Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

O'Reilly Factor


Recommended Posts

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

Amen! way to go!

[quote]Bill,

Stop cheapening John Paul II's papacy with your bloviating!

The pope gave an apostolic letter January 21, stating "Participation in Sunday Mass in not only an important obligation," he said, "but above all a profound need of every faithful person."

I don't understand what it is you expected the pope to do -- it's like someone criticizing the pope because of Catholics that take the pill. The pope can't force Catholics to attend mass any more than God can. Are we going to criticize Jesus for letting Judas betray him, too?

If you want to blame anything, there are a LOT of things we can blame, such as modern materialism and the greatest sin that the pope warned us about: the loss of the sense of sin. [/quote]

Posted

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' date='Apr 5 2005, 07:50 PM'] Bill,

Stop cheapening John Paul II's papacy with your bloviating!

The pope gave an apostolic letter January 21, stating "Participation in Sunday Mass in not only an important obligation," he said, "but above all a profound need of every faithful person."

I don't understand what it is you expected the pope to do -- it's like someone criticizing the pope because of Catholics that take the pill. The pope can't force Catholics to attend mass any more than God can. Are we going to criticize Jesus for letting Judas betray him, too?

If you want to blame anything, there are a LOT of things we can blame, such as modern materialism and the greatest sin that the pope warned us about: the loss of the sense of sin. [/quote]
:clap:

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I want to know if HE attends mass every Sunday and holy days of obligation.

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

i doubt he does.

Posted

ugh :angry: The media didn't take too long in turning to disrespect and talking points. I knew all the honoring and documentaries wouldn't last long. I don't ahve cable to watch the O'Reilly Factor, but I heard about his previous comments. All over the media, except for a few rare exceptions, the "reporters" and talking heads are putting their spin on the coverage, and on people's feelings regarding JPII's death. They seem to find every dissident they can think of to interview, I feel like shouting at the TV, "ask me about the Church's teaching, ask some FAITHFUL Catholics for a change." :angry:

conservativecatholic
Posted

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' date='Apr 5 2005, 07:14 PM'] I want to know if HE attends mass every Sunday and holy days of obligation. [/quote]
He's really Catholic and a big family man. I'm sure he attends Mass every Sunday. I don't know if many of yall were watching tonight's show but he slammed the media for catholic hatred. Way to go Bill!

crusader1234
Posted

Why do people even listen to Bill O'Reilly. He's a half wit with a big mouth and the ability to cut the mic of anybody that tries to make a point. At least Ann Coulter and Al Franken wait their turns before they shoot off their mouths.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I like the word "bloviating" :rolling:

Posted

I watched the O'Reilly factor last night and tonight and here are my thoughts

O'Reilly is perfectly within his realm as a Catholic to question Vatican Foreign Policy. When it came to the low church attendence et cetera, I think he was just genuinely concerned. Like he said, he doesn't want us to turn into Denmark. I really didn't object too much to the honest concerns he brought up and think that for the most part he was within Catholic Teaching. It was one of the more respectful discussions of the "future of the Church" by the media I saw yet while still being honest and not being mindless. He never really proposed opposing doctrine or anything bad like that and he at one point mentioned how he's not an expert in these things, that's why he was seeking advice. Choice of guests.. blah annoying. I mean, He gets a Catholic to support the anti-war thing who also had somewhat of the ora of a liberal on other issues, and a protestant to support the war. You could have had two Catholics and really had a frank and honest discussion about how to confront terrorism and the Catholic Just War ideals.

Tonight, when you got past the rhetoric and yelling it boiled down to three points about the New York Times that were important
1. In the actual news story they called him a "polarizing" figure, when facts indicate him to be more of a uniter and it is absurd to blame him for polarization in the Church caused by dissenters from Catholic Teaching claiming catholicity
2. The opinion piece cited the Catholic ex-priest as if he was an expert on things Catholic, when in reality the guy is an extremely far left guy who has called the Church "evil"
3. The opinion piece was in a section of the newspaper that is often mistaken for actual news stories, not just opinion pieces, and in the smaller newspapers that get stories from the NYT they are often printed as news stories, even if the "critic" section is supposed to be opinion.

Those were my thoughts.. I didn't think O'Reilley stepped over the line. He got closer to the line than he had before, but I think that was something that he had to do to deal with the issues he is concerned about. He honestly wants direction from the Church and from the pope, he feels that the direction the Pope gave him was not practical and did not give a good alternative to fighting that would still protect our citizens and stop the terrorists. These are legitimate concerns and the application of war or the death penalty can be debated by Catholics according to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. Debate away, deal with your concerns... at least you're looking to the Church for guidance. Bravo on your honesty, Mr. O'Reilley, regardless of whether you are right. Now, I am annoyed with his sex abuse crisis remarks and church attendence remarks, but I still don't think he necessarily crossed the line.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...