Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

overview of Marian teachings


Recommended Posts

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[b]Mary as Mother of God[/b] (431 AD—Council of Ephesus (defined as dogma))
In the Council, Mary was defined as "theotokos" ("God-bearer") in opposition to the Nestorian heresy which attempted to tear Jesus' humanity from His divinity. Mary is the mother of the second person of the Holy Trinity made man: Jesus. The simple syllogism of Cyril of Alexandria can be summed up as such: Jesus is God, Mary is the mother of Jesus, and therefore Mary is the Mother of God.
In this instance, motherhood is taken to mean that a woman communicates to her offspring a nature identical to her own—mother produces body and God animates it (by infusing the soul). However, Mary does NOT give Jesus His divine nature, or His divine personhood; she DOES give Him a human nature identical to her own that is inseparably united with His divine nature & divine personhood. Thus, Mary gives birth to a Son who is truly God, and therefore Mary is rightly called the Mother of God.
Where do we see evidence for this in Scripture? Luke 1:32 "He shall be called Son of the Most High"… who is the 'Most High'? God. Thus, Jesus is the 'Son of God'; furthermore, Mary then, gives birth to the 'Son of God' and thus becomes the Mother of God. We also read in Galatians 4:4 that "God sent His Son, born of a woman", thus again Mary is the Mother of the 'Son of God' who is God, and thus she is the Mother of God.

[b]Mary's Perpetual Virginity[/b] (Confirmed by 2nd Constantinople (an Ecumenical Council))
This dogma states that Mary was virginal [i]before[/i], [i]during[/i], and [i]after[/i] the birth of Christ. The first of these: before the birth of Christ, all Christians agree on and accept—the prophesy of Isaiah 7:14 "Behold, a virgin shall conceive and bear a son", and this is confirmed in the New Testament in Luke 1:35 & Matthew 1:20-23.
The second aspect of this dogma is probably the most confusing for many—that Mary was virginal [i]during [/i]the birth of Christ. By this, it is meant that in a miraculous manner, Christ passed through the womb of Mary without loss of her virginity—as light passes through glass without damage to the glass, so too, Christ passed through the womb of Mary without any physical damage to Mary. Thomas Aquinas explains by saying that it is not right that he who came to heal corruption should violate someone physically. The Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC 449) states that the birth of Christ did not diminish Mary's virginity, but rather, sanctified it.
The third and final aspect is probably the most controversial. Mary was remained virginal even [i]after [/i]the birth of Jesus. Mary's response to the Angel in Luke 1:34 "how can this be…" revealed a disposition (a vow, if you will) of perpetual virginity. Why? Naturally, if Mary had intended on having relations with Joseph the announcement that she should become pregnant would not be a surprise. As God has only one first born Son, so too does Mary. It is a reverencing of God becoming man, not a slam on sexuality.
Some objections to this last aspect include Matthew 1:18 and 1:25 ("before they came together" & "knew her not until…"). Both simply establish what has not yet taken place [i]regardless [/i]of what takes place after. 2 Samuel 6:23 says that Michol had no children until the day of her death…does this imply she had children after she died?! Of course not. Next, usually the "brethren of the Lord" are brought up (Mark 6:3). The Greek word for "brother" ("adelphos") can also mean cousin, near relative, or even kinsmen—it is not exclusive to blood brother—the Old Testament Hebrew "ah" has the same meaning and was often used between men who could not be literal blood brothers (ex. Genesis 13:8, and 12:5, among others). The use of "brother" in the Scriptures and in the Church has always tended to have a universal context, rather than a blood relationship. Western culture has tended to make the term exclusive (though, we still have fraternities ("frater"="brother" in Latin)). For the most part, the "brethren of the Lord" is not seen as something "disproving" Mary's virginity in most other parts of the world.

[b]Mary's Immaculate Conception[/b] (Dec. 8, 1854, Papal infallible statement by Bl. Pius IX)
This privilege is exclusive to the person of Mary at the moment of her conception (the moment her soul was infused into the embryo). By Immaculate Conception it is meant that from her conception, Mary is preserved from Original Sin and all its effects. She possesses fully both the preter-natural (natural immortality of the body, infused knowledge, and integrity (harmony between reason & emotions)) and supernatural (life in grace) gifts that were lost in the Fall. How does this apply to Mary? With infused knowledge she is able to recognize the supernatural significance of events of God (ex. "kept all these words in her heart" Luke 2:51), she did not have concupiscence, and retains the supernatural gift of fullness of grace (also seen in Luke 1:28). All of this, though, must be kept in view of the merits of Jesus Christ—Mary was saved by an application of the graces of Jesus Christ (thus, she was saved in a special fashion by Christ (Luke 1:49)).
Where is this seen in Scripture? If we look at the protoevangelium—Genesis 3:15, we see that God puts enmity (complete and radical opposition) between the woman and the serpent, and between the seed of the woman and the seed of the serpent. This passage is called the protoevangelium (or "first Gospel") because it is a promise of Salvation (a prophetic text). The seed of the woman is seen to be Jesus Christ, thus the woman is Mary. The SAME enmity exists between the woman and the serpent as exists between their respective seeds. If Mary was partly sinful, then she was partly with Satan and wouldn't possess the enmity of Genesis 3:15. Secondly, we look in the New Testament to Luke 1:28 "Hail, full of grace", the Greek "kekaritomene" is a perfect participle and refers to an action that has been completed in the past but has a current significance—thus, the Angel is saying "Hail, you who have been perfected in grace"—as an action completed in the past (the Immaculate Conception).

[b]The Assumption of Mary into Heaven[/b] (Nov. 1, 1950, "Munificentissimus Deus" Pius XII)
The assumption of Mary into Heaven is practically the natural consequence of her Immaculate Conception. Building off of Genesis 3:15 again, Mary, with (and under) Jesus triumphs over sin (through her Immaculate Conception) and death (corruption of the body through her assumption). Let us also return to Luke 1:28, the woman "full of grace" would not experience corruption through sin. And in Revelations (11:19) we see that the Ark of the Covenant is in Heaven… Mary is the new Ark of the Covenant. The Ark contained the presence of God—fragments of the tablets (10 Commandments), a piece of Aaron's staff (priesthood), and some of the manna that fed the Israelites during the Exodus. Mary also contained the presence of God in much the same way—Jesus is the new Law-giver, the High Priest, and the Eucharistic one (the "bread of life"). Furthermore, in the Psalms (132:8) we read "Arise, O Lord, into Your resting place: You and the ark, which You have sanctified". In this passage, however, let us also clarify the distinction between ascension (as in Jesus' ascension), and Mary's assumption… Jesus' ascension was in virtue and by His own power, Mary's was not on her own, but only by and through a grace of God she was taken up (assumed) into Heaven—Christ rose (and ascended) into Heaven on and by His own accord. In relation to the other dogmas (namely, as the Mother of the God, and the Immaculate Conception), it is appropriate that Jesus would protect His mother from bodily corruption of the grave (in respect of the 4th Commandment), and as a natural effect of her Immaculate Conception Mary would not experience corruption of the body, nor would she have to wait until the end of time for the resurrection of the body.
As a side note/footnote… the question of Mary's "death" has not been formally declared by the Church. And it matters not in relation to any of the dogmas whether she was assumed alive, or after a temporary separation of the soul and body (death)—she still remained free from corruption of the body. There are two claimed tombs of Mary, one in Jerusalem, and one at Ephesus (both empty, of course—the one in Jerusalem has a stronger argument for perhaps being the real tomb), but in any case, Mary has already been assumed, body and soul into Heaven—and whether or not she experienced separation of the soul and body prior to her assumption does not affect any aspect of the dogma.

[b]Co-Redemptrix, Mediatrix, and Advocate[/b] (has not yet been declared dogma, but IS doctrine)
The four Marian dogmas all describe Mary's relation to Jesus, but this fifth doctrine (a certain revealed truth yet to be solemnly defined) describes Mary's relationship as spiritual mother—Mary's relation to humanity. These are the three specific roles of Mary's maternal mediation: Co-Redemptrix, Mediatrix, and Advocate.
Co-Redemptrix= Mary's unique participation in the [i]acquisition [/i]of the graces of redemption [u]by Jesus Christ [/u](literally translated: "woman WITH the redeemer"… and we do see Mary at the foot of the Cross)
Mediatrix= Mary uniquely participates [u]with and under Jesus [/u]in the [i]distribution [/i]of the graces of redemption
Advocate= Mary's role of [i]interceding [/i]on behalf of all humanity [u]to the throne of Christ the King[/u]
Firstly, however, we must address Mary's spiritual maternity. As Mary is the Mother of Christ, the head of the Church, so too, she is likewise spiritual Mother of all members united to Christ. At the foot of the Cross (John 19:26-27) the crucified Christ gives Mary to John (who is representative of all humanity—because Calvary has a universal significance), and John takes Mary into his "idios" (=one's own)—his inner self, not his geographical residence.
Secondly, Mediatrix is a title given to Mary because of the unique way in which she participates in the ONE mediation of Jesus. All Christians (the Saints in Heaven, and those who pray on earth), are called to share and participate in the perfect mediation of Jesus. We are all called to be co-mediators—to act as a 'go-between' for another and Christ. In essence, this is what we do when another person asks us to pray for them. The goal of mediation is not to distance, but to reconcile. Furthermore, the Catholic Church does acknowledge and teach that ALL mediation is unconditionally dependent on the ONE perfect mediation of Jesus Christ (CCC 2664). 1 Timothy 2:5 does not exclude subordinate co-mediators (for prayer is a form of mediation, and just previously Paul exhorts the Christians to pray for him), but rather, 1 Timothy 2:5 excludes rival/opposing mediators. To have others participate in the perfect mediation of Christ does not obscure the glory of God, but rather further manifests it. Christians are obliged to participate in Christ's perfect sonship (and become adoptive sons of God through Christ—Galatians 4), and all are called to participate in the priesthood even though Christ is the only High Priest (etc.). Jesus is the one, perfect, Mediator, and Mary by her unique participation is called Mediatrix, and we (and the other Saints in Heaven) are tertiary co-mediators. Why/how does Mary have a unique participation? In Luke's Gospel Mary directly mediates 2 occasions of grace: Jesus' (the source of all grace) presence in her womb mediates grace to Elizabeth (when she is overshadowed by the Holy Spirit), and then to John the Baptist in the womb (who leaps). The Wedding at Cana in John 2:5 shows Mary mediating (/interceding) for Jesus' first public miracle & ministry. Lastly, Mediatrix is implicit in the term "mother"—mothers mediate, and intercede for their children (we see this all the time today). For Mary, as universal Mother this extends through Jesus to the rest of the Body of Christ (us, as Christians), and thus Mary is Mediatrix (co-mediator in a unique way).
Mary is Co-Redemptrix (the "woman WITH the redeemer"). Of course, there is only one Redeemer, we (as Catholics) DO distinguish between what is unique of Jesus and secondary to Mary… that is not at all the understanding of any of the above terms (which is why catechesis (teaching) is immensely important). We see Mary intimately involved (through the grace of God) in Redemption (yes, it is accomplished by Christ—obviously—but Mary is there, intimately participating), in Genesis 3:15 we see that the woman (Mary) is intimately involved in the crushing of the serpent's head, and in Luke 1:38 Mary's "yes" to God's plan initiates her participation in the mission with her Son—the body she gave to Christ is the instrument of Redemption (see Hebrews 10:10). And this role of Mary is confirmed a short while later in the words of Simeon (Luke 2:35)—the presentation in the temple is a foreshadowing of Calvary, where a mother offers her Son to the Father (the temple is a place of sacrifice). At the foot of the Cross, Mary consents to the immolation of her Son—she gives up her right as Mother to protect her offspring, she not only endured this, but positively consented to it for the Redemption of all humanity by Jesus Christ.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

bumpity, bump, bump, bump (cuz I have no patience).


If I stick this on a Protestant site, with a little introduction... have I left anything out? Any misinformation? Too much? Do I smell of elderberries a writing/typing.. I need suggestions.

Posted

I'm not as far along as you, so I didn't spot any errors.

The writing is at a fairly high level - if you think you might be posting over the heads of the other members of that site, you might want to simplify, clarify.

I didn't really follow this thought

Of course, there is only one Redeemer, we (as Catholics) DO distinguish between what is unique of Jesus and secondary to Mary… that is not at all the understanding of any of the above terms (which is why catechesis (teaching) is immensely important).

I can't see you discussing the opposing position/understanding unless it is to interpret it in light of your basic premse, (after all, what would be left for the opposing viewpoint to do?) but if you're going to say there are other, incorrect interpretations of the words, you might want to identify what they are, or which ones, and use that to steer your catechetical effort.

phatcatholic
Posted

some things i would add:

for mary as Mother of God, the words of Elizabeth, "who am i that the mother of my Lord should come to me."

for the assumption of mary, possible introduce the idea of the queen mother always reigning w/ the king. if Jesus reins in heaven as king, then he must have w/ him his queen mother. also, to make this easier for the protestant mind to accept, it helps to point out that ALL men will go body and soul to their eternal destination. so the concept is not foreign to scripture, and the only difference w/ mary is that she experienced this before the rest of us. finally, add the verse "the wages of sin is death." since she has no sin, it is right that she not pay the wage of death.

as for mary's role as co-redemptrix/mediatrix/advocate, i wrote this at a protestant forum a while ago and u may be able to use the scripture citations:[list]people often mistake the "one" as speaking of number, when it is really speaking of primacy. Jesus is our "one mediator" not in the sense that he is our only mediator, but in the sense that he is our [i][b]primary[/b][/i] mediator. just as God is our "one father" but we have many fathers, both biological ([url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Hebrews+12%3A9§ion=2&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=heb&NavGo=12&NavCurrentChapter=12"]Heb 12:9[/url]) and spiritual ([url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=1+Cor+4%3A15§ion=2&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=heb&NavGo=12&NavCurrentChapter=12"]1 Cor 4:15[/url]), Jesus is our "one mediator" but we have many mediators. every time we pray for someone, or lead them to Christ, we act as mediators. Paul asks us to take this role ([url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=1+Timothy+2%3A1+-+3§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=1ti&NavGo=2&NavCurrentChapter=2"]1 Tim 2:1-3[/url]), and this right before the verse in question. likewise, Jesus paid the ultimate price, yet Paul "completes what is lacking in the afflictions of Christ" ([url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=col+1:24&version=rsv&st=1&sd=1&new=1&showtools=1"]Col 1:24[/url]). Jesus is the direct means of our salvation, yet we too can "save some" ([url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=ro+11:14&version=rsv&st=1&sd=1&new=1&showtools=1"]Rom 11:14[/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=1co+9:22&version=rsv&st=1&sd=1&new=1&showtools=1"]1 Cor 9:22[/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=jude+1:23&version=rsv&st=1&sd=1&new=1&showtools=1"]Jude 1:23[/url]). God did not have to, but he has desired for us to work with Him to achieve his work on earth ([url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Mark+16%3A20§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=1ti&NavGo=2&NavCurrentChapter=2"]Mark 16:20[/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Rom+8%3A28§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=mr&NavGo=16&NavCurrentChapter=16"]Rom 8:28[/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=1+Cor+3%3A9§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=ro&NavGo=8&NavCurrentChapter=8"]1 Cor 3:9[/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=2+Cor+6%3A1§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=1co&NavGo=3&NavCurrentChapter=3"]2 Cor 6:1[/url]).

all together, this shows me that Jesus is the "one" not in number but in primacy. his mediatorship is direct and pre-eminent. ours may be indirect and subordinate...........but it still exists.
[/list]
other than that i think its great. its packed w/ info, which i like, and i think it was written well.

pax christi,
phatcatholic

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...