Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

...or so I've been told. Both of these popes were prolific writers, as was JPII.

Who knows the "official" process of declaring a pope "the great", and why were Leo and Gregory given this title? Why were none of the other popes given it?

Posted

JMJ
4/4 - Annunciation of the Lord (Second Day of the Novendiales)

I only know of four "greats" in the Church...Gregory the Great, Leo the Great, Basil the Great and Albert the Great. These men represent four major areas where they were profound leaders - Gregory in pastoral matters, Leo in political matters, Basil in liturgical/theological matters, and Albert in matters dealing with the hard sciences.

If they are going to name John Paul "the Great", it will be hundreds of years before it is so done. Not only does it have to involve popular acclaim, but he'd have to be a saint, a doctor of the Church (which he may very well be), and have had such a profound influence on the history of the Church such that it cannot be reversed - so it would seem.

Keep in mind, too, that there have been very many holy and learned men who have been canonized, but have not been Great Doctors of the Church (Augustine, Thomas Aquinas and Pius V come immediately to mind).

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Pio Nono' date='Apr 4 2005, 05:31 PM'] Keep in mind, too, that there have been very many holy and learned men who have been canonized, but have not been Great Doctors of the Church (Augustine, Thomas Aquinas and Pius V come immediately to mind). [/quote]
I thought Aquinas was the Angelic Doctor...or is that not the same as being a Doctor of the Church?

Posted

I guess phatmass will try to do it's part in the "popular acclaim" category of the process. Haha

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' date='Apr 4 2005, 05:39 PM'] I thought Aquinas was the Angelic Doctor...or is that not the same as being a Doctor of the Church? [/quote]
he's not a "Great" doctor, that's what he was saying

RemnantRules
Posted

my patron saint is Gregory the Great ^_^

Posted

JMJ
4/4 - Annunciation of the Lord (Second Day of the Novendiales)

Yeah, Aquinas is the Angelic Doctor, but he's not a Great Doctor (which makes one wonder why Albert the Great, his tutor, is Great but Thomas is not). There was a period during medieval times when all the great schoolmen got special titles (i.e. Bonaventure, Peter Abelard, Duns Scotus...even William of Ockham, much now to our chagrin). Only Albert came out on the same level as Basil, Gregory and Leo, though.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Forget the great title I want him beatified!

cmotherofpirl
Posted

and the polish bishops are calling him great and asking for intercessory prayers :D

geetarplayer
Posted

Also, it is important to note that Leo the Great personally stopped Attila the Hun's invasion on Rome, and Gregory the Great himself pushed back the Lombards.

So what did John Paul II do that was so great?

Um...

ONLY SINGLE-HANDEDLY CRUSHED THE SOVIET UNION! :club:

-Mark

Posted

I thought Nichola I the Great was a "the great"

Is this not official?

God Conquers
Posted

I thought St. Peter was "great" as well.... hmm

Q the Ninja
Posted

The great means they helped changed the world, which I don't know if Thomas did as much. Take this, not by Theological standards, but it's something along those lines.

Posted

An interesting article:

[font="Times"][b]John Paul the Great by popular acclaim[/b]
By Brian Murphy in Rome (AP)
April 6, 2005

It is being proclaimed by powerful clergymen, printed in newspapers and even tucked into a Vatican-drafted homily: Pope John Paul the Great.

A worldwide movement is building to honour the late pontiff with a title that has been given only twice - and to predecessors who led the church more than 14 centuries ago.

Whether John Paul II becomes the third depends on the followers and church leaders rather than any formal process, experts in Vatican law and tradition say.

"It's vox populi on a grand scale," said Father Robert Taft, a professor of church history at the Pontifical Oriental Institute in Rome. "If people keep calling him the Great then he will become the Great."

A canon law authority, James Conn, noted there is no "code or procedure" to add the title. "It's more of a popular acclamation," said Father Conn, who teaches at Rome's Pontifical Gregorian University. "It gains strength and credibility each time it's proclaimed."

Which is becoming often.

Italian newspapers were filled with the honorific. "The long farewell to John Paul the Great," read the headline in Corriere della Sera on Monday. The official Vatican newspaper, L'Osservatore Romano, called him "John Paul II, the Great", and Catholic-oriented websites were full of references to "the Great" pope.

"So how would he be remembered? He will be Pope John Paul the Great," said Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O'Connor of Britain.

The text for a Mass on Sunday in St Peter's Square called the late Pope "John Paul the Great", a title usually designated for popes considered worthy of sainthood. But the reference was dropped by Cardinal Angelo Sodano when he delivered the homily.

No explanation was offered by the Vatican. But Holy See texts are considered official even if not read aloud.

"He was the most significant leader of our times. I'd say he was the man of the century, and at some time in the future may he get another title, 'Pope John Paul the Great'," said Bishop Edward Kmiec of Buffalo, New York.

It would be the first time in many centuries.

The 5th century pope Leo I, or Leo the Great, was known for his stirring writings and his unwavering defence of the fundamental theological concept of Christ having two distinct natures, divine and human. He also persuaded Attila the Hun to spare Rome and managed to save many Romans from torture and other abuses during a later rampage by vandals.

The other pope to carry the title, Gregory I, brought a monastic simplicity to the church during his 14-year papacy ending in 604 and used its vast holdings to help starving citizens of Rome during battles with rival states.[/font]

StPiusVPrayForUs
Posted

First of all, I'm disgusted by this title. He's not a canonized saint but people are already walking around like self proclaimed Popes and giving him titles left and right. Pray for the Pope's soul and let God's just judgment reign.

God Conquers
Posted

The Archbishop of Ottawa has also called him Pope John Paul the Great.

So... if it's vox populi:

JOHN PAUL THE GREAT!

argent_paladin
Posted

StPiusVPrayForUs:

Dude, chill! That is how it happens. These titles are only given by popular acclaimation. It is similar with canonization. There are likely millions of saints who will never be canonized because no one went to the great effort to work towards it. But you have to pray to a person BEFORE he/she gets canonized. As I said in a previous post, one should not refer to John Paul as "the Great" in any official liturgy.


That being said, I think that "the Great" is partially honorific and partially an identifier. First, notice that all the greats have non-apostolic names. It wouldn't make sense to call John XXIII "the Great" and not John the Evangelist. So, you cannot have an apostolic name. So, your name has to be a bit unusual, but not so unusual that you are unique. When people say Augustine, you know exactly who he is talking about. That is the value of "the Great". There were many Leos, Basils, Alberts, etc in Church history, so historians used these labels to differentiate them. I am not sure that will every be necessary for JP2 because it is unlikely that any historian would confuse him with JP1. It suffices for identity purposes to simply refer to him as John Paul, because people know who you mean.

However, perhaps in a hundred years or so, there will be confusion, since there were two in a row. Anyway, there were likely dozens of saintly popes who, at the end of their reign, were considered great. Only history will know how the legacy of the Pope fares. And, the Greats tend to be so named more for what the did within the Church than without.

Posted

JMJ
4/5 - St. Vincent Ferrer

I can't believe that I missed this one...

One of the Apostles is buried in Santiago de Compostela in Spain. He's not the bishop of Jerusalem, brother of the Lord and the great Liturgist - he's known as St. James the Less.

The guy in Spain is the son of Zebedee, and he's known as St. James the Great. So I guess there's five. :P

Posted

[quote name='jgirl' date='Apr 4 2005, 10:41 PM']I thought Nichola I the Great was a "the great"

Is this not official?[/quote]
Indeed there were three "great" popes: Gregory I, Leo I, and Nicholas I--just check out the list of Popes at newadvent:

[url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12272b.htm"]List of Popes[/url]

(Popes #45, 64, and 106)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...