at0m1c Posted April 17, 2005 Posted April 17, 2005 [url="http://www.letusreason.org/RC1.htm"]Marys sinlessness[/url] Basically, this site uses the word [u]Kechari tomene[/u] against Her. I don't know Greek so I don't know what to say. Also, [quote](215 AD Tertullian) “God alone is without sin. The only man who is without sin is Christ; for Christ is also God” (The Soul 41:3). Clement of Alexandria “ The Word Jesus Christ alone was born without sin.” St. Irenaeus says, “Being obedient she became the cause of salvation for herself and for the whole human race.” For more on the early Church and quotes on the virgin and the woman of Rev.12 see the writings of Hippolytus, On Christ and Antichrist, 61, in ANF, V:217 . If we go through history we find many of the popes did not believe in Mary being sinless; Augustine Bishop of Hippo “Whatever flesh of sin Jesus took, He took of the flesh of the sin of his mother. Jesus did not partake of sin, but took of his mother, which came under the judgment of sin.” Augustine “ He, Christ alone, being made man but remaining God never had any sin, nor did he take of the flesh of sin. Though He took flesh of the sin of his mother.” Augustine of Hippo and Thomas Aquinas (rewrote the Christian religion as a platonic one while Thomas Aquinas rewrote it as a Aristotelian one.) The two greatest theologians of the church Both canonized as saints denied the immaculate conception that Mary was conceived without sin.[/quote] Then they list several Popes who taught that she was not sinless? How can this be? There are too many points of contention to list out, so take your time to look at it..
phatcatholic Posted April 17, 2005 Posted April 17, 2005 i'll take a crack at it...... [quote]In Luke 1:34 when the angel Gabriel first appeared to her and announced the savior would be conceived in her womb, she responded, “ how can this be since I do not know a man.” Mary asked the angel what manner of greeting is this. If she was sinless certainly she would have known and understood the things of God, but Mary could not understand why she had been selected for this honor. In Luke 2:49-50 When Mary and Joseph after a day's journey found out that Jesus was missing from their company they went back to find Him. After two more days they found Him teaching in the temple teaching. Mary then asks Jesus why he did not leave with them, they looked high and low for him? His response is, why did you look all over for me? Did you not know that I must be about my fathers business (work)?” Lk.2:50: “But they (both Mary and Joseph) did not understand the words he spoke to them.” Notice in both accounts Mary does not understand the things of God. Someone who is sinless would know God’s ways and not need a explanation. It is sin that corrupts ones understanding of spiritual things. What did they not understand? That Jesus would be about His Fathers business. In this account we see Mary equal with Joseph in not understanding.[/quote] yes, sin can negatively effect our ability to know/understand the ways of the Lord. but, sinlessness does not necessarily make one all-knowing or omniscient. if this were true then adam and eve would not have been tempted by the "knowledge" that the forbidden fruit provided. secondly, we are creatures. we have human brains. we exist w/in the confines of time. we simply can't know everything that God knows. so, even as sinless creatures, we will have questions and occasionally be unable to understand the ways of the Lord. finally, the second example of jesus in the temple is not even an instance of spiritual discernment. they didn't know where he was. he could have been anywhere. even if mary were to come to the conclusion on her own that jesus was about his father's business, that doesn't necessarily mean he would be in the temple. [quote]Nowhere does the Bible says Mary was sinless or the exception to sin. For such a miraculous event the Bible surely would have spoken to this issue. [/quote] this is an argument from silence. it could just as likely be that the writers just knew that their audience believed it already, so there was no point in addressing it [i]explicitly[/i] (note that her sinlessness is present [i]implicitly[/i] in the bible). also, we must note that the early church was still trying to understand the life of Christ and his teachings. so that would have been their main reason for writing. at any rate, its natural of mary to take a backseat to Christ [quote]But again it is not apostolic tradition. If Mary was conceived without sin then her parents would have certainly known and would have assumed she was to bare the Messiah.[/quote] not necessarily. this is conjecture on his part. [quote]The Catholics say she became sinless later in life. This would mean God took someone who has the nature of sin and completely change them to be sinless like Jesus Christ--without a virgin birth. Certainly such a miracle would be mentioned in the Scripture, but it is not![/quote] when he mentions her becoming sinless "later in life" i'm assuming he is referring to the debate that existed in the early church over rather she was made sinless at the moment of conception or shortly thereafter, while still in the womb. however, as our understanding of biology, and the infusion of the soul, and the infusion of grace grew and developed, the Church came to believe that mary was made sinless at the moment of conception. so, that is what we believe, as reflected in pius ix's dogmatic statement:[list]"We declare, pronounce, and define that the doctrine which holds that the most Blessed Virgin Mary, [i][b]in the first instance of her conception[/b][/i], by a singular grace and privilege granted by Almighty God, in view of the merits of Jesus Christ, the Savior of the human race, was preserved free from all stain of original sin, is a doctrine revealed by God and therefore to be believed firmly and constantly by all the faithful." [/list]so, we definitely do not believe she became sinless "later in life." as such, there is no change from a sinful nature to a sinless one. instead, the grace of Christ anticipates the stain of sin, it fills her w/ grace before sin can take its hold. [quote]The Bible has no hint of such a thing to occur and actually says the very opposite in no uncertain terms in Romans 3. Accusing all of humanity to be under sin except for one, the God/man with the virgin birth.[/quote] is there a chapter in the bible more maligned than Rom 3?!?! i would be hard-pressed to find one. ANYway......the context of the verse, both w/in paul's intentions for writing this chapter (and the letter to the romans as a whole) and david's intentions for writing the psalm that paul is quoting shows that it is not the intent of either of them to make a blanket statement about all of humanity. david is lamenting the sinfulness [i]of the Jews[/i], and Paul is reminding them of this lament so as to prove that they are no greater than the gentiles and that their faithlessness can indeed be counted against them. [quote]In Luke 1:46-47: After she visits Elizabeth and she is blessed she exalts the Lord saying “ My soul magnifies the Lord, and my spirit has rejoiced in God my savior.' Here Mary is saying that God is her personal savior, only sinners need a savior.[/quote] not [i]exactly[/i] true. Duns Scotus, the great marian theologian, makes the important distinction:[list]"the perfect Mediator must, in some one case, have done the work of mediation most perfectly, which would not be unless there was some one person at least, in whose regard the wrath of God was anticipated and not merely appeased." [/list]in other words, God saves us by freeing us from sin once it takes hold. but, he saved Mary by protecting her from sin, by not allowing it to take hold in the first place. in both instance, the Lord acts as Savior. so, mary's words in vs. 46-47 do not betray her sinlessness. [quote]In vs. 48 Mary states “ Henceforth all generations will call me blessed for He (God) has done great things for me and Holy is His name and His mercy is on those who fear Him.”Notice she says God is Holy not herself, that He will have mercy upon her. Mercy is withheld punishment, only a sinner needs the mercy of God.[/quote] she doesn't glorify her own holiness b/c she's the paragon of humility. she would much rather glorify God for the great things he has done. her entire speech here, in vs. 46-55 is a testament to this. as for the Lord's mercy, she's not speaking of how it applies to herself, but instead making a general statement about how he has always been merciful to his people. look at the verse again, this time in context: [b]50 [/b]And his mercy is on those who fear him from generation to generation. [b]51 [/b]He has shown strength with his arm, he has scattered the proud in the imagination of their hearts, [b]52 [/b]he has put down the mighty from their thrones, and exalted those of low degree; [b]53 [/b]he has filled the hungry with good things, and the rich he has sent empty away. [b]54 [/b]He has helped his servant Israel, in remembrance of his mercy, [b]55 [/b]as he spoke to our fathers, to Abraham and to his posterity for ever." even if she were speaking about his mercy towards her in particular (which could be asserted, since it was likely the Lord's mercy towards her that compelled her to recall his mercy towards his people), that does not necessarily mean that she was a sinner. for one, mary may not have even known that she was preserved from sin (which i think is a possibility). so, she would have been incredibly humbled by the fact that he chose her to bear his Son. secondly, sinlessness does not equal perfection. sinlessness is only perfection in spiritual purity, not in [i]all [/i]things. for example, others may have had talents or other inate abilities that she didn't possess. also, her body was still disposed to sickness. she still got hungry and tired (in other words, she didn't have a glorified body). so, mary could have seen the Lord's mercy in his decision to choose her despite these other imperfections. [quote]It wasn’t until 1850 that the church endorsed Mary's sinlessness. Luke says by the Holy Spirit she is a sinner by needing a savior but the Pope says she does not. So then the Bible would be wrong and a man called the Pope is right, it can't be both.[/quote] the ECF's obviously attest to the endorsement of the church long before 1850. see these articles: --[url="http://davidmacd.com/catholic/mary_in_the_early_church.htm"]Mary in the Early Church and Today[/url] --[url="http://ic.net/~erasmus/RAZ482.HTM"]Dialogue on Patristic Consensus: Particularly Mariology[/url] --[url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/2003/0301fea3sb2.asp"]Athanasius on Mary[/url] --[url="http://www.staycatholic.com/ecf_immaculate_conception.htm"]The Early Church Fathers on the Immaculate Conception[/url] --[url="http://www.cin.org/users/jgallegos/immac.htm"]Immaculate Conception[/url] --[url="http://www.bringyou.to/apologetics/a95.htm"]The Development of the Immaculate Conception[/url] --[url="http://www.cin.org/users/james/questions/q052.htm"]Aquinas and the Immaculate Conception[/url] --[url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/2003/0309frs.asp"]Mary: "Full of Grace"[/url] once the position of the church and the words of the bible are properly understood, then both can in fact be correct. [quote]She also states God has done great things for her, yet in Catholic theology today it is more the opposite. She has done great things for God! How clear is the Bible to speak to today’s current trends of religion.[/quote] prove it! everywhere you turn you see catholic apologists and theologians affirming that it is only b/c of God's work in her life that she is so highly respected. [quote]In the Catholic translation of the Bible ( Douay Rheims) it reads in Luke 1:28 “ the angel said to her: Hail Mary full of grace the Lord is with thee.” Unanimously in all the other translations which are from the Greek not Latin it says “ Rejoice, highly favored one the Lord is with you, blessed are you among women.” At first we notice she is blessed among women not exalted above them.[/quote] i disagree. she is "blessed among women" b/c she is "full of grace." even if we translate this as "highly favored" she is still exalted among women, for no woman has been so highly favored. [quote]She is chosen in preference to all the women upon earth, not men. [and later on he says:] Besides it says “blessed are you among women!” Not among men and woman.[/quote] so what? the angel is about to reveal to her that, out of all the women on earth, [i]she [/i]will be the mother of the messiah. so, it makes sense that the angel would comment on her place among all women. plus, these words aren't used to prove her sinlessness (that's not what the angel is trying to get across) so there's no need to address her place among all mankind. basically, the angel is saying "you are full of grace, and the lord has chosen you from among all women to be the mother of his Son." [quote]The word for grace is what is being disputed, Roman Catholics state is a special measure to Mary only. This does not fit the Biblical record. This word in the Greek is Kechari tomene (a perfect participle in the verb form, an omega verb) it means the one who God has graced, to give undue favor only sinful people need God's grace. .... This word for grace is from the root word Charitoo in Ephesians 1:6 it is also used of the believers in that church, “graced us.” .... This term is also used of Stephen in Acts 6:8 yet no one would claim that he too is without original sin. This is the same used for all who have been graced by God. Mary was no different in this respect.[/quote] yes, the root word for kecharitomene (charitoo) is used elsewhere in the bible. but, it is only found in this form in one place: luke 1:28. here it has a meaning unlike that found in eph 1:6 and acts 6:8. from Fr. Mateo's booklet [i]Refuting the Attack on Mary[/i] we read:[list]"...Luke 1:28 uses the perfect passive participle kecharitomene. The perfect stem of a Greek verb denotes 'continuance of a completed action'; 'completed action with permanent result is denoted by the perfect stem.' [Blass/DeBrunner and Smyth]. On morphological grounds, therefore, it is correct to paraphrase kecharitomene as 'completely, perfectly, enduringly endowed with grace.'" [/list]the form of charitoo found in eph 1:6 and acts 6:8 is not the same, so the meaning is different there. [quote]If full of grace means without sin than what of the grace given to believers, God’s grace is promised to all the believers collectively[/quote] it is my understanding that the grace given to mary and the grace given to us is the same. however, the effects of this grace are different b/c of when the grace is received. we receive God's grace [i]after [/i]we have been stained by original sin, so we have the inclination to sin (concupiscence) that comes w/ original sin and causes us to sin even after we have been forgiven. since mary was protected from sin by grace, this inclination is not hers. [i][b]that said, i invite correction on this point, if it can be asserted that the grace mary received is substantially different from the kind that we receive.[/b][/i] [quote]How does anyone get this to mean without sin when the bible says only God is without sin is beyond belief. John 1:14 ”And the Word became flesh and dwelt among us, and we beheld His glory, the glory as of the only begotten of the Father, full of grace and truth. V.15-17 6And of His fullness we have all received, and grace for grace.” pleérees cháritos full of grace Full is the from the word it means to “fill” (literally or figuratively [imbue, influence, supply (Interlinear Transliterated Bible ) To have grace does not mean one is sinless it means God's favor toward that person(s).[/quote] again, the form of the word charitoo is not the same. we read [url="http://home.nyc.rr.com/mysticalrose/marian4.html"][b]here[/b][/url] that "kecharitomene means 'you who were and continue to be full of and completed in grace'. Now grace is not mere unmerited favor, but God's gift of spiritual life and communion with Himself. Sin and grace are opposed (Romans 5:20-21), and grace saves us from sin (Eph 2:5, 8). So Mary's fullness of grace indicates a complete absence of sin." the author of the article we are refuting goes on to list Eph 1:6; Luke 1:30; Gen 6:8; Exo 33:12; Ezra 9:8; Ps 84:11; 2 Cor 9:8; and Rom 6:15 in an attempt to create a parallel between the grace mary received and the grace other bible characters receive. however, like i said before, the unique form of the verb charitoo in luke 1:28 shows that the grace mary received is working differently, or in a unique way in her life. note also that, if the same grace is given in every instance, it can still have a different effect based on [i]when it is given[/i]. [quote]Mary brought a sacrifice of two turtledoves in accord to Jewish law in Leviticus chapter 12. One was for a burnt offering, the other was for a sin offering. This couldn’t have been for the child who was the Holy one, the sinless spotless lamb of God. This must have been for her own uncleanness. Mary's conformity to the law is an admission she was a sinner needing to be restored by cleansing, only sinners need cleansing.[/quote] there is no such admission here. from [url="http://www.cin.org/users/james/questions/q051.htm"][b]this article[/b][/url] we read:[list]The basic answer is that Mary submitted to the childbirth purification ritual--with its mandatory sin offering--for the same reasons that Jesus submitted to circumcision (a purification ritual symbolizing being made spiritually clean; cf. Deut. 10:16, 30:6, Jer. 4:4, Rom. 2:29), celebrated the Passover (which was also a sin offering so that God's wrath would pass over the household), and baptism (another purification ritual; Acts 22:16, 1 Peter 3:21). In fact, if there were any difficulty in explaining Mary's submission to the purification ritual, it would be ten times harder to explain Christ's submission to these rituals since he was instrinsically and infinitely holy, while Mary was merely rendered entirely sinless by God's grace, as we shall be. The first reason Christ submitted to circumcision and Passover was that the Mosaic Law required it, and he (like Mary) was "born under the Law" (Gal. 4:4). The second reason is that to remove any cause for criticism and slander on the part of others, Christ submitted to things in the Mosaic Law of which he had no personal need or requirement (cf. Matt. 17:24-27). The third reason is that Christ did these things in order to provide an example for others--an example of obedience to the Mosaic Law with regard to circumcision and Passover, and an example of obedience to the Christian Law in the case of baptism. There were other reasons as well (such as the fact that these rituals pointed toward Christ), but the three that have been given are a more than adequate explanation of why Mary submitted to the Mosaic Law ritual of purification after childbirth (including its sin offering). She was born under the Law, she wished to give no occasion for slander in her conduct, and she wished to give an example to others. [/list]Aquinas also addresses this apparent difficulty [url="http://www.newadvent.org/summa/403704.htm"][b]here[/b][/url]. unfortunately, i'll have to postpone the rest of my rebuttal for a later time. i need to get a few things done before i go home (i'm at work right now). i hope what i have written so far is helpful. i will finish when i get a chance. pax christi, phatcatholic
phatcatholic Posted April 22, 2005 Posted April 22, 2005 i just realized that i never got around to finishing my response to the "let us reason" article against mary's sinlessness. so, i would like to finish that now.... [quote]Another point of contention with the Scripture-- If Mary is the woman of Revelation 12 as Roman Catholics say, it describes her with birth pains which according to the Bible is a judgment on sinners (Gen. 3:15-16).[/quote] what we have to remember about this woman from revelations is that she represents three different entities (Israel, the Church, and Mary), each one in a different way and neither one entirely (or perfectly). so, some qualities of the woman represent the Church, while others represent Mary. likewise, some of the actions that take place are literal, while others are figurative. any biblical scholar, catholic or protestant, will tell you that it is dangerous to approach the book of revelations w/ only one form of interpretation. w/ this in mind, lets look now at the verses in question: [b]Rev 12:1-2[/b] [b]1 [/b]And a great portent appeared in heaven, a woman clothed with the sun, with the moon under her feet, and on her head a crown of twelve stars; [b]2 [/b]she was with child and she cried out in her pangs of birth, in anguish for delivery. the claim against mary's sinlessness that we are addressing presupposes that the woman in these verses is mary, so there's no need to defend that here. if the woman is mary, then the child is Jesus. but, what of these "pangs of birth"? i contend that this "birth" is spiritual, not physical. for one, we have much evidence from scripture that points to mary's sinlessness, in which case she would indeed have no pain in physical child birth. secondly, labor pains are often used as a metaphor for the suffering that we go through when we attempt to bring Christ to the world, when we "birth him" w/in the hearts of men: [b]Isa 42:13-16[/b] [b]13 [/b]The LORD goes forth like a mighty man, like a man of war he stirs up his fury; he cries out, he shouts aloud, he shows himself mighty against his foes. [b]14 [/b]For a long time I have held my peace, I have kept still and restrained myself; now I will cry out like a woman in travail, I will gasp and pant. [b]15 [/b]I will lay waste mountains and hills, and dry up all their herbage; I will turn the rivers into islands, and dry up the pools. [b]16 [/b]And I will lead the blind in a way that they know not, in paths that they have not known I will guide them. I will turn the darkness before them into light, the rough places into level ground. These are the things I will do, and I will not forsake them. [b]Isa 53:10-11[/b] [b]10 [/b]Yet it was the will of the LORD to bruise him; he has put him to grief; when he makes himself an offering for sin, he shall see his offspring, he shall prolong his days; the will of the LORD shall prosper in his hand; [b]11 [/b]he shall see the fruit of the travail of his soul and be satisfied; by his knowledge shall the righteous one, my servant, make many to be accounted righteous; and he shall bear their iniquities. [b]John 16:20-22[/b] [b]20 [/b]Truly, truly, I say to you, you will weep and lament, but the world will rejoice; you will be sorrowful, but your sorrow will turn into joy. [b]21 [/b]When a woman is in travail she has sorrow, because her hour has come; but when she is delivered of the child, she no longer remembers the anguish, for joy that a child is born into the world. [b]22 [/b]So you have sorrow now, but I will see you again and your hearts will rejoice, and no one will take your joy from you. [b]Rom 8:19-23[/b] [b]19 [/b]For the creation waits with eager longing for the revealing of the sons of God; [b]20 [/b]for the creation was subjected to futility, not of its own will but by the will of him who subjected it in hope; [b]21 [/b]because the creation itself will be set free from its bondage to decay and obtain the glorious liberty of the children of God. [b]22 [/b]We know that the whole creation has been groaning in travail together until now; [b]23 [/b]and not only the creation, but we ourselves, who have the first fruits of the Spirit, groan inwardly as we wait for adoption as sons, the redemption of our bodies. [b]Gal 4:19 [/b]My little children, with whom I am again in travail until Christ be formed in you! Mary feels this pain at the foot of the cross. by physically bringing jesus into the world she also provides him who is our means of salvation. at the cross, jesus is working to make this a reality, and mary is there, uniting her suffering to his, experiencing the pain that is necessary so that Jesus may be born w/in the hearts of men. Simeon prophecied the suffering that mary would have to endure ("Behold, this child is set for the fall and rising of many in Israel, and for a sign that is spoken against, and a sword will pierce through your own soul also, that thoughts out of many hearts may be revealed.") and it is this suffering that is being alluded to in Rev. 12. [quote]At the wedding feast of Cana, Mary realizes the wine has run out. She makes Jesus aware of the need, He replies “woman what do I have to do with you, my hour has not yet come.” Jesus felt she was going to reveal who He was before the right time and manner. He let her know He is not subordinate to a persons request, He is not subject to another person's will, not even His own earthly mother, only His Fathers who is in heaven. She had no say in his ministry. Jesus obeyed the law to honor both His Father and his mother, but he would not allow her to choose the time of his disclosure. She receives this correction and then proceeds to tell everyone to listen to her son. Jesus obeyed the commandments of God perfectly as it states “to honor your father and Mother.” In Luke 2:51 we see Jesus was subject to His parents, not Mary alone.[/quote] this has nothing to do w/ her sinlessness [quote]What are the ramifications of Mary being sinless? She would be the first human being without sin since Adam. She would qualify to be our substitute just as Jesus, since only a sinless being could redeem mankind. There would have been no need for Jesus.[/quote] this is not true. for one, it is essential that the sacrifice be timeless. b/c she was sinless, she may not have died (we don't know for sure) but she was still a human creature living w/in the confines of time. her birth marked her beginning in time, so her sacrifice would not have been retroactive, it couldn't have saved the saints who came before her. furthermore, her sacrifice would have marked her death in time, she could not have saved those who came after her. however, the second person of the trinity exists outside of time, so His sacrifice is able to save all men, past present and future. also, it is necessary that the sacrifice be by its very nature something perfect. it must be essentially perfect. there can be no excuse. however, mary's excuse is Jesus Christ. were it not for him, she would have inherited the stain of sin. she was dependent upon Christ for her sinless, where as Jesus depends on no one for his. so, mary does not replace jesus in this way either. [quote]The Bible is clear only God is holy in this way. 1 Sam.2:2 says, “there is no one holy as the Lord,” in Rev.15:4 we see the redeemed singing the song of the lamb in heaven “You alone are Holy.” They are not singing this to Mary![/quote] no one is as holy as the Lord, not even mary. b/c jesus is God, and b/c of his intimate union with the Father as a person of the Trinity, his holiness is compounded. his perfection multiplies his holiness as well. the Son and the Father are substantially one. mary, although she was sinless, cannot make these other claims. so, while mary was indeed the holiest of creatures, her holiness pales in comparison to that of Jesus. no one is claiming that their holiness is equal, and the sinlessness of mary doesn't necessarily make them equal. [quote]If you are without sin, you are Deity! (this of course means after Eve sinned and before the resurrection where all believers will be changed together to have a completely new nature not having sin).[/quote] this is ridiculous. the Lord is much more than sinless. he is also omniscient and omnipotent. he transcends time. he is never-changing. he is perfect in every way. mary simply cannot make these claims about herself. so, while she is sinless, she is far from divine. [quote]We see the rule of sin in mankind is to all people, no exceptions. “All have fallen short of the glory of God” (Rom.3:23). All who have sinned and fall short or deprived of the glory of God. For one to be sinless as Mary is claimed to be means they have the glory of God. Yet God himself states “my glory I will not give another.” The only one who shares in this glory is Jesus (Jn.17:5), Mary did not have God’s glory, only Jesus did. Rom.5:12 tells us sin entered the world through one man and spread to all as death reigned. The only exception is the holy one from all eternity. It took nothing short than deity to accomplish sinlessness in the flesh via the virgin birth. The virgin birth was the vehicle but not a source for his sinlessness. Romans 3:10-12 “As it is written, There is NONE righteous, no, NOT ONE: There is NONE that understandeth, there is NONE that seeketh after God. They are ALL gone out of the way, they are together become unprofitable; there is NONE that doeth good, no, NOT ONE.”[/quote] well, we have already discussed the intentions of Paul when he spoke the words reference to here, so there is no need for me to repeat myself. as for God sharing his glory, i wonder how the author understands grace. is not the grace of God his glory that he shares w/ us? what would the author say of these words from Peter?: [b]2 Pet 1:2-4[/b] [b]2 [/b]May grace and peace be multiplied to you in the knowledge of God and of Jesus our Lord. [b]3 [/b]His divine power has granted to us all things that pertain to life and godliness, through the knowledge of him who called us to his own glory and excellence, [b]4 [/b]by which he has granted to us his precious and very great promises, that through these you may escape from the corruption that is in the world because of passion, and [i][b]become partakers of the divine nature[/b][/i]. here and elsewhere throughout the bible (cf. John 14:23; Rom 5:14-19; 2 Cor 5:17; 2 Thess 1:11-12; 1 John 3:2) we see that man shares in the nature of God and is conformed to his very image through the grace (aka "divine energy") that he bestows upon us. the verse that he uses to refute this (Isa 42:8) is taken out of context. here it is again: [b]Isa 42:8[/b] I am the LORD, that is my name; my glory I give to no other, nor my praise to graven images what he is saying here is that no one else is God like he is God. he is affirming his transcendance above all creatures and pagan idols. no one becomes God upon reception of his grace...........but we do share in his nature. [quote]If Mary ascended to heaven like Jesus, this incredible act of someone raised in a resurrection or never dying would certainly be recorded in Scripture. Yet it is suspiciously omitted from John’s writings, the one who she was entrusted to be looked after by Jesus. John’s last book the Revelation was written 85-90 A.D. Neither John nor any historian of the early church records this.[/quote] but the deaths of many prominent christians are not mentioned. peter was crucified upside down. paul was beheaded. these events would have been momentous enough to mention, but they aren't. i think this is b/c the NT writers are only concerned w/ the death of one person: Jesus Christ. it is [i][b]the life[/b][/i] of everyone else that is important, and the bible has much to say about the life of mary. as far as John is concerned, we do see allusions to mary's assumption in the woman from revelations. i don't think we should expect more, considering that the book of revelations, by its very nature, alludes to many things instead of stating them explicitly. [quote]This is an unknown doctrinal event that evolved until it was ratified in 1854. Roman Catholic tradition has made speculation into doctrine with Mary being guarded from actual sin by becoming sinless. This concept was around from about the twelfth century, and was developed into a papal decree of December 8, 1854.[/quote] if the "event" we are referring to is her assumption, then that wasn't "ratified" until 1950. it was her sinlessness that was defined in 1854. furthermore, this "concept" didn't just appear in the 12th century. we find it in ECF testimony as far back as the first century, in accounts of mary giving birth to jesus w/o pain, and by justin martyr and irenaeus the second century, in their comparison of mary w/ eve (go [url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/2003/0309frs.asp"]here[/url] and [url="http://www.cin.org/users/jgallegos/immac.htm"]here[/url]). [quote]Mary's body rests in the ground with the rest of the saints waiting for the resurrection. There are no personal raptures until the first resurrection occurs.[/quote] her body is in the ground? prove it. where is she buried? also, his claim about the rapture is not true. enoch and elijah were raptured into heaven. after Jesus' resurrection, the bodies of the saints were raised and even went about the city! so, there is a precedence in the bible for what happened to mary. [quote]Mary waited in the upper room for the Holy Spirit with the rest of the apostles and disciples. Mary was not numbered among the apostles nor is she exalted in any way above their ministry as the 12 pillars of the churches foundation. She is not mentioned in heaven as the apostles are the foundation for the new Jerusalem. Nowhere do we find the apostles conferring with Mary in doctrine. Nor are there any miracles attributed to her as are with the apostles.[/quote] so what! that doesn't mean she can't be sinless [quote]While Mary, Jesus earthly mother is to admired for her servitude, she needs to be honored only as much as God honors her, not more. She is a role model for women, as well as men but not to be exalted in equality with the Son. Col.1:18 tells us that Christ in all things is to have the PREEMINENCE.[/quote] agreed! God has honored her greatly, by protecting her from sin and raising her up to heaven w/ him. we honor her only b/c of the honor that the Lord has bestowed upon her. she is certainly NOT exalted in equality w/ the Son, and the contrary has yet to be proven. [quote]Paul warns and gives New Testament commands 1 Timothy 2:11-13: “Let the woman learn in silence with all subjection. But I suffer (allow) not a woman to teach, nor to usurp authority over the man, but to be in silence. For Adam was first formed, then Eve. “If Christ is the last Adam and the Church relates Mary to Eve she still has the inferior role to Adam. 1 Timothy 2:11-14: “Let the woman learn in silence with all subjection. But I suffer (allow) not a woman to teach, nor to usurp authority over the man, but to be in silence. For Adam was first formed, then Eve. And Adam was not deceived, but the woman being deceived was in the transgression. “Why is it we now have Mary whose words are recorded but twice in scripture, currently speaking new revelation to their church. Paul says she is not to speak in church, no woman is to have authority over a man. to give the prominence that the Catholic Church does gives her preeminence over man, and it is breaking scripture commands. 1 Corinthians 14:34-35: “Let your women keep silence in the churches: for it is not permitted unto them to speak; but they are commanded to be under obedience, as also saith the law. And if they will learn any thing, let them ask their husbands at home: for it is a shame for women to speak in the church.”[/quote] the lack of understanding here is becoming appauling. mary is inferior to Christ. we would claim no less, and she wouldn't either. she is his handmaiden and the model of humility. everything she does points to her son. "do what he tells you" she says to us. all of the marian doctrines have as their foundation some truth about Christ. mary as the "mother of God" was affirmed so as to protect the equally divine and human natures of Christ. her sinlessness points to the retroactive nature of God's work on the cross and the perfection of that work. these are just two of the doctrines in question (go [url="http://home.nyc.rr.com/mysticalrose/marian.html"]here[/url] and click on each doctrine to see how it exalts Christ). they all do the same thing: give Jesus Christ the preeminence. what comes next in the article we are refuting is a list of ECFs and popes who apparently rejected mary's sinlessness. it will take some work to look up these references and read them in context. so, i will have to save this third installment in my response for another time. thanks for being patient. pax christi, phatcatholic
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now