Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Cardinal Law's Role in Rome Sparks Outrage in U.S.


Recommended Posts

Posted

[url="http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&u=/nm/20050408/us_nm/pope_usa_law_dc"]Cardinal Law[/url]

cmotherofpirl
Posted

They can get over it.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

To be honest, I cringed when I first heard about that. I don't think it's particularly a great thing.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

He was assigned a major basilica after he left the US.
So to remove him so he can't say a Mass for the Holy Father which is part of his current job as a further puinishment is wrong.

Brother Adam
Posted

They need to leave well enough alone.

Posted

Who's Cardinal Law, what's his role, and why would it outrage Americans?


Greg

Posted

how do people who were abused by homosexual priests, who were put into position by liberals become liberal?...

Posted

Who cares, honestly.

I guess that we can add Cardinal Law's sins to that of blasphemy of the Holy Spirit as the now two sins that are unforgivable.

While it is a horrible thing that he did, I can't help but pray for him. I also forgive him, precisely because it is WJWD. It is not my place to judge him on this, I can either forgive him or I can hold a grudge and stay bitter for my whole life.

Hmmmmmm......I choose the former. WWJD?

Cam

argent_paladin
Posted

I hardly see it as a promotion to be the Cardinal Archbishop of Boston, one of the oldest and, until recently, most revered diocese in the US, to the archpriest at a single church, abeit a major basilica in Rome. I see it as a form of exile. What would they have the Church do? Throw him on the street? And then do they object to him peforming mass in his own basilica? Perhaps some cringed when an impeached President who admitted to lying about marital infidelity went to pay respects to the Pope in the official US delegation. But, Clinton still is a former president, so it was protocol. If Clinton can be forgiven for lying to America and covering up his mistakes, why not Law? At least the media didn't celebrate his new job, the way they did Clinton's new library.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I don't take issue with it, myself. But I think that, if possible, it may have been better if Law was given a lower profile and they had another cardinal say the mass because the scandal was so recent. In my humble opinion.

But who knows. From what I've read, the man is truly sorry, so people ought to stop crucifying him.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

That would not be fair to him. THis is the Church assigned to him and he has the right to say Mass there. He is still a cardinal of the Church.

Ash Wednesday
Posted (edited)

Never mind then. I'm not going to drag this out. -_-

Edited by Ash Wednesday
argent_paladin
Posted

Yeah. Who is the "they" that would substitute someone else. Only the pope could do that, and the see is currently vacant. Only Cardinal Law himself could have recused himself. And that might not have been a bad idea.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I'm not really in the know of protocol -- I said "if possible." But if it isn't possible, then I guess that's life.

[quote]And that might not have been a bad idea.[/quote]

Agreed.

I think what bothers me most is having the Boston scandals dragged into the whole papal funerals and election. I blame that in particular on the press -- wanting to create one of their precious melodramatic "firestorms" more than anything else. If anyone is rubbing salt into an old wound, it's them. I just don't want to see this revisited during a time like this.

But I suppose I shouldn't be surprised. :rolleyes:

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I think its a terrible idea for him to remove himself to please a tiny vocal minority.
The man has been punished by the Pope, removed from his diocese and given a largely ceremonial position to end his days. You don't add fresh punishments over and over or bury him before he is dead.
They can get over it.

Q the Ninja
Posted

I like Cardinal Law. He is over at Santa Maria Maggiore, a wonderful church. (It's where Pope St. Pius V is buried). I like him there because there are occassionally English goings ons for me to attend. :)

I know some of my friends were a little surprised by his appointment there, but people really seem to like him here. I know I do.

I think the Pope liked him too, for he appointed the Cardinal to St. Mary Major's, and the Pope sure seemed to like Mary.

Posted

Anyone one help me out in this thread on the issue? (post responeses here my name is Moses the Black in there):

here is the link: [url="http://www.sphereofhiphop.com/forums/index.php?act=ST&f=9&t=14393"]LINK![/url]

Mateo el Feo
Posted

Slightly off topic:

I think it's interesting that the major news media reported on a "protest" when Cardinal Law during a mass he led. This protest consisted of two women handing out leaflets during the mass. They were escorted out of Vatican City.

In contrast, Catholic demonstrations (e.g. pro-life, etc) can have participants numbering in the hundreds of thousands, and we're lucky if it results in an 80 word write-up hidden in the back of a local newspaper.

Posted

Personally, I think he should've been deported to a desert island to do penance the rest of his years. Protecting sexually abusive priests is shameful.

Mateo el Feo
Posted (edited)

<Rant>

My own opinion is that the Catholic Church is not the temporal authority of the United States. If this man is a criminal and the government had proof or suspicion of his criminal acts, the government (i.e. State of Massachusetts) has failed to protect its citizens by allowing him to leave their jurisdiction without a criminal trial.

If Cardinal Law got off on a technicality, then the blame should be aimed at the legislature for not having robust laws to handle such cases.

Accused citizens should be tried for their crimes in a court of law. I don't think that the statute of limitations has applied to Cardinal Law, since his own actions are still fairly recent--we're not talking about some priest who died 40 years ago.

Sometimes I get the impression that non-Catholics expect the Church to "defrock" priests and cardinals, as if this is a substitute for the rule of law that our country claims to live under.

</Rant>

PS--I can't wait for someone to tell me I'm just a blind loyalist to the Catholic Church for holding these views. ;)

Edited by Mateo el Feo

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...