Oik Posted April 21, 2005 Posted April 21, 2005 I empathize with the feelingso of exclusion the SSPX have. I however, would never allow myself to be in schism with the Church. Bro. Adam brings up a good point. I think evyone else has had some good feed back here too. As far as the tridentine Mass is concerned, that is not where the Holy Spirit is leading the Church and I am certain that He has made that abundantly clear. I love the Tridentine Mass and the Novus Ordo Mass. Where is the Church going, toward the Novus Ordo. The new recvision of the Roman NMissal due out in English (in probably three years) will, I think, really impact the Novus Ordo in America. Will we see the return of a Rudescreen (sp?), commuion under one speices and on the tongue, communion rails, and restrictions on altar servers and Extra-ordinary ministers? Doubtful. We will see a return to usage of Latin in the Mass, though only with a couple of prayers (maybe about 10 to 20 percent of the Mas MIGHT be in Latin). Some people will start receiving communion on the tongue. (Personally, I'd like to see Priests offering Intinction as well). Few women will start using Chapel veils, if any at the Novus Ordo (hey, they do at EWTN!) There will be a return (though only in rarity) of the usage of Gregorian chant and (maybe) organs. Church archeticture MIGHT get better. Rejoice and pray. These are exciting times. I think it was St. Therese who said "we must be the changes we want to see." I think this is going to be the theme of our times.
Cam42 Posted April 21, 2005 Posted April 21, 2005 [quote]I'm not sure the SSPX is very formally against Vatican II necessarily, though they are against what has happened since then (which is understandable but definitely does not justify a schism).[/quote] They are in schism because they are disobedient. Archbishop Lefebvre separated himself from Rome by consecrating (ordaining) bishops without the approval of the Holy See. Properly speaking on the bishops are excommunicated, however, the "faithful" are adhereing to a schismatic principle, precisely that they are being led by those who are excommunicated. Although, they are formally opposed Al. This is from the SSPX website: [quote]Our position must be: " ...we refuse... to follow the Rome of neo-Modernist and neo-Protestant tendencies which became clearly manifest during the Second Vatican Council and, after the Council, in all the reforms which issued from it." (Declaration of Archbishop Lefebvre, APPENDIX I)[/quote] Taken from [url="http://sspx.org/SSPX_FAQs/appendix_I._declaration.htm"]The Declaration of Archbishop Lefebvre[/url]; made at Econe, Switzerland on November 21, 1974. So, the SSPX actually does formally refuse the Vatican Council II. Cam
Pio Nono Posted April 21, 2005 Posted April 21, 2005 JMJ 4/21 - St. Anselm Also, let's not forget that the SSPX has caused a lot of confusion and has done markedly more to confuse and splinter the faithful than to draw them together. Even if they get their requests granted by the Vatican, they must apologize and make restitution for the sins the organization has committed against the unity of Christ's Church.
Cam42 Posted April 21, 2005 Posted April 21, 2005 [quote name='Pio Nono' date='Apr 21 2005, 12:47 PM'] JMJ 4/21 - St. Anselm Also, let's not forget that the SSPX has caused a lot of confusion and has done markedly more to confuse and splinter the faithful than to draw them together. Even if they get their requests granted by the Vatican, they must apologize and make restitution for the sins the organization has committed against the unity of Christ's Church. [/quote] Amen....
Aloysius Posted April 21, 2005 Posted April 21, 2005 yep, amen. my main point was that they are not sedevacantists, I did not realize they were formally opposed to the Council ITSELF (as opposed to poor implementation or liberal understandings of it). I thought they were more logical than that, because to me logic demands that either they proclaim sede vacante to justify their belief that Vatican II was wrong or they must accept Vatican II simply saying it is implemented wrongly. It doesn't make sense for a "faithful" group of Catholics to say that the legitimate successor to St. Peter called a council which included all the successors of the apostles alive in the world but it was wrong.
Mateo el Feo Posted April 21, 2005 Posted April 21, 2005 [quote name='Pio Nono' date='Apr 21 2005, 01:47 PM'] JMJ 4/21 - St. Anselm Also, let's not forget that the SSPX has caused a lot of confusion and has done markedly more to confuse and splinter the faithful than to draw them together. Even if they get their requests granted by the Vatican, they must apologize and make restitution for the sins the organization has committed against the unity of Christ's Church. [/quote] Here's my own "controversial" perspective: A few years ago, a Catholic priest gave a talk during a vocations retreat in which he explained (in the presence of around five other priests) that we should expect that homosexual marriages (i.e. monogomous sodomy) would soon be accepted and blessed by the Catholic Church--he said it's only a matter of time. Not a single priest flinched...I just looked around waiting for someone to have the courage to speak up. Admittedly, I didn't have the courage, myself. Leaving the Catholic Church to attend an SSPX church--in schism with the Catholic Church--is an unfortunate reaction for Catholics who go through the kind of scandalizing experience I just described. I would argue that much of the attraction of the faithful to their schism is to escape the heterodox priests [i]in good standing[/i] who think that they have a license (by virtue of their ordination) to change/ignore whatever faith/moral teaching that the Catholic Church has. I should emphasize that scandalized Catholics don't only go to "traditionlist" churches like SSPX--they go to Evangelical Churches, too. What's sad is not so much that SSPX was declared to be in schism--they should be. What is truly sad is that there are so many Catholic institutions in which individuals (priests, religious, lay) are substituting their own "truth" for the Truth proclaimed by Our Lord, and through His Catholic Church, which just fuels the alienation and exodus of otherwise faithful believers. If we're going to look for people to publicly apologize for the faithful's confusion, let us start with those who "officially" represent that Catholic Church, even as they undermine the teachings of the Catholic Church. The litany of abuses includes: child abuse, pro-sodomy advocates, liturgical abuse, advocating birth control, focusing on temporal works as ends instead of the salvation of souls, accepting abortion, women priests, and teaching that Our Lord is "one path" to salvation. For me, this is why the election of Pope Benedict XVI is so promising. I feel that he understands the need to continue pushing for greater fidelity to the fullness of Holy Scripture and Holy Tradition. I suspect that the SSPX leadership sees the same thing. God bless.
Guest T-Bone Posted April 22, 2005 Posted April 22, 2005 If the leadership of the Church ever endorses: woman priests; homosexual marriage; birth controll; abortion; et al., I will have to, according to my conscience, be in schism...
Cam42 Posted April 22, 2005 Posted April 22, 2005 [quote name='T-Bone' date='Apr 22 2005, 02:49 AM'] If the leadership of the Church ever endorses: woman priests; homosexual marriage; birth controll; abortion; et al., I will have to, according to my conscience, be in schism... [/quote] Reverse your position and you have it......You wouldn't be in schism for adhereing to the truth, you would be standing with the Church. The schism would be from those who abandon those priniciples that are orthodox. Your quote is a great apologia for the SSPX position. I don't think that you want that. Cam
dUSt Posted April 22, 2005 Posted April 22, 2005 If the church ever endorses all of those things, then I will too. Although it would never happen, if it did, I would conform. The will of the church is the will of God, and I would never try to conform God to my own conscience, but form my conscience to the will of God.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now