phatcatholic Posted April 2, 2005 Posted April 2, 2005 [quote name='thedude' date='Apr 1 2005, 09:43 AM'] Has anyone tried the Handbook of Christian Apologetics? The author, Peter Kreeft (he wrote the Catholic Education article above), has posted many of his wiritings on the existence of God at his website: [url="http://peterkreeft.com/featured-writing.htm"]http://peterkreeft.com/featured-writing.htm[/url] [/quote] yes, that is an excellent book
Antonius Posted April 2, 2005 Posted April 2, 2005 [quote name='Pieta' date='Mar 30 2005, 05:48 PM'] Perhaps the action of the Holy Spirit softens their hearts and allows them the state of mind necessary to take in the complexity of God. [/quote] I would say it is rather that we, theists and atheists alike, do not understand the[i]simplicity[/i] of God. He is infinitely simple according to Aquinas. It is a very simple concept to think about, if not to actually do. God exists, He loves us (more than we can understand), and we conform our lives to His Will. The words are simple... Jesus didn't give us the Summa Philosophica at the Last Supper. He didn't write a huge book and in it there is the Theory of Everything. Nonetheless, Truth is Truth. One will not see God until he looks farther than himself and even the human race. But that's my humble opinion. Did you give the guy Pascal's Wager?
Pistos Posted April 4, 2005 Posted April 4, 2005 I read that Pascal's Wager is a bit off because it does not take into account a parallel comparison of the costs involved, only the outcomes. If the four outcomes all have equal cost, then Pascal's Wager is quite convincing. But when the cost of being Christian equals self-denial, being ostracized, misunderstood, rejected by family, friends and society at large, and maybe even physical trials and martyrdom, it colours the argument somewhat. It would be like asking: "Would you pay a dollar now, to get this thousand bucks you see in my hand; or would you rather pay me ten thousand dollars today, and receive a billion dollars next week, which I have to *cough* mail to you *cough*?" [url="http://www.google.com/search?q=pascal's+wager"]Googling for Pascal's Wager[/url] gives a handful of rejections and rebuttles.
cmotherofpirl Posted April 4, 2005 Posted April 4, 2005 Get a copy of [i]Handbook of Chistian Apologetics.[/i]
argent_paladin Posted April 10, 2005 Posted April 10, 2005 (edited) I have found that atheists respond well to CS Lewis, who was an atheist. I would recommend "Mere Christianity" or "Surprised by Joy" which tells of how he converted from atheism to Christianity. Edited April 10, 2005 by argent_paladin
Pio Nono Posted April 10, 2005 Posted April 10, 2005 JMJ 4/9 - Third Sunday of Easter (Eighth Day of the Novendiales) The best philosophical argument that I've ever seen argues against the atheist's assertion, "I know that a god or gods do/does not exist." In order to [i]know [/i]the falsity of a conclusion, one must [i]know [/i]the falsity of one of the premises. If we can both agree that "a being independent of the universe that caused the world to come to be" is a working definition of "God", then... (1) The universe came to be. (2) All things that come to be have a cause independent of themselves. (3) Therefore, the universe has a cause independent of itself. Premise (1) might be attacked by atheists, but remember, to [i]know [/i]that (3) is false, they have to [i]know [/i]that (1) is false. No cosmologist today would assert that he KNOWS that the universe did not come to be. It's at least as probable as it is not. Premise (2) is self-evident in my mind, but I'm willing to call it as probable as it is not as well.
Pio Nono Posted April 10, 2005 Posted April 10, 2005 JMJ 4/10 - Third Sunday of Easter (Eighth Day of the Novendiales) BTW, my argument doesn't prove the existence of God - all it does it show that we can't [i]know[/i] (in the way that atheist wants knowledge) that God does not exist.
phatcatholic Posted April 11, 2005 Posted April 11, 2005 its interesting how we can't know that he doesn't exist, but we can know that he does exist. how does that work exactly? (maybe i need to re-read this thread....)
Pio Nono Posted April 11, 2005 Posted April 11, 2005 JMJ 4/10 - Third Sunday of Easter (Eighth Day of the Novendiales) Well, as I see it anyway (take that for what it's worth), there are three ways we can know something - let's call it "X". (1) We can know everything about X. (2) We can know something about X, but not everything. (3) We can know nothing about X. The atheist, so it seems, would like to assert proposition (1). If X is God, then the atheist claims we can know everything about God - since there's only one thing to know, namely, that He does not exist. The theist, especially the Christian theist, would like to assert proposition (2). We can know some things about God (i.e. omniscience, omnipotence, &c.), but we can't know everything about Him. The agnostic, so it seems, would like to assert proposition (3). However, I stand to say that proposition (3) is self-refuting. If the agnostic says, "We can know nothing about God," I would respond, "Can we really know nothing? It seems that we know one thing, namely, that God has the property of being-unknowable-to-us." I'll shut up with the philosophy now.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now