Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Media and liberals act as if Church Doctrine...


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

...can be changed. They act like it is a decision of the Pope to change the Church's stance on abortion, premarital sex, contraception, female ordination,Homosexual marriage etc. It is not the decision of the Pope to change God's will. Why is that so hard to understand for some?

Here is an example.

[url="http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=1506&ncid=2357&e=1&u=/afp/20050407/ts_alt_afp/vaticanpopeuswomen_050407132327"]Women in Church[/url]

I agree it can be [i][b]very[/b][/i] difficult to live by these doctrines.

Edited by socalscout
Posted

and why do they act like America is the centerpiece of Catholicism instead of a part of it? <_<

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Lil Red' date='Apr 7 2005, 01:54 PM'] and why do they act like America is the centerpiece of Catholicism instead of a part of it? <_< [/quote]
Exactly and then the also poll American nonCatholics about the Church's Doctrine. Why?

Probably because they are finding more faithful than not and it is messing up there "Church is too conservative" angle.

Edited by socalscout
Guest Eremite
Posted

For the secular media, Catholicism is simply another religion. They expect it to change like any other religion might change. Catholicism is nothing unique for them, except in that it is loathed to change. But they attribute that to men obsessed with power, rather than God's protection.

What gets me mad is when CATHOLICS, especially priests, go on secular media shows and start talking like the heathen. They're supposed to be giving the media a clue, and they don't have one themselves.

Posted

[quote name='Eremite' date='Apr 7 2005, 01:57 PM'] What gets me mad is when CATHOLICS, especially priests, go on secular media shows and start talking like the heathen. They're supposed to be giving the media a clue, and they don't have one themselves. [/quote]
exactly! <_<

Posted

Good ole Call to Action :getaclue:

Posted

[quote name='Eremite' date='Apr 7 2005, 01:57 PM'] For the secular media, Catholicism is simply another religion. They expect it to change like any other religion might change. Catholicism is nothing unique for them, except in that it is loathed to change. But they attribute that to men obsessed with power, rather than God's protection.

What gets me mad is when CATHOLICS, especially priests, go on secular media shows and start talking like the heathen. They're supposed to be giving the media a clue, and they don't have one themselves. [/quote]
YES! They must be very selective when they choose their Catholic clergy "spokesperson". Their producers probably actually look for dissident priests instead of the ones that tell it like it is.

Posted

To be a "Cafeteria Catholic" is to disagree with the Holy Spirit.. is it not?

Posted

[quote name='Tony' date='Apr 7 2005, 02:01 PM'] To be a "Cafeteria Catholic" is to disagree with the Holy Spirit.. is it not? [/quote]
I would say at the very least.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

When the pope was ill, and when he died, I knew there were people that were CHOMPING AT THE BIT to start the attacks. They could NOT stand, and still can NOT stand the attention and coverage.

And so there you have it, they give in, and can't even WAIT until he's buried no less. Just couldn't help themselves.

Posted

The liberals have been hoping the next Pope will change dogma to be more "liberal" for some time now. Never happens, never will. When the next Pope takes office, they'll be once more disappointed.

What I find odd is the mentality of "liberal" Catholics that want the Pope to change the Church's teachings is that this implies that the teachings are just human rules that can be changed at will, or by democratic vote, rather than divine, unchanging teachings. If this is the case, why belong to the Catholic Church at all? Why not just leave and join a "church" or other organization that agrees with your own views? (There's plenty out there!)
When you stop to think about it, this doesn't make much sense.

God Conquers
Posted

The media is projecting what they want to happen onto the CAtholic CHurch.

The very fact that they are using polls and commenting on them is laughable.

The Church does not take polls.

Posted

amen! As Cardinal Ratzinger always says: "Truth is not determined by a majority vote!!"

we aren't a democracy people so stop acting like GOD cares about your opinion!! :irate:

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

I'm sick of the media acting as if the Church were just the City-State of the Vatican City. We've got nutters out there saying that the next pope should change all these things, as if he's a politician with the power to override the Holy Spirit, as if he's trying to play into the hands of the members of the Church. He's trying to help them get to Heaven, not to give them whatever they want, Heaven on earth. At the same time, these nutters who say that the pope should do these things, as if he were a politician, are also saying that he's not a politician, and shouldn't be recognized as a foreign head-of-state with lowered flags.

There was an atheist on today saying that the pope wasn't a head-of-state, but a mere spiritual leader. He also said that he was a sexist and a terrible cruel man, for opposing contraception in Africa, on top of any number of other things. It's outrageous.

I really, really hope that Cardinal Arinze gets elected and sticks to his guns on contraception in Africa...I'd love to see them try to take him on there.

Theologian in Training
Posted

[quote name='socalscout' date='Apr 7 2005, 05:00 PM'] YES! They must be very selective when they choose their Catholic clergy "spokesperson". Their producers probably actually look for dissident priests instead of the ones that tell it like it is. [/quote]
I diagree. My spiritual director has been on every day since he is contracted by (MS)NBC. The Academic Dean here has been on CNN (Espanol). Our history professor is going to be covering the funeral as will my spiritual director.

In fact, for some odd reason, there has been a high demand of priests from this seminary, that they had to postpone an important meeting they needed to have because they have all been on TV or have appointments to be on TV.

Also, a few of the seminarians here have been on Foxnews, MSNBC, and local news channels as well.

From what I have been told and what I hear they are enlightening these people in the news, my spiritual director was trying to convert Larry King with his vial of Padre Pio's blood. One of the seminarians, when he went on Foxnews, had some of the news casters in tears. These people are so uncatechized or irreligious that now that they are getting heavy doses of religion they don't know what to do.

Yes, you have this and that nut or this or that person who thinks the Church is strictly a human organization and views it as such, but some of these newspeople have no idea what is going on. They are so intrigued and probably learning about the Catholic Church for the first time, even those of them that are Catholic.

Granted, this is my take on the whole thing. Perhaps you are just turning on the TV when some progressive liberal wanted to use the news to push his / her agenda, but I can tell you for a fact there are some very Orthodox priests and seminarians getting put on the air as well.

Just my .02, take it for what it's worth

God Bless

toledo_jesus
Posted

not on hardball. that show was awful two nights ago. They had a 'sister' who was dissident, a columnist from TIME magazine who said very ignorant and hurtful things about the pope, and some other guy that I can't remember who didn't help the situation. I wrote an e-mail.

argent_paladin
Posted (edited)

The media believes:

1. The Church is a democracy.
2. Americans are the most important groups in the Church.
3. Making the Church more like the world is the goal of the Church.


All are false. It is amazing that these people have the audacity to criticize something they so obviously don't understand.

Edited by argent_paladin
toledo_jesus
Posted

let's just leave...let the Amatholics have their church.

God Conquers
Posted

I agree with Theo.... there are some VERY good and orthodox commentators... even on the very anti-catholic (normally) CBC Fr. Tom Rosica is the main commentator, and he is definately one of the most orthodox and incredibly outspoken (and WELLspoken) priests that I know.

There are several other priests here in Canada that I know are bery bery good and they are commentating.

And isn't George Weigel doing one of the major US stations?

I'm seriously considering this a miracle.

Posted

[quote name='Tony' date='Apr 7 2005, 03:00 PM'] Good ole Call to Action :getaclue: [/quote]
You're not going to believe this, but last weekend I was at the Midwest Young Adult leadership conference, went into one of the workshops, discovered that one of the speakers was one of the CTA (and I don't mean the Chicago Transit Authority) head honchos (honchas?), and it was there that we got word of the Pope's passing.

(One of my friends tape recorded the talk and sent it to the local auxillary bishop).

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...