Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

How is it possible she never sinned if the acts that we sometimes do out of ignorance are sins? Since Jewish people back then didn't know the full truth of God, wouldn't they do a lot of those? I'm confuzled, someone help please?

Posted

[quote name='Eremite' date='Mar 21 2005, 07:11 PM'] What kinds of acts? [/quote]
Well there are a lot of things. Like if we do anything out of ignorance that's a sin, isn't it still a sin?

Posted

One must remember that a sin can be descirbed as a choosing of something other than God, a deliberate turning our back to Him. Another definition is found inthe CCC 1849 "caused by a perverse attachment to certain goods." I do not think that Mary would of had any perverse attachment to any good. She was full of grace...

Ignorance diminishes culpability, to what extent we cannot know.

thessalonian
Posted

The question you must ask is, "if God made adam and eve in the Garden and they were sinless, then could he make another human that was sinless"? Obviously the answer is yes. Then another significant question is "did adam and eve have to sin?". I would hope your anwer would be no. It boggles the mind that one's conscience could be fully formed but Adam and Eve's were in the garden. That is why their sin was fully culpable. They had free will also. The free will that we have when Christ frees us from the bondage of sin by his grace. Mary had such free will. We will never understand this until we are completely free of concupecusence (sp?), the tendancy toward sin. These are the only two questions that matter in this discussion. Mary had a fully formed conscience and the grace to act according to it at all times. There was no sin, even out of ignroance because her nature was not corrupt as ours is. We are so far from what she was we cannot even believe it is possible, just as we cannot believe that a man can be celibate as a priest all the days of his life. But it is true, by the grace of God only of course.

God bless

Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' date='Mar 21 2005, 09:52 PM'] The question you must ask is, "if God made adam and eve in the Garden and they were sinless, then could he make another human that was sinless"?  Obviously the answer is yes.  Then another significant question is "did adam and eve have to sin?".    I would hope your anwer would be no.  It boggles the mind that one's conscience could be fully formed but Adam and Eve's were in the garden.  That is why their sin was fully culpable.  They had free will also.  The free will that we have when Christ frees us from the bondage of sin by his grace.  Mary had such free will.  We will never understand this until we are completely free of concupecusence (sp?), the tendancy toward sin.  These are the only two questions that matter in this discussion.  Mary had a fully formed conscience and the grace to act according to it at all times.  There was no sin, even out of ignroance because her nature was not corrupt as ours is.  We are so far from what she was we cannot even believe it is possible, just as we cannot believe that a man can be celibate as a priest all the days of his life.  But it is true, by the grace of God only of course.

God bless [/quote]
I don't get how we doing something out of ignorance is bad but she doing it isn't. I love Mary and I understand she's the Mother of God but I don't understand how she wouldn't hurt him by being ignorant and sinning unless I missenterpretted something along the way. I mean let's say she stole skittles from her friend and I did the same. We were both small and didnt know. Wouldn't it be a sin anywayz? Tell me where I'm wrong in this because I'm a bit ignorant in what the CHurch means by sinning even out of ignorance? THnx for the replies btw.

Posted

Being ignorant doesn't always mean you are sinning. There is vincible and invincible ignorance.
Vincible ignorance is ignorance that you can overcome. When your conscience is in doubt, you are vincibly ignorant, because you can conquer that ignorance by research or help. You are required to clear up this vincible ignorance in order to form a good conscience. If you do not, you purposefully lead yourself into sin, since you might act on this doubtful conscience (since you are doubtful as to whether the action is right or wrong, it's sinful to act upon since there is the possiblity that the action is wrong).

BUT there is invincible ignorance. If Mary was ignorant at all, she was invincibly ignorant. (I don't know this--I haven't studied Marian doctrine) This is ignorance that cannot be overcome. It is ignorance that you cannot do anything about.
Invincible ignorance is present when a conscience is certain, but erroneous.
That is, you might be completely sure that something is right, but it in fact is morally wrong. You are invincibly ignorant of this fact, because you have no way of knowing it's wrong. In fact, you don't even know you're ignorant!

In this case, if you follow your certain conscience, even if it is in error, you are not sinning. (Primacy of Conscience) The conscience must also be compelling rather than permissive. That is, you are compelled that an action is either right or wrong (not just okay under certain circumstances).

If something was wrong, but Mary's concience was [i]certain[/i] that it was right, she should follow her conscience. In following her certain, compelling conscience she would not be in sin.

Sin requires knowledge (or certainty) that the act is wrong, and full constent to do the act anyway.
If you are certain that stealing someone's skittles is right (not just permissible, but RIGHT as opposed to WRONG), and you have no way of thinking otherwise, then you should snatch up those skittles. You're concience is compelling and certain, so you should follow it, despite the fact that it is in error.


Sorry, this probably has nothing to do with Mary, but with all the terms like "ignorance" and "sin" and "conscience" being used, I couldn't help but talk about the primacy of conscience. Sorry if it has no relevance whatsoever.

Posted

actualy: regardless of whether you are CULPABLE for a sin, it is still a sin (just you're not to blame)

but it's dogmatic that she never committed any sin I'm pretty sure. no sin at all. meaning that she didn't even commit one that she wasn't culpable for.

I mean, if I kill someone because I have a mental illness, technically I have SINNED but I didn't have full consent of the will/full knowledge that what I was doing is wrong so I am not culpable for it, it won't be counted against me. the sin was still committed, and I was the person committing it.

so no, Mary could never have even done a sin for which she wasn't culpable. if you think about it, she did not have the FALLEN NATURE that inclines you towards sin. so even if she didn't KNOW not to do something BECAUSE it was bad, she wouldn't have done it because she wouldn't have had the fallen nature that would make her want to do it (not to say she wasn't tempted with anything, but instrinsically within her person there was nothing that arose the desire to do anything sinful)

for a CRAZY example, say that the meat on fridays in lent thing was an always and everywhere sin no matter what, all the way back to the creation of the universe.

well, on Fridays Mary probably would have just had such a strong craving for fish and such a distaste towards meat that she wouldn't have sinned. the image of God she was created in is fully in tact, not fallen in any way, so she is not prone to sin.

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

[quote]but it's dogmatic that she never committed any sin I'm pretty sure. no sin at all. meaning that she didn't even commit one that she wasn't culpable for. [/quote]

It's a fact and it is exactly this point that I was making. She did not even steal a piece of sugar cane when she was little. Children get angry with eachother and take what is not theirs and disobey their parents out of concupesencse (i.e. due to their fallen natures). My you daughter took a doll from a store recently. She did not sin because she could not know the impact of what she did and has no real understanding of sin. (she's only 4). Yet she did do it because of the corrupt nature within her, caused by the passing of original sin. The stain of original sin was washed away at baptism but the tendency toward sin was not. Mary did not have original sin or the corrupt nature that goes with it. Therefore by God's grace she committed NO SIN. Not even in ignornace.

493 The Fathers of the Eastern tradition call the Mother of God "the All-Holy" (Panagia), and celebrate her as "free from any stain of sin, as though fashioned by the Holy Spirit and formed as a new creature".138 By the grace of God Mary remained free of every personal sin her whole life long.

508 From among the descendants of Eve, God chose the Virgin Mary to be the mother of his Son. "Full of grace", Mary is "the most excellent fruit of redemption" (SC 103): from the first instant of her conception, she was totally preserved from the stain of original sin and she remained pure from all personal sin throughout her life.

It must be remembered as well that if she sinned when she was little those sins would have formed habits that she would have had to overcome as an adult. i.e. she would have sinned. Sins are not discreet events that do not have permanent affects whether we are culpable or not.


Blessings

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

ok lets try this from the top shall we?

Fall of Man- Adam and Eve sinned through the sin of pride by disobeying God's commandment. This let sin enter the world, let death in, broke the harmonies between man and God, man and nature, and man and man, and most of all resulted in man's fall from the Grace of God (CCC #399 et al.). It was not a fall in nature. It resulted in the stain of original sin, it formed the human condition that we are now in. The is what Thessalonian was talking about, concupisince. The tendency towards sin. By the original sin it created a condition, a stain on our nature (not a change in it), that humans tend towards sin through temptation.

Application to Mary- As mentioned earlier, if God can create one creature without the stain of original sin, why not two? Thus He created Mary w/o the stain of original sin because it was necessary that she become the Ark of the New Covenenant and thus be sinless. The difference is that Mary held on to that grace where Adam and Eve fell. She preserved this grace through her humility, lowliness, and service to God. That is why she was chosen. Because she was full of the grace needed to remain free from sin. As Thessalonian said, she had the full free will and conscience of a human, and that is just it. She had such a conscience and will to serve God that she abstained from sinning. It helps when you are created without original sin I imagine. The big deal is where Adam and Eve fell, Mary did not. Where Adam and Eve answered "No" to God, Mary said "Your will be done." She did not have the stain of original sin that leads to concupsince, and she held on to that grace throughout her life.

My statement about ignorance diminishing culpability was not meant to be applied to Mary, for indeed ignorance diminishes our blame, but it does not change the fact that we sinned. It was more or less aimed at the satement that the early Jews sinned out of ignorance of the true God, such as God being Trinity. That is revelation and they cannot be fully accountable for something that was not revealed to them.

I hope this helps and doesnt actually make it more confusing.

Posted (edited)

Sorry, I know I just posted, but something regarding the fall being from grace and not in nature.

If original sin resulted in a change of nature, then Mary was not created the human natrue that we have. If Mary was not created with the nature that we have, nor was Christ. If Christ did not assume our nature then He could not of saved us. Thus the change must of been a fall from grace that caused a [b]stain[/b] on our nature.

Edited by Paphnutius
Posted

thnx a lot guys, that really helped.

Posted

the kid actually did "sin", it's just that the kid was not CULPABLE for that. She stole, and theft is objectively a sin. she sinned. she is not culpable for that sin so it is as if she didn't sin. I just wanted to clarify that to make the point that she couldn't have even committed a sin out of ignorance, it would have been sin she just wouldn't have been culpable

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Mar 22 2005, 10:55 PM'] the kid actually did "sin", it's just that the kid was not CULPABLE for that. She stole, and theft is objectively a sin. she sinned. she is not culpable for that sin so it is as if she didn't sin. I just wanted to clarify that to make the point that she couldn't have even committed a sin out of ignorance, it would have been sin she just wouldn't have been culpable [/quote]
Distinction noted and agreed upon.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...