he was under 18 so they couldn't fry him.



So? Bad choices lead to bad consequences.
If you deliberately take a life you forfeit your own. [/quote]
his braggadocio is another indication that he had not thought about this with an adult mind, nor was he dealing with the consequences as an adult.

If you take a life you deserve punishment. That's true. But adolescents and younger do NOT have the full capacity of an adult. My position is that we have a juvenile justice system. We should stick to it or drop it altogether. They have drawn a line at 18, and i think that's fair. Now, as far as what to do with these kids, I don't know.

Posted

I'm so glad that they made this decision, now we are one step closer to getting rid of the death penalty all together, which is what needs to happen.

toledo_jesus
Posted

[quote name='zwergel88' date='Mar 1 2005, 07:19 PM'] I'm so glad that they made this decision, now we are one step closer to getting rid of the death penalty all together, which is what needs to happen. [/quote]
I wouldn't go that far...It should still be a right of governments to put to death those who threaten the safety of its citizens. today the death penalty should be rare because we can contain most criminals, but still available for those times when a criminal is so dangerous that imprisonment would not be sufficient, ie he starts killing other prisoners.

Posted

as PSPX once pointed out to me, criminals could be contained 1000 years ago as well. it's not like prisons had high escape rates, and island prisons were all the rage. send them to siberia or Australia and be rid of them.

so I no longer buy the argument to use it less frequently because NOW we can contain criminals. Everyone takes that and assumes that we now can contain them but when the death penalty was ok we couldn't. actually, we could... so yeah I don't get it..

MilesChristi
Posted

[quote]The supreme court handed dwon a ruling showing that it is unconstitutional to proscribe the death penalty to a crime if they were under 18 when they commited the crime.[/quote]

I wonder when they'll decide that it's unconstitutional to prescribe the death penalty to unborn babies, who have committed no crimes. :rolleyes:

MichaelFilo
Posted

Don't question the law, you'll fail at making any sense of it.


Children are impresionable, it's true. To kill one for something they did is greviously wrong. Whats funny is when you think you can cure someone without attending to their spiritaul needs. IF you won't give them that treatment, then giving them the DP is full acceptable, because a full cure cannot happen any other way, and they remain a menace to society. That is why I appreciate Bush (the senator, not the president) and his faith-based prisions here in Florida, they are the right step to curing the ills of those who are ill in mind. If you won't gratn them that, then better to kill them before they take more lives and put their souls in more uncertanty.

God bless,
Mikey

Posted

you mean Bush the governor. anyway, yeah, that's great. that's why the Church should have more temporal power, the state can't cure criminals and it basically knows it.

opposing the death penalty does not have its root in spiritual thinking, however. It began to be questioned at the Enlightenment when people started thinking of death as the final end and thus there is never any reason to end mortal life.

The Church has always seen certain grave crimes as making a person deserve death. And it has always seen the threat of death as the ultimate conversion method. Many a man (I would argue probably more than those in life imprisonment) has been driven to repentance when faced with their own mortality.

The state has just recourse to the DP for capital crimes.

argent_paladin
Posted

The traditional teaching of the Church does not exclude, presupposing full ascertainment of the identity and responsibility of the offender, recourse to the death penalty, when this is the only practicable way to defend the lives of human beings effectively against the aggressor. If, instead, bloodless means are sufficient to defend against the aggressor and to protect the safety of persons, public authority should limit itself to such means, because they better correspond to the concrete conditions of the common good and are more in conformity to the dignity of the human person. Today, in fact, given the means at the State's disposal to effectively repress crime by rendering inoffensive the one who has committed it, without depriving him definitively of the possibility of redeeming himself, cases of absolute necessity for suppression of the offender today ... are very rare, if not practically non-existent.'
CCC

Note, it mentions the responsibility of the offender. Age is a factor in ascertaining responsibility. And a society should be consistent. If we as a society don't believe that a person is responsible enough to vote until 18, join the military, make contracts, etc then why do we believe that he is responsible enough to be executed for his crimes?
Of course, to be totally consistent, if a 17-year-old is not capable of making a rational decision to kill another with full volition (and thus doesn't deserve death) then why is a 17-year-old deemed capable of making a rational decision to kill another with full volition when that other is her unborn child? Why are the rules different for a 14-year-old girl who has an abortion than a 17-year-old who kills someone?
Bottom line: Society has the right to decide when a person takes on the rights and responsibilities of adulthood. There is reasonable scientific evidence that 18 is a good dividing line between legal minority and majority in our society.

MichaelFilo
Posted

Yes, and science itself says that each human is unique, and while 18 can be a good age at which we call a person an adult, and give them the responsibilities of that position, many people are adults much earlier. If you can commit premedated murder, you're an adult and in court should be treated as such. Gaining the privelages of an adult doesn't make you anymore an adult then hitting a certain age. Some 20 year olds are more childish then I am, some 14 year olds are more mature than I can ever hope to be. While witholding privelages is an understandable practice, witholding punishment is not, since the punishment must fit the crime.

God bless,
Mikey

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...