Mrs. Bro. Adam Posted March 18, 2005 Posted March 18, 2005 [quote name='Phazzan' date='Mar 18 2005, 10:49 AM'] A song by Metallica called 'One' depicts a man who in the context of war has lost all four limbs, as well sight and hearing. He is essentially a living piece of meat, with no way of communicating and grasping reality. Hypothetically, if such a thing was to actually happen would you support allowing a person to die a natural death or would you argue there is a moral obligation to keep that person alive? I would think seeing as there would be no way for this person to recover, the right thing to do would be to put him (or her) out of his misery. [/quote] That's called murder.
Gal. 5:22,23 Posted March 18, 2005 Posted March 18, 2005 (edited) The latest: Congress Seeks Order to Keep Schiavo Alive Mar 18, 9:13 AM (ET) WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. lawmakers said on Friday they plan to issue a congressional subpoena to keep alive Terri Schiavo, the brain-damaged Florida woman at the heart of a heated debate over the right to die. "Later this morning, we will issue a subpoena, which will require hospice administrators and attending physicians to preserve nutrition and hydration for Terri Schiavo to allow Congress to fully understand the procedures and practices that are currently keeping her alive," three Republican leaders said in a statement. The lawmakers -- House Speaker Dennis Hastert of Illinois, House Majority Leader Tom DeLay of Texas and Government Reform Committee Chairman Tom Davis of Virginia -- support the reform committee's inquiry into the long-term care of incapacitated or non-ambulatory adults. The subpoena will be joined by a Senate investigation, the lawmakers said. "This inquiry should give hope to Terri, her parents and friends, and the millions of people throughout the world who are praying for her safety," the statement said. "This fight is not over." Schiavo has been fed through a tube since she suffered an incapacitating heart attack in 1990. Her husband contends she would not have wanted to be kept alive in what court-appointed doctors describe as a persistent vegetative state. Her parents dispute this, saying their daughter responds to them and could improve with rehabilitation. The House (of Representatives) on Wednesday and the Senate on Thursday passed legislation aimed at prolonging Schiavo's life, by allowing federal courts to review the case. But the U.S. Supreme Court declined to step in, sending the matter back to a Florida court. Late Thursday night, several senators announced they were still holding talks and Congress -- which is supposed to start a two-week recess -- might return on Monday to work on the bill. Even if Schiavo's feeding tube is removed at 1 p.m. Friday, death would not be instantaneous. In a White House statement, President Bush said, "In instances like this one, where there are serious questions and substantial doubts, our society, our laws, and our courts should have a presumption in favor of life." He was due to visit Florida to talk about Social Security on Friday. Schiavo was in her mid-20s when she became ill and had no "living will" or written directive about end-of-life care. She remains at the Woodside Hospice in Pinellas Park, Florida, under police guard. Outside demonstrators held a prayer vigil. The Florida legislature failed on Thursday to agree on legislation aimed at stopping or delaying removal of the feeding tube, and Republican leaders said prospects were bleak for an agreement on Friday. Edited March 18, 2005 by Gal. 5:22,23
Phazzan Posted March 18, 2005 Posted March 18, 2005 [quote name='Mrs. Bro. Adam' date='Mar 18 2005, 10:59 AM'] That's called murder. [/quote] Really? If a loved one was in the same situation, would you want them living out their days confined to a bed, with no way of communicating, functioning, expressing emotion and no concept of reality? I would hate for a loved one to live their life in perpetual fear, anger and frusturation.
St. Catherine Posted March 18, 2005 Posted March 18, 2005 [quote]I would think seeing as there would be no way for this person to recover, the right thing to do would be to put him (or her) out of his misery. [/quote] Putting someone out of his or her misery is not dying a natural death. Like Mrs. Bro Adam said it is murder.
Phazzan Posted March 18, 2005 Posted March 18, 2005 [quote name='St. Catherine' date='Mar 18 2005, 11:27 AM'] Putting someone out of his or her misery is not dying a natural death. Like Mrs. Bro Adam said it is murder. [/quote] Is it murder to take someone off life support?
Luthien Posted March 18, 2005 Posted March 18, 2005 Shes not on life support, shes getting food and water from a tube... You need food and water.
Brother Adam Posted March 18, 2005 Author Posted March 18, 2005 It is indeed murder to starve a person to death Phazzan. We are morally obligated to provide Terri with food and water. A person does not get to decide to live or die. That is reserved to God alone. The Church makes certian measures as far as extrodianary means to preserve life, but water is not considered extraordinary.
Mrs. Bro. Adam Posted March 18, 2005 Posted March 18, 2005 [quote name='Phazzan' date='Mar 18 2005, 11:13 AM'] Really? If a loved one was in the same situation, would you want them living out their days confined to a bed, with no way of communicating, functioning, expressing emotion and no concept of reality? I would hate for a loved one to live their life in perpetual fear, anger and frusturation. [/quote] They still have feeling. They can still communicate with our marvelous Savior. Just because they're confined to their bed doesn't mean that they're dead. It means that they've still got life, and if Christian, are bearing their cross.
Mrs. Bro. Adam Posted March 18, 2005 Posted March 18, 2005 [quote name='Phazzan' date='Mar 18 2005, 11:34 AM'] Is it murder to take someone off life support? [/quote] Yes
popestpiusx Posted March 18, 2005 Posted March 18, 2005 The distinction is between extraordinary means of preserving life and ordinary means. We are not bound to use extraordinary means in every case. We are bound to use ordinary means in every case. Food and water are ordinary means of life preservation. Keep in mind, Phazzan, that she is NOT in a persistent vegetative state. She is NOT in a coma. She is NOT brain-dead. She is able to acknowledge people. She can smile and laugh. She can follow objects around the room when asked to (like a balloon, as one doctor used). She IS being sedated as well and refused the opportunity for recovery/ rehabilitation. Every single human being alive requires food and water for survival. Keep that food and water from the person and without exception (barring miracles) they will die. The case will set a precedent that anyone not capable of feeding themselves may be starved to death for any reason or no reason at all. Think of everyone that entails. In my opinion this case is even more dangerous (if that is possible) than Roe v. Wade simply because, as sick as it may be, Roe v. Wade has a definite limit. This case will not.
Fidei Defensor Posted March 18, 2005 Posted March 18, 2005 The judge has reinstated his order, and the tube is coming out.
Fidei Defensor Posted March 18, 2005 Posted March 18, 2005 About 45 min ago. Check CNN.com for more info if you want.
Mrs. Bro. Adam Posted March 18, 2005 Posted March 18, 2005 A judge can't out rule the senate. Can he?
Phazzan Posted March 19, 2005 Posted March 19, 2005 [quote name='Mrs. Bro. Adam' date='Mar 18 2005, 12:21 PM'] They still have feeling. They can still communicate with our marvelous Savior. Just because they're confined to their bed doesn't mean that they're dead. It means that they've still got life, and if Christian, are bearing their cross. [/quote] And what if they don't believe in Jesus? Or say they convert with their thoughts, how nice. But what then? Imagine, living in a dark place, unable to move, express emotion, or communicate in any shape or form. And can you imagine the mental complications that would arise from it? Dementia, psychosis, amnesia, paranoid delusions, inevitably insanity and complete loss of cognitive function. So then you have a person who is completely unaware of his own existence, the world and everything in it, but you keep him alive anyway for what? Because only God can give and take life? Well I disagree. Humans give and take life everyday. God gave us a conscience to decide when it's right and when it's wrong. Unfortuantly I think many Catholics are so relentless in pursuing their moral objectives they lose sight of common sense and what's humane. As for Terri, I don't think she should be allowed to die because she shows some sings of functioning, and therapy might help her. In this case, life should be given the benefit of the doubt.
Lounge Daddy Posted March 19, 2005 Posted March 19, 2005 [quote name='Lil Red' date='Mar 18 2005, 12:33 AM'] all i have to say is that tomorrow is a day of fasting and abstinence...any one else going to do it and offer all of it up for terri? [/quote] yes
Mrs. Bro. Adam Posted March 19, 2005 Posted March 19, 2005 [quote name='Phazzan' date='Mar 19 2005, 05:37 AM'] And what if they don't believe in Jesus? Or say they convert with their thoughts, how nice. But what then? Imagine, living in a dark place, unable to move, express emotion, or communicate in any shape or form. And can you imagine the mental complications that would arise from it? Dementia, psychosis, amnesia, paranoid delusions, inevitably insanity and complete loss of cognitive function. So then you have a person who is completely unaware of his own existence, the world and everything in it, but you keep him alive anyway for what? Because only God can give and take life? Well I disagree. Humans give and take life everyday. God gave us a conscience to decide when it's right and when it's wrong. Unfortuantly I think many Catholics are so relentless in pursuing their moral objectives they lose sight of common sense and what's humane. As for Terri, I don't think she should be allowed to die because she shows some sings of functioning, and therapy might help her. In this case, life should be given the benefit of the doubt. [/quote] Are you God? Do you know what plan He has for every living human here on Earth? By taking a life you're playing God. You're saying, "You don't deserve life even though you're alive." Are you a pyschologist? A pyschiatrist? Any type of doctor at all? Who are you to say who should live and who should die? How would you like it if another human decided that you're not worthy of living? I'm sorry, but your theory falls directly in line with Hitler's ultimate goal. How sad.
Mrs. Bro. Adam Posted March 19, 2005 Posted March 19, 2005 What's more humane? Letting a person live, or making their last week or two fill with excruciating pain?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now