Guest Eremite Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 Oh definitely, if Americans themselves revolted against the government, that would be completely different.
Guest Eremite Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 [quote]Wouldn't that be a reason to have a crown? I mean the Queen of England wears a crown. And isn't she the sovereign of a state?[/quote] Sure, but the Queen of England isn't the successor of St. Peter (the Pope's primary and most important role). Simplicity of demeanor reflects simplicity of heart. [quote]when put on the head of the Pope, it symbolizes the threefold Authority of the Pontiff in a non-liturgical way.[/quote] I have no problem with the Tiara in theory. The Popes who did wear it weren't prideful (most of them, anyway). The context of modern society, however, and the drastically different status of the Papacy disinclines me toward the restoration of this practice. This same threefold authority can be expressed in some other simple way (eg, I know the Franciscans represent the three vows they take with three cords around their waste). [quote]Why wouldn't he wear it? The title "Servus Servorum Dei," is only one of the many titles that the Successor of Peter has. I believe that Summus Pontifex is one as well.[/quote] Because, as I said above, servant is the most fundamental and most important role of the Bishop of Rome. Unlike regular temporal rulers, he is the chief fisher of souls in the Church. Jesus, King of Kings, did not feel the need to have lavish displays of his Kingship (though he did have some, such as the anointing with the expensive oil). In a non-Liturgical setting, I think the Church should bear a posture of simplicity, as it serves as a better witness to the world, that the Kingdom is not about riches and glory, but about humble serve in Christ. This is not a rant against everything nice in the Church. Liturgical celebrations should bear the note of solemnity, as should Churches, which have a specific eschatological significance.
Cam42 Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 [quote]In a non-Liturgical setting, I think the Church should bear a posture of simplicity, as it serves as a better witness to the world, that the Kingdom is not about riches and glory, but about humble serve in Christ.[/quote] And that is your opinion, however, there are many who disagree. What so much more noble about playing the pauper? I think that to promote the riches that the Church has can be a strong witness to the world. Sure there is a charism to the simplicity, but there is also a charism to the riches of the Church. Is playing the pauper always a good thing? Nope. My opinion, however, I think that the Church will agree that the patrimony and noblity she is due is worthy of her 2000 year history, as well. Cam
Guest Eremite Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 [quote]And that is your opinion, however, there are many who disagree.[/quote] It's like Chesterton said. Catholics agree about everything. They just disagree about everything else.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 [img]http://www.answers.com/main/content/wp/en/4/4b/PiusXtiara.jpg[/img] look its one of my Favorite Saints Pope Saint Pius X! Look at him rocking that Papal Tiara! for shizzile!
Don John of Austria Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 (edited) [quote name='Pio Nono' date='Apr 25 2005, 07:04 PM'] JMJ 4/25 - St. Mark the Evangelist I'm not taking sides here, but if you're going to claim to argue philosophically, give me a philosophical argument. I don't see an argument here, just a series of assertions, one after the other. [/quote] I didn't make a philosophical arguement, I stated that that is the philosophiical distinction in the West. If you would like coroberation of that read Frederick Wilhelmsen founding Chair of Philosophy at University of Dallas.. it is the fundemental reason that in republics the executive branch has always been given power and the legeslative has been give Authority. In Christendom the Church had Authority and the king had the Power. Any decent medieval historian can tell you this is so. Or for that matter you could read Plato's Republic where it is addressed quite early on. Edited April 26, 2005 by Don John of Austria
Q the Ninja Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 What I can't understand is if it's not important, why is it in everything Vatican somewhere?
Don John of Austria Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 [quote name='Eremite' date='Apr 25 2005, 07:39 PM'] Fidei, Americans know how to survive. Whether the war for independence, the depression, or terrorism. The Pope, God bless his soul, would be signing his own death certificate if he tried to take on the United States. [/quote] Really it wasn't that long ago that the Cardnial of New York bent that State to his will with that same siomple threat, " fine then I'll close the schools Monday" and that was only the schools in New york City. Now if you think that the United States would kill the Pope for such an act you might be right but I seriously doubt it.
Don John of Austria Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 [quote]A crown is a material thing. By itself, it does nothing. The modern Roman Pontiffs have had absolutely no problem exercising their temporal duties in the modern world, from the appointment of Bishops to any other necessary duty. Walking around in crowns would not get them any more power or rights than they already possess.[/quote] So is a Chalice should we get rid of those as well.
Pio Nono Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 [quote name='Cam42' date='Apr 25 2005, 07:12 PM'] Not to be a total drag Pio, but it is still a possiblity. Just because the John Paul's didn't use the tiara doesn't mean that it has been abrogated. The possbility still exists. Although I don't think that Benedict XVI chose to do this. And I agree that we need to stop complaining about our Blessed Mother. Cam [/quote] JMJ 4/25 - St. Mark the Evangelist I'm not trying to be a drag either - I'd LOVE to see them break out that tiara. All I'm saying is that we shouldn't complain about what we've got in front of us, that's all. And some people are just complaining about our Mother, the Church, and I'm just telling them to stop. Besides, I like the fact that they brought back the traditional pallium for the Pope. Very medieval-looking.
Don John of Austria Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 [quote name='Pio Nono' date='Apr 25 2005, 08:22 PM'] JMJ 4/25 - St. Mark the Evangelist I'm not trying to be a drag either - I'd LOVE to see them break out that tiara. All I'm saying is that we shouldn't complain about what we've got in front of us, that's all. And some people are just complaining about our Mother, the Church, and I'm just telling them to stop. Besides, I like the fact that they brought back the traditional pallium for the Pope. Very medieval-looking. [/quote] I am not complaining about the Church and I am certianlynot complaining about his Holiness, I am contesting the Anti Tiara faction nothing more.
dspen2005 Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 Don John --- why is it so important that the Pope be crowned? you speak of the Pope's temporal power/rule, but is that less diminished when he is not crowned? isn't it more in keeping with Christ's message to have sold the tiara and given the revenue to the poor?
Don John of Austria Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 [quote name='dspen2005' date='Apr 25 2005, 08:31 PM'] Don John --- isn't it more in keeping with Christ's message to have sold the tiara and given the revenue to the poor? [/quote] No.
dspen2005 Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 why not??? didn't Christ tell lazarus to sell his possessions to follow him?
Cam42 Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 [quote name='Pio Nono' date='Apr 25 2005, 08:22 PM'] JMJ 4/25 - St. Mark the Evangelist I'm not trying to be a drag either - I'd LOVE to see them break out that tiara. All I'm saying is that we shouldn't complain about what we've got in front of us, that's all. And some people are just complaining about our Mother, the Church, and I'm just telling them to stop. Besides, I like the fact that they brought back the traditional pallium for the Pope. Very medieval-looking. [/quote] fair enuf..... And for the record, I love the pallium....very traditional....very Pope Innocent III. Do a google image search..... Cam
toledo_jesus Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 it's not Anti-tiara. It's "is a hunk of metal with jewels stuck on it essential to our understanding of the pope's role?" we acknowledge his authority and that's all we need to do. Most people don't live in the Feudal system anymore, Don John.
Q the Ninja Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 The Pope wouldn't get enough money from the crown to do any good for the poor.
Don John of Austria Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 [quote name='dspen2005' date='Apr 25 2005, 08:44 PM'] why not??? didn't Christ tell lazarus to sell his possessions to follow him? [/quote] First it wasn't lazarus. Second Peter didn't sell his possesions his house is still his while he a follower of Jesus so that obvously wasn't a requirment. Third The Pope is the Vicar of Christ, simular to the Chalice ( not the same but simular) being made of precious metal, the Pope should be cloaked in all manner of finery to do so gives Glory to the Lord. Mother Teresa was a follower of Christ but no more so than St. Louis ( perhaps not even as much so, we shall see if she is canonized[ although i doubt she won't be.) There are many roles to play in following Christ. Not all involve selling what one has and giving it to the poor. Remember the poor we will always have with us.
Q the Ninja Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 (edited) [quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Apr 25 2005, 07:48 PM'] it's not Anti-tiara. It's "is a hunk of metal with jewels stuck on it essential to our understanding of the pope's role?" we acknowledge his authority and that's all we need to do. Most people don't live in the Feudal system anymore, Don John. [/quote] Dude, chill. This is perfectly acceptable. We live with Tradition, not against it. I think this "Vatican II" spirit has got to end. This is not something that necessarily has to go away, and for those of us who would like to see it retained some day, that would be great. Edited April 26, 2005 by Q the Ninja
Don John of Austria Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 [quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Apr 25 2005, 08:48 PM'] it's not Anti-tiara. It's "is a hunk of metal with jewels stuck on it essential to our understanding of the pope's role?" we acknowledge his authority and that's all we need to do. Most people don't live in the Feudal system anymore, Don John. [/quote] Ah well then most people are ignorant louts, that being said it is irrelevent to the discussion.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now