Dave Posted April 5, 2005 Posted April 5, 2005 (edited) There's a site called "Catholic Tradition" (whose link I won't give because it's not exactly faithful to the Magisterium) that has lots of traditional Catholic prayers and stuff, but it's clear that the webmistress leans in a radical traditionalist direction. I'd been thinking about e-mailing her and responding to her "rad-trad" beliefs, but when I saw the following excerpt in her online tribute to the Holy Father, I was so mad that I felt I couldn't let it slide without speaking up: [b]As "great" as he appeared to modern man, I prayed above all for him that God would be merciful. Yes, I said merciful: John Paul II was the source of monstrous scandal that affected the faith of countless Catholics who were thrown in to the throes of utter confusion and incomprehension; many felt abandoned and betrayed. While he reached out to those of other faiths and no faith at all, he left his own flock to shepherd themselves, a crime that will not be accurately weighed and accounted for until the Last or General Judgment. When he kissed the Koran, an act so scandalous as an affront against the charity we owe God and His Truth above and in truth a false charity, which we may be inclined as weak individuals to extend to our neighbor, that words failed and only the tears of desolation could speak. And while he committed this blasphemy and in public, faithful Catholics in the English-speaking world were being denied their very birthright of the Traditional Roman Mass and the Traditional Sacraments by almost every bishop in violation of 2,000 years of Tradition and the expressed wishes of the Pontiff. While he called for a prayer meeting of all the world's religions to be held at Assisi, in violation of the teachings of MORTALIUM ANIMOS: On Religious Unity by Pope Pius XI, faithful Catholics were being thrown out of their own parishes, sometimes with the aid of the local police, and the Pope turned away, refusing to exert his rightful power to intercede and command his bishops as only the Roman Pontiff can. God answered "Assisi" with a thunderous earthquake that severely damaged St. Francis's church and its surrounds of beautiful frescoes. When Assisi II happened, despite the warning from Heaven, God answered with a thunderous silence on the one hand------punishing us by leaving us to our sins, and on the other, the widespread imbalance in weather and storms began its devastating march over man and continues today. It is as if nature itself is horrified at the scandal and is convulsing in reaction. And so many more scandals of the same genre, such as misleading the faithful on evolution, breaking with Tradition on altar girls, a seemingly small thing but in reality the signal that Tradition was no longer sacred as commonly understood by the mass of the faithful, no pun intended. And that signal had repercussions for the faithful who fought and still fight the "good fight": They were witnesses that obedience was to be disparaged and disobedience to be rewarded, at the very least a discouragement, and at worst a betrayal. I say betrayal, because John Paul II personally promised Mother Angelica of EWTN that he would never approve of altar girls, a promise well within his power as Pontiff and within Tradition. No Pope worthy of the name would have dared such a thing, yet he deigned to do this anyway and belie his own promise. The faithful warned him that such an approval would be disastrous and no one of us takes any comfort that we were all too prescient. Oh, that we had been wrong and had to "eat crow", a sweet blessing for us if only it could have been so.[/b] I already have materials to help me out, but I could use some input from those here. Thanks. Edited April 5, 2005 by Dave
IamCatholic Posted April 5, 2005 Posted April 5, 2005 What exactly do you need help with? What kinds of things are you expecting to say? I think I might have seen a site like that before. It has a lot of holy pictures, right? I am talking about www.catholictradition.com (or .org or something like that); is that the one you mean? Everything I saw on there was good when I saw it, but I guess they might have become schismatics now or something. Anyway, what kinds of things are you looking for to help?
IamCatholic Posted April 5, 2005 Posted April 5, 2005 I just checked. the one I have seen is www.catholictradition.org. If that is the one you are talking about, let me know, and I can help look for things on there or maybe help some way.
Socrates Posted April 6, 2005 Posted April 6, 2005 Unfortunately most of these "Rad-Trads" are quite beyond reach of rationality, and it is dubious they will listen to any arguments which disagree with their own conclusions. I think the best thing to do is simply pray for their souls, that they may return to the True Flock.
phatcatholic Posted April 6, 2005 Posted April 6, 2005 "IamCatholic".................welcome to phatmass and the Apo Board! its good to have ya
Dave Posted April 6, 2005 Author Posted April 6, 2005 Yes, IamCatholic, that's the one. Thanks a million. Please send me a private message so I can cite the areas that concern me. Socrates-- I know that the webmistress attends indult Masses rather than SSPX Masses ... however, her attitude is indistinguishable from members of various schismatic groups.
Catholic_Pinoy Posted April 8, 2005 Posted April 8, 2005 [quote name='Dave' date='Apr 5 2005, 09:41 PM'] No one wants to venture a possible response? [/quote] I'm sure the folks at [url="http://forums.catholic.com"]http://forums.catholic.com[/url] will be able to give you some great responses.
Dave Posted April 8, 2005 Author Posted April 8, 2005 I already posted there. And several people have commented that there's really no point in responding to such accusations against the Holy Father because such people won't be open to what I have to say anyway.
phatcatholic Posted April 8, 2005 Posted April 8, 2005 i just can't get into catholic vs. catholic debate
Timothy Posted April 8, 2005 Posted April 8, 2005 I have been thinking a lot about what has been written here Dave. The Scripture verses that come to my mind when I read what the person has wrote above are: 2 Timothy 2:23-26 23 Avoid foolish and ignorant debates, for you know that they breed quarrels. A slave of the Lord should not quarrel, but should be gentle with everyone, able to teach, tolerant, correcting opponents with kindness. It may be that God will grant them repentance that leads to knowledge of the truth, 6 and that they may return to their senses out of the devil's snare, where they are entrapped by him, for his will. Matthew 18: 15-17 "If your brother 12 sins (against you), go and tell him his fault between you and him alone. If he listens to you, you have won over your brother. If he does not listen, take one or two others along with you, so that 'every fact may be established on the testimony of two or three witnesses.' If he refuses to listen to them, tell the church. If he refuses to listen even to the church, then treat him as you would a Gentile or a tax collector. I hope this helps you. May God be with us all.
dspen2005 Posted April 10, 2005 Posted April 10, 2005 simply reply that he is the successor of St Peter. he has not changed any doctrine/dogma of the Faith. Those who would defile his reputation and character simply incur the anger of God, by whom JP2 was appointed.
phatcatholic Posted April 11, 2005 Posted April 11, 2005 good call any attack on his character or reputation is an ad hominem attack anyway
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now